Apologies if this review is all over the place. In honor of this New Years-themed read, I'm writing this review while watching New Year's Eve TV specials...
I read this because I needed a fun New Years-themed book to end my reading year with, and I'd heard great things about this book, particularly from someone I follow in the book community who raved about it. Unfortunately... I really didn't think this book was exceptional. It was very much a typical cheesy YA contemporary with sub-par writing, even with the theme of grief interwoven.
This is another example of a book where I love the concept of the book—being snowed in at an airport on New Year's Eve—but something about the story just didn't sell it for me, and I think a big part of why I didn't like this book was that I couldn't stand Ryn as a character. I just find her to be so, so annoying and she comes across as really immature a lot of the time: in how she handles situations, in how she tries and fails to think logically... And I get it, I get it. She's gone through something incredibly traumatic. Of course she isn't going to be thinking right. Of course she's going to do things that make me want to shake her because she isn't at all in a great headspace and you can't tell someone that there's a wrong way to grieve. But even with all of that, I still can't help but think that she acts so much more immature than she should be. She's, what? 17 or 18 in this book? But she literally acts like she's twelve years old.
I know this is a symptom of her grieving process and it has a larger significance in the novel, but I'm sorry, I couldn't stand how she constantly needed to Google search random questions into her phone every two seconds—it's just fucking stupid. Not to mention how scarily obsessed she is with her phone in general to the point where she freaking screams like a child having a tantrum any time someone even tries to take it from her. Regardless of how annoying she is though, she still ends up meeting a boy, Xander, who can't help falling in love with her because he likes everything about her, which is perhaps the biggest puzzle of all, because she's honestly the most unlikable person imaginable. Seriously, I'm going through the whole novel trying to piece together what this boy sees in her and I'm really stumped; I mean, she's not exactly a fun girl. She literally spends the whole novel dismissing every fun idea or adventure that Xander has, resists him at every turn, is pouty and irritable toward him, lashes out childly... I'm sorry, where are you seeing this girl who's so interesting and irresistible??
Even taking the grief of Lottie's death out of the equation, Ryn still isn't even a remotely interesting person in the shadow of Lottie, which leads to two issues I had with this novel:
1. I really didn't like how Ryn was so, SO dependent on Lottie. I get that that's part of the issue she has to confront in the novel, but it sort of just reveals how weak and boring of a character she is if she has to have Lottie as a crutch for the entire novel, to the point where Lottie subsumes her entire existence and Ryn doesn't know how to live or BE without Lottie. So she just doesn't have any identity at all? She's just an amorphous blob without Lottie?
2. For how much this novel tried to convince me how amazing Lottie was, I really didn't find her so great. It's so typical and I feel like I've seen this SO many times in YA contemporaries: the gorgeous, rebellious best friend who always captures everyone's attention and is just effortlessly cool in every way. Think Allison from Pretty Little Liars. Everyone gushes to you about how perfect this person was, but the more they tell you, the more you start thinking, "...Is this person really all that?" It partly goes back to good writing: if you really have to spend the entire novel trying to sell this character to me on how great she was, that's sort of saying something. Great writing is simply writing the character and letting me figure it out for myself. In this case, I found Lottie such a carbon copy of every "cool/glamorous" best friend trope, not to mention she's incredibly reckless, flighty, and not very clear-headed. Oh, but that's just Lottie! That just makes her who she is! There's even a ridiculous scene where Lottie drags Ryn to play poker in an underground poker joint, and not only is it honestly something out of a really bad, cliche movie scene (Lottie even says "See you boys next time!" after collecting her winnings... ugh) but it's just entire pages gushing about how effortlessly perfect Lottie is:
"Lottie ended up winning over six hundred dollars that night. It turned out she was a natural at poker. Not that I was surprised. Lottie was a natural at most things. It also probably didn't hurt that she blatantly flirted with every guy she was in a hand with. I watched her convince a six-foot-four dude with multiple piercings that her crappy two-seven offsuit was something to be afraid of simply by the way she pursed her lips as she bluffed up the pot. It seemed like regardless of which cards she was dealt—rags, pocket aces, high kickers, low kickers—it never mattered. She always won. Just like in life."
... Like, really? Reeeeeally? Is she really just that amazing? For some reason, I'm just not buying it...
Other things
-- This book also happens to have one of my least—least—favorite tropes of all time: a character who acts so much older than they realistically should, to the point of coming across as obnoxiously pretentious. I sometimes call it the John Green Effect. There's a character in the book, Troy, who's a child prodigy of sorts. And I swear to god, his whole existence is one big eye roll. Every time he speaks I just want to grown inwardly, because his dialogue is so over-the-top and similar to Sheldon Cooper on The Big Bang Theory, which, I'm sorry, is just too much for me. I don't find that realistic to everyday life at all, no matter how smart you are. No one talks like this Here's just a lovely example:
"Oh, come on! the boy yells. "This is preposterous!"
"This is the perfect example of common sense tripping over the frivolity of bureaucratic red tape... I am fully capable of using the lavatory myself!"
Again: no one talks like this. It just comes across as so cliche and I can't take any character seriously who talks like this.
-- Uggggh, for the love of god, it is 2018: We are too far progressed to still be using words like "crazy super slut" in YA novels, especially for an entire page straight. Yeeeah. This is that kind of novel.
-- Another detail that kept popping up and annoying me was the how the author kept describing Lottie's brain splattered across the dashboard or over the clock stuck at 10:05 a.m. Over. And over. And over again. Yes, I totally get why this description is powerful, I get how visceral and raw and heartbreaking this description is. But the beauty of it is, you only need to write it once for it to leave an impact. The problem is, the author kept relying on this description so many times, it eventually lost its significance and intensity. After a while, it just becomes repetitive and lazy writing.
* * *
Final Thoughts: Again, the concept of this novel seemed really fun and promising, but I was really let down by this, especially with how much it was hyped by certain people (*cough*) At the end of the day, this was just a very mediocre YA contemporary with immature teenagers who brought this entire book down. What a disappointing note to end my 2018 reading on!