Revenge
by Dani Hoots
⚡️ I was provided an ARC by the author in exchange for an honest review
🌟: 1 / 5
📚: Two shapeshifting bounty hunters are hired to hunt down a member of high society with with promise of information about the man responsible for the destruction of their home.
💭: I don’t even know where to begin with this review, so I will start with summarizing exactly how I feel about it: this book is not good. I had a lot of problems getting through reading it— everything from the characters, to the plot, to the worldbuilding and setting, to the writing itself made this book feel like a marathon to get through.
Revenge follows Ellie and Zach (please note that every character in this book has a wild biblical-style name that is never used after they’re introduced), two bounty hunters who are also the last of a race of shapeshifters on their planet, as they accept a job to assassinate a prospective member of an elite society before he is inducted. In exchange, they’re promised information that leads to the whereabouts of Cor, Ellie’s ex, who they believe orchestrated the genocide of their people when they were teenagers.
A big element of their characterization of almost all of the characters lie within the racial traits of whatever type of alien they are; however, we don’t actually see many of these traits or learn much of anything about these different races, and instead, we get statements along the lines of “this character is always grumpy because he is x alien.” There is very little, if any, description of these races (one of them is never actually explained, there are 6 races in the book and we only learn about 5), despite the fact that (sorry spoiler alert) the majority of the plot essentially revolves around genocide and a race war reaching its boiling point. Even main characters who are from different races living on this planet are never shown as distinct from each other, aside from the differences in name only. Many of them are a shape-shifting race? The concept that they can do it to begin with is just dangled in front of readers constantly, but we only ever see it twice and never in any meaningful way (honestly why even have your main characters be shapeshifters if it never actually comes up beyond just having them constantly state that they can change their appearance, WHY?!). One is half of the alien equivalent to a mermaid? Brought up vaguely multiple times and then never explored or explained. It honestly just felt so lazy in terms of both worldbuilding and characterization, and I was just so completely frustrated and almost blindsided by the fact that this major and half-assed aspect of worldbuilding came to play such a pivotal role in the plot.
Characters are so one dimensional, despite the fact that this book is written from four different points of view and readers literally get to see into their heads— Zach’s entire personality is that he likes fruity drinks and is asexual, while Ellie is “not like other girls” because she likes whiskey and is out for revenge (which is used at least once per page in chapters written in her point of view).
As mentioned before, the worldbuilding in this book is just bad. Space westerns aren’t a new concept, but this book almost gives off the impression that the author didn’t use the existence of the genre as a benchmark at all. Instead, Revenge feels like it just pulled random tropes of science fiction and western writing without bothering to integrate them in any cohesive way. I think it’s important to note at this point that imagery is a super important element within any type of fiction writing, but especially one with a clearly very elaborate world like in this book. In an attempt to turn off the scientific side of my brain and suspend disbelief, I let myself get caught up on the fact that I had no grasp on the races, geography, or technology that the characters encountered and had to continually flip back to chapter one, where many of these basic things were explained for the first, and only, time. [Just as a side note— one of the things that really got me hung up was the fact that the characters all ride horses and use coin money, but about halfway through, they just suddenly switch to using credit cards and riding on some sort of space tram thing (also never explained)].
Essentially there were never reassurances or context clues that certain things were something that we had seen before, which just made me feel lost while reading it. If you include all of the times where statements about technology or the setting or any other offhand thing was just thrown out as if we were supposed to know about this already with no explanation, then I felt lost A LOT. (Also please don’t get me started on the fact that about a third of this book is just descriptions of poker games because I do not understand poker and I don’t know if anyone who reads this book would understand enough about poker to determine whether or not a character is clever or something. I had no idea what was happening in those scenes, honestly, it was hellish for me.)
I feel like I jokingly say that some books I read don’t really feel edited, but I genuinely don’t think that this one was. From wrong synonyms being used and weirdly frequent subject-verb agreement errors to the same sentence being repeated with a word or two changed and statements blatantly contradicting each other (within the same paragraph or on the next page!), I almost felt like I was having flashbacks to elementary school English tests where you had to correct grammar in a short reading.
I’m guilty of having to go back and reread paragraphs because I accidentally skim them, but I found myself going back a lot more frequently than I ever have in a single book because I thought I was missing something that was almost never actually there. There was a point where I sat down and had to diagram out the setting because it read more as a brain teaser (a la an “if A is bigger than B, but B is taller than C, A must be how big?” comparative puzzle) than an actual description or imagery-filled statement. Revenge also constantly does this thing where characters will refer to something very specifically (for example, a character getting “the illness” and another being inducted into “an elite society”), as if we are already supposed to know or it will be explained later, and then never elaborates or explains what that specific thing actually is at any point.
At times, I assumed that I was reading the outline of a book more than an actual completed work. Major plot points were just really dropped throughout the book, more as statements than things that are shown or explained, with dialog sprinkled on top of them as almost an afterthought. Even the main characters’ apparently carefully planned out schemes were just so clumsily plotted out that it felt laughable at times. The story felt so disjointed that I assumed that I was missing something. The plot of this book is definitely there, but it’s more of a bare bones and no meat at all situation, there’s a scaffold to it but nothing compelling to tie points together in an engaging way.
Also a major component of the plot is essentially written to mock sex work and the fact that one of the characters has to stoop to doing it? It’s so demeaning and uncomfortable to read over and over (and over because it just keeps going) again. At first, part of me really hoped that maybe this would show the character being empowered by this job or having them talk to the other characters about how they shouldn’t imply that sex workers are morally bad or deserve to be degraded for their job, but somehow it became almost a running joke throughout the story that this character was a sex worker and deserved to be shit on for it. It was probably the worst way that I could have seen this storyline go, and somehow the author managed to do it.
Uh also Space Nazis get introduced at 88% and it just kind of ends? I think that they author tried really, really hard to give readers a cliffhanger that would make them want to read the next book in the series, but instead we get more of a “well it looks like we have a race war on our hands, do you guys want to go to my mom’s house?” It’s the unsatisfying end that an unsatisfying book deserves, I guess. This is easily the worst book I’ve read all year, and even after stewing on this book for a week after finishing it, there really was nothing that I would highlight or write home about. Would not recommend if you value your own time, even if you’re absolutely desperate for a queer space western.
TL;DR I hated this book, I hated writing this review, I need to go calm down because I’m mad that I spent so much time reading this book and then writing this review.