Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Southern Homebrew Mystery #2

The Proof Is in the Poison

Rate this book
Moonshine shop owner Hattie Hayes is ready to lend a hand when a mystery starts brewing at a train convention in Chattanooga, TN, in this charming cozy mystery series.

Now that her moonshine shop is up and running, Hattie Hayes can focus her efforts on expanding her fledgling business to events in the area, like the Chattanooga Choo Choo Model Train Convention, which is running full steam ahead at the convention center down the block. Hattie is all aboard, seizing this perfect opportunity to promote her Southern homebrew to the folks who have come to the city for the annual event.

But when an attendee dies after drinking some of Hattie’s moonshine, she’ll need to prove her innocence. Between tight-lipped train hobbyists and competitors for a coveted convention prize, Hattie has a wide array of suspects to choose from, and she’ll need to use all the tricks up her sleeve to make sure her moonshine business can survive a murderer and stay on track.

288 pages, Mass Market Paperback

First published June 7, 2022

30 people are currently reading
396 people want to read

About the author

Diane Kelly

69 books1,227 followers
Award-winning author Diane Kelly writes romance and romantic mysteries featuring feisty heroines, quirky sidekicks, and sexy leading men, with humor that leaves readers laughing out loud.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
119 (27%)
4 stars
188 (43%)
3 stars
103 (24%)
2 stars
16 (3%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews
Profile Image for Kerrin .
382 reviews217 followers
June 8, 2022
Whenever I read a book written by my friend, Diane Kelly, I always learn something new. Her second book in the Southern Homebrew Mystery Series The Proof Is In the Poison, is both intriguing and informative. When a competitor at the Chattanooga Choo Choo Model Train Convention dies after drinking some of Hattie Hayes’ moonshine, Hattie goes to great lengths to protect her reputation and guarantee the success of her newly opened Moonshine Shack. Along the way, the reader learns about 1. The competitive world of model train exhibits; 2. How poison is readily found in many common household cleaners; and best of all, 3. How to make several fun cocktails using flavored moonshine.

5-Stars. This book was published on June 7, 2022. Many thanks to NetGalley and Berkley Books for my advanced reader copy.
Profile Image for Kristina Anderson.
4,053 reviews83 followers
June 2, 2022
The Proof is in the Poison by Diane Kelly is the second A Southern Homebrew Mystery. It can be read as a standalone if you have not had the time to read The Moonshine Shack Murder. I thought The Proof is in the Poison was well-written with realistic, developed characters. I like Hattie Hayes and her grandfather, Ben. They are delightful, lively characters especially Ben. Granddaddy as Hattie calls him is a hoot. I like the premise for this cozy mystery. Hattie owns the Moonshine Shack where she sells the moonshine she creates. I love the description of her store especially the façade. She has made it look like an old moonshine shack in the mountains (like her ancestors had). The Chattanooga Choo Choo Model Train Convention is in town, and it is an opportunity for Hattie to promote her moonshine. Hattie has arranged to have a mixer at the hotel where many of the conventioneers are staying with coupons to encourage people to visit her shop. She even came up with unique moonshine cocktails with fun names. I enjoyed the descriptions of the model trains, displays, and items for sale. I learned quite a bit about model trains. I loved the train references and puns throughout the story. The author really managed to work in train metaphors throughout the story. There is a great line that ends that book that I especially enjoyed. I found all the information on moonshine to be fascinating. The author knows her history on this topic. The historical details add depth and interest to the story. The mystery was fun. I will admit that it is a cinch to solve. However, I enjoyed the crime and following Hattie as she worked on solving it. I like how Hattie’s mind works. I think, though, that she needs to work on her questioning technique. Hattie needs to be more subtle, so she does not alienate potential clients. The reveal scene was a delight. I laughed quite a bit. I appreciated that she kept Ace (the detective on the case) in the loop. I am glad that Hattie has a good working relationship with the detective on the case. Of course, Hattie has a close relationship with Marlon. I think it is a great touch that he is a mounted officer. There was some repetition regarding the suspects and the case details. Those details do not need to be repeated so frequently. I found the method of murder to be unique. It was clever how it was laid out. We get to learn some interesting information regarding it as well (I would say more but I do not want to spoil it for you). There are recipes at the end for the three drinks served at the convention mixer (railroad themed drinks). I am looking forward to Hattie’s next escapade. All aboard for Hattie’s latest adventure in The Proof is in the Poison with clown car cocktails, railroad replicas, acrimonious competitors, a boorish bully, railway trivia, an exterminated engineer, killer hooch, and a smoky disclosure.
Profile Image for Kim.
791 reviews48 followers
May 20, 2022
Once again Diane Kelly shows us what an amazing writer she is when it comes to characters in The Proof is in the Poison, book two in the Southern Homebrew Mysteries. I love that the main character, Hattie, actually shares information with the police. Although it helps that the hunky, horse riding officer is her boyfriend. But in this book she’s even more helpful to the Sheriff, Ace, which is leading to a great relationship between the two of them… way better than in the first book. Then there’s Smoky, the cat who travels with Hattie to her Moonshine Shack, and Granddaddy, who is a wonderful bit of comic relief and full of knowledge about ‘shine and the area.

