Frankenstein collects horror manga-ka Ito's adaptation of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, a series of short stories about a school boy, Oshikiri, who keeps getting into various creepy situations, and a bunch of one-off short-shorts at the very end, including one in tribute to Ito’s dog.
The Frankenstein story is the longest one, and it’s a (too) faithful adaptation of Mary Shelley's original. It turns out to be rather flat, compared to Ito’s own original work, and less than scary. Shelley’s story weaves in social commentary, but Ito lets that go to focus on the basic story, and this turns out to be a disappointing approach. What is terrific is Ito's line work, and yes, he only seems to be getting better as an artist.
The second half of the book features loosely connected stories of Oshikiri, a short—this fact makes its way into every story in some way, yes—largely uninteresting and unpopular boy who is living alone in a large mansion which seems to feature an alternate dimension. These stories are the best part of the book by far, because they allow Ito to do what he does best, to go a little crazy with his art work in order to creep us out. The stories involve friends who get murdered in this parallel world, noises in the walls (reminded me of Poe’s “Tell Tale Heart”), shallow graves, and so on.
* Some are ludicrous, such as “Neck Specter,” where Oshikiri seems to hallucinate his friend with an elongated neck. But the twist at the end from what we assumed was Oshikiri’s madness makes it turn successful creepier. Horror and the ludicrous are often wedded, but especially in Ito. Something that both Poe and Hitchcock fully understood.
* "Bog of Living Spirits” involves a small lake where students disappear, including a very popular boy followed by a crowd of creepy girls; they force Oshikiri to swim into the bog to look for the cool guy's droned body, no luck; ghost orbs hover, an indication of all the drowned.
* "Pen Pals” features a loner girl whom Oshikiri befriends who clearly is writing letters to herself, increasingly threatening letters leading to her violent suicide. Again, as with “Neck Specter,” we think we know what is going on, until (gulp), Oshikri himself begins to get threatening letters in his own handwriting.
* In ”Intruders” Oshikiri hears footsteps in his house and invites some classmates in, where they discover the graves of their own dead selves, killed in another dimension.
*”Hell of the Doll Funeral” is a short nightmare of children turned into dolls, and, well, then funerals. The translator calls this “dollification,” heh.
I don’t like it when Ito writes about his own cats and dogs, as he does here at the end. Breaks the ghostly mood. Collect them elsewhere..
This is not in the greatness category of Ito's Uzumaki or Tomie; it’s, if you think mainly of the workmanlike Frankenstein adaptation, a three star book, but the improving artwork and some of the Oshikiri stories pushes this into the four star category for me. I thought this might also have been intended as an homage to nineteenth century horror beginning with the Shelley and then with some nods to Poe here.