Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

"Indian" in the Cabinet: Speaking Truth to Power

Rate this book
A compelling political memoir of leadership and speaking truth to power by one of the most inspiring women of her generation

Jody Wilson-Raybould was raised to be a leader. Inspired by the example of her grandmother, who persevered throughout her life to keep alive the governing traditions of her people, and raised as the daughter of a hereditary chief and Indigenous leader, Wilson-Raybould always knew she would take on leadership roles and responsibilities. She never anticipated, however, that those roles would lead to a journey from her home community of We Wai Kai in British Columbia to Ottawa as Canada’s first Indigenous Minister of Justice and Attorney General in the Cabinet of then newly elected prime minister, Justin Trudeau.

Wilson-Raybould’s experience in Trudeau’s Cabinet reveals important lessons about how we must continue to strengthen our political institutions and culture, and the changes we must make to meet challenges such as racial justice and climate change. As her initial optimism about the possibilities of enacting change while in Cabinet shifted to struggles over inclusivity, deficiencies of political will, and concerns about adherence to core principles of our democracy, Wilson-Raybould stood on principle and, ultimately, resigned. In standing her personal and professional ground and telling the truth in front of the nation, Wilson-Raybould demonstrated the need for greater independence and less partisanship in how we govern.

“Indian” in the Cabinet: Speaking Truth to Power is the story of why Wilson-Raybould got into federal politics, her experience as an Indigenous leader sitting around the Cabinet table, her proudest achievements, the very public SNC-Lavalin affair, and how she got out and moved forward. Now sitting as an Independent Member in Parliament, Wilson-Raybould believes there is a better way to govern and a better way for politics—one that will make a better country for all.

Audiobook

296 people are currently reading
2910 people want to read

About the author

Jody Wilson-Raybould

5 books119 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,307 (36%)
4 stars
1,559 (43%)
3 stars
597 (16%)
2 stars
86 (2%)
1 star
32 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 496 reviews
Profile Image for Muckney Tipping.
20 reviews1 follower
September 17, 2021
Anyone who comes away from this book still believing the slanderous insults JWR's detractors have levied, ought to ask themselves why would a grown woman subject herself to this abuse willingly? The indisputable facts of the matter are that 1) she is highly principled, and believes in values that outweigh her own professional comfort, and 2) Justin Trudeau is a pandering snake.

The PMO has in the past decades clearly mutated into a bloated, entitled body of power-hungry unelected wonks who would rather aggrandise themselves at the expense of their country's institutions than admit they made a mistake, or relinquish a modicum of power.

I think we're very lucky to have Jody Wilson-Raybould set such a fine example of principled conduct in this age, and I only hope other would-be leaders are watching.
Profile Image for Carole .
673 reviews101 followers
December 19, 2021
“Indian” in the Cabinet: Speaking Truth to Power by Jody Wilson-Raybould is an example of corrupt power in government. Wilson-Raybould was elected as a Liberal member of parliament in the Canadian legislature. The prime minister, Justin Trudeau, appointed her Minister of Justice and Attorney General, making her the legal representative of Canadians. What this book is about is the fact that she was bullied and threatened by the prime minister and his minions in order to have her give judicial favours to a huge corporation, SNC-Lavelin. In her position, she refused to do wrong when she knew what was right. What happened after is exactly what electors believe cannot happen. She was demoted, ostracized and publicly humiliated. Would this have happened if she had not been a woman as well as being Indigenous. This is a retelling of an appalling misuse and abuse of power and has left Canadians with concerns of what else could this prime minister do. I have read this audiobook in the voice of the author. She was courageous in front of bullying opposition when she stood her ground and showed the stuff she was made of. I am proud of Jody Wilson-Raybould and we should strive to elect more politicians with ethics and honesty like her. Highly recommended.









Profile Image for Matt.
4,860 reviews13.1k followers
February 22, 2022
Give her 4.5 stars!

