I’ve generally enjoyed reading Patterson’s books, which I get from the library because I don’t find him good enough to buy and keep in my library. He’s mind candy – simple, fast-paced, detective and mystery-oriented adventures that can be read in about two to three days and easily left behind. Nice escapism, but nothing super memorable.
However, I must say that back in 2017 I read his heavily promoted novel, “The Black Book” co-written with David Ellis. This was one of his best books (along with the list of his many co-authors) that I had read in a long time. It was a detective story of Billy Harney, who survives a shooting with his girlfriend and partner while investigating corrupt government officials and police officers in Chicago. The big kicker is that the mystery was well thought out, had multiple layers, and even more important (for those of us who confidently feel that we can figure out the guilty party before he/she is revealed), the outcome was surprising and extremely well-delivered! What a payoff ending!
Then, in 2021, Billy Harney returned in the aptly titled, “The Red Book”. This time, Detective Harney, had recovered from his first adventure and medically cleared to return to work. The second book is a lot like the first one in style, plotting, and pace. However, you can enjoy this one without having reading the first one. You are fine either way. And like the first book, there was a lot of good things to enjoy in this one.
Now, in 2022, Patterson and Ellis have brought back Harney for a third thriller, changing the book type title lingo to “Escape” and setting up Detective Harney’s hunt for a child kidnapper. Evidently, the success of the first two books have generated enough desire for a third outing and possible series potential with another sympathetic Patterson created law enforcement officer.
“Escape” starts off with Harney and his partner tailing a potential kidnapper of a teenage girl, and ends in a devastating outcome that surprisingly caught me off guard. No spoilers here, my friends, but it was an impactful and sad event that kicked the plot forward in a way that invested the reader emotionally into the outcome of the story.
Harney finds himself involved in two big investigations. One that involves being the lead for a task force focused on a major gang bust, taking down Jericho Hooper, the leader of the Imperial Gangster Nation, the biggest and most powerful street gang in Chicago. Hooper is so smart he’s never been caught. He also launders millions of dollars a year through his nightclubs, strip clubs, and laundry mats. He has twenty-year-old advanced mathematics prodigy, Mason Tracy, that takes care of his books and keeps everything under the IRS thresholds for investigation.
The other investigation is personal for Harney and has brought him pain and loss. A teenage girl comes to Harry, pleading with him to protect her mother. It appears that the mom has found out horrible things about her husband, enough to drive her to leave and divorce him. However, the daughter’s overheard her father plotting to kill her mom because of the damaging information she has. Can Harry stop him in time?
There was a lot going on in this book. A lot, yes. A lot. Multiple plotlines ran parallel until most of them connected in interesting ways and surprising ways; although there was some convoluted and far from realistic situations happening. One key rule to reading Patterson is that you really have to suspend your sense of reality and disbelief to enjoy the adventure. Sometimes a lot. This was one of those times.
I enjoyed Billy Harney as a lead character, his side bar comic moments on the bar stage, and his hope for a potential romance. Still, as most Patterson lead heroes, he is pretty much physically beat to a pulp chasing bad guys by the end of the book, and barely escapes death several times. That’s the cost of being a detective lead in a Patterson series.
I struggled a bit with the bad guys though in this one. Jericho Hooper is built up pretty big in the beginning but plays a smaller role than expected, and also comes across a bit stiff and one dimensional. I also struggled with Henry Arcola. Was he brilliant or was he cocky and overconfident. They kept flipping his character around throughout the book. One minute he’s a psycho and the next he was brilliant. It felt like the writers couldn’t make up their mind, which made him appear as inconsistent and unrealistic.
My other challenge with this one was there was so much going on with the many storylines and characters dropping and out. In some ways, too many activities and variables negatively impacted the telling of the story. Although the suspense and mysteries weren’t bad, there were some actions and outcomes that didn’t really make sense to me and hurt the plotting. I would mention a few, but I don’t want to give away any spoilers.
Overall, this book was an okay escapist read if you are willing to suspend your sense of realism in the storytelling. Still. I rather like Billy Harney as a lead character. He is basically Chicago’s version of New York’s Michael Bennett, another Patterson series (but more established). Billy is a lot like Michael Bennett, minus the 10 children. With the surprise twist in the last few pages, it’s safe to say that Billy will be returning again, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. I would read another one of his and hope they improve their storytelling and develop him more in his own unique way.
Rating – 3 stars out of 5.