Kelly also does a fantastic job introducing all the new characters that are involved in the train convention. They all have lots of depth and feel like they have been in the series since the first book.

I also enjoy how Kelly incorporates all the moonshine history and recipes, along with regional history and descriptions. They really add an in depth layer to the series, and I love reading books where I learn new things. And in this one the reader gets to learn a lot about miniature trains too!

Unfortunately I did find myself skimming a lot because of how repetitious Hattie was going over the suspects and their motives. I know this happens in every cozy mystery, but I felt like it was even more than usual in this one. I was going to give The Proof is in the Poison three stars instead of the four that I gave because of all the skimming I did… but I really do love the characters and think they, along with all the history and descriptions are so well written that I decided to go up a star.
Profile Image for LORI CASWELL.
2,866 reviews328 followers
December 22, 2024
Dollycas’s Thoughts

The Chattanooga Choo Choo Model Train Convention is chugging right along and with The Moonshine Shack just down the street owner Hattie Hayes is capitalizing on the opportunity to promote her Southern homebrew to the members and all their visitors. She has convinced the hotel convention manager to hold a Monday Moonshine Mixer featuring her moonshine. She even worked with the bartenders to create train-themed drinks.

When a train enthusiast and leading contender to win at least one of the many contests passes out and dies by his exhibit Hattie’s “shine” takes the blame. She knows she is meticulous when she makes her flavored moonshine and no one else who drank had ill effects so now she has to prove she had nothing to do with the man’s death. Just walking around the convention center she found several suspects, now she needs to get them to talk.

Will Hattie be able to bottle a murder? or has The Moonshine Shack served its last jar of shine?

Ms. Kelly has created some wonderful characters for this series. I love the relationship Hattie has with her granddaddy. She picks him up almost daily from the Singing River Retirement Home, where he waits for her on his metallic red scooter usually surrounded by two or three senior ladies looking for fun and companionship. He goes with her to the shop where he visits with customers, makes recommendations, whittles cute little critters, and takes a little nap or two. He is a big fan of model trains and is excited to go to the convention with Hattie to hand out flyers and swag to everyone. He is so proud of her for taking on the family business and taking it to new heights. She is also a darn good amateur sleuth.

I also love the relationship that is building between Hattie and the handsome Officer Marlon Landers. He is a mounted officer, and his horse Charlotte is a big, beautiful chestnut mare with a flaxen mane. The relationship is new, but he truly cares about her and wants to keep her safe. The woman takes some crazy risks that scare the bejesus out of him. Detective Candance Ace almost took Hattie’s antics in stride.

Solving the mystery was based more on observations than questioning suspects which was a good thing because Hattie needs to work on her interview skills but she has gotten better than she was in the first book, The Moonshine Shack Murder. The detective knew Hattie could help her because she had spent a lot of time at the convention hall and knew things about the attendees that helped put things in perspective. I don’t think she knew the lengths Hattie would go to though to catch the killer. Holy cow! I was on the edge of my seat during the entire chase and I believe I was holding my breath. Yes, I had the right suspect at the top of my list before Hattie but I really had a great time tagging along with her for every step.