There are many who consider Canada to be a land of docile individuals, happy to live together and work in harmony. For those readers, this book will dismiss that sentiment, while remaining much more orderly than anything our neighbours to the South may exemplify when handling political scandal and unrest. Jody Wilson-Raybould wrote this political memoir, not only to explain to Canadians her role and perspective in the SNC-Lavalin Affair, but also to set the record straight one some of the comments that came from within the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO), as well as those who chose to tar and feather her for believing in the constitutionality of laws and ministerial discretion. Wilson-Raybould offers a refreshing look into the world of Canadian politics, indigenous representation, and the power wielded within the PMO to keep Cabinet members and Members of Parliament in order. Scintillating for those who love this sort of book.

Jody Wilson-Raybould grew up understanding the struggle of the indigenous from an easily age, though she was able to escape some of the horrors of residential schools in Canada. Wilson-Raybould explores some of the issues that faced children and families who fell within the indigenous circle, telling the reader about how stereotypes built walls and impeded progress, so much so that her father turned into an advocate for the region along Canada’s West Coast.

Receiving a formidable education without forgetting her roots, Wilson-Raybould began working as an advocate to help her people and speak out as her father taught her to do. There came a time when Wilson-Raybould had to wonder if she were actually making a difference, as crime was high and indigenous people appeared to be overly represented in court dockets and prisons. Still, she strive to make a difference while speaking to groups around the province of British Columbia as a hard working prosecutor.

She rose through the ranks and ended up being a strong representative for the BC indigenous community on the national stage, which caught the eye of the newly minted leader of the Liberal Party of Canada, Justin Trudeau. He convinced Wilson-Raybould to run for office in a new riding during the 2015 federal election and hoped she would soar, making a name for herself in short order. Wilson-Raybould speaks repeatedly about this first federal election campaign and how unique it was to anything she had done.

After winning, she was quickly pulled into an inner circle with which she was not yet familiar, and touted as being a possible member of the new Trudeau Cabinet. Her being a woman, a strong legal advocate, and a member of an indigenous community (not in that order) helped her secure a spot as one of the elite members in the front row, as Minister of Justice and Attorney General. Wilson-Raybould used her new position to push for major changes, under the guidance of new Prime Minister Justice Truman, tackling mandatory minimum sentences, cannabis legalization, and pushing for more legal rights for indigenous victims of crime. Things were going well for Jody Wilson-Raybould and she appeared to be a rising star.

As time progressed, Wilson-Raybould noticed a change in the prime minister, whose idealism was apparently tainted slightly by an agenda that needed pursuing. Still creepily offering hugs and warm platitudes at every turn, PM Trudeau offered his Minister of Justice support to move her agenda along. However, all this ended when the SNC-Lavalin issue crossed Wilson-Raybould’s desk. Explained well in the book, the event involved a denied request by the Director of Public Prosecutions to pursue alternatives in a case against a large Canadian company. This was not overridden by Wilson-Raybould, much to the chagrin of the PM and many within the PMO. Turmoil arose, as well as threats and strong arming, though nothing would change Wilson-Raybould’s mind about not getting in the middle of it. She was soon turned into a pariah within cabinet and soon booted from the Liberal Party, forced to run in the next federal election as an independent. All this baffling drama plays out throughout some keep chapters in the book.

While there is much more to the story tha that, it is up to the reader to explore the nuances as presented within the pages of this book, Jody Wilson-Raybould offers up some intriguing narrative about her life, her struggles, and the duplicity of the Trudeau power structure, without getting into mud slinging. What is also highly interesting in this case is that white she wrote the book, the political situation in the United States was reaching a boiling point, showing how partisan rhetoric can guide and overtake a political narrative. While this is by no means the only scandal to have rocked Canadian politics, it seems to be one of the most lopsided and truly baffling cases in recent memory. All while the prime minister attempted to exert control and vilify those who stood up for what they believed, supported by the core constitutional documents of the Canadian federation.

