What do you think?
Rate this book
What Is and Could Be
Timothy Wright’s life revolves around stories. Ever since he had his accident, books have been his only window to the outside. The characters inside are family—he’s sailed the high seas in quest of a white whale, plunged through rabbit holes, and been scolded by the ghost of Christmas present. But when a cheerful Veridan maid comes into his family’s employment, he begins to remember that life could be more than what happens between the pages of his books. In fact, it may be that of all the adventures he’s called home, the most frightening, exhilarating, and rewarding one is yet to come.
ebook
First published January 19, 2019
1 person is currently reading
68 people want to read
About the author
Katelyn Buxton
13 books95 followersHello and welcome!
If you’ve chanced across this page, odds are you’re wanting to know a little more about this "Katelyn" person you found on the Internet. Well, the truth is, I’m just like any other author. I spend my days dreaming about stories and falling hopelessly, head-over-heels in love with my characters. I'm the author of the Warriors of Aralan series, as well as a sci-fi standalone called Tè Nan Lezar, and a couple of nineteenth-century-inspired serializations titled What Is and Could Be and To Live and To Breathe.
When not pursuing a literary career, I can be found with my nose buried inside a book I didn’t write, baking cookies, taking photos, learning French, watching movies, and spending time with my friends and family. My passion is to always give God the glory through my writing in hopes that these stories will touch some lives.
If you’ve chanced across this page, odds are you’re wanting to know a little more about this "Katelyn" person you found on the Internet. Well, the truth is, I’m just like any other author. I spend my days dreaming about stories and falling hopelessly, head-over-heels in love with my characters. I'm the author of the Warriors of Aralan series, as well as a sci-fi standalone called Tè Nan Lezar, and a couple of nineteenth-century-inspired serializations titled What Is and Could Be and To Live and To Breathe.
When not pursuing a literary career, I can be found with my nose buried inside a book I didn’t write, baking cookies, taking photos, learning French, watching movies, and spending time with my friends and family. My passion is to always give God the glory through my writing in hopes that these stories will touch some lives.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews
March 23, 2023
"He wondered if the sun would part the clouds soon. It had been raining for such a long time."
Such is our first glimpse into the Could Be of Timothy Wright's life. The story that follows is one of the loveliest I have read, and leaves me thoughtful and eager for more each time. When so much in life and in literature tells us implicitly or explicitly that life is meaningless, this story, full of hope, is refreshing and precious.
Katelyn's love for words, books, and writing brought to life in Timothy's character makes this tale dear to me as a friend and a fellow bookworm and writer. I'm amazed at how seamlessly and authentically faith blends with fiction, as Timothy reconnects with his Creator and tries to make sense of what is and what could be. The characters filling his world--from beloved, persistently loyal Mary, to St. Vincent, the "feathered horror" of a parrot, to the insufferable Astors--bring the story to life with laughter and tears (and swearing in dog latin, when St Vincent is involved).
Make a cup of tea, grab a blanket, and read this book!
Such is our first glimpse into the Could Be of Timothy Wright's life. The story that follows is one of the loveliest I have read, and leaves me thoughtful and eager for more each time. When so much in life and in literature tells us implicitly or explicitly that life is meaningless, this story, full of hope, is refreshing and precious.
Katelyn's love for words, books, and writing brought to life in Timothy's character makes this tale dear to me as a friend and a fellow bookworm and writer. I'm amazed at how seamlessly and authentically faith blends with fiction, as Timothy reconnects with his Creator and tries to make sense of what is and what could be. The characters filling his world--from beloved, persistently loyal Mary, to St. Vincent, the "feathered horror" of a parrot, to the insufferable Astors--bring the story to life with laughter and tears (and swearing in dog latin, when St Vincent is involved).
Make a cup of tea, grab a blanket, and read this book!