I appreciated all the information about model trains and all the contests held at this convention. There was a time when our children were small that a plywood board painted green with tracks, trains, assorted buildings, and scenery sat on a table in our garage. We attended some local conventions and they were great family days that sparked our imaginations. The enthusiasts in this story took things to a high level and the author described each set-up so well I envisioned each one easily.

Heartwarming characters, an intriguing mystery, tons of model train info, interesting moonshine drinks, and a heart-pounding showdown all came together to make The Proof Is in the Poison a Perfect Escape. I am unsure why I got behind on this series but I am moving book 3, Fiddling with Fate up on my TBR stack.

I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.

Profile Image for Maria.
2,992 reviews96 followers
July 7, 2022
I've always been fascinated with trains (but not to the extent of owning one; never enough room) so this setting was wonderful for me. I loved picturing the different setups the exhibitors had and googled a few of the different trains and locations that were mentioned. I found the mystery intriguing and kind of thought I knew who did it and was sad to see I was right (not because it wasn't set up well but because of who it was). I am really enjoying this series and can't wait to see what happens next.
Profile Image for L.M..
Author 4 books22 followers
June 2, 2022
Chattanooga is playing host to a model train convention and Hattie Hayes is hoping to lay tracks from the convention center directly to the front door of the 'Shine Shack. Unfortunately one of the train enthusiasts keels over after enjoying some of Hattie's fruit 'shine and the police order her business shuttered until they can prove who spiked Bert Gebhardt's drink.

The Southern Homebrew series is the first I've read by Kelly and I have really enjoyed it. This series is classic cozy mystery fare: young lady starting a business on her own, quirky friends, elderly mentor, grumpy-but-adorable pet, sexy beau, and a bloodless crime ridding the cast of a merciless villain. Hattie pokes around, annoying local police, and spots one clue after another until the final ah-ha moment when she ties everything together. It's perfect! While I do appreciate authors trying new twists and changing up the settings or backgrounds, reading a cozy that goes exactly how you'd expect it to go is... cozy.

While I have not read Kelly's other series, I highly recommend this one to anyone who's a cozy purist such as myself. This book was a quick, fun read.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
Profile Image for Yvonne.
1,338 reviews266 followers
June 22, 2022
A model train convention is coming to Chattanooga, TN and Hattie Hayes is ready for it. She’s trying to make her new moonshine shop a success and plans to do some advertising at the convention. Along with her grandfather, they spread the news about the shop to all who attend the show.

Things take a nasty turn when one of the model train vendors ends up dead and Hattie’s moonshine is taking the blame for it. Someone poisoned his moonshine and Hattie is accused of the crime. It’s up to Hattie to prove her innocence for the sake of her shop and, of course, for her own freedom.

This is the second book in this series and it’s just as fun as the first one. The mystery storyline is contained in this book so you won’t feel lost if you didn’t read the first book. The author, also, gives the reader some background information in this one. However, I suggest you read the first one since this is such a cute series.

Hattie is a unique character and she’s surrounded by a wonderful supporting cast. Her grandfather is a fun loving guy on a scooter. Hattie even has a cat named Smokey who loves hanging around the moonshine shop.

This book got off to a slow start for me as there was much information on model trains. I thought it was a bit too much, but then the story really took off. Hattie’s a bit too nosy sometimes, but what amateur sleuth isn’t? Not to mention she has every reason in the world to want to find out who the killer is since it appears they are framing her for murder.

There’s an explosive finale as Hattie takes matters into her own hands. It’s all fun and exciting. Hattie even has a little romance going on and it’s very sweet. This is a charming mystery that kept me guessing until the end.





FTC Disclosure: I voluntarily reviewed a free Advance Reader Copy of this book from NetGalley and the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Profile Image for Karen Stallman .
882 reviews98 followers
April 24, 2022
“The Proof Is in the Poison” the 2nd instalment in A Southern Homebrew Mystery series by Diane Kelly. This is first book I have read in the series, and it can be read as a standalone. I have since purchased the previous one so I can be all caught up in time for book 3.