I was expecting something that was not only well-paced but highly informative when I chose this book. Jody Wilson-Raybould did not disappoint in the least, providing the reader with a strong narrative and great themes on which to build. She exemplifies her rise to power and the difference she made throughout her single term as a Liberal Member of Parliament, most of which was spent in Cabinet. Wilson-Raybould pulls no punches, but does not sully any names along the way. Rather, she attempts to set the record straight for those readers who want to get an inside scoop on what took plaice and how SNC-Lavalin played out behind closed doors (without violating Cabinet confidence). Wilson-Raybould does an amazing job through long and detailed chapters, providing the reader with what they need to make an informed decision on the subject matter. Her approach is second to none and provides the reader with a refreshing look at politics under Prime Ministrer Trudeau, a man who appears outwardly one way and privately another.

Kudos, Madam Wilson-Raybould, for a refreshing look at what went down. There are two sides to every story and I thank you for yours!

Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
1 review
September 17, 2021
To answer someones question as to why Indian in quotation is because here in Canada now called Indigenous people not Native not Indian - being native I personally prefer native but who am I.

Finally a real look into the workings and back benching that goes on in the PMO. Justin Trudeau is nothing more than a spoiled, tyrannical child that needs to be taught a lesson. He has financially destroyed Canada and then has audacity to call $600 million dollar election in the middle of a pandemic.
Profile Image for Joshua.
193 reviews3 followers
October 26, 2021
Canadian politics needs less Justin and more Jody.

It's been interesting to watch some of the narratives about this book - that it is a revenge piece against the Prime Minister. It's far from that. Does it expose his hypocrisy? Yes. Is it critical of how he runs a government? Yes. But it's much more than that. It's an indictment of the failures of our political system, which centralizes power and leans less on policy, and more on talking points. Wilson-Raybould lays out how this approach to politics is foreign to her, having spent her time as an Indigenous leader in a system where consensus is critical, and what would be viewed as political jockeying to “beat” the opposition isn’t the first thought of leaders. She also lays out solutions to the problems in our political system, and her voice will be missed in the House of Commons (though I am hopeful she will continue to speak out and push for the changes our system desperately need).

This book and JWR's experience left me feeling both more cynical and more hopeful about the future of Canadian politics. Cynical because her experience in the government and the institutions of government were largely terrible - and she exposed how our system has become a partisan mess - but hopeful because with more people thinking like JWR, the system can change. It won't be easy, but I share her optimism. I highly recommend giving it a read if you have any interest in current affairs and politics.
Profile Image for Diana Tsui.
7 reviews
September 19, 2021
Compelling memoir written from the lens of a principled leader and Indigenous woman navigating a political system that continues to perpetuate power imbalance, systemic racism, and marginalization. Indigenous and racialized peoples, particularly women, continue to be tokenized to advance political mandates designed and created to seize and sustain power for the privileged few - white men. When Indigenous and racialized peoples speak truth and refuse to succumb to the demands of the privileged, they are sacrificed, silenced, and marginalized.
Jody Wilson-Raybould reminds readers that Canada, a democratic country that is portrayed to have fairer, just, and ethical governance systems and institutions still has a long way to go in its a treatment ofIndigenous and racialized peoples. Racism and discrimination, even when “invisible”, are very much well and alive. These systems of inequity and oppression are particularly evident in partisan circumstances where core democratic principles of fairness, transparency, and accountability are sacrificed for power.
Profile Image for Jon Coutts.
Author 3 books38 followers
September 21, 2021
Jody Wilson-Raybould has an outlook on politics that's inspiring, if a touch idealistic. But the take away here is that today's partisanship is bad for parliamentary democracy, and Trudeau is as vaccuously power-friendly as he sounds.
Profile Image for Ashley.
320 reviews70 followers
November 30, 2021
Points were made.

Throughout this whole affair, I've wanted to hear more from Jody Wilson-Raybould, the fearless Indigenous leader in Canadian politics — so I jumped when I heard she was writing a book about her experiences in Ottawa. The appointing of her as our justice minister and attorney general was such a huge moment, and it was one of the biggest and most enraging disappointments when our government let her down. How our Prime Minister continues in his position without consequences for his (numerous) past scandals is beyond me. And Jody's account clearly illustrates Canada's need for a political overhaul, especially when it comes to respecting our Indigenous peoples and starting a meaningful path towards reconciliation. The SNC Lavalin affair was only one instance that exemplifies the way our government tries to get away with corruption, and belittles Indigenous people and women in the process.