August 2, 2022
4.5 stars
It's always a special privilege to read a book written by a dear friend. This is a light fantasy set in an alternate world based on Victorian England. There are elements in the storytelling that remind me much of Charles Dickens and I heartily enjoyed this story, especially the themes of healing and hope. While I think some character arcs could be more fully fleshed out on the page, I did nonetheless enjoy this story. And I have to admit, St. Vincent is my favorite character. We need more obnoxious parrots providing unnecessary commentary on life.
It's always a special privilege to read a book written by a dear friend. This is a light fantasy set in an alternate world based on Victorian England. There are elements in the storytelling that remind me much of Charles Dickens and I heartily enjoyed this story, especially the themes of healing and hope. While I think some character arcs could be more fully fleshed out on the page, I did nonetheless enjoy this story. And I have to admit, St. Vincent is my favorite character. We need more obnoxious parrots providing unnecessary commentary on life.
July 23, 2022
A quaint, charming, and redemptive coming of age tale that is set in Victorian England, What Is and What Could Be makes for a novel that is unlike anything that I had ever before encountered. As a huge fan of coming of age narratives, I had never before read one that takes place in such a setting. Whenever I think of Victorian novels, I tend to think of the likes of Jane Austen and Charlotte Bronte; I most certainly do not think of “coming-of-age”—so this unique quality alone drew me to the work. What Is and What Could Be effortlessly incorporates the societal plights of the time period in such a manner that they end up proving imperative to the plot of the story. Even while our main character Timothy has been raised upper-class, and while initially he is not particularly aware of the plight of the lower-classes surrounding him, there is so much permeating beneath the surface of Timothy’s life that comes into fruition over the course of the novel.
The writing of What Is and What Could Be is also eloquent. I have remarked in my reviews of the Warriors of Aralan novels that I have not always been the hugest fan of Buxton’s writing style. It often came across to me as rough and unpolished. However, by her eighth and most recent book in the Aralan series, Buxton had hit her stride, such that her writing became effortless and eloquent. What Is and What Could Be further improves upon this trajectory in her work.
As for the characters, Timothy makes for a multi-layered and engrossing protagonist whom it quickly becomes impossible not to resonate with. While we only catch brief glimpses of Timothy’s father’s personality, he is also quite compelling. I look forward to learning more about him as the series progresses! I had mixed feelings, however, about the secondary main character of Mary. She is certainly lovable, but I had been hoping for a bit more of a dynamic and vivid personality with her. I also wish that her faults had been illustrated more poignantly. While I love a good moral compass character in fiction, something felt slightly lacking, seeing that she is one of only two major characters of the work.
I will also admit that something about the work did not entirely grab me the same way that most of the Warriors of Aralan books did—which strikes me as odd, considering that coming of age stories are usually my jive, whereas fantasy is not necessarily my go-to genre. Objectively, though, I think that What Is and What Could Be makes for one of Buxton’s most refined works, if not her very best—and I am certain that it will resonate deeply with numerous readers. Several plot threads are left unresolved, such that I quite look forward to discovering how it all will unfold in the sequel!
The writing of What Is and What Could Be is also eloquent. I have remarked in my reviews of the Warriors of Aralan novels that I have not always been the hugest fan of Buxton’s writing style. It often came across to me as rough and unpolished. However, by her eighth and most recent book in the Aralan series, Buxton had hit her stride, such that her writing became effortless and eloquent. What Is and What Could Be further improves upon this trajectory in her work.
As for the characters, Timothy makes for a multi-layered and engrossing protagonist whom it quickly becomes impossible not to resonate with. While we only catch brief glimpses of Timothy’s father’s personality, he is also quite compelling. I look forward to learning more about him as the series progresses! I had mixed feelings, however, about the secondary main character of Mary. She is certainly lovable, but I had been hoping for a bit more of a dynamic and vivid personality with her. I also wish that her faults had been illustrated more poignantly. While I love a good moral compass character in fiction, something felt slightly lacking, seeing that she is one of only two major characters of the work.