Moonshine shop owner Hattie Hayes is ready to lend a hand when a mystery starts brewing at a train convention in Chattanooga, TN.

I liked Hattie and her cat Smoky and we can’t forget her granddaddy ( I loved him). I also enjoyed the setting of Chattanooga, Tennessee. There is a great cast of side characters Marlon, Charlotte the horse, Kiki, Nora and Ace.

The mystery is interesting and had lots of twists which kept me guessing. I had no idea who the killer was till Hattie did. I’m looking forward to the next book , and seeing what’s in store for Hattie and the Moonshine Shack.

I highly recommend this cozy series to all my friends.

I requested and received an advance reader copy of this book from Berkley Publishing and Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Stephanie.
521 reviews84 followers
June 20, 2022
This was such a fun cozy! Most of this one takes place at a model train convention, which normally would not interest me, but Diane Kelly does a fantastic job of making the setting fun and including new characters connected with the convention. I loved the way our protagonist, Hattie, helped to solve the murder without being dense or irritating. I really enjoyed watching the development of her relationships with Marlon and Ace. Kelly does a great job of incorporating the history of moonshine into the story without being overbearing or making it feel like a history lesson. My one con is that I did get bored with Hattie's repetitive thoughts of the suspects and their motives. The ending was a wild ride (literally), and I am excited for book 3!

Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley Books for providing an eARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Olivia Blacke.
Author 14 books618 followers
June 27, 2022
In the engaging cozy mystery THE PROOF IS IN THE POISON by Diane Kelly, Hattie, her feisty grandpa, and Smoky the grumpy cat run a rustic moonshine business (blackberry moonshine? YES PLEASE!). When a model train festival comes to town, Hattie dons her kitschiest overalls and heads on down the track to peddle her 'shine. Her booming business turns into a train wreck when one of the contestants drops dead and Hattie's moonshine is suspect #1. To clear her name, she launches an investigation that culminates in the BEST CHASE SCENE EVER.

Bonus: There are moonshine cocktail recipes in the back and a hot love interest on horseback.
Profile Image for Sue Em.
1,800 reviews121 followers
January 20, 2023
Well-written cozy highlighting moonshine production with a murder set at a model train convention. Moves quickly leavened by tons of interesting info about 'shine, model trains and train history.
129 reviews
December 8, 2024
I usually love Diane Kelly’s writing, but for some reason the model train convention setting didn’t really work for me.
Profile Image for Tari.
3,636 reviews103 followers
May 31, 2022
Another fun adventure with Hattie and Granddaddy! I recently read the first book and enjoyed it so much, I was happy to be able to get hold of this ARC for this book releasing next Tuesday. I get such a kick out of Granddaddy and his enthusiasm for pretty much everything. I could just picture him zipping around that model train show on his scooter. And the whole idea of a model train convention, let's just say Sheldon would be in paradise. (actually so would my husband lol).

I was definitely wrong in my guessing whodunit and didn't really think about this person much until Hattie started suspecting them. I love how ideas just come to her no matter where she's at, even on horseback with her boyfriend Marlon. Although what a great guy to have around when she got a case idea, right? I really like Det. Ace now and how she included Hattie in the investigation--although her reasoning for letting Hattie help was totally spot-on, I still had to giggle at it and thinking yep, perfect reason for strong-willed Hattie.

When the three besties got together, we met little Colton who was probably cutting his teeth on solving a mystery with his auntie Hattie. I like that Kate didn't let being a mom slow her down in wanting to be with her buddies and sleuth a little. It was just pack the kiddo and take off. And I just thought, a baby in a stroller makes a great cover. Who'd suspect a baby of being a little sleuth?

There was a pretty exciting chase before the actual showdown which was pretty peaceful, the showdown not the chase, lol. Hattie and Marlon's date at the end took them past some posters that highlighted the next event that I look forward to reading about in the next book!

I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book provided by Berkley Publishing via NetGalley, and my opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Noreen Trotsky.
155 reviews6 followers
May 18, 2022
In the second book in the series, we find Hattie & her grandfather caught up in another murder. This time the plot is centered around a train convention, which was fine, but not something I really want to read about. Hattie & the rest of the characters made it fun, though. Hattie is spending more time thinking about her relationship with Marlon while trying to clear her name. On another note, I do wish that Marlon would stop calling Hattie “filly”. Some might find it cute, but I find it somewhat demeaning.

