Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

人類學好野 —— 關於人類的,我都想學

Rate this book

222 pages

Published May 1, 2020

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

黃修瑋

1 book

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
3 (23%)
4 stars
7 (53%)
3 stars
3 (23%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
Profile Image for J.Adams.
45 reviews1 follower
August 26, 2023
本書由中文大學多位人類學家所撰寫。雖然取材地點並不是在香港,唔少報導人都係來自支那,但當中亦都能引起共鳴,又或者至少有一定嘅參考價值。
文章主要分為五大部份,第一部份探究一樣嘢嘅價值係點樣建構而成。寶石點解可以賣到咁貴?台灣鯖魚點解會有海鮮價 ?
第二部份探討社會入邊嘅異類生活,包括網絡成癮青年、自閉症學童及教師、義肢使用者。記載住佢哋面對唔同嘅阻礙同困難,點樣巧妙地使用生活智慧同策略,以建構具合法性嘅自我。
第三部份講述唔同社會關係,包括現代嘅平等助人關係、婚姻、移民工嘅同性關係。特別欣賞作者呈現出關係當中嘅矛盾,例如「平等」背後嘅面紗,喺所謂「無分彼此」之中,又需要各種區分去維持呢種嘅平等。而呢種狀態或者都顯示出我哋「正身處於一個前現代、現代同後現代並置嘅複雜社會狀態。」
第四部份探討政治,當中嘅議題涉及尋求庇護者、重建。背後帶出身份認同、生活自主嘅反思。
第五部份解構田野工作者嘅專業。包括點樣處理同調整自己嘅定位,以及闡釋一種另類、多元、細緻嘅觀察方式。
總括而言,呢本書可以令我對世界產生更大嘅好奇,開始去問一啲冇人會問嘅問題:「呢樣嘢係點樣形成?」。亦告誡自己喺妄下判斷之前,多去理解一啲冇人想去理解嘅嘢。
56 reviews1 follower
November 2, 2026
A decent introduction to anthropology. While its subject matter is closely related to that of sociology, it is its methodology that defines the discipline. Anthropologists spend months to years with their informant to conduct participant observation and in-depth interview as part of their fieldwork. The product of their work becomes an ethnography. The book collects 12 articles from anthropologic scholar with diverse themes ranging from: gem trading in Pakistan, environmentally conscientious fish market in Taiwan, tennage camps for internet addicts, the toilet training of ASD in China, amputees and their prosthetics, homeless and their volunteers, the moulding of the marital values of a Shanghai's woman, the homosexual relationship among domestic worker, asylum seekers in Hong Kong, redevelopment and democracy, fieldwork in Italy's Chinese-owned cafe, and abandoned village in China.

I love how most articles non-judgmentally capture the acts and responses of the informants as "real" as possible. I particularly love the article on expousing the underlying economy of 可樂 in a rehabilitation camp where instant joy is tightly regulated. It shows that human behaviours, even in an estranged societal construction, power and capital struggle still persist. The whole issue captures the unique educational desire (Andre Kipnis) in China and the growing anxiety among male teenagers.

While the book's themes are diverse, the quality differs and it might be too superficial again.

1. overlooking the origin and means of gems-> Marx commodity fetishism, alienation between man and the production of commodity

2. Instructor responsible for a production line for "normal/functional reproducer" and caring for ASD & at-stakedness: [Mary Douglas: An Analysis of Concepts of Pollution and Taboo]body as the symbolic origin of social moral order-> body excretion as the taboo of social order-> those with taboo contact thus are socially disgraced-> vicious cycle: only morally disgraced do such jobs <-> people are morally disgraced because they do such jobs

3. Women from the 50s of China struggled through the 60s Cultural Revolution, they challenged the subverted social status and projected feminine values-> uncivil individual [Yan, Yunxiang, Private Life Under Socialism: Love, Intimacy, and Family Change in a Chinese Village 1949-1999]
「一種偏重強調個人的權利和利益的事, 而對個人對社區和他人的義務則輕描淡寫的,不平衡、不完整的個人主義」

4. migrant worker as breadwinner, communication device, away from past moral barrier, tomboy more experience and stronger identity. Judith Butler "doing gender", a binary masculine+ feminine pair increase the visibility of their homosexual relationship, confirming to others that they are in romantic relationship

5. asylum seeker, and the idendity of Hongkonger (race/blood-related/ethnicity vs civil identity e.g. Canada, US, Brazil), mainlander as the new ethnic other ironically

6. Fieldwork as a form of both observation and participation, intersectionality (race, class, gender)-> positionality -> displacement
Profile Image for deartomato.
117 reviews4 followers
March 3, 2025
中大人類學者文章合集,從人類之外的生物和物品價值,到人類社會的群體形態、人際關係、政治可能,再到對人類學者自身角色及狀態的反思:跟著本書探索「例外」和「可能」。
Profile Image for Amos Tai.
42 reviews
October 30, 2021
一直都想涉獵人類學同社會學,並比較吓佢哋喺方法同理論上嘅分別,咁啱中文大學嘅同事出咗呢本入門書,點可以錯過呢。「好野」嘅意思係大部分人類學研究都要做 #田野調查,原來唔係印象中只集中喺偏遠地區嘅少數族群,而係會深入現代社會各種社群了解佢哋嘅生活同故事:巴基斯坦寶石市集商人、從台灣漁民看海洋生態發展、中國網癮治療及自閉症康復機構嘅日常運作、香港關心露宿者嘅志願者嘅心態、居港菲籍移民工當中嘅同性關係、喺重慶大廈與難民對話、土瓜灣舊區重建點影響當地居民、喺意大利當咖啡師嚟了解當地華人移民、等等。我自己就睇得好過癮,既從學術角度研究、亦以身心去體會人類行為思想嘅錯綜複雜,改變並豐富咗自己某啲固有、表面嘅認知,並反思身為「人」嘅意義。好似編者噉講,「關於人類的,還有很多要學」。
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews