What do you think?
Rate this book
The Secret Ingredient
NOW A HALLMARK CHANNEL ORIGINAL MOVIE!
Love is like a perfect recipe… You never want to lose it.
Years ago, Kelly McIntyre and Andrew York were engaged and dreaming of opening a restaurant together. Then he chose an opportunity to study in Paris over the small-town life they’d planned, and their romance came to a bittersweet end.
But Kelly’s doing fine. She’s not only the owner of a potbellied pig named Gray, but also of her own bakery. Business is good—so good that she’s invited to compete in a Valentine’s Day bake-off. As she prepares for the contest, she tries not to get distracted by Andrew’s visit to town.
When Andrew sees Kelly, it stirs up his old feelings. Little does he know that soon, in New York, he’ll compete against her in the bake-off…and they’ll both realize how much their past is a part of them still.
This irresistible romance includes a free Hallmark original recipe for Honey Almond Cake with Berries and Mascarpone Crème Fraiche.
Love is like a perfect recipe… You never want to lose it.
Years ago, Kelly McIntyre and Andrew York were engaged and dreaming of opening a restaurant together. Then he chose an opportunity to study in Paris over the small-town life they’d planned, and their romance came to a bittersweet end.
But Kelly’s doing fine. She’s not only the owner of a potbellied pig named Gray, but also of her own bakery. Business is good—so good that she’s invited to compete in a Valentine’s Day bake-off. As she prepares for the contest, she tries not to get distracted by Andrew’s visit to town.
When Andrew sees Kelly, it stirs up his old feelings. Little does he know that soon, in New York, he’ll compete against her in the bake-off…and they’ll both realize how much their past is a part of them still.
This irresistible romance includes a free Hallmark original recipe for Honey Almond Cake with Berries and Mascarpone Crème Fraiche.
336 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published February 12, 2019
295 people are currently reading
921 people want to read
About the author
Nancy Naigle
60 books2,188 followersNEW RELEASE: A South Hill Christmas Keepsake—out now!
USA TODAY bestselling author Nancy Naigle writes heartwarming small-town stories of love, faith, and second chances. With more than forty novels to her name, eight have been adapted for television on Hallmark Channel, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries, and FOX Nation. Her award-winning ECPA Bestseller The Shell Collector was also the first FOX Original Movie and is now streaming on FOX Nation.
Nancy’s newest Christmas novel, A South Hill Christmas Keepsake, is a heartfelt story inspired by her real-life hometown in Virginia—a tale of lost love, small-town wonder, and rediscovering the magic of community during the holidays.
Up next, she’ll return to the beloved Whelk’s Island universe in Home No Matter Where (coming May 2026), the third installment in The Shell Collector series—continuing her signature blend of coastal charm, healing, and hope.
After a successful career in the banking industry, Nancy followed her heart and took early retirement to write full-time. Now living in the small town of Franklin, Virginia, she crafts stories that celebrate the simple joys of life, the beauty of belonging, and the power of love to restore even the most fragile hearts.
When she’s not writing, you’ll find her browsing antique shops, painting, or weaving pine needle baskets—always on the lookout for the next small spark of inspiration to turn into a story you’ll never forget.
USA TODAY bestselling author Nancy Naigle writes heartwarming small-town stories of love, faith, and second chances. With more than forty novels to her name, eight have been adapted for television on Hallmark Channel, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries, and FOX Nation. Her award-winning ECPA Bestseller The Shell Collector was also the first FOX Original Movie and is now streaming on FOX Nation.
Nancy’s newest Christmas novel, A South Hill Christmas Keepsake, is a heartfelt story inspired by her real-life hometown in Virginia—a tale of lost love, small-town wonder, and rediscovering the magic of community during the holidays.
Up next, she’ll return to the beloved Whelk’s Island universe in Home No Matter Where (coming May 2026), the third installment in The Shell Collector series—continuing her signature blend of coastal charm, healing, and hope.
After a successful career in the banking industry, Nancy followed her heart and took early retirement to write full-time. Now living in the small town of Franklin, Virginia, she crafts stories that celebrate the simple joys of life, the beauty of belonging, and the power of love to restore even the most fragile hearts.
When she’s not writing, you’ll find her browsing antique shops, painting, or weaving pine needle baskets—always on the lookout for the next small spark of inspiration to turn into a story you’ll never forget.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 247 reviews
May 1, 2024
In this yummy second-chance romance featuring two bakers, Kelly and Andrew are high school sweethearts with a plan to open their own diner/bakery when Andrew’s family interferes and sends him away to Paris for formal cooking training. And so ends their romance. Seven years later, he’s back in town. Kelly has opened her own bakery and has a thriving business. And when an opportunity to participate in a cooking show and bake-off comes up, she jumps at the chance.
This was one of those DELICIOUS books that was perfect for cuddling up with on a cold day. So many yummy food descriptions, especially cakes and cookies. I felt like I was working in a bakery right beside Kelly. It was set near Valentine’s Day, which made for a nice holiday read.
This was one of those DELICIOUS books that was perfect for cuddling up with on a cold day. So many yummy food descriptions, especially cakes and cookies. I felt like I was working in a bakery right beside Kelly. It was set near Valentine’s Day, which made for a nice holiday read.
February 13, 2020
The Secret Ingredient by Nancy Naigle
A beautifully sweet and heartwarming contemporary romance. The perfect story to be made into a Hallmark movie. Second chance troupe. Clean romance.
Andrew and Kelly were friends from a young age. Their love of cooking together and developing new recipes evolved into an engagement. When Andrew had the chance to train in Paris, Kelly was supportive and then devastated when Andrew didn’t return home.
This book takes place seven years later when Andrew visits home and begins to realize that Kelly is still the love he shouldn’t have walked away from.
So touching. Sugar-coated romance. Well paced. The drama of the New York events were engaging and delicious. I loved everything about this book.
A beautifully sweet and heartwarming contemporary romance. The perfect story to be made into a Hallmark movie. Second chance troupe. Clean romance.
Andrew and Kelly were friends from a young age. Their love of cooking together and developing new recipes evolved into an engagement. When Andrew had the chance to train in Paris, Kelly was supportive and then devastated when Andrew didn’t return home.
This book takes place seven years later when Andrew visits home and begins to realize that Kelly is still the love he shouldn’t have walked away from.
So touching. Sugar-coated romance. Well paced. The drama of the New York events were engaging and delicious. I loved everything about this book.
January 24, 2019
Kelly McIntyre and Andrew York had everything going for them— engaged and with plans to open a restaurant. However, when Andrew is offered the chance to study with a pastry chef in Paris, he can’t resist, and the two drift apart. Seven years later, Kelly’s on top of the world with her own bakery that’s so successful she’s offered the chance to compete on a televised baking competition. She’s so focused on her new life that she almost doesn’t care when Andrew waltzes back into town. Almost. They won’t be able to avoid each other forever, though, as Andrew’s also been chosen to compete.
Considering Kelly runs a bakery, it’s no surprise that cakes are mentioned repeatedly. One that plays a pivotal role is a Triple-Layer Honey Almond Cake— a mouthwatering confection that everybody wants a slice of. That cake is a lot like this book. Sweet and rich, but with a ton of depth. And sure, with so many layers, one slice would be enough, but author Nancy Naigle has provided a generous slab with plenty for leftovers.