The book can be read as a stand alone. Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for a digital ARC of the book. This review can also be found on my Goodreads page.
Profile Image for Heather.
Author 22 books504 followers
September 25, 2022
This is fun series set at a Moonshine Shack in Chattanooga, TN. I loved her quirky characters and all the details about moonshining and miniature trains. Add this series to your TBR list.
Profile Image for Kim.
1,162 reviews16 followers
March 26, 2024
I really enjoyed the first book. I enjoyed the relationship between Hattie and her Grandpa. In this book there isn’t as much of their relationship or Hattie’s store since it takes place mostly at the conference center. The mystery is full of twists and turns to keep the reader guessing though I didn’t figure it out pretty early in the story.
Profile Image for Margie.
1,714 reviews26 followers
May 7, 2022
The Proof Is in the Poison is the second book in author Diane Kelly's Southern Homebrew Mysteries series. Main character Hattie Hayes has opened the Moonshine Shack. With the Chattanooga Choo Choo Train Convention happening in town Hattie is looking forward to lots of sales of her moonshine.
Then someone puts a poison in one of her moonshine jars and miserable Bert Gebhardt turns up dead. I enjoyed learning about moonshine. I really like the characters in this book and I am thrilled that the animal spotlighted is Charlotte the horse. This was a fun whodunit to read!

I received an ARC and this is my honest review.
Profile Image for OpenBookSociety.com .
4,104 reviews135 followers
July 9, 2022
https://openbooksociety.com/article/t...

Brought to you by OBS Reviewer Jeanie

I enjoyed this fast-paced 2nd in series even more than the first! The characters, especially Hattie and her grandfather, are engaging and endearing. Having become invested in Hattie in the series debut, this novel solidified that I want to see more of this protagonist. The model railroad convention in Chattanooga was a fascinating and fun setting, almost tempting me to look for a show to enjoy. The train theme is throughout, including songs with trains and train terminology or adages. The mystery was intriguing, and I had to cheer for Hattie as she tried to find the real killer.

It has been interesting to learn about moonshine in this series! Moonshine is in Hattie’s blood. She learned how to make it from her grandfather, Ben, when she was growing up. She left her stable office job to do what she loves, produce and sell moonshine in the family tradition. She was very careful when she made it, and those who drank it thought she made the perfect product in various fruit flavors.

Hattie spent the first morning of the model railroad convention handing out flyers for her product to collectors and vendors. The hotel bar would use her moonshine in a special mixer that first night with special train-themed drinks. She and Ben learned there was much more to the model train/ railroad hobby than they thought. They met many enthusiasts, some whose wives were involved in it with them. Other wives had their own activities together while their husbands spent the hours in various model train/ railroad themed workshops or seeing other people’s setups.

Hattie and Ben watched enthusiasts in various stages of setting up their latest railroad models for which they hoped to win first place. One man was Bert, who they had seen yelling at one of the housekeeping staff in the hotel that morning. He wasn’t very personable; his wife Dana was friendly and proud of the ribbons and trophies Bert won over the years. Even when Bert was rude to her, she recovered quickly and made excuses for him.

The mixer at the hotel bar was a success, and afterwards Dana and some of the wives came to the Moonshine Shack to try the ‘shine samples and use their convention discounts. A couple mornings later, judging began on some of the contests. Dana told them that Bert was so nervous about the judging that he drank half a jar of ‘shine the night before, plus a couple shots that morning, and oh, did he look like it. Before the judges made it to his booth, however, Bert fell over dead. By the end of the day, Detective “Ace” regretfully shut down the ‘shine shack pending tests on her product. Bert died from methanol poisoning, and the culprit was thought to be the ‘shine. Dana had only a small amount the night before and had a little bit of methanol in her system as well, for which the hospital treated her.

It was horrifying for Hattie to think she may have made a dreadful mistake that killed someone. She thought about Marlon, who she had recently begun dating. A police officer, he frequently rides his horse on his beat. He might have to arrest her if they can’t discover a different source of poison, just like his great-granddaddy, a sheriff, had once arrested her great-granddaddy, a moonshiner, during Prohibition.

