English poet Gerald Massey was quoted as saying:
“Not by appointment do we meet delight or joy; they heed not our expectancy; but round some corner of the streets of life they of a sudden greet us with a smile.”
It was in late November 2017 that I walked into my local Indigo store and while I was there browsing the shelves a certain book cover caught my eye. The cover was exquisitely designed with many of the classic gothic styles: the Victorian wrought iron gate in the foreground, the distant, eerie manor house on the other side, the inky shadows of the overgrown grounds and best of all the title of the book adorned in antique gilt lettering. Looking at cover, I already got the sense of being pulled into an enticing, savory and dark tale.
The book was “Black Rabbit Hall” by Eve Chase.
I brought the book home, began reading, and over the course of the next ten days found myself suspended between the world of my daily routines and the mysterious and otherworldly place called Pencraw Hall. A place where one timeline tangles into another, a place that moves at its own chosen pace. I quickly came to care about the enduring characters and found myself imagining what would happen to them, even when I wasn’t reading the book itself.
“Black Rabbit Hall” was the best book I read this year. And that’s saying a lot because I read a few others that I really liked. If Massey were here, he’d probably say that this confirms what he said: when I walked into the bookstore that day there’s no way I could have predicted that I would discover delight and joy on the shelves. How could I know that I would discover one of my all-time favorite stories that day? I’ve read hundreds of novels, this one is firmly planted in my top three of all time.
I was so thrilled with “Black Rabbit Hall” that I dashed out to purchase “The Wildling Sisters” in hard cover. I was planning to begin reading it in a couple weeks, so I unwisely lend the book to another person who wanted to read it, and unfortunately I never saw it again. I recently went back to the bookstore and found a paperback edition (last copy) of “The Wildling Sisters.” I brought the book home to read, but have to admit feeling some anxiety. “Black Rabbit Hall” was so good, could Chase’s next in line possibly be as good? I didn’t have to read very far before I had my answer.
“The Wilding Sisters” story, like “Black Rabbit Hall” is told in two timelines, about fifty years between them, and also like “Black Rabbit Hall” Chase writes the timelines in such a way that each are distinct standalones, and yet interwoven, dependent on each other at the same time.
One timeline taking place in the modern day, tells us the story of Will Tucker, a widower who lost his wife Mandy in a tragic car crash, leaving him and his 11 year old daughter Bella lost in grief. The sudden privation of a loving mother understandably leaves Bella “clinging to her father’s hand as if he were the last human left on earth.
Sometime after Mandy’s passing, Will meets Jessie, and a year and a half later she finds herself pregnant with his child. Despite this significant change in situation, Jessie tries to maintain some form of independence by maintaining her own home. Jessie is concerned about how Bella, a teenager by now, will react to this new woman living under the same roof as her and her father, trying to take the place of her late mother. It turns out that Bella chooses to make it clear that she isn’t interested in making things easy or comfortable for Jessie. Time moves on and eventually it is the practical necessities that take over. Jessie is finding it increasingly difficult to be pregnant and, at the same time, maintain a household completely on her own. On top of this, Will does his best to entice her to take the plunge and move in with them. To convince her he speaks from his heart by telling her that he doesn’t want to waste another minute of his life without her, “I need you, we need you Jessie” he says.
Will’s appeal is successful, Jessie moves in and six months later they welcome their new girl Rory. Shortly after Rory’s birth, Will and Jessie seem to come to a mutual conclusion - one that can be summed up in the words of Kate Winslet when she said, “The countryside is very good for my head.” They come to believe that a move from the noisy, bustling city to the quiet, tranquil countryside would be the best thing for everyone. Will secretly hopes that the peace he finds in the country will help push his nightmares about Mandy’s car accident away. Both Will and Jessie are hopeful that a more rural setting would remove Bella from some of the teenage social pressures weighing her down at a time when she’s still reeling the passing of her mother. Jessie, for her part, believes that if they move to the country she will have a fresh start chance at a better relationship with Bella as well as a healthier setting for Rory to grow up than in the city.
We first meet Jessie, Will, Bella and Rory, viewing a manor house they are considering for purchase. It’s probably not quite large enough to officially tag it as a manor house, but more than large enough for the four of them all the same. It’s also a “fixer-upper” which means there is a chance the house might be within their price range. The house, they learn, has traditionally been called “Applecoat.” Bella is now a sixteen year old, and Chase does an excellent job of helping us to visualize her:
“She’s slumped on the window seat, pecking out a text on her phone. A twist of too-long legs, and inky hair…she’s the striking spit of her dead mother. Sensing Jessie’s questioning gaze, she lifts her pale aquiline face, narrows her eyes to glossy pupil-filled cracks, and answers it with a fierce look of refusal.”
Three year old Rory, unlike her step-sister, is making herself right at home in this country house. She’s intently studying a snail as it crawls, she “giggles and looks up: Jessie sees her own pixie pretty features miniaturized…she grins back Rory’s delight as it quickly becomes her own.”
I thought Eve Chase chose an excellent setting to introduce the major players in this modern day scene. It allows us to see them out of their comfort zone and provides an opportunity for the individual aspects of the family dynamic to play out in an authentic and yet still intriguing way. As I read this scene, a family checking out a potential new home, I thought of how each member of my own family would respond. I think I can say quite easily that if someone were a fly on the wall as we toured a potential new home, they would get an accurate view of who we are and how we interact with one another. This would be especially true if we were not in complete agreement on the move itself, which is most definitely the case in the modern day timeline of “The Wildling Sisters.”
In the other timeline, we meet Bunny Wilde, the date is May of 1959 and she finds herself a woman at a crossroads. Bunny was widowed a number of years earlier when her husband, driving home, collides with an evening train. Apparently she then took up with a handsome, eccentric painter who eventually betrays her by finding a new muse, “Some Berkeley Dress Show model” Bunny regularly complains while sipping blood orange gin. She’s been a stage actress, finding the offers for roles diminishing as she enters her late-career phase.
Bunny has four daughters: Flora is seventeen, Pam sixteen, Margot fifteen and Dot is twelve years old. Bunny is finding it increasingly difficult to keep her four girls “in stockings, and hats and food” so when an overseas job offer arrives, she gathers her daughters together then shocks them by telling them she’s taking a job as a secretary at the foreign office counsel in Marrakesh, Morocco. Her friends, the Breamish’s have influence there, and knowing her plight offer her a job. But the four sisters are not done being collectively shocked. Bunny then informs them that they’ll be spending the summer at Applecoat Manor with their Aunt Sybil and Uncle Peregrine. All of the girls think exactly the same thing at exactly the same moment, “But what about Cousin Audrey?” They’ve all heard about the mournful pall that’s hung over Applecoat since the disappearance of their cousin Audrey five years ago. Audrey was Sybil and Peregrine’s only child and even as the girls are listening to their mom’s plans, they know that Applecoat will not be the same carefree and adventurous place that they once spent summers as girls. Before Audrey went missing.
This is the scene that sets the stage for a most shocking summer for the Wilde Sisters.
As the story proceeds, Eve Chase delicately ties one thread after another between the 1959 timeline and the present day part of the story. She got it right again, just as she did so brilliantly in “Black Rabbit Hall.”
“The Wildling Sisters” is a smashing good story, impressively written, and captivating right to the finish!