The characters are completely charming. Kelly is talented and determined, but she also has a playful nature that can only come from someone who perfects sweets all day long. Interestingly, Naigle has crafted Andrew in much the same way. They do have differences, but on the page they read as a perfect pair. This works. Even though it should be easy to dislike Andrew for leaving Kelly, it’s nearly impossible since they’re obvious matches.
This leads to some of the richest layers of the story. Kelly and Andrew had different ideas for obtaining their same high school dream, and it results in the complicated mess of their relationship as the book begins. Their eventual growth, especially for Andrew, stems from not only reconciling their past, but also considering their present. Both appear to be outwardly triumphant in their culinary professions, but Naigle has some insightful comments on dreams and what it actually means to achieve success.
The story does take some time getting to the cooking competition. The bulk of the action takes place in their hometown in North Carolina. Naigle is an expert on crafting idyllic tiny towns, and this one is no exception. It helps carry the plot as Kelly and Andrew stumble into each other again and again, the small size easily forcing them into situations where they’re in close proximity. Of course, it’s populated with a cast of fun supporting characters who are enthused at the prospect of the two ending up together.
However, once the story gets to the cooking competition, it’s a race to the finish. There’s a complete shift of pace, marking a total change from life in the sleepy town to the hustle and bustle of New York City. There also are a ton of fun surprises. Naigle is a master of telegraphing information to the reader that will surely lead to a collision for the main characters at some point. She writes with a wink.
Simply put, The Secret Ingredient is a wonderful treat.
Note: I received a free ARC of this book through NetGalley.
Considering Kelly runs a bakery, it’s no surprise that cakes are mentioned repeatedly. One that plays a pivotal role is a Triple-Layer Honey Almond Cake— a mouthwatering confection that everybody wants a slice of. That cake is a lot like this book. Sweet and rich, but with a ton of depth. And sure, with so many layers, one slice would be enough, but author Nancy Naigle has provided a generous slab with plenty for leftovers.
The characters are completely charming. Kelly is talented and determined, but she also has a playful nature that can only come from someone who perfects sweets all day long. Interestingly, Naigle has crafted Andrew in much the same way. They do have differences, but on the page they read as a perfect pair. This works. Even though it should be easy to dislike Andrew for leaving Kelly, it’s nearly impossible since they’re obvious matches.
This leads to some of the richest layers of the story. Kelly and Andrew had different ideas for obtaining their same high school dream, and it results in the complicated mess of their relationship as the book begins. Their eventual growth, especially for Andrew, stems from not only reconciling their past, but also considering their present. Both appear to be outwardly triumphant in their culinary professions, but Naigle has some insightful comments on dreams and what it actually means to achieve success.
The story does take some time getting to the cooking competition. The bulk of the action takes place in their hometown in North Carolina. Naigle is an expert on crafting idyllic tiny towns, and this one is no exception. It helps carry the plot as Kelly and Andrew stumble into each other again and again, the small size easily forcing them into situations where they’re in close proximity. Of course, it’s populated with a cast of fun supporting characters who are enthused at the prospect of the two ending up together.
However, once the story gets to the cooking competition, it’s a race to the finish. There’s a complete shift of pace, marking a total change from life in the sleepy town to the hustle and bustle of New York City. There also are a ton of fun surprises. Naigle is a master of telegraphing information to the reader that will surely lead to a collision for the main characters at some point. She writes with a wink.
Simply put, The Secret Ingredient is a wonderful treat.
Note: I received a free ARC of this book through NetGalley.
June 4, 2019
THE SECRET INGREDIENT is not the first book I've ever read by Nancy Naigle and it certainly won't be the last. The twists and turns keep coming and I had to know how it was going to end! Every time I thought I knew where this story was going, a few pages later, Ms. Naigle threw me for a loop and I knew I was wrong! I'm kicking myself for not reading this wonderful novel sooner. I knew I was going to love this story just by the description.....love is like a perfect recipe.....you never want to lose it!
THE SECRET INGREDIENT is a quick read and unputdownable! There were quite a few times when reading it that I wanted to reach into the pages and shake Kelly and Andrew to wake them up because I mean, what were they thinking? I found myself laughing one second and then being totally aggravated the next. If you are looking for a great story with lots of giggling to pull you out of your book slump, you can’t go wrong with THE SECRET INGREDIENT. I’m so excited to read more by Nancy Naigle and she is one of my auto buy authors.
I've got to tell you, the whole time I was reading this I was craving cake in the worst way! THE SECRET INGREDIENT begins with Andrew and Kelly having the perfect lives. They have big dreams of opening a restaurant together until the day he has the opportunity of a life time. Now Andrew is gone, their engagement is off, and the six months he was supposed to be away in Paris have come and gone. Kelly tries to move on with her life and owns her own bakery now, but she is alone, with the exception of her pet pig, Gray! Gray stands for Good Riddance Andrew York! I thoroughly enjoyed reading THE SECRET INGREDIENT.
Seven years later, Andrew comes home for a visit. He knows Kelly hates him so he thinks he will be able to avoid her for the few days he is there. Yeah, well we all know how that's going to go right? Will these two ever be able to let go of the past and maybe have another chance at love? I was really hoping so. When they both find themselves in a baking competition, it's really going to tug at your heart strings! You won't know who to cheer for! There is so much going on in this story, but Ms. Naigle does a wonderful job of weaving all the pieces together. All of the characters will have you feeling sad and then yelling on the same page. More than once I wanted to be in Baileys Fork, NC with my new found friends! Once you finish devouring this story, you are going to want to tell everyone you know about THE SECRET INGREDIENT.
I received a complimentary copy of this book through Netgalley. All opinions expressed are my own and were voluntarily given.
February 25, 2019
If you ever want to read a book which can make you crave a CAKE - it is this book. It made want to stuff my face with it, and I am not even a cake lover.
The story was a second chance romance between Andrew and Kelly, high school sweethearts who planned to marry and open their restaurant, till Andrew was offered an opportunity to study baking in Paris, and he never made it back home. Kelly started her own business The Cake Factory which boomed and made their town famous. 7 years on, Andrew was back, and the chemistry between them still burned high. Both were invited to participate in a baking competition in a television series, and the book ended in the bake-off.
Nancy Naigle has written a sweet book which started a bit slow but soon picked up, the story rose like the layers of the cake. The characters were cute and the atmosphere created was warm like an oven. I love books where the romance is light as a butter, and Kelly and Andrew were both so likable and sweet as a muffin. (I like muffins more). Being a Hallmark book, there was love in its pages and a recipe at the end of the book of a Triple Layered Honey Almond Cake with Berries and Mascarpone Creme Fraiche...
The descriptions of the cakes were mouth watering. And I couldn't resist buying one from the bakery. Just a slice with tea and another with my coffee... Ah well.. The cake is all gone now!!
The story was a second chance romance between Andrew and Kelly, high school sweethearts who planned to marry and open their restaurant, till Andrew was offered an opportunity to study baking in Paris, and he never made it back home. Kelly started her own business The Cake Factory which boomed and made their town famous. 7 years on, Andrew was back, and the chemistry between them still burned high. Both were invited to participate in a baking competition in a television series, and the book ended in the bake-off.
Nancy Naigle has written a sweet book which started a bit slow but soon picked up, the story rose like the layers of the cake. The characters were cute and the atmosphere created was warm like an oven. I love books where the romance is light as a butter, and Kelly and Andrew were both so likable and sweet as a muffin. (I like muffins more). Being a Hallmark book, there was love in its pages and a recipe at the end of the book of a Triple Layered Honey Almond Cake with Berries and Mascarpone Creme Fraiche...
