I am a HUGE fan of Mel Torrefranca's YouTube channel (If you haven't come across it, you should check it out). She's an inspirational author with incredible talent and the rare gift of staying motivated. Although she has written two other novels, Memory Minefield was the first of her works that I've read. That being said, I was unfortunately disappointed by the novella.
First, a summary: Ari Cortez is a memory loss victim of this pandemic, struggling to find a normal life. But with everyone telling her different versions of who she used to be, Ari has to trust herself to discover the truth. Jeremy Sargo, who is suffering from the loss of his best friend, fakes being a memory victim for money. The two people meet in a memory loss therapy session and both help each other regain their lost identities.
Let me start simple: The novella really could have been amazing. The premise is fascinating and the plot is fast-paced and well thought out. Mel has put a lot of thought into this. But I felt the execution of the book felt lazy and underdeveloped.
In terms of plot, this story was super unexpected; pretty much all the plot twists surprised me, and I liked how the story ended. I think it succeeded in staying true to the theme of truth vs. lies throughout.
On the other hand, I have MAJOR complaints about the character development in this book. Most of the characters feel one-dimensional and even in the dialogue, everyone sounds the same.
Ari, specifically, doesn't have any strengths or weaknesses. She lacks the personality and flair that is necessary to connect with her as a character and as a result, I find that her story doesn't particularly resonate with me. That being said, this isn't necessarily a problem. Ari's whole dilemma is that she is a memory loss victim; her entire arc is struggling with her identity. As a reader, I can forgive Ari for not having a personality at the start of the book. However, even by the end, Ari fails to change or develop in any way. She comes across as a side character in her own story in some ways. That is, I cared more about the events of the novella than how they affected Ari. This is a problem, considering Ari is the main protagonist.
On the contrary, I think Jeremy was a character who was portrayed well, especially the way his arc progressed throughout the story. While in the beginning, much of the subtlety with Jeremy's internal conflict is lost (the majority of the writing in this book breaks the traditional rule of "show, don't tell"), by the end I do feel as though Jeremy has been changed by the events in the story and that his ending, while bittersweet, makes sense in the context of the story.
One more thing that I was disappointed about with the novella is the lack of worldbuilding. I think world-building would have made this story come to life, especially since the premise has so much potential to expand. The entire plot is based around this "memory pandemic," but the scale of what the main characters are going through is unclear because we are not given a chance to see how the pandemic has affected other people or society as a whole. If someone asked me why Mel chose to focus on these two characters, in particular, the truth is I would have no idea what to say. Their stories don't fit into any sort of bigger picture.
Overall, I think Memory Minefield was a mixed novella, some parts were good, others not so great. Even though this review is not the most positive, I will say that reading this book will not change the way I see Mel as an author. She's talented, hard-working, determined and I've seen her deliver before. Even if I feel as though her novella did not reach its full potential, I do not doubt that her next works (including an upcoming dystopian trilogy) will continue to build on her skills. I look forward to reading more of Mel's work in the future!