3/5
Missing the spark the first one had, and doesn't progress the story in any meaningful way
After being pleasantly surprised by The Black Coast, I was ready to love this one. But for me, this just wasn't enough. I was ready for the plot to really get started, but so much of this felt like filler, and after over a thousand total pages over these two books, I'm shocked that I don't feel like I really know or care about these characters. Not a bad book at all, the world is still great and the action is fun, but this was ultimately a letdown for me.
I don't have too much to say about the plot except that 90% of it felt like filler. Saw somewhere that this is going to be a trilogy, and if so, this suffers from severe middle book syndrome. Some of the events that this ended with, were events that I was expecting at the beginning. All of the characters have their own little sidequests, which I really hope is building up to something in book three, but most of the storylines felt wasted and unimportant to the overall plot. The ending also felt forced, especially with the focus suddenly coming back to the Black Keep after they were absent for most of the book, in a kind of poor attempt to recreate the last battle in the first book. I just think for a sequel, this did next to nothing to advance the story.
In my review of the first book, I didn't have a lot to say about the characters, and I'm sad to say that I still don't. I was expecting to get to know these characters better, but I'm still not invested in them. Sure, I like some of them, like Saana, Daimon, Marin and Zal, but I wouldn't say I'm that invested in them. Each character's chapters are usually short, which makes them much easier to get through and much more action-packed, but the downside to that is that I just couldn't get attached to any of them. Coupled with the fact that each character's "side quest" felt so unimportant, led me to be bored for the majority of this.
Most of my praise of the first book was for the world. The world is still excellent, and I like the differences between these peoples, but it felt like after the freshness and uniqueness of the first book kind of wore off. I'm now used to this world, and as a result, it's not as interesting to me. I don't exactly know how to explain it, but my favorite part about The Black Coat was how it its different cultures and peoples combined with their different world views to create interesting conflict. That was largely absent here, and the dynamic between the Naridans and Tjakorshi people is still here, but underutilized. So, in summary, the best things about the first book just weren't as good in this one. That might be because the uniqueness has worn off for me, or that it doesn't use its strengths as well in this sequel, or a combination of the two.
Overall, this was a disappointment after how much I enjoyed the first book. This isn't a bad book at all, but I think it needed to do more than it did, and these characters are still not living up to their potential. This ends on several cliffhangers, so I'm still going to check out the third one.