The descriptions of the cakes were mouth watering. And I couldn't resist buying one from the bakery. Just a slice with tea and another with my coffee... Ah well.. The cake is all gone now!!
February 21, 2019
ARCE REVIEW
This book is so freakin' cute if the publisher wasn't already Hallmark I'd say it screams Hallmark. I loved the characters, I loved the story, I really enjoyed the baking competition. One of my favorite tropes is second chance romance and this was such a great one. Kelly and Andrew were highschool sweethearts they met at her dad's diner he was the cook and she waited tables and baked they were kindred spirits. They had made plans to open a restaurant together but when the opportunity for Andrew to study baking in Paris came up he took it with a promise he'll be back for their wedding. Andrew was then offered a spot in a culinary school and he never made it back home.
Kelly may not have had Andrew there to help fulfill her dreams but that didn't stop her from going on alone; she started The Cake Factory. A custom cake business that made it big when a rockstar gave her a shout out at a local music festival since then the business has boomed, it's even helped turn Bent Fork from a quaint little town to a place to be. Fast forward seven years Andrew is finally back stateside and visiting his family before he has to go to New York, he wanted to keep the visit quiet but his sister in her usual fashion couldn't let him which turned out to be a good thing because he got to see Kelly again. The first time in seven years they see each other and his feelings for her haven't changed or diminished in any way. Kelly would love nothing more than to give into her feelings for him but she knows he's just going to leave again. He's made a name for himself in France and while he may not have his own restaurant yet his life is in France and she can't let him in to her heart only to watch him walk away again.
To Kelly's surprise she gets invited to compete in her favorite bake-off competition show's Valentine episode. The only stipulation is that she can't tell anyone she going to be on it. Unbeknownst to her Andrew is also going to be on the show. Once in New York, Naigle builds the anticipation and creates the same feeling you get when watching a baking competition on T.V. She describes the action of the competition so well along with the mouth watering confections Kelly and Andrew make. I really wanted cake after reading this book. Overall, Naigle once again creates wonderful characters in a quirky small town and gives us a statifyingly good romance with such a sweet ending.
This book is so freakin' cute if the publisher wasn't already Hallmark I'd say it screams Hallmark. I loved the characters, I loved the story, I really enjoyed the baking competition. One of my favorite tropes is second chance romance and this was such a great one. Kelly and Andrew were highschool sweethearts they met at her dad's diner he was the cook and she waited tables and baked they were kindred spirits. They had made plans to open a restaurant together but when the opportunity for Andrew to study baking in Paris came up he took it with a promise he'll be back for their wedding. Andrew was then offered a spot in a culinary school and he never made it back home.
Kelly may not have had Andrew there to help fulfill her dreams but that didn't stop her from going on alone; she started The Cake Factory. A custom cake business that made it big when a rockstar gave her a shout out at a local music festival since then the business has boomed, it's even helped turn Bent Fork from a quaint little town to a place to be. Fast forward seven years Andrew is finally back stateside and visiting his family before he has to go to New York, he wanted to keep the visit quiet but his sister in her usual fashion couldn't let him which turned out to be a good thing because he got to see Kelly again. The first time in seven years they see each other and his feelings for her haven't changed or diminished in any way. Kelly would love nothing more than to give into her feelings for him but she knows he's just going to leave again. He's made a name for himself in France and while he may not have his own restaurant yet his life is in France and she can't let him in to her heart only to watch him walk away again.
To Kelly's surprise she gets invited to compete in her favorite bake-off competition show's Valentine episode. The only stipulation is that she can't tell anyone she going to be on it. Unbeknownst to her Andrew is also going to be on the show. Once in New York, Naigle builds the anticipation and creates the same feeling you get when watching a baking competition on T.V. She describes the action of the competition so well along with the mouth watering confections Kelly and Andrew make. I really wanted cake after reading this book. Overall, Naigle once again creates wonderful characters in a quirky small town and gives us a statifyingly good romance with such a sweet ending.
February 18, 2019
4.5 Stars, 5 Stars if they make this into a movie. 😃
Author Nancy Naigle has blended delightful characters, a charming town, a few surprises and some great cooking to create an entertaining and delicious story. Kelly McIntyre is a hometown girl from Bailey’s Fork, North Carolina who loves to bake. Her boyfriend Alex York was the cook and between the two of them they created some delicious dishes. Their dream is to get married and open their own restaurant. Their future seems set, until Alex is offered an opportunity to study under a famous, master chef in Paris. Kelly waits for Alex to come home for seven years, but he never returns. When the story begins Kelly is in Bailey’s Fork and has opened The Cake Factory. Her creative use of flavors has made her famous. She has her own house and loves her pet pig, GRAY (which stands for Good Riddance Alex York.) Alex, still living in Paris, gets an invitation to a baking competition in New York City, so he flies in from Paris a few days early and decides to visit his hometown. He wants to mend some fences with his family. It is a small town, so of course he runs into Kelly and their feelings are still there, yet buried a bit. Kelly insists things are over, but as they run into each other on several occasions, sparks ignite. Is there a chance for them to get back together?
The first part of the book is a bit slow, with them getting to know about each other and their lives, but the second part takes off. This book is wonderful. You will meet characters that become your friends and a town that would be fun to visit. I enjoyed getting to know both Kelly's and Alex's families. I liked how some of the family relationships were mended in a very believable way. The romance is light, sweet and I found it easily believed. As I said at the beginning of my review, this would make a wonderful Hallmark movie. (unless it already is). I loved the recipe at the back of the book for the starring dish, Triple Layer Honey Almond Cake with Berries and Mascarpone Crème Fraiche. Not sure if I will try to make it (I am not much of a cake baker) but it sure sounds delicious. I highly recommend this culinary romance. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book upon request. The rating, ideas and opinions shared are my own.
Author Nancy Naigle has blended delightful characters, a charming town, a few surprises and some great cooking to create an entertaining and delicious story. Kelly McIntyre is a hometown girl from Bailey’s Fork, North Carolina who loves to bake. Her boyfriend Alex York was the cook and between the two of them they created some delicious dishes. Their dream is to get married and open their own restaurant. Their future seems set, until Alex is offered an opportunity to study under a famous, master chef in Paris. Kelly waits for Alex to come home for seven years, but he never returns. When the story begins Kelly is in Bailey’s Fork and has opened The Cake Factory. Her creative use of flavors has made her famous. She has her own house and loves her pet pig, GRAY (which stands for Good Riddance Alex York.) Alex, still living in Paris, gets an invitation to a baking competition in New York City, so he flies in from Paris a few days early and decides to visit his hometown. He wants to mend some fences with his family. It is a small town, so of course he runs into Kelly and their feelings are still there, yet buried a bit. Kelly insists things are over, but as they run into each other on several occasions, sparks ignite. Is there a chance for them to get back together?
The first part of the book is a bit slow, with them getting to know about each other and their lives, but the second part takes off. This book is wonderful. You will meet characters that become your friends and a town that would be fun to visit. I enjoyed getting to know both Kelly's and Alex's families. I liked how some of the family relationships were mended in a very believable way. The romance is light, sweet and I found it easily believed. As I said at the beginning of my review, this would make a wonderful Hallmark movie. (unless it already is). I loved the recipe at the back of the book for the starring dish, Triple Layer Honey Almond Cake with Berries and Mascarpone Crème Fraiche. Not sure if I will try to make it (I am not much of a cake baker) but it sure sounds delicious. I highly recommend this culinary romance. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book upon request. The rating, ideas and opinions shared are my own.