I will also admit that something about the work did not entirely grab me the same way that most of the Warriors of Aralan books did—which strikes me as odd, considering that coming of age stories are usually my jive, whereas fantasy is not necessarily my go-to genre. Objectively, though, I think that What Is and What Could Be makes for one of Buxton’s most refined works, if not her very best—and I am certain that it will resonate deeply with numerous readers. Several plot threads are left unresolved, such that I quite look forward to discovering how it all will unfold in the sequel!
November 17, 2021
I would be delighted if cozy, lowkey alternate Victorian fantasy became a trend. We need more books like this, please!
This is a cozy family drama with lots of humor and heart. The Wright family has been limping along since a tragic accident several years ago. The arrival of a young new maid and an irascible parrot brings new life to the house and starts each member of the family down the path of healing and reconciliation.
I enjoyed the literary references and the brief Secret Garden vibes. A quiet drama like this is deceptively hard to write since there is no flashy plot or fancy tropes to hide behind. It is all about the complexity of humanity and finding the transcendent truths in the ordinary. While Buxton very nearly pulls it off, there were just a few things missing for me.
The characters fell just short of feeling real to me and I couldn't fully connect with them. The scenes were short and often ended very abruptly, preventing me from actually settling in anywhere. And while the emotional arc of Timothy was clearly the story's priority, the plot felt a little bit muddled to me (Chekhov's guns unfired, late foreshadowing, unclear climax, and an ending that sparked more questions than gave resolution).
But the themes about finding healing from brokenness, finding strength in weakness, and being willing to strive and fight for what "could be" instead of settling for "what is" were all beautifully done. And they are messages we all need to hear.
If you are looking for a sweet, cozy, faith-based read, then you should definitely pick this one up. I personally am very interested to see what happens to the Wright family next.
This is a cozy family drama with lots of humor and heart. The Wright family has been limping along since a tragic accident several years ago. The arrival of a young new maid and an irascible parrot brings new life to the house and starts each member of the family down the path of healing and reconciliation.
I enjoyed the literary references and the brief Secret Garden vibes. A quiet drama like this is deceptively hard to write since there is no flashy plot or fancy tropes to hide behind. It is all about the complexity of humanity and finding the transcendent truths in the ordinary. While Buxton very nearly pulls it off, there were just a few things missing for me.
The characters fell just short of feeling real to me and I couldn't fully connect with them. The scenes were short and often ended very abruptly, preventing me from actually settling in anywhere. And while the emotional arc of Timothy was clearly the story's priority, the plot felt a little bit muddled to me (Chekhov's guns unfired, late foreshadowing, unclear climax, and an ending that sparked more questions than gave resolution).
But the themes about finding healing from brokenness, finding strength in weakness, and being willing to strive and fight for what "could be" instead of settling for "what is" were all beautifully done. And they are messages we all need to hear.
If you are looking for a sweet, cozy, faith-based read, then you should definitely pick this one up. I personally am very interested to see what happens to the Wright family next.
March 24, 2024
Stories about friendship don't get much more heart-warming than this one. Timothy is such an endearing yet complex character, and it's truly a joy watching him grow and move forward with the help of cheerful, down-to-earth Mary.
Of course, no review of this book is complete without mentioning St. Vincent, the delightfully contrary parrot. Thanks for all the smiles, St. Vincent. Sorry I can't remember your full name at the moment. 😆
If I were to change anything about What Is and Could Be, I'd make it actually be set in 19th century London, instead of just being in an alternate world based on it. Sometimes figuring out what was the same as our world and what was different kind of confused me. But I understand that the choice of an alternate world gives the author freedom to deviate from the timeline of real history, so it definitely opens up more possibilities.
I first read this on Wattpad a few years ago and enjoyed it, but it impacted me more the second time around. I've been craving something simple, fresh, and wholesome, and this checked all those boxes. A perfect springtime read!
I want to go plant something in my garden now...