The author has gifted us with a great, three-dimensional cast of characters, most of whom feel like new friends. I like the close relationships Hattie has with her grandfather and her friends. I also enjoy Smoky, Hattie’s pet and the shack’s feline mascot. Even though Marlon and Hattie are getting to know each other, he believes in her attention to the details of producing ‘shine, and Ace, the detective, is willing to listen to and utilize information Hattie finds.

The humor brings welcome relief from some of the more stressful moments, including Hattie reading stories to her friend Kate’s infant son and changing them to reflect 21st century women. I liked learning more about the moonshine business. I was stunned when Hattie confronted a couple people at the convention, all but outright accusing them of killing Bert! The irony of the chase was not lost on this reader; it was equally frightening and funny. The ending of this Southern cozy mystery is very satisfying, leaving no loose ends. I can’t wait to see the next mystery in this series, and highly recommend this one!
Profile Image for Lali & Michelle.
336 reviews6 followers
November 4, 2023
Series: 2/3 in the Southern Homebrew series

Setting: Chattanooga, Tennessee with its population of almost 200,000 isn't really a small town setting although the author tries to create that feel by having the protagonist live in a cabin in the woods and own a small downtown business. But the business is just down the street from a large hotel and convention center so the feel is a little confusing. There is an extra bonus, though, because the history of the town does feature fairly prominently. (4/5)

Sleuth: Hattie is the proud owner of the Moonshine Shack, which is only fitting since her family have been moonshiners for generations and she learned the trade from her granddaddy. She dresses in overalls and uses lots of "folksy" idioms. She says over and over how she is a buttinsky and nosy and so on, perhaps trying to ward the reader off from thinking those very things--but it doesn't work. I still find her somewhat annoying and unlikable. Not great for a protagonist in a cozy. Her best quality is her love for her grandfather. (3/5)

Side characters: It is nice to see an older character featured in a book, but unfortunately her grandfather doesn't play a role in solving the mystery. Hattie just picks him up at the retirement home each day so he can spend time in the shop whittling little figures and talking with the customers. Would have been nice if he had been included in the mystery someway. Hattie's friends Kiki and Kate seem nice enough but there is not much about them aside from an afternoon they spend sleuthing together. But Hattie's love interest Marlon is bleh. He is a mounted police officer who actually lives in a loft in a barn so he can be near his horse. And he is always calling Hattie "little filly." Yuck. (3/5)

Plot: Mattie is hoping a local model train convention will be an opportunity to promote her moonshine business. While handing out flyers, she sees one of the participants get in altercations with a maid at the hotel, a judge for the model train competition and two fellow competitors. Cozy readers know that unsavory people never prosper, so it is no surprise when he dies under suspicious circumstances. The murderer has laced Hattie's moonshine with methanol and she is determined to discover who is threatening her business. There are so many ludicrous things about this plot. First, the wife of the murder victim stays at the convention after he is murdered--and she is still attending the convention events. What? And they have two sons and grandchildren. Wouldn't she want to be with them? The police detective even says, when she needs to take some tools to check them out, that it's okay because she will return them early enough for the wife to still have time to sell them before the convention ends. Because every widow would stay until the last day of the convention even though her husband has just died. So annoying. Then the ending of the murder involves Hattie and the suspect jumping on the side of a moving train and having to hold on through a long tunnel. Get it? They are at a model train convention and the ending scene involves a train. Such clever plotting. (2/5)

Extras: One of the friends has a cute baby.

Continue with series?: Probably not. The author also wrote one of my favorite series the K-9 Paw Enforcement series. Doesn't seem like this was written by the same author.
Profile Image for Jeanie.
1,311 reviews1 follower
December 15, 2022
I don’t even drink, and I’ve been captivated by Hattie Hayes and this delightful series! Until I started reading this series, I didn’t realize people still made moonshine, or even that it was legal anywhere. And I really had no clue that it could be made in so many different flavors! There’s no limit to what I can learn from this series. Hattie has recently started dating Marlon, a police officer who does much of his work on horseback.