February 5, 2019
The Secret Ingredient is a delightful story that is the perfect Valentine's Day read for romance, love based on friendship and reconciliation. Kelly and Andrew were high school sweethearts who shared a love for cooking and creating new recipes. Her specialty was baking while Andrew loved to cook and create dishes. He worked in the Main Street Cafe, Kelly's family's restaurant, in Bailey's Fork, North Carolina while in high school. They were in love and planned to marry June fourth, a year after graduation. But Andrew's great aunt in Paris approached with a special opportunity to study in Paris under a great pastry chef for six months. He and Kelly decided he should do it. But he impressed the chef and was offered a full ride to study in Paris. He wanted Kelly to join him and marry but she did not want to leave her home. Both were hurt but stood their ground.
Seven years later, Andrew is still in Paris working for a famous chef running one of his restaurants.
He returns home for a short visit with family before going to New York City. He was invited to compete in Four Square Valentine's Day Bake-Off, a baking contest with a cooking network, but cannot tell anyone so he says he is going to help with a restaurant opening in the city.
Kelly has a successful bakery, The Cake Factory, that has grown into an online business selling her cakes, cupcakes and goodies across the nation and employing many of the townspeople. She has also been invited to compete in the contest but cannot tell anyone. Her friend and assistant, Sara, is the only who knows. Kelly tells her family that she is going to on a business convention to Orlando.
Andrew and Kelly have some unresolved issues that caused awkwardness when they see each other again but they spend a little time together before he leaves town. There is still some spark or something between them.
Without going into too much more detail, this is a sweet and lovely story of two people who enjoy their profession and have worked hard to get where they are. Will they find a way to meet in the middle? What will happen in the contest? They don't know that the other one is a contestant. And who to pull for? I couldn't decide but it is a happy ending that brought a smile and warm feeling. It is a sweet uplifting story. There is a great recipe at the end that I am hoping to try out.
I received a complimentary ARC from Hallmark Publishing through NetGalley. All opinions stated are mine only.
Seven years later, Andrew is still in Paris working for a famous chef running one of his restaurants.
He returns home for a short visit with family before going to New York City. He was invited to compete in Four Square Valentine's Day Bake-Off, a baking contest with a cooking network, but cannot tell anyone so he says he is going to help with a restaurant opening in the city.
Kelly has a successful bakery, The Cake Factory, that has grown into an online business selling her cakes, cupcakes and goodies across the nation and employing many of the townspeople. She has also been invited to compete in the contest but cannot tell anyone. Her friend and assistant, Sara, is the only who knows. Kelly tells her family that she is going to on a business convention to Orlando.
Andrew and Kelly have some unresolved issues that caused awkwardness when they see each other again but they spend a little time together before he leaves town. There is still some spark or something between them.
Without going into too much more detail, this is a sweet and lovely story of two people who enjoy their profession and have worked hard to get where they are. Will they find a way to meet in the middle? What will happen in the contest? They don't know that the other one is a contestant. And who to pull for? I couldn't decide but it is a happy ending that brought a smile and warm feeling. It is a sweet uplifting story. There is a great recipe at the end that I am hoping to try out.
I received a complimentary ARC from Hallmark Publishing through NetGalley. All opinions stated are mine only.
April 10, 2020
What a great light hearted easy read. Perfect relaxing read in the chaos going on right now. I really enjoyed reading this fun book. Thanks for a great book Nancy!
February 12, 2019
What a wonderful love story written by Nancy Naigle. Perfect for a Hallmark movie for Valentine’s Day. I really loved this book!
The characters are so easy to relate to. The descriptions of the desserts had me drooling and made me want to taste them all.
Can Kelly and Andrew get beyond the past and repair the damage that has occurred?
Absolutely loved G.R.A.Y. Who is he, well....
You will have to read this book to find out!!
Thank you NetGalley and Hallmark Publishing for the opportunity to read this book.
The characters are so easy to relate to. The descriptions of the desserts had me drooling and made me want to taste them all.
Can Kelly and Andrew get beyond the past and repair the damage that has occurred?
Absolutely loved G.R.A.Y. Who is he, well....
You will have to read this book to find out!!
Thank you NetGalley and Hallmark Publishing for the opportunity to read this book.
February 23, 2019
Also available on the WondrousBooks blog.
Actual rating: 3.5
I could have given the book 4 stars, but I felt that that might be somewhat misleading.
Don't get me wrong, The Secret Ingredient has many virtues, but it doesn't particularly qualify as what I would consider a really good book (which is what I used 4 stars for, as opposed to 5 stars, which I give very rarely nowadays).
The Secret Ingredient is a sweet book about two high school sweethearts who go on different paths soon before getting married and end up seeing each other again 7 years later. This, of course, leads to them re-thinking their lives and the choices they've made. Their struggles culminate in a bake-off in New York, in which, unknowingly, they are competing against each other.
It was all very cute and fun to read, and I thoroughly enjoyed the lengthy descriptions of cakes and other sweets and pastries. My god, I've never craved cake as much. So much so, in fact, that I went and bought cake! And I don't even like desserts that much.
On the other hand, I had an issue with the book which basically boiled down to my distaste for a live not lived. I am well aware that this is a personal view, but I do admit that it influenced the reading process for me. What I mean is that I've never been contended with staying in my hometown, never travelling, never seeing the world, never experiencing any of the things that the world has to offer, and the world is a huge place. I know that many people think this is the perfect life and I'm not going to contradict their own feelings, but to me it seems a bit ignorant to never even try to see the magnificent things there are out there. Which is basically what Kelly does the entire book, and she is made out to seem like the good guy, while Andrew is blamed time and again that he left for Paris to become a chef. The other characters good-heartedly mock him for being a "big shot"and "an important chef", as if it's a bad thing that he wanted to try more than his small town was offering him. This really frustrated me, because if you really think about it, if all people believed that this was the proper thing to do - stay at home and try to make it work with what you have, I wouldn't even be able to write this review or read this book, because why would I even need to learn English, when I speak my own language, Bulgarian, perfectly well.
Lastly, and this is a question here: do people really speak like this with their families in America?
I'm not joking. I'm Eastern European, we're not that affectionate.
Actual rating: 3.5
I could have given the book 4 stars, but I felt that that might be somewhat misleading.
Don't get me wrong, The Secret Ingredient has many virtues, but it doesn't particularly qualify as what I would consider a really good book (which is what I used 4 stars for, as opposed to 5 stars, which I give very rarely nowadays).
The Secret Ingredient is a sweet book about two high school sweethearts who go on different paths soon before getting married and end up seeing each other again 7 years later. This, of course, leads to them re-thinking their lives and the choices they've made. Their struggles culminate in a bake-off in New York, in which, unknowingly, they are competing against each other.
It was all very cute and fun to read, and I thoroughly enjoyed the lengthy descriptions of cakes and other sweets and pastries. My god, I've never craved cake as much. So much so, in fact, that I went and bought cake! And I don't even like desserts that much.
On the other hand, I had an issue with the book which basically boiled down to my distaste for a live not lived. I am well aware that this is a personal view, but I do admit that it influenced the reading process for me. What I mean is that I've never been contended with staying in my hometown, never travelling, never seeing the world, never experiencing any of the things that the world has to offer, and the world is a huge place. I know that many people think this is the perfect life and I'm not going to contradict their own feelings, but to me it seems a bit ignorant to never even try to see the magnificent things there are out there. Which is basically what Kelly does the entire book, and she is made out to seem like the good guy, while Andrew is blamed time and again that he left for Paris to become a chef. The other characters good-heartedly mock him for being a "big shot"and "an important chef", as if it's a bad thing that he wanted to try more than his small town was offering him. This really frustrated me, because if you really think about it, if all people believed that this was the proper thing to do - stay at home and try to make it work with what you have, I wouldn't even be able to write this review or read this book, because why would I even need to learn English, when I speak my own language, Bulgarian, perfectly well.