Of course, no review of this book is complete without mentioning St. Vincent, the delightfully contrary parrot. Thanks for all the smiles, St. Vincent. Sorry I can't remember your full name at the moment. 😆
If I were to change anything about What Is and Could Be, I'd make it actually be set in 19th century London, instead of just being in an alternate world based on it. Sometimes figuring out what was the same as our world and what was different kind of confused me. But I understand that the choice of an alternate world gives the author freedom to deviate from the timeline of real history, so it definitely opens up more possibilities.
I first read this on Wattpad a few years ago and enjoyed it, but it impacted me more the second time around. I've been craving something simple, fresh, and wholesome, and this checked all those boxes. A perfect springtime read!
I want to go plant something in my garden now...
November 4, 2023
I absolutely loved this story! A Jane Austen inspired story that takes place in an alternate 19th century timeline that explores a sweet friendship between two young people—Timothy and Mary.
**I originally read this book on Wattpad. I received an ARC and have expanded my review. This is my honest opinion and I was not paid for a particular response.
The world was gray, washed of all color.
These are the opening thoughts of Timothy Wright. A missing leg from a childhood accident leaves fifteen-year-old Timothy feeling as though he’d been robbed, not just of a leg, but of his future. A couple chapters later, Timothy bemoans that “Everything was broken. Like himself.”
One of the things that pulled me into this book is how relatable Timothy is. Most of us probably don’t have a missing limb, but we have all experienced times of brokenness, loss, and weakness. We’ve might have felt apart from the rest of the world or wondered where we would find strength to go on. Yet this is not a depressing story, but one full of hope.
What Is and Could Be is a Jane Austen inspired story that takes place in an alternate 19th century timeline that explores the idea of what is and what could be through the sweet friendship of two young people—Timothy and Mary. Timothy lives in Thameton (alternate version of London) of Solarium (the British Empire) and Mary is Veridan (Irish).
I do wonder (this is not criticism on my part, just curiosity) why the author chose to use an alternate version of the Victorian era rather than write it as a pure historical novel. Perhaps, to give the story the freedom to go beyond the restrictions that real time would place on it. Do not assume that this is laziness on part of the author. It is clear she has done her research. I think even a history buff would enjoy finding the tidbits of history slipped into the novel and spotting where it might differ from real time. The end of the book has a nice “Behind the Story” section that I enjoyed. There are also several tributes to classic books, hidden within the pages of the novel.
What Is and Could Be is not a story that’s going to grip you with non-stop action. Rather it draws you in through the lives of its characters. It’s a great comfort read when you need a book that will leave you feeling good. I’ve read it twice (the first when it was still on Wattpad), and the second reading is like sitting down with a couple of good friends with warm coffee. One of the ways I judge a good book is by how often I think about the story after it’s finished. Or a desire to read it a second or third time. Often for me, once I know the ending, the allure of the story is gone. That was not at all the case with What Is and Could Be.
As I read through What Is and Could Be the second time, I took a moment to jot down a few lines of each chapter. It was easy to find a humorous or teaching moment or simply something I could relate to in every chapter. There are a good many quotable passages; however, the writing is not at all pretentious. I found it easy to read, and did not feel like I had to look up definitions or wonder what the writer was trying to say. Katelyn’s writing style is simple, yet beautiful.
For a more detailed review with spoilers, see my blog review: https://leannarapier.com/book-review-...
**I originally read this book on Wattpad. I received an ARC and have expanded my review. This is my honest opinion and I was not paid for a particular response.
The world was gray, washed of all color.
These are the opening thoughts of Timothy Wright. A missing leg from a childhood accident leaves fifteen-year-old Timothy feeling as though he’d been robbed, not just of a leg, but of his future. A couple chapters later, Timothy bemoans that “Everything was broken. Like himself.”
One of the things that pulled me into this book is how relatable Timothy is. Most of us probably don’t have a missing limb, but we have all experienced times of brokenness, loss, and weakness. We’ve might have felt apart from the rest of the world or wondered where we would find strength to go on. Yet this is not a depressing story, but one full of hope.