This time, Hattie and her grandfather, Ben, are spending time at the model railroad convention, which I found fascinating! Reading about the various kinds and setups of trains made me want to attend one, just once, since so many people prepare their sets to be historically and mechanically correct.

Hattie was handing out flyers and talking with people as they set up before the official beginning of the event. The hotel bar will use her ‘shine the first night in a special event with railroad-themed drinks, and she is offering specials to anyone who comes to her shop from there. The excitement of the first night of sales is over with quickly when it a man is found dead after drinking some of her ‘shine. While it is the only jar that seems to have had issues, Hattie is devastated when thinking she could have made a terrible mistake that caused someone’s death.

Something isn’t adding up, however, and Ben and Marlon are confident in how she prepares any product sold with the Moonshine Shack label on it. The man who died had upset a few people around the convention, not to mention his wife. They just have to find out before the event is over and people leave.

I loved how fast-paced this mystery is, the laugh-out-loud humor throughout, and the regular characters. Diane has another winning series that I hope will be around for a long time. I highly recommend this novel to all who enjoy well-written cozy mysteries with humor, moonshine, and the setting of the beautiful area around Chattanooga.
Profile Image for Moondance.
1,188 reviews62 followers
March 26, 2023
Thunk.

Hattie Hayes is back in the second book of the Southern Homebrew Mystery series. A model train convention is in town and a competitor dies after drinking Hattie's moonshine, Hattie goes full on sleuth to prove that her 'shine is safe and to catch a killer.

This fun series has taught me so much about moonshine and its rich history. Although not a fan of 'shine, I really appreciate all the research that has gone into the story. I never knew how competitive model train builders were! There was a lot of good information about that hobby as well. The geek in me loved the chemistry behind the poisoning. I live alone but often talk things through as I'm reading. My cats got an earful about why I don't use commercial cleaning products and stick to natural as much as I can.

I enjoy the relationship between Hattie and her grandfather. Watching the budding relationship between Hattie and Marlon is a joy as well. Of course, Smoky the cat adds his own stamp on the story. As does Marlon's horse Charlotte.

The climatic take down of the murder suspect had my heart pounding (and yes, I was talking it out with the cats!) Hattie has no fear and a strong sense of right and wrong.

I can't wait to read the next book in this series.

Oh, there are recipes for the 'shine drinks for those that are adventurous.
Profile Image for Tracy Hartman.
21 reviews3 followers
June 30, 2022
The Proof is in the Poison: A Southern Homebrew mystery- book 2
By: Diane Kelly
Published: June 7, 2022
Publisher: Berkley
Kindle pps: 284

In Diane Kelly’s Southern Homebrew 2, The Proof is in the Poison, Hattie, Granddaddy, and friends are hot on the trail of yet another murder mystery. This time everything goes down add a model train show. I was so sure that I had the correct method and murderer as it turns out I had the correct method but my eyes were on the wrong suspect… again. Job well done!

I absolutely love this series, who doesn't love a little moonshine with their mysteries? Granddaddy is up to his old tricks, Kiki add extra flair, and I cannot wait to see where this love interest goes. Smoky the cat and Charlotte the police horse are just the icing on top of a very delicious cake.

As always, I walked away from the book having learned more than one new thing. I love how Kelly always manages to slip in bits of unknown information to the general public. How can learning something new be so much fun? I really hope this series continues for quite a while, as it is currently one of my favorites. keep shining, Firefly!

A definite 5-star book!
Profile Image for Jae.
880 reviews1 follower
March 6, 2023
Hattie is excited to promote her moonshine at a model train convention in the nearby convention center. She hands out fliers and hosts a moonshine mixer at the attached hotel. Hattie's marketing pays off when several convention goers visit her shop and buy moonshine. However, when one of the convention participants dies after drinking some of Hattie's shine, the police force her to close her shop while they determine the exact cause of death. With her livelihood on the line, Hattie does some snooping of her own, digging up several clues that she passes along to the detective in charge of the case. Hattie won't rest easy though until a killer is caught and her moonshine is exonerated.