Lastly, and this is a question here: do people really speak like this with their families in America?
"I'm experimenting with a few new flavors (...)"
"I'm sure it will be wonderful," Mom said. "Everything you make always is."
"Thank you for always encouraging me. I love you. You're the best mom a girl could as for."
I'm not joking. I'm Eastern European, we're not that affectionate.
February 10, 2019
I've been a fan of Nancy Naigle since I read her very first book. She is my go-to author for sweet romances. The Secret Ingredient was a second chance romance, which happens to be one of my favorite troupes. I adored getting Kelly and Andrew's story in The Secret Ingredient.
Kelly McIntyre and Andrew York were engaged 7 years ago when Andrew is given the opportunity of a life time to study in Paris and he decides to stay after graduation. All their dreams of opening a restaurant together and marriage and family come to an end when Andrew stays in Paris. When Andrew comes home for a surprise visit 7 years later, he honestly only wanted to see his family, yet everything changes when his mom and sister give him a surprise welcome home party and Kelly is in charge of all the desserts.
Kelly has lived her dream back in their hometown by opening her own bakery called The Cake Factory. Kelly has become a huge success in her business and has helped Bailey 's Fork have a booming economy. Her bakery has allowed her to employ 100 full time bakers and helped other businesses in town. When Kelly is approached to participate in Valentine's Cake-bakeoff, she quickly agrees, not knowing that is the real reason Andrew is back in the states. None of the contestants can let anyone know where they are really going for the secret bake-off, or they will be immediately eliminated from the contest. I enjoyed seeing Andrew and Kelly reconnect before they both headed to New York for the bakeoff. There was such a sweet connection between them.
Most of the story does take place in their small hometown, and Ms. Naigle does an amazing job making the small town and the people in the town come to life. I loved seeing how the town had grown and changed while Andrew was gone and yet was completely welcoming to him when he returned. I find that the small town in a Nancy Naigle book becomes another character in the story right along side the people. I did love seeing both Kelly and Andrew in the baking competition. They had such different training, with Andrew's being from professional chefs in Paris, and Kelly's being from her grandmother, yet were both rockstars when it came to coming up with amazing ideas.
The Secret Ingredient was such a wonderful sweet romance. The small town setting was absolutely perfect for the story and I loved the crazy fun trip to New York every bit as much as I enjoyed the time in the small town. Kelly and Andrew were so much fun to see grow and mature over the course of the story not only as individuals but as a couple. The Secret Ingredient is another winner from Nancy Naigle.
Rating: 4 Stars (B+)
Review copy provided by publisher
Kelly McIntyre and Andrew York were engaged 7 years ago when Andrew is given the opportunity of a life time to study in Paris and he decides to stay after graduation. All their dreams of opening a restaurant together and marriage and family come to an end when Andrew stays in Paris. When Andrew comes home for a surprise visit 7 years later, he honestly only wanted to see his family, yet everything changes when his mom and sister give him a surprise welcome home party and Kelly is in charge of all the desserts.
Kelly has lived her dream back in their hometown by opening her own bakery called The Cake Factory. Kelly has become a huge success in her business and has helped Bailey 's Fork have a booming economy. Her bakery has allowed her to employ 100 full time bakers and helped other businesses in town. When Kelly is approached to participate in Valentine's Cake-bakeoff, she quickly agrees, not knowing that is the real reason Andrew is back in the states. None of the contestants can let anyone know where they are really going for the secret bake-off, or they will be immediately eliminated from the contest. I enjoyed seeing Andrew and Kelly reconnect before they both headed to New York for the bakeoff. There was such a sweet connection between them.
Most of the story does take place in their small hometown, and Ms. Naigle does an amazing job making the small town and the people in the town come to life. I loved seeing how the town had grown and changed while Andrew was gone and yet was completely welcoming to him when he returned. I find that the small town in a Nancy Naigle book becomes another character in the story right along side the people. I did love seeing both Kelly and Andrew in the baking competition. They had such different training, with Andrew's being from professional chefs in Paris, and Kelly's being from her grandmother, yet were both rockstars when it came to coming up with amazing ideas.
The Secret Ingredient was such a wonderful sweet romance. The small town setting was absolutely perfect for the story and I loved the crazy fun trip to New York every bit as much as I enjoyed the time in the small town. Kelly and Andrew were so much fun to see grow and mature over the course of the story not only as individuals but as a couple. The Secret Ingredient is another winner from Nancy Naigle.
Rating: 4 Stars (B+)
Review copy provided by publisher
February 20, 2019
I’m fairly new to Nancy Naigle’s work, having only read one other book by her. But, that said, let me tell you this: she is amazing! Having the chance to read this delicious novel was so fun! I loved her writing style, the hope and the characters that are woven together, all of it! It was a phenomenal read!
Andrew and Kelly’s characters were awesome. I loved the way they were chiseled, and seeing them interact together really played out like it was a movie on the Hallmark channel. I truly love when a book can do that!
Andrew’s character was my favorite. I loved how he developed throughout the story, and seeing how things were when he returned home. Though I’ll be honest. I wasn’t sure what to think of his breaking their engagement and traveling away. I wanted to shake him! But, I also saw how it needed to be like that to full feel the emotions of these awesome characters, to fully understand that it needed to be done so he could understand his true feelings.
This is most definitely a 4 star novel that I should high praises to. Andrew and Kelly needed just one thing from Naigle for this book……just one secret ingredient……..and she did it beautifully! Well done, Naigle. This is a keeper book on my shelf and I can’t wait to read more of your work!
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and was under no obligation to post a review, positive or negative.*
Andrew and Kelly’s characters were awesome. I loved the way they were chiseled, and seeing them interact together really played out like it was a movie on the Hallmark channel. I truly love when a book can do that!
Andrew’s character was my favorite. I loved how he developed throughout the story, and seeing how things were when he returned home. Though I’ll be honest. I wasn’t sure what to think of his breaking their engagement and traveling away. I wanted to shake him! But, I also saw how it needed to be like that to full feel the emotions of these awesome characters, to fully understand that it needed to be done so he could understand his true feelings.
This is most definitely a 4 star novel that I should high praises to. Andrew and Kelly needed just one thing from Naigle for this book……just one secret ingredient……..and she did it beautifully! Well done, Naigle. This is a keeper book on my shelf and I can’t wait to read more of your work!
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and was under no obligation to post a review, positive or negative.*
January 3, 2019
Small town romance, characters so well described and second chances. What's not to like?
Nancy Naigle has done it again with a book so engrossing you'll be sad to see it end. 5+ stars!
Nancy Naigle has done it again with a book so engrossing you'll be sad to see it end. 5+ stars!