"We don't deserve Jody" was a thought I had frequently while reading this memoir, but in the end, I truly think we are in desperate need of someone like her to get our nation back on track, prioritize the important issues, and deliver results. And of course, to govern in a way that is honest and transparent and with the best intentions at heart.
Profile Image for Shirley Schwartz.
1,428 reviews75 followers
September 21, 2021
Ms.Wilson-Rabould served as an elected Regional Chief in the province of British Columbia before she decided to move into federal politics. This is her compelling story about the time that she spent as a sitting MP in federal government, and she spares no punches in the telling. To say it was eye-opening is putting it mildly. Reading it during an election campaign was timely and enlightening. Her achievements in public life are extraordinary. Her grasp of what needs to be done in Canada to make it a better place to live is compelling and rings true throughout. I wish Ms. Wilson-Rabould all the best in her future endeavours, and it certainly won't be the last time we hear from her I'm sure.
Profile Image for Alida.
639 reviews
October 29, 2021
This book could have used a good editor. It's repetitive at times, and at others, glosses over what would have been useful information. I still gave it 3*s because I admire this courageous woman for standing up to the top powers in the Liberal government. If the entire book had been written like the concluding chapter, I would have given it 5*s.
Profile Image for Rennie.
1,013 reviews1 follower
October 19, 2021
It was interesting to read the actual transcript of the recorded call with Wernick. He definitely made it clear as to what the desired outcome was. He did not know he was being recorded but was experienced enough to say that what was being asked was not illegal. I found it interesting that JWR did agree to call Ms. McLaughlin. Why do that when she had no intention of understanding more about the proposed DPA that had been rejected or giving credence to any of the arguments in favour of granting one to SNC? It may have caused MW to think there was hope for the political pressure being brought to bear. Yes, the legislation possibly was bespoke for SNC and I have no idea if the DPA for SNC was similar to those granted in other countries but this was not a personal attack, it was business as usual in politics and nothing is likely to change that.

SNC has the weaknesses that any large employer has along with the influence necessary to mitigate their impact on the bottom line. When there are jobs in home ridings to be bought with tax money, altering/weakening legislation or winking at infractions (orphan wells), it is likely that whatever wish list these large employers put forward is agreed to more often than not. Not a good thing but likely SOP in Canada and most other countries as how things go is influenced more by corporations than those elected to run governments.

There is no doubt that political interference was on the table. This is not new in Canadian government. It is often not covered or analyzed well and parked in a dark cupboard but it has been a fact of political life forever. Sad, of course but thinking otherwise is naive and we seem not to have the public will to change it. It would be interesting to hear accounts of other elected officials and how similar the experience JWR had was to theirs but they did not record their calls.

I was left with the impression of a person who wants the limelight and affirmation of being a political casualty due to her principles. Politics is not kind to anyone who refuses to play the game and the game under our powerful PM/PMO is all about control whether you are Mr. Harper or Mr. Trudeau and that is the real issue. It requires all MPs to park their principles, vote as told to and keep quiet about any concerns they may have to keep their seat and continue to perform as an extra in the drama we call democracy.

Ms. JWR chose not to keep quiet and good for her to air her experience with politics as it is today.
Profile Image for JW.
843 reviews2 followers
October 2, 2021
Something rotten stinks in Ottawa, and JWR gives her thoughts on what it is.

(SPOILERS: It's morally bankrupt partisan cult-think.)

