TW: sex, assault, dubious consent.
In trying to explore manga, I am using recommendations from friends and from different genres I have found online. Specifically when looking for queer manga, I came across the concept of the omegaverse. It sounded like an extreme example of a type of manga that may help define some edge lines to the cognitive map of this new type of literature I'm delving into. I'm also looking to read some horror and some more slice of life. If I conflate the overall concept of an omegaverse with its representation in this specific title, I apologize, and look forward to correcting moving forward.
Initially, the expanding of our binary gender construction into 6 sounded like an interesting way to queer the subject. I was struck after finishing vol 1 by just how much the alpha, beta, omega system reinforces heteronormativity and gender essentialism. While the male/female binary is opened up, with each having an alpha, beta, and omega subcategory (with both male and female omegas able to become pregnant), each of these categories is fixed and most of the world building deals with the specific, distinct, and unchangeable biology of each identity. Gender identity is given and falls from biology. There are not more options for one to choose, rather there are narrower categories to fit people into. Treating this as some kind of xenoanthropological sci-fi study-piece, it has its fascinating moments. Relating it back to sex and relationships between humans, it feels constricting and devoid of romance; everything, include love and romance, stems from biological imperatives.
I say all of this, however, as a gay man...
This is a book series centering two men (boys, interestingly and problematically) having sex with each other, but it is now clear to me that it is written by a woman for women to read. It feels not for me. Not that I'm gate-kept from it, but in that it was not written with me in mind. The alpha and omega relationship is a way to explore toxic heterosexual power dynamics and rape culture. The fact that it is two men in this instance provides, perhaps, a bit of distance from the subject. The threat of sexual violence permeates the omegaverse; omegas are under constant threat from alphas and still form relationships with them. Through the threat of assault, omegas experience and negotiate attraction to specific alphas. This reflection of rape culture lies in the background of a series of explicit gay sex scenes that "play" with issues of consent. As a (white) man, I can comment on how problematic this is and also how "interesting" because of the privilege patriarchy affords me to have some objectivity and distance from the consequences of rape culture and toxic heteronormativity. In some weird way, the omegaverse construct may give someone without my privileges a modicum of that distance while reading Megumi and Tsugumi (and, not unimportantly, space in which to consume smut!). I want to celebrate this space being carved out. Also, it renders my opinions, if not moot, that of an outsider and one that should perhaps be taken with a grain of salt.