February 12, 2019
In honor of Valentine's Day this week, I thought it would be fun to review a Hallmark story! If you love baking shows or baking competitions, you will LOVE this book. I am not a baker and I really don't love baking AT ALL but I sure wish I had someone to bake all these yummy sounding desserts for me- especially the Almond Honey Cake with Strawberry Cream. That was the main event dessert of the book and it sounds delish! The recipe is included with the book so if anyone wants to try it out and bring it over to me, that would be awesome and appreciated! 😋😀🍰
I can see why this book is from Hallmark! It has all the feel good elements to it that Hallmark is known for. I could easily picture this book as a movie. Kelly and Andrew have a second chance at first love. I love that Kelly went on to fulfill all her dreams without Andrew and has made a huge name for herself doing what she loves. She is a strong woman and a kind woman as well. She handled all situations with grace and class. She was very easy to like. Andrew? It took time for him to win me over because I am a girl who doesn't trust easily and he was not good to Kelly. He had a lot to prove. By the end he had mostly won me over. 😉
This was an easy reading, heartwarming, love story. Sometimes the details of all the baking became tedious and a bit long to me, but overall, I really enjoyed this story.
Content: kissing
- I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
I can see why this book is from Hallmark! It has all the feel good elements to it that Hallmark is known for. I could easily picture this book as a movie. Kelly and Andrew have a second chance at first love. I love that Kelly went on to fulfill all her dreams without Andrew and has made a huge name for herself doing what she loves. She is a strong woman and a kind woman as well. She handled all situations with grace and class. She was very easy to like. Andrew? It took time for him to win me over because I am a girl who doesn't trust easily and he was not good to Kelly. He had a lot to prove. By the end he had mostly won me over. 😉
This was an easy reading, heartwarming, love story. Sometimes the details of all the baking became tedious and a bit long to me, but overall, I really enjoyed this story.
Content: kissing
- I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
December 25, 2018
Nancy Naigle's newest, The Secret Ingredient is such a great read. Protagonists Kelly McIntyre and Andrew York begin the story as waitress and cook in a family owned restaurant. They have recently become engaged and are so much in love that working together in a small cafe is a love affair. Andrew has taught himself most of the art of cooking but he and Kelly have worked together on baking pastries and developing new recipes. In late summer Andrew's Aunt Claire has called from Paris with an invitation for him to be enrolled in a 6 month program to study at a renowned school in Paris. He could stay in her carriage house it truly was an opportunity he could not pass on. Although he preferred studying to become a chef he thought this would be a foot in the door. He and Kelly felt that although they would be apart, it is only 6 months and he would be home. They could marry and she could work on further developing her plan to open a cake shop.
As things sometimes go, Andrew did so well he was fortunate to be offered to study under a renowned Chef Francois who owned several restaurants throughout France. He took that opportunity, Kelly did not want to relocate to France. Her home was in Bailey's Fork, North Carolina. Her folks were there and she was going to own a business there, end of story or so she thought.
The novel is a delight. I was up late finishing it as it was just too good to put down. I thank Hallmark her publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read Ms. Naigle's book before it is published in February of 2019.
As things sometimes go, Andrew did so well he was fortunate to be offered to study under a renowned Chef Francois who owned several restaurants throughout France. He took that opportunity, Kelly did not want to relocate to France. Her home was in Bailey's Fork, North Carolina. Her folks were there and she was going to own a business there, end of story or so she thought.
The novel is a delight. I was up late finishing it as it was just too good to put down. I thank Hallmark her publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read Ms. Naigle's book before it is published in February of 2019.
December 14, 2018
The Secret Ingredient by Nancy Naigle. Such a wonderful Hallmark love story. This book will make you hungry for dessert. I loved the descriptions you can really imagine what the cakes look like. Read the Secret Ingredient by Nancy Naigle. What more could you want chocolate, candy flowers and a proposal on Valentines Day.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 19, 2018
This delightful story quickly drew me in and kept me turning the pages until the very end. There were so many unique elements of the story to keep you invested in the outcome of Kelly and Andrew’s journey to rediscovering their once upon a time HEA. The ending is definitely not predictable which only made the story that more of a five star read. This book has been added to the list of the many books I’ve enjoyed by this author and read again.
This ARC book was complimentary, provided by the Publisher and NetGalley. I am voluntarily providing my honest review.
This ARC book was complimentary, provided by the Publisher and NetGalley. I am voluntarily providing my honest review.
January 13, 2019
Sweet and comforting- this book tops the cake! Blend delightful characters, a charming town, a few surprises and voila!- a tasty treat for readers.
Author Nancy Naigle has created a lovely character in Kelly McIntyre. Kelly is a hometown girl from Bailey’s Fork, North Carolina who likes to bake little treats and dream big. Her boyfriend Alex York seemed to share her vision of life in Bailey’s Fork. As young lovers, they were the kind who carved their initials in the town tree. Their future would be a piece of cake! Until…Alex went in a different direction…to Paris to study under a master chef.
Kelly waited for Alex to come home, but when the story begins, seven years have gone by, and Kelly is in Bailey’s Fork and Alex is still in Paris. Kelly is living her dreams and opened The Cake Factory. Her creative use of flavors has made her famous. She has her own house and loves her pet pig, GRAY (which stands for Good Riddance Alex York.) GRAY is one of the stars of the book!
Life changes when Alex gets an opportunity in New York City, so he flies in from Paris a few days early and decides to visit his hometown. He needs to mend some fences with his family, and even though he wanted to avoid her, he begins to rekindle his feelings for Kelly. She insists things are over. Is there anything that can bring them together? Well, sometimes, you need a sweet reminder.
As much as I loved Kelly- a pretty, friendly young woman with talent and business sense, the first part of the book was a bit slow. But, then the most exciting thing happens, and the second part of the book is a delight. No spoilers- but there is a Valentine’s Day Bake-Off.
Will Kelly and Alex finally learn the recipe for a good relationship and marriage? Is there a secret ingredient? (Did you know that James Thurber said, “The most dangerous food is wedding cake.”)
This book is scrumptious. You will be served characters that become your friends, a town that would be fun to visit, and even inspiration to bake creatively. There are added layers of sweet treats in this book as well, as we also get to know Kelly and Alex’s family and friends.
The icing on this “cake”? There’s a Recipe for Triple Layer Honey Almond Cake with Berries and Mascarpone Crème Fraiche, a Hallmark Original Recipe. Showstopper! Highly recommend.
I received an ARC from Hallmark Publishing and this is my honest review.
Author Nancy Naigle has created a lovely character in Kelly McIntyre. Kelly is a hometown girl from Bailey’s Fork, North Carolina who likes to bake little treats and dream big. Her boyfriend Alex York seemed to share her vision of life in Bailey’s Fork. As young lovers, they were the kind who carved their initials in the town tree. Their future would be a piece of cake! Until…Alex went in a different direction…to Paris to study under a master chef.
Kelly waited for Alex to come home, but when the story begins, seven years have gone by, and Kelly is in Bailey’s Fork and Alex is still in Paris. Kelly is living her dreams and opened The Cake Factory. Her creative use of flavors has made her famous. She has her own house and loves her pet pig, GRAY (which stands for Good Riddance Alex York.) GRAY is one of the stars of the book!
Life changes when Alex gets an opportunity in New York City, so he flies in from Paris a few days early and decides to visit his hometown. He needs to mend some fences with his family, and even though he wanted to avoid her, he begins to rekindle his feelings for Kelly. She insists things are over. Is there anything that can bring them together? Well, sometimes, you need a sweet reminder.
As much as I loved Kelly- a pretty, friendly young woman with talent and business sense, the first part of the book was a bit slow. But, then the most exciting thing happens, and the second part of the book is a delight. No spoilers- but there is a Valentine’s Day Bake-Off.