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
11 reviews
September 19, 2021
Marieke Walsh, the lovely and well-informed Globe reporter, said she didn't believe that the publication of this memoir six days before the September 20 election day in Canada would hurt Justin Trudeau much as the SNC-Lavalin scandal had already been adjudicated. This is, as Wilson-Raybould makes clear, only partly true. Trudeau's appointed ethics commissioner, Mario Dion, nonetheless found him guilty of contravening section 9 of the Conflict of Interest Act with regard to SNC-Lavalin, a contravention that strikes at the heart of our democracy. Also, Trudeau has done everything to cover his ass by limiting the freedom of cabinet ministers like Wilson-Raybould to speak due to cabinet confidentiality and solicitor-client privilege. According to Wilson-Raybould, the RCMP are still investigating the SNC-Lavalin affair to see if criminal charges can be laid, a investigation badly hampered by the muzzling of existing and former cabinet ministers by the corrupt and autocratic Trudeau. So when voting tomorrow, Canadians should remember that the leader of the Liberal Party is at best a lawbreaker, and quite possibly a criminal who belongs in jail. So public-spirited Canadians should be hugely grateful to Wilson-Raybould for pushing up the publication date of her book from October to September and hurting Trudeau's chances of retaining power.
On p.134, Wilson-Raybould writes : “An unexpected obstacle that delayed passage of the MAID [Medical Assistance in Dying] legislation was ‘Elbowgate’, the May 18, 2016 incident in the House of Commons where the prime minister suddenly got up from his seat, and, in an effort to get the Opposition whip through a bunch of New Democrats, accidentally elbowed an NDP member of Parliament and all hell broke loose. It created a reality that delayed our vote on MAID and meant we were increasingly at risk of missing the Supreme Court of Canada deadline.” There are so many things wrong with this account, it is hard to know where to start. There is no mention that Trudeau yelled at the New Democrat MPs “Get the f—k out of my way!” as he pushed his way towards Gordon Brown, the Opposition Whip, probably the first time in the history of Canada that a sitting Prime Minister disgraced himself by dropping an F-bomb directed at multiple MPs. Wilson-Raybould does not mention that it was a female MP, Ruth Ellen Brosseau, that Trudeau elbowed. He elbowed her so hard in the breast that you can hear her cry out in pain in the video of the House of Commons session and she had to leave the sitting for a while. Trudeau frog-marched the Opposition Whip across the floor of the House towards his seat, an act of thuggery that Brown very much resented. However, in his so-called apology Trudeau acted like he was in an alternate universe, speaking about guiding Brown to his seat. There was absolutely no need for him to interfere in any way with the proceedings. The Opposition MPs were clearly trying to stall Brown taking his seat because traditionally both Government and Opposition Whips are seated before the Speaker calls a vote, but only the House Whip really needs to be seated. It seems that Trudeau was as clueless about this as he is on so many other things you would expect him to know about. As Wilson-Raybould herself said, Trudeau did the passage of her legislation no service, but considerable harm: The legislation “received royal assent on June 17, 2016. We missed the court-imposed deadline by eleven days.”
It seems strange that Wilson-Raybould, who suffered so much ill-treatment from Trudeau, would write so protectively about how he disgraced himself in the so-called Elbowgate incident. Frogmarch-gate or F-bombgate would have been a more appropriate name for it. It showed Trudeau for what he was: a dimwitted thug and a pathological liar, someone who would lie even about his behaviour towards Gordon Brown when a video seen by millions clearly showed that he was lying. Perhaps Wilson-Raybould goes on Trudeau because he was, in however clueless a way, trying to help her expedite the passage of a bill that was important to her, even if he only made things worse.
Profile Image for Noah Guerin.
74 reviews1 follower
September 27, 2021
"I'm still mad at myself for that, for being convinced at one point in time that the PM was an honest and good person when in truth he would so casually lie to the public and then think he could get away with it."

"This is why I think the image-driven emptiness of much of how the Liberal government operates is becoming dangerous, selling lofty rhetoric but failing to act in ways that live up to it breeds cynicism and even hopelessness that change can ever take place through our regular political processes and culture."

JRW's "tell-all" about her rise through Indigenous politics to MOJAG of Canada and downfall during the SNC-Lavalin affair is extremely well-written and reinforces the image of a self-interested and incompetent phony many Canadians have yet to realize is still running our country. The extent to which he is actually running it is discussed a bit in this novel which makes it all the more sad. I only wish it had been released sooner so that perhaps it could have had a bigger impact on the election.

Besides the obvious details the book is meant to cover, JWR dives into her experience in Indigenous politics and the reader really gets to know JWR on a personal level. It's really a shame that this all had to go down the way it did because JWR really seems like the kind of person we would all want representing us in Ottawa, a rational, patriotic Canadian who sees both the good in our country and what needs to be improved, who is not entangled in the corruption or partisanship we expect from politicians these days and someone who works hard and actually gets meaningful things done.

