Hmmmmmm. So, I want to start by stating that I enjoyed this book, but I think authors need to stop extending series. This series should have stopped at Library of Souls in my opinion.
I did like this book! But it definitely isn’t my favorite in the series. I felt the pacing was just odd, and I think it was like that because mostly only 3 main things happen in this story, and there just wasn’t much going on. In AMOD there was a glorious mystery element, and codes, and scavenger hunts. This book didn’t have any of the iconic code mystery elements that Ransom Riggs is such a master at in the other books. I’m not entirely sure how I feel about this Prophecy plot, I’m not super into it. I felt like the characters didn’t get much time to shine, we barely got any heart to heart convos or sweet moments. It was mostly just focusing on getting from A to B. The plot point concerning the “Bad Guy Villain” had me disappointed in Ransoms creativity a bit. Which I hate saying! The ending did have a great cliff hanger for sure, and I did like the twist he threw in at the end. I enjoyed the world, the darkness, and the strangeness of it all. It also brings back nostalgia for me. I yet again really love Ransoms writing. This book just felt like it was lacking the substance that the other books had. I liked A Map of Days more for sure, it felt more rich and expansive. This book was a bit “clipped” feeling. I don’t know how I feel about the new romance, on some levels I understand it, but it doesn’t feel very exciting. Ugh, idk. I did enjoy reading it! And at the end I was on the edge of my seat, but it just felt like it fell flat a bit.