Will Kelly and Alex finally learn the recipe for a good relationship and marriage? Is there a secret ingredient? (Did you know that James Thurber said, “The most dangerous food is wedding cake.”)
This book is scrumptious. You will be served characters that become your friends, a town that would be fun to visit, and even inspiration to bake creatively. There are added layers of sweet treats in this book as well, as we also get to know Kelly and Alex’s family and friends.
The icing on this “cake”? There’s a Recipe for Triple Layer Honey Almond Cake with Berries and Mascarpone Crème Fraiche, a Hallmark Original Recipe. Showstopper! Highly recommend.
I received an ARC from Hallmark Publishing and this is my honest review.
December 25, 2018
Wonderful story about second chance love! Kelly & Andrew had their lives planned out. Get married & Andrew would run the cafe while Kelly did all the baking. Then Andrew received the chance of a lifetime. He won a scholarship to go to Paris & study. They both agreed he had to go. The problem is that he went & never came back. Now, seven years later, he’s come home for a short visit & is questioning everything he’s accomplished & what he had to give up to get there.
I really enjoyed this story & its characters. Kelly channeled her pain & anger into her career. Even though she didn’t have the fancy schooling & never left her hometown, she’s become quite a success. In some ways, she’s a bigger success than Andrew with his schooling & work in Paris. I loved that her pet is not a typical pet & is named Gray. That was a fantastic symbol. This was set around Valentine’s Day & is a great love story.
I really enjoyed this story & its characters. Kelly channeled her pain & anger into her career. Even though she didn’t have the fancy schooling & never left her hometown, she’s become quite a success. In some ways, she’s a bigger success than Andrew with his schooling & work in Paris. I loved that her pet is not a typical pet & is named Gray. That was a fantastic symbol. This was set around Valentine’s Day & is a great love story.
February 12, 2019
A heartwarming second chance romance that will delight all.Andrew and Kelly had their lives planned out, both being chefs until Andrew got a chance to go to culinary school in Paris. Fast forward seven years, Andrew has finally returned home for a visit. Kelly has opened her own bakery, which has flourished. Upon Andrew's return home he is realizing what's missing in his life, his one true love Kelly. Unbeknownst to each other they are competing in a Valentine's Day bake off.
This is book that I could not put down, makes you warm all over. Loved Kelly and Andrew, so perfect for each other. The secondary character of Gray, Kelly's potbellied pig. His name was just perfect!! If you have a sweet tooth this will be the perfect read for you, it made me hungry!! I believe this would be the perfect Hallmark movie!! I highly recommend.
This is book that I could not put down, makes you warm all over. Loved Kelly and Andrew, so perfect for each other. The secondary character of Gray, Kelly's potbellied pig. His name was just perfect!! If you have a sweet tooth this will be the perfect read for you, it made me hungry!! I believe this would be the perfect Hallmark movie!! I highly recommend.
March 20, 2019
It's Nancy Naigle, enough said
The Secret Ingredient is a marvelous, fast moving, fast-food tale! It is amazing how Nancy Naigle can give us what we expect and yet constantly give us the unexpected.
The Secret Ingredient is a marvelous, fast moving, fast-food tale! It is amazing how Nancy Naigle can give us what we expect and yet constantly give us the unexpected.
March 25, 2019
First off, I love when books have recipes that are delicious. Second, who coukd go wrong with a Hallmark book? I love the clean writing, the witty characters, and the charming setting. Plus, an adorable, mischievous pig throw in, justvsteals the cake!! A must read!!
December 13, 2021
Is the secret ingredient garbage?! Because this book was full of it.
January 30, 2019
Hallmark Publishing, please tell Hallmark Movies that we need to have this book made into a movie now! A fresh idea with a delightful, heartwarming take on second-chance romance, this one hits the heart in the best of ways. I loved every part of this book, down to the tiniest details, and hated to see it end!
Andrew and Kelly had big plans for their small-town life together. He may be a cook at Kelly's parents' diner where Kelly is a waitress, but with his skills in the kitchen and her talent for baking, they plan to open their own restaurant one day. Recently engaged with a wedding a year away, Andrew gets the opportunity to study under one of the best pastry chefs in France. Then somehow, six months away from home turns into seven years, and Andrew returns home for a short visit on his way to New York City. His emotions are scattered as he discovers that, not only has Kelly made her dreams come true without him, but her cake factory is well known across the country and a vital part of the community by employing locals and revitalizing Main Street.
Naigle gives us one of the most clever plot twists I've ever seen that has Andrew and Kelly unknowingly competing against each other in the midst of their getting reacquainted, healing old hurts and rekindling their old love. In spite of the developments being predictable, since the reader is in on the secret, this book had me fully involved and reading eagerly to devour the details. We've all likely watched baking competitions on television, but this competition was far more exciting and effortlessly held me captive every step of the way, and all without commercial interruptions.
With a little of everything, this book has something to offer any reader. Phenomenal descriptions of baked goods so vibrant you can taste them. A sweet but angsty romance between admirable, endearing characters with great chemistry while still maintaining a Hallmark rating. Colorful, loveable secondary characters who can’t help but interfere (thankfully). A fresh twist on an old trope with plenty of action and excitement to keep the reader riveted to the page. And let's not forget Grey, the teacup pig with a hog-sized personality. You’re sure to find a lot to love in this delightful, humorous, heartwarming read!
*I reviewed an advance copy of this book freely and voluntarily, having made no commitment to provide a review and receiving no compensation of any kind from any source for this review.
Andrew and Kelly had big plans for their small-town life together. He may be a cook at Kelly's parents' diner where Kelly is a waitress, but with his skills in the kitchen and her talent for baking, they plan to open their own restaurant one day. Recently engaged with a wedding a year away, Andrew gets the opportunity to study under one of the best pastry chefs in France. Then somehow, six months away from home turns into seven years, and Andrew returns home for a short visit on his way to New York City. His emotions are scattered as he discovers that, not only has Kelly made her dreams come true without him, but her cake factory is well known across the country and a vital part of the community by employing locals and revitalizing Main Street.
Naigle gives us one of the most clever plot twists I've ever seen that has Andrew and Kelly unknowingly competing against each other in the midst of their getting reacquainted, healing old hurts and rekindling their old love. In spite of the developments being predictable, since the reader is in on the secret, this book had me fully involved and reading eagerly to devour the details. We've all likely watched baking competitions on television, but this competition was far more exciting and effortlessly held me captive every step of the way, and all without commercial interruptions.
With a little of everything, this book has something to offer any reader. Phenomenal descriptions of baked goods so vibrant you can taste them. A sweet but angsty romance between admirable, endearing characters with great chemistry while still maintaining a Hallmark rating. Colorful, loveable secondary characters who can’t help but interfere (thankfully). A fresh twist on an old trope with plenty of action and excitement to keep the reader riveted to the page. And let's not forget Grey, the teacup pig with a hog-sized personality. You’re sure to find a lot to love in this delightful, humorous, heartwarming read!
*I reviewed an advance copy of this book freely and voluntarily, having made no commitment to provide a review and receiving no compensation of any kind from any source for this review.
March 2, 2019
The Secret ingredient is the latest book by Nancy Naigle. Kelly McIntyre had her heart broken by former fiancé Andrew York when he chose the opportunities offered him at French cooking schools while staying with his aunt who lived there. Andrew has done well. In fact, so well he hasn’t been home in 7 years.