I highly recommend this to anyone interested in Canadian politics, I think she does a great job laying out the whole story, I only wish she could have shared more but as she makes clear in the book, that is out of her hands.
Profile Image for Fraser Simons.
Author 9 books298 followers
December 20, 2021
I imagine most people are going to pick this up to see the accounting of the SNC Lavalin affair, and on that front Raybould is very thorough. She also goes into the granular aspects of how she transitioned into government from Indigenous government. Some of the day-to-day ministrations as serving as the Minister of Justice and and Attorney General.

I think this book is actually too granular in some respects and the voice struggles because you can tell she’s very good and used to technical writing and not so much crafting an active and compelling storytelling voice. The result made this a bit of a slog, especially coupled with a generally mediocre narration on the audiobook.

However. I think this is very substantive and great. She is one of the few politicians with integrity and backs up her thinking and her ethics with action. She is blunt and honest about absolutely everything and is unafraid of holding people to account, rather than putting the party first above everything. Unfortunately it’s a confirmation of our liberal government pretty much functioning exactly as expected. Their priority is to hold power and obfuscate accountability despite their overt performative gestures at the start of their reign saying and doing the right things for change, but keeping none of the most important goals and commitments people who voted for the party took to heart.

Raybould is one of the few leaders who we actually need in power.
Profile Image for Hannah.
430 reviews
September 17, 2021
If you've ever wanted to be an MP or in particular a Minister, read this book to abandon that dream. I loved hearing the inner workings of parliament and day to day work as a minister, even though it sounds rough. I've always found these days politics is far too partisan and really enjoyed the take here since she clearly feels the same. Takes a while to get to what we all came here for - the SNC Lavalin mess, but even then the preceding chapters were more interesting to me.

I was surprised at the personal turns in the book, particularly over her miscarriages. It was refreshing (maybe not the right word?) to see this openly discussed.
Profile Image for shannon ✨.
234 reviews30 followers
November 16, 2021
Jody Wilson-Raybould (Puglaas) is one of the most intelligent, hard-working, and strong Canadian politicians I’ve witnessed in recent Canadian governments, and this book reflects every bit of that.

Through her career in Indigenous politics and federal politics she has maintained her willpower and stood firm in her values and made every effort to advance Indigenous self-governance and justice for all marginalized Canadians.

As someone who has been in the thick of partisan politics (strong Liberal member and volunteer in 2015 and political candidate in 2019 for the Green Party of Canada) I have a small understanding of the evil that is partisanship and how it can effect democracy and good governance. I think, like Wilson-Raybould, a lot of Canadians truly believed Justin Trudeau’s 2015 rhetoric of “doing politics differently”. Now after three federal elections in 6 years, it’s fair to say that it’s important to reflect on our values, and hold our governments accountable. I think in recent years we glorified Justin for not being Stephen Harper, being good looking, and not being a Conservative, but as Wilson-Raybould beautifully illustrates in her book, this simply isn’t enough.

“Indian” in the Cabinet was an incredible deep dive into the ugly partisanship in Canadian government, how this partisanship impacts good governance and ethics, and the lack of transparency and accountability our politicians have to all citizens. This book was also an important reflection on the misogyny, racism, colonialism, and paternalism that is still so present in politics and societal institutions and the lack of understanding and caring to remove barriers for underrepresented people.

Long story short... use this book to reflect on who you want to represent you in government. Think critically about your values and who you vote for. And stop using rose coloured classes when looking at politicians you like and criticize them often for not creating change for people who need it.

Bravo Puglaas.
Profile Image for Lauren Claire.
664 reviews4 followers
December 26, 2021
I'm struggling with my review for this one, since I really don't know what to make of this book. You kind of always have to take these kind of autobiographies from people on one side of a scandal telling their side of the story only with a grain of salt, kind of like with A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies, and Leadership.

