𝑾𝒊𝒏𝒅𝒔 𝒐𝒇 𝑪𝒉𝒂𝒏𝒈𝒆, Alastair Stone Chronicles, Book 27
by R. L. King
This episode of the Stone Chronicles was loaded! Almost every character from the previous 26 books at least had a mention. There was action galore, and, for me, anyway, a lot of it had Stone working on his own, rather than depending wholly on help from both his mundane and magical friends. Don't get me wrong, he included those friends in the action a lot -- but it was also nice to see him making decisions (right or wrong) on his own.
The proofing/editing was excellent, with only one problem noted. At location 4851 on my Kindle Fire, there was this slight proofing error: "He pictured Ian lying on the side of injured on the side of a road somewhere." Oops. But that was it. No grammar errors, no misspellings that I noticed, and the plotting and pacing were also spot on. My only complaint, and what made a difference between the 4 stars I rated this book and the 5 I would have liked to rate it.
MAJOR SPOILERS MAY FOLLOW:
If you haven't read this book, and plan to, you should probably stop reading now.
A few months ago, the author noted on the Chronicles Facebook page that this book would end on a cliffhanger. If you read my reviews, you know for me a cliffhanger is the kiss of death for a 5-star rating. I told her I would be knocking off a star, as I do for every other author I follow when they end a book without ending the plot issues. I had decided not to read this until #28 comes out in December, but a few days after posting that this would end on a cliffhanger, she posted again that she had reviewed the ending and decided it really wasn't much of a cliffhanger as all the book's loose ends were tied up. So, being the trusting fool, er, fan, that I am, I read #27 as soon as I could.
Sigh. Problem is, the author evidently does not know what a cliffhanger is. Here's what was and wasn't tied up:
1. Aubrey and Susan were married -- yep, that end was tied up.
2. The issue of "the changing" was not tied up. Yes, Stone closed the rift that he thought might be the cause of the changing, but it was never said that was the actual cause, nor was the issue of whether the change definitely would be permanent. Yes, Stone was willing to consider the issue ended, but with the widespread occurrences, there was really no way to know for sure. So this plot issue has more than one loose end.
3. Where are all the dragons? The only one he could find was Gabriel, a scion like himself, and Aldwyn, who found Stone rather than the other way around.
4. Where was Ian? We know he was kidnapped, and the evidence seemed to say that he was in another dimension, but that dimension was never identified.
5. The book ends with Stone accepting help from Aldwyn (reluctantly, and without knowing exactly what the cost of such help would be) in finding and rescuing Ian. When he arrives at the place (and different dimension?) where Ian was, he discovers that a) Aldwyn was the one who kidnapped Ian, and that, unlike what was promised by Aldwyn, when Stone activated the spell to return them both home, it only took Ian, leaving Stone alone in a place he had no information on, and, to be truthful, not knowing whether the spell took Ian home or to some other place where Aldwyn could hold him in order to coerce cooperation from Stone.
I don't know about anyone else, but that all seems like a hell of a lot more than not much of a cliffhanger. I didn't even mention Amber's accident, and whether that was an accident, or some other machinations of Stone's enemies. I'm still debating whether to take off another star from the review, just because I feel lied to. I don't like being lied to.