I thought this was a cute novella. I really like the idea for the whole series--and y'all know I'm a sucker for a fairytale retelling.
Beauty and the Beast is classic, one of the most popular stories to retell, so sometimes it can become a little cliche or overdone. But the twist in this one was actually really neat. I liked the idea behind the plot a lot. And the romance was actually kind of sweet. There were a few nods to the classic elements like the library and the rose that still had a fresh new take and felt like a natural part of the story.
I liked Astrid's sister. She was sweet. And I really liked Ivy. I was definitely curious about her. Astrid was okay. I didn't like or dislike her honestly. I liked her role in the story, but not much about who she was really stuck out to me. I liked that she was protective over her little sister and I loved how that created the reason for her cursing the prince. But I struggled to understand and connect to her a lot (which I'll expand on below). The prince was okay too. I liked his backstory, and as it's a novella, there wasn't much room to expand on that, though I was curious about it and wish there had been. He also felt a little...off to me. I loved that he struggled with bitterness and the palace expectations. It was cool to see what made him so impatient with the women of the court and his parents. I liked how he had to learn to stand on his own and, of course, he was endearing because he loved books and learning and gardening, etc. His interests made him unique and I liked that a lot. But it also kind of felt like he was a "beast" just because the story needed him to be. His outbursts didn't feel super natural to me and I'd wished they felt a little smoother, a more cohesive part of his character. He just seemed a little hot and cold, which I didn't love.
I think my biggest issue with the novella was that, cool as the twist was, I didn't love how it was set up. The whole idea is that Astrid's sister is spurned by the prince and Astrid then gets back at the prince to teach him a lesson. But...her sister's "spurning" wasn't really a big deal, and though we spent a portion of the story teetering between whether or not Astrid would actually curse him for it, it still felt a little cardboard. And like a bit of an overreaction on Astrid's part. I just struggled to really buy into it. I think it was mostly because I had a really hard time feeling what Astrid felt. I saw what the page said she felt, but I didn't connect with her and feel it too. I didn't get angry on my sister's behalf and I didn't see the need for the prince to learn a lesson. So, I just didn't emotionally connect when she got upset, which made it harder to care. Her choices just didn't feel realistic to me.
Additionally, and on a more technical level, there were a few phrases and small parts that were redundant. We got the same information twice in some places. And some phrases were used four or five times, possibly to emphasize a thematic point, but we really didn't need it in every single place. I got the point and/or would have liked a little variety. I'd have liked to be shown the growth and lessons learned rather than just told through dialogue. But that may just be a stylistic/editing preference.
I think the book is set in a world I'm not familiar with because I haven't read any of the author's other books. We stayed on the palace grounds, and had a few different mini-settings. The story is a novella, so I didn't expect a lot of in depth worldbuilding, but there was enough hinted at to make me curious about other books by the author. Also, the woods and the library were fun.
Content: the book is a sweet, clean romance. No foul language or violence. The enchantress does curse the prince, so some mild fantasy magic, but there was nothing truly dark about it. The story explores ideas of bitterness, forgiveness, anger, vengeance, etc. which would make for good conversation starters. I'd be comfortable giving the novella to a preteen.
This is the second book in the series I've read, so I'm looking forward to the rest. And I'm curious to check out more of Camille Peters's work in the future.