I listened to it in audiobook format, and it was interesting to hear JWR's account as read by her. There were parts of it I found really fascinating, mostly about what her job as a minister was like, but the rest of it I'm kind of left scratching my head.

I guess the biggest question I'm asking myself is...what exactly did you expect, Jody? As a politician, you have to...be political? And not always play by the rules? Is that surprising to you? We need look no further than south of the border to see what people will do to hold on to power. This goes beyond naïveté to me and goes into foolish territory. If you're not willing to play the political game, then what are you doing in politics?

While I fully support her agenda and working towards reconciliation, I got so tired of her holier-than-thou attitude by the end of this book and nearly didn't finish. I don't doubt Jody entered politics to do good, particularly for her Indigenous community, but it feels like she squandered an opportunity to do actual good by turning her nose up at the game you have to play to get things done. She makes very fleeting references to how she was perceived and how she might have done things differently in hindsight, but otherwise washes her hands completely of any responsibility for how things went.

As a book, it was also just really repetitive and bounced around from topic to topic without any narrative thread.

Yeah, JT and his minions are sleazy, that's not surprising. What's surprising to me is that her desire to take the moral high ground took precedence over anything else.
Profile Image for Shafiqah Nor.
208 reviews
October 2, 2021
She spoke truth to power and this book reveals what I suspected all along, that she is a woman of integrity. This book is honest. It is also a very important piece of perspective from Canada's first Indigenous woman Minister of Justice and Attorney General.

The dual role of MoJ and AG, and the conflation between the two risks undermining the rule of law was very well articulated in the book. I learned about JWR's role and her internal advocacies to stem the legacies of colonialism. She is someone very principled and this memoir made me understand why.

From the beginning, she sheds light on the distinction and differences between Indigenous politics and Canadian federal politics. JWR was one of the first female regional chief for BCAFN, she did not romanticize her experience in Indigenous politics, disclosed the sexism and misogyny, and gave a very transparent account of her struggles and emotions. But the stark differences between two worlds is where it is at.

I think this memoir is really about her reconciling between Indigenous cosmovision and holistic paradigms versus federal partisanship for power in Canadian politics. This is such a key piece on Canada's path to reconciliation.

The fact that JWR saw and understood politics beyond the party lines makes me disappointed that she left federal politics. But I don't believe we have seen the last of her.
Profile Image for Rachel.
104 reviews
April 11, 2022
I had looked forward to reading this book for a while. There could be some differing opinions on the narration order or the optimism that Wilson-Raybould holds at the end, however this is a book I would recommend to anyone. As a non Indigenous person that does not reside in BC, it provided a glimpse to how BC Indigenous leadership operates by the author’s account. I found it interesting how she came to run for the Liberals and her overall takeaway regarding partisanship especially after being elected as an Independent MP (the first woman to do so). It is discouraging to consider what the political world currently is, and what it’s always been. Wilson-Raybould concludes with a statement about continuing to bring the " unseen to be seen " in regards to the challenges across this country and I think this book contributes to that vision.
Profile Image for Jeffery Guichelaar.
62 reviews2 followers
September 18, 2021
Some real insight into the ongoing failures and hypocrisies in Canada in government. As always JWR speaks truthful, clearly, and brings strong ideas to a better path forward for Canada, despite the sad realities around us now. A great exemplar of courage and example more of us should follow.
Profile Image for Wesley Burton.
28 reviews1 follower
September 22, 2021
This book was a real eye opener on a number of issues. I highly recommend it to anyone curious about how government works in Canada and how detrimental partisanship is.
438 reviews16 followers
September 23, 2021
Jody Wilson-Raybould is a class act: a woman of integrity and thoughtfulness who took the high road in her account of her time in Ottawa (2015-2021). She was the first Indigenous Minister of Justice and Attorney-General of Canada, a role that should have been a groundbreaker for Crown / Indigenous relations, and would have been game-changing, had Justin Trudeau exercised good judgement. But alas, he did not. Instead, he took the short-sighted, partisan politics view that she should 'play ball' on a criminal case against SNC Lavalin, and comply with his desire to grant them a deferred prosecution agreement (DPA). She refused to go along with 'politics as usual' and stood her ground on a matter of principle, becoming a heroine to the people of Canada (at least, those of us who can think beyond Liberal political needs).
I think anyone who knew anything about JWR should have guessed that she would not compromise her integrity for the sake of a government that had been playing political games with Indigenous rights for a couple of centuries. It was written large in her life story that she opposed this type of political BS, as she had spent her life to date seeking consensus and co-operation in matters of justice for Indigenous groups that she represented. But I guess Trudeau thought she would be so overwhelmed with the thrill of working for him that she would do his bidding. Anyone who watched her testimony on the issues would have noticed that she paused to think before she spoke. In a political world, where everyone else was spewing pre-packaged party lines, she stood out as someone who did her own thinking. She is to be admired, along with Dr. Jane Pilpott who resigned as a matter of conscience in support of JWR. Alas, the two most admirable members of Cabinet were gone, and Canada got stuck with people who only know how to say Yes, Justin.
Profile Image for melhara.
1,863 reviews91 followers
December 29, 2022
Right from the prologue, this book dives into the SNC-Lavalin affair, exposes Trudeau's poor leadership, and criticizes the Canadian government.

