The Trial is a young adult contemporary thriller with substantial Lord of the Flies vibes where a group of semi-obnoxious teenagers must try to survive in the depths of the jungle after a series of unfortunate events. But as well as the survival of the entirety of the group, there are personal battles raging and being fought, too, stemming from a truly harrowing set of perfectly aligned circumstances. Travelling via private plane, the story follows three basketball players and four cheerleaders from a high school sports centre as they attend basketball playoffs with the girls being there to support and encourage the guys to win. But the last day of the tournament has just passed, and the two teams are on their way back to their school when they decide to throw a raucous party on board to celebrate their freedom. Unfortunately, the plane ends up experiencing problems mid-air causing it to crash and land on a remote, seemingly uninhabited exotic island.
With supplies onboard looking starkly finite and already running out, the group realises they have zero survival skills to keep them alive until those back home discover they did not land back safely. Main character and amateur sleuth Hayley is massively regretting applying to be a cheerleader as her only reason for doing so was to boost her chances of being accepted at an Ivy League University by showing her interest in extra-curricular activities. Now, their lives have been reduced to the mundane, repetitive tasks of finding the basic elements: food, water, warmth and shelter, but little do they realise, the nightmare is only just beginning... spending so much time alone together, tempers fray and anger rises, but they have no one else to rely on but each other. Who will survive this hell on Earth and make it home to their family alive? This is a compelling and heart-pounding thriller with the isolated setting really making it a cracker of a book. The thought that the place could be harbouring a merciless killer and someone who delights in wreaking havoc at a time of such hardship is horrifying, and the tension and nail-biting twists throughout only add to the sheer terror you feel for them all as a reader.
It keeps you guessing until the end, and the fast-paced narrative combined with the idea of a group of casual acquaintances who have to depend on and trust each other implicitly and a cinematic yet oppressive atmosphere, and I struggled to put it down. The Trial really puts the word trial into trials and tribulations as the adversity of both the collective and individual members of those stranded reaches fever pitch, and an unsettling, sinister energy begins to overtake everything. It is an absorbing and, at times, nail-biting thriller with a mystery at its centre over who among them is out to hurry along their peers' demise and who it is that will try anything to attempt to bring it about. As well as the issues they face in relation to survival, Bates touches on topics she's known for exploring in her nonfiction, namely sexual consent, assault, rape, privilege, toxic masculinity, misogyny, class, gender identity and equality which I feel are important subjects to introduce in YA books, and she does so in a subtle, non-preachy manner. A thrilling and thoroughly entertaining read. Highly recommended.