The setting of a model train convention was certainly unique, and I enjoyed it. The participants/contestants were serious about their set ups and their vying for prizes, all of which meant there were a multitude of suspects. Hattie took some rather foolish risks, which exasperated her kinda-sorta boyfriend, Marlon. Characters were portrayed well and the plot flowed smoothly.

Very good, four stars.
Profile Image for Andrea.
1,788 reviews24 followers
September 5, 2022
I loved visiting Hattie again even if we didn’t see her store that often. She did have good reasons to be out and about though because she was catering part of the events at the model railroad convention and then she was trying to convince them to come try her stuff again because we all know she didn’t do it. So that could bother some, but it most of it felt like business trips.
I love learning about the model railroad community. We get a bit of history, a bit of cryptids, and a bit of crafting. While I am not very crafty, I did enjoy reading about people who are.
There were lots of suspects and still the ending surprised me. There were clues along the way and I even picked up some of the clues, but I didn’t trace the clues back to the murderer. So it was just the right level of mystery for me.
The romance between Hattie and Marlon progressed nicely. I like a slow burn romance, so this was perfect for me.
Read this if you like a mystery with lots of suspects and some fun crafty elements.
Profile Image for Laurie Pinnell.
111 reviews1 follower
September 6, 2022
This story was the first one I read in this series. May I say it won't be the last. Set in Chattanooga, TN it was a familiar setting to me as my husband and I traveled through there and spent some time there years ago. Hattie runs a business, the Moonshine Shack. Her moonshine is suspect in the cause of death to a convention for model trains attendee.
Ms Kelly's attention to detail is definitely praise worthy. I was so engrossed in the model trains, the making of moonshine, and then the murder investigation that as I got deeper into the book the more I couldn't put it down. This book is definitely a page turner. I think I was borderline obsessed with finding out who actually did it, why and how! There are a lot of cozies that I like, a good amount I love and some that I can't say enough about. It's hard to put into words how much I enjoyed this book. I highly recommend you give this book a try. It has everything I look for in a cozy.
Profile Image for Syd.
311 reviews
March 13, 2025
2.5 Stars

My thoughts on this 2nd in the Southern Homebrew series are a bit scattered. I really enjoyed the concept of a mystery at a model train convention. The setting was so unique and made me want to find a model train exhibit like the one that's described to visit.

But Hattie herself drove me crazy. She was constantly meddling, questioning people she considered suspects and she put herself in grave danger toward the end of the book.
Her police officer love interest warned her a few times to be more careful, but she never listened. I'm surprised he didn't throw up his hands and walk away after witnessing the danger event.

I liked that Hattie was working with the police and giving over 'evidence' she found, but I thought it was pretty unrealistic that the detective would share info with her.
Overall, I liked this book, but its not a favorite. I have the 3rd in the series but may hold off on it for a while.
Profile Image for Lisa Malmquist.
771 reviews23 followers
June 26, 2022
Hattie Hayes has a moonshine shop in Chattanooga, Tennessee. It is a family tradition to make moonshine and her grandfather taught her.
But Unlike her great grandpa, nowadays, she sells it legally !
Meanwhile, there is a model train convention in town and all the contestants are gathered for a fun few days and compete for prizes.
She goes there to promote her moonshine shop and holds a trivia contest at a bar for the convention attendees.
BUt, trouble is brewing when a contestant dies from drinking her moonshine. She knows it wasn't her fault but her livelihood could be in danger if people think her moonshine is poisoned.
What can she do but to jump in the investigation and prove her innocence?!
Fun series!
Profile Image for Darla Taylor.
1,851 reviews
August 1, 2022
Hattie Hayes is promoting her business, a local moonshine store, at the Chattanooga model train convention. Things are going well until one of the attendees dies after drinking some of Hattie's shine. Hattie then sets out to find a killer and prove that her moonshine is safe.

This is the second book in what promises to be an excellent series. Diane Kelly definitely keeps you entertained. The book's well-written and I love the various characters and their relationships. The story was captivating from the beginning and the mystery will keep you guessing. I'm really looking forward to the next book. I highly recommend both book and series. Yes, you could read this book as a stand-alone, but I suggest reading the series in order for the most benefit and enjoyment.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.