"the Superiority keeps us all in cages of different kinds. They control us and call it peace, but it isn't peace when we don't have a choice."
ReDawn is the second novella of the Skyward Flight trilogy belonging to the Skyward series. All three novellas are placed between book two (Starsight) and book three (Cytonic). While the previous story, Sunreach, was told from the perspective of FM, a human, ReDawn's MC is Alanik, a representative of the nation of UrDail.
While every Sanderson book is more or less political, I couldn't shake the feeling that ReDawn is especially political. It kind of reminded me of Mistborn because of the civil war problem. But while I felt engaged in the political issues of Misborn, I couldn't bring myself to feel the same about it in ReDawn. I feel like I didn't spend as much time as I should've with Alanik and her people and that's why I didn't care about their problems as much. I knew that the situation was serious and that the stakes were high, but the only thing I felt engaged in were the Skyward Flight's involvement in the story.
"Progress of ReDawn!" Nanalis declared. "May her enemies be swiftly silenced for the good of us all."
The story's bad guys - Nanalis and Quilan (and partially Winzik, I guess) - weren't flashed out enough. All Nanalis did was making speeches while Quilan, a cytonic, flew around chasing after Alanik and her human allies. You start up the story without knowing anything about these characters and you finish up the story the same way. The Superiority (and with it, Winzik) was out there, but again, all they did was talk with Quilan, and that was that. Because of all of that the seriousness of ReDawn's situation didn't struck me as hard as it should've.
Never mind that the Superiority had kept us contained here all this time, punishing us for rebellion. Never mind that if we accepted their peace, we also had to accept their control over every aspect of (our lives). They already made us paupers, withholding advanced technology from us because we rejected their rule."
That is another issue of mine. I understand what the author tried to do here: to highlight the difference between the situation's of ReDawn and Detritus when it came to their relationship with the Superiority. But this difference was quite shocking not only to the members of the Skyward Flight, but to me as well. We know that Detritus was attacked by the Superiority's ships over and over again. We know that the humanity was supposed to be exterminated. And now we find out that the UrDail's people didn't fought for their lives. They fought because they were denied the Superiority's high technology and because they felt isolated. But they were mostly left alone while the humanity battled every day to survive. Because of that I couldn't care about the UrDail's situation as much as I did about Detritus.
'How do you do that?', I asked Jorgen.
'I send the slugs an image of a location. And then we ask nicely.'
'You ask nicely?'
'It's not the only way', Jorgen said. 'But it's ours.'
The big amount of slugs, the bonding program and the Skyward Flight members in general are not the only reasons I am giving ReDawn four stars instead of three (but definitely the main ones). I LOVE the relationships between the human pilots and the slugs. I swooned every time the slugs had shown up. These things are so very cute, it should be criminal! And the bond between them and the pilots? I teared up when I read that the slugs treated the humans like their family. All they needed (except for the food, of course) was more friends, more family and that's something so incredibly heartwarming, I'm truly at loss of words.
The island trees floated in the miasma of ReDawn, their roots planted in large chucks of naturally occurring acclivity stone. The trees grew thick layers of bark, deep enough that entire rooms could be excavated beneath its surface without reaching the living parts of the tree near the base of the branches.
This is another reason I am giving ReDawn four stars instead of three - the worldbuilding. I mean, THEY ARE LIVING ON THE TREES! HOW COOL IS THAT?!
"Go!" Jeshua yelled through the glass at Jorgen. Her voice was faint, but I could make out what she said next. "Do better than we did."
THE ENDING?! MR. SANDERSON, HOW DARE YOU?! I was excited to read Evershore, because of my boy Jorgen being the MC (finally!), but with that ending now I'm no longer excited, just worried. Why, oh why, oh why, oh why? Why was it necessary?! I mean, I know that every action has its consequence, I understand it, but this could've been avoided! They learned their lesson! *tears*
Anyways, despite all my worries, I'm jumping to Evershore right away. It's a third novella happening between Starsight and Cytonic so I can easily pick it up before reading Defiant. I hope with everything in me for five stars, but we will see how things will turn out (personally I can't imagine myself giving a Jorgen book a low rating! :))
Skyward series - my rating:
1. Skyward: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)
2. Starsight: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)
2. 1 Sunreach: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)
2.2. ReDawn: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)
2.3 Evershore: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)
3. Cytonic: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5)
4. Defiant: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)