Wanting to pick up a new series, this first book in a three-part series sounded interesting to me. Two cousins, Riley and Alfie, are sailing with Riley's dad and Alfie's mom, when they find themselves shipwrecked and marooned in a lost island, Atlantis, where things are, well, weird. So how was the book?
Overall, I quite enjoyed this book. The story is simple, but is well told, so I was engaged throughout. Everything seems okay in Atlantis, everyone is polite and helps each other out and live in peace, until the ugly sides start showing, especially when it comes to the cloaked people, who are basically anthropomorphic animals,and how they are treated by the normal humans in Atlantis. All the while, Riley and Alfie have to set their differences aside to get through this place and find out what happened to her dad and his mom.
The story is mainly elevated by a group of likable main characters. Riley and Alfie had the typical flaws of kids in their age range, especially the more emotional and volatile Alfie, but they remain likable as they go through thick and thin together and develop a closer bond. Bastian and Miss Pigglesworth are likable throughout as the new friends; Maggie is a welcome motherly figure, Galina is a good friend despite the communication issues, while Pea is an absolute delight and arguably my favorite character in the book. Gideon was also great as the gentle giant who makes it his mission to aid and protect the main characters. The rest of the characters are adequate in their roles, especially Kerry, one of the few other kids in the island, who goes above and beyond being a mean girl. I do wish the other children could have had a bigger role in the story, though.
The story has some flaws, though. Like how at times Riley and Alfie don't really sound their age in their dialogue, and how the story, as I said, is very simple, a lot of it is the same stuff without any new twists, and many questions are left unanswered, though since it's a three-part series, it does mean that questions will be answered later, so that wasn't much of a big flaw. Beyond that, it's still a good story with good characters. And another thing that put a smile to my face is the big hints that the author is a big fan of Gargoyles, which is my favorite tv show of all time, from little details such as a cat-woman named Maggie, but mainly due to the inclusion of gargoyles in the story; gargoyles that turn to stone during the day and come alive at night, with the one we meet being seven feet tall, having a notably deep voice, being very protective, and being called Gideon, and it all feels so very much like the main character in Gargoyles, Goliath, voiced by the incomparable Keith David. It was just something that made the geek in me smile.
In the end, despite the simplicity and a couple of flaws, this was a fun, enjoyable book, and I look forward to continuing the series.