There were certain aspects of this book that I enjoyed, including learning about the differences between Indigenous and mainstream politics. While it was certainly interesting to read Wilson-Raybould's perspective on Canadian governance from the viewpoint of an Indigenous person who grew up with Indigenous politics, this book was kind of a mess.

This book was both repetitive and all over the place. It bounced back and forth between the SNC-Lavalin affair to Wilson-Raybould's other political experiences, and back to SNC-Lavalin. The book also expects readers to already have a good understanding of recent Canadian politics, the Indian Act, the Idle No More Movement, and most importantly (as it makes up the bulk of this book), the SNC-Lavalin affair before reading this book. It would have been beneficial if background information was provided for readers first, before taking a deep dive into the details of the matter.
Profile Image for Gail Amendt.
808 reviews31 followers
June 8, 2022
It was great to read the views and experiences of one of the few interesting people in Canadian politics in recent years. Jody Wilson-Raybould was hopelessly naive when she entered federal politics, having no political experience outside indigenous politics, which is very different from mainstream Canadian politics. In spite of her inexperience, she became the token "Indian" in Justin Trudeau's cabinet, before losing that position and ultimately her membership in the Liberal caucus over the SNC Lavelin affair. I have to say that she and I agree on what is broken in Canadian politics, as the best interests of the party seems to be put before the best interests of Canadians time and time again. She explains what happened in as much detail as she is able due to confidentiality rules. It does get a bit dry at times, but is still an interesting and enlightening read.
Profile Image for Lolo.
32 reviews4 followers
September 21, 2021
WOW!
This book was everything I expected and more. Focusing on JWR's experience as an Indigenous woman, lawyer, Liberal MP and Independent MP, this book also included much more than just JWR's scandal. Focusing on the importance of good governance over good government, this book was yet another eye opening experience to how the Canadian Federal Government continues to push aside Indigenous voices, inherent rights, and ultimately uses the term "Indigenous" as an action word to gain the vote.

5/5 stars
Profile Image for Julia.
575 reviews46 followers
January 2, 2022
i will never understand how dan breznitz’s silly book about innovation won awards over this!

jody writes about her time in government in an accessible way. this is probably the first memoir that i’ve read where i didn’t want to put it down.

jody excellently grapples with the dysfunction of our canadian electoral system and the problematic nature of our governing structures. she sheds light on the inner workings of politics and the disillusionment i think we all have felt at one point or other from the current trudeau government.

final thoughts? get a best friend like jane
Profile Image for Nancy.
104 reviews4 followers
November 15, 2021
A very interesting read, plus as a bonus, I just saw her interviewed on W5.
Profile Image for Nat D.
49 reviews4 followers
Read
April 20, 2022
Idk why I'm still surprised when the media portrays complete inaccuracy to protect those in power. I didn't know much about the SNC-Lavalin scandal before reading this book, but now I feel like I have a tiny bit more info on the shitstorm that happened in Canadian politics in 2019
Displaying 1 - 30 of 496 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.