Meanwhile in those 7 years, Kelly has followed the dreams they had made together. Although not formally trained, she has not only opened her own bakery, but has also opened a very successful internet presence for her baked goods. She has purchased the dilapidated buildings adjacent to her parent’s Main Street cafe, turning it from an eyesore to her factory and profitable rentals, bringing jobs and renewal to downtown Bailey’s Fork, NC.
The tv food competition Four Square is about to hold their big Valentines bake-off. Chefs from all over have been nominated. Chef Andrew and master baker Kelly have both been tapped but neither knows the other one was. All participants are sworn to secrecy. Before the challenge begins the first week of February, Andrew, unannounced, comes home to Bailey’s Fork to see his family. They are so excited to see him and sister Dawn throws a party to welcome Andrew home. Dawn is sure to order desserts and service from Kelly so that Andrew and Kelly can cross paths. And Dawn is sure to make this happen even more.
Meanwhile, the producers from the competition pay a special visit to Kelly in her bakery. She is in the company of her assistant and friend, Sara, when the offer is made to her to compete. She is sworn to secrecy but at least has her friend in on the ruse.
Both parties head to NYC for the exciting competition. The conclusion is unexpected and the fun of the story will make the reader smile. I did enjoy this book and I do recommend it!
Meanwhile in those 7 years, Kelly has followed the dreams they had made together. Although not formally trained, she has not only opened her own bakery, but has also opened a very successful internet presence for her baked goods. She has purchased the dilapidated buildings adjacent to her parent’s Main Street cafe, turning it from an eyesore to her factory and profitable rentals, bringing jobs and renewal to downtown Bailey’s Fork, NC.
The tv food competition Four Square is about to hold their big Valentines bake-off. Chefs from all over have been nominated. Chef Andrew and master baker Kelly have both been tapped but neither knows the other one was. All participants are sworn to secrecy. Before the challenge begins the first week of February, Andrew, unannounced, comes home to Bailey’s Fork to see his family. They are so excited to see him and sister Dawn throws a party to welcome Andrew home. Dawn is sure to order desserts and service from Kelly so that Andrew and Kelly can cross paths. And Dawn is sure to make this happen even more.
Meanwhile, the producers from the competition pay a special visit to Kelly in her bakery. She is in the company of her assistant and friend, Sara, when the offer is made to her to compete. She is sworn to secrecy but at least has her friend in on the ruse.
Both parties head to NYC for the exciting competition. The conclusion is unexpected and the fun of the story will make the reader smile. I did enjoy this book and I do recommend it!
December 16, 2019
I'm a big fan of romances in the kitchen; baking or cooking or restaurants. This was a sweet second-chance romance between high school sweethearts. It had been many years since their break up. Kelly remained in their hometown, growing her pastry business to enhance her parents' restaurant--a restaurant that Andrew was once expected to take over as a short-order cook. However, Andrew is encouraged to go to Paris to study under a pastry chef--and the implication is that Andrew's parents intended for him to go far away from the notion of marrying right out of high school. While everyone didn't seem opposed to Andrew and Kelly's union, it seemed like they were accepting of their relationship as fully established adults, which seemed unfair and meddlesome.
While the couple had a chance to come together after brief introductions of their lives after their break up, there were points where it was almost too saccharine-ey sweet: lots of 'I love you's and "forgiveness" that felt contrived, especially during competition. Despite knowing each other for years, I felt the couple should have spent time getting to know their adult selves, especially after spending the latter half of the book apart.
As expected from a Hallmark Romance novel, the couple found their happily ever after. Lovers of sweet romance will enjoy this tale and the many descriptors of baking and a reality show competition.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this novel in exchange for an honest review.
While the couple had a chance to come together after brief introductions of their lives after their break up, there were points where it was almost too saccharine-ey sweet: lots of 'I love you's and "forgiveness" that felt contrived, especially during competition. Despite knowing each other for years, I felt the couple should have spent time getting to know their adult selves, especially after spending the latter half of the book apart.
As expected from a Hallmark Romance novel, the couple found their happily ever after. Lovers of sweet romance will enjoy this tale and the many descriptors of baking and a reality show competition.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this novel in exchange for an honest review.
November 19, 2019
There were huge chunks where I REALLY got into this book and other moments when I couldn't care less. Having just read Christmas in Evergreen I was ready to give Nancy Naigle another go (I mean I have been on a Hallmark kick lately) and this one wasn't Christmas themed (although with the snow on the cover it could have been holiday themed.... and speaking of the cover - whoever photo-shopped the cake on the cover... shame on you! It's awful!). Kelly and her fiance called it off years ago after he went to Paris to take a baking class and never returned. She fulfilled "their" dream of opening a very successful bakery all on her own and without that dumbass. Seven years later, old feelings return when Andrew comes back home to visit. Maybe they should have tried to make it work. Is it too late now? Things will get even trickier though when they find out their both competing on the same baking show. Do old wounds ever heal. Cheesy as all get out and super predictable. I dd however love all the baking show bits. That was fun and made me VERY HUNGRY while listening to the audiobook!
December 8, 2023
3.5 stars, rounded up
I have read several of this author's books and have found that they're romance books that don't turn my stomach like so many romance books do. (Reminder: I prefer mysteries and thrillers, so the romance genre is not high up on my list!) Her books are *not full of either syrupy sweetness or explicit sex scenes, which is a major plus in my book.
Kelly and Andrew, the main characters, are realistic people with realistic backgrounds and dreams. Their families are involved and supportive, a nice change of pace from the "she has no one in her corner" stories. Andrew is not a pastry chef, so his invitation to compete in the bake-off seems a little contrived, but it had to happen to advance the story. The ending was done well, so I wasn't too bothered by its predictability.
Until I'm disappointed by one of Ms. Naigle's books, I'll continue to read them when I need/want a sweet, feel-good romance.
I have read several of this author's books and have found that they're romance books that don't turn my stomach like so many romance books do. (Reminder: I prefer mysteries and thrillers, so the romance genre is not high up on my list!) Her books are *not full of either syrupy sweetness or explicit sex scenes, which is a major plus in my book.
Kelly and Andrew, the main characters, are realistic people with realistic backgrounds and dreams. Their families are involved and supportive, a nice change of pace from the "she has no one in her corner" stories. Andrew is not a pastry chef, so his invitation to compete in the bake-off seems a little contrived, but it had to happen to advance the story. The ending was done well, so I wasn't too bothered by its predictability.
Until I'm disappointed by one of Ms. Naigle's books, I'll continue to read them when I need/want a sweet, feel-good romance.
February 8, 2019
Previously engaged, when Andrew returns to his hometown and sees Kelly, the feelings are still there. Still hurt, Kelly slowly accepts his friendship, after all, he's leaving again. The heart wants more, could this be a second chance?
A secret opportunity of a lifetime falls into Kelly's lap, and she's off to New York before they can talk of a future. A chance meeting in the city leads to a night of dinner. At the finale, it's revealed they are competing against each other. Serendipity. In it together, only one can win, and each has plans for the prize. Who has the secret ingredient to take it all?
A sweet, second chance romance, with baked goods, a pig named Gray, and most importantly: Love!
**I received an ARC from NetGalley.**
A secret opportunity of a lifetime falls into Kelly's lap, and she's off to New York before they can talk of a future. A chance meeting in the city leads to a night of dinner. At the finale, it's revealed they are competing against each other. Serendipity. In it together, only one can win, and each has plans for the prize. Who has the secret ingredient to take it all?
A sweet, second chance romance, with baked goods, a pig named Gray, and most importantly: Love!
**I received an ARC from NetGalley.**
Displaying 1 - 30 of 247 reviews