What Is and Could Be is a Jane Austen inspired story that takes place in an alternate 19th century timeline that explores the idea of what is and what could be through the sweet friendship of two young people—Timothy and Mary. Timothy lives in Thameton (alternate version of London) of Solarium (the British Empire) and Mary is Veridan (Irish).
I do wonder (this is not criticism on my part, just curiosity) why the author chose to use an alternate version of the Victorian era rather than write it as a pure historical novel. Perhaps, to give the story the freedom to go beyond the restrictions that real time would place on it. Do not assume that this is laziness on part of the author. It is clear she has done her research. I think even a history buff would enjoy finding the tidbits of history slipped into the novel and spotting where it might differ from real time. The end of the book has a nice “Behind the Story” section that I enjoyed. There are also several tributes to classic books, hidden within the pages of the novel.
What Is and Could Be is not a story that’s going to grip you with non-stop action. Rather it draws you in through the lives of its characters. It’s a great comfort read when you need a book that will leave you feeling good. I’ve read it twice (the first when it was still on Wattpad), and the second reading is like sitting down with a couple of good friends with warm coffee. One of the ways I judge a good book is by how often I think about the story after it’s finished. Or a desire to read it a second or third time. Often for me, once I know the ending, the allure of the story is gone. That was not at all the case with What Is and Could Be.
As I read through What Is and Could Be the second time, I took a moment to jot down a few lines of each chapter. It was easy to find a humorous or teaching moment or simply something I could relate to in every chapter. There are a good many quotable passages; however, the writing is not at all pretentious. I found it easy to read, and did not feel like I had to look up definitions or wonder what the writer was trying to say. Katelyn’s writing style is simple, yet beautiful.
For a more detailed review with spoilers, see my blog review: https://leannarapier.com/book-review-...
November 17, 2021
I don’t even know where to begin with this review, because I can’t stop raving about this book when given the chance! What Is and Could Be is a heartfelt tale about friendship, hope, struggle, and starting again. I love the characters to pieces. I enjoyed seeing the world and events through both Timothy’s and Mary’s eyes equally, something that doesn’t always happen in books that switch POV. Their different backgrounds and perspectives color their points of view so naturally. Buxton is excellent at giving these characters a lot of emotional depth — you want what they want, you feel their joys and sorrows, you want to see them grow and thrive. The growth of friendship between them felt so natural with all the little missteps and moments of understanding until it unfolds into something beautiful. I loved Timothy’s arc in this story as well — the fits and starts make the growth feel so earned and natural.
Which isn’t to say that the side characters aren’t interesting in their own right. Timothy’s parents who are both flawed and capable of growth, the icy wealthy Astors that serve as a foil to the Wright family, and St Vincent (yes I am counting him because he is a treasure) all hold my interest when they emerge on the page.
The world the story is set in feels so real as well. It’s an alternative Victorian England, with an authentic feel that stems from the author’s love of the period. And set as the backdrop of Timothy’s struggles of finding a place and purpose and Mary’s efforts to help her family, is the reality of child labor that has built many people’s wealth — including Timothy’s family’s. It makes for a compelling background conflict.
I love the blend of humor and heartfelt in this story. It’s made me both laugh and cry. Every time I read this book (which has been several times now — it’s very re-readable), I pick up on something new. This time I’ve been finding new bits of wisdom. This is a book I needed to find at this time in my life, an acknowledgment of loss and pain and struggle with a reminder of hope and the beauty that can be found even in difficult times.
People who love classic literature will enjoy all the little nods to famous tales (and Timothy’s library) and people who love writing and telling stories will find a lot of relatable moments as Timothy embarks on that journey. There’s a natural beauty to the prose that’s enjoyable while not overly showy. As a fair warning, the ending will leave you longing for the sequel.
Definitely do not miss this book! But do come find me after you’ve read it so I have people to fangirl with.
I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
Which isn’t to say that the side characters aren’t interesting in their own right. Timothy’s parents who are both flawed and capable of growth, the icy wealthy Astors that serve as a foil to the Wright family, and St Vincent (yes I am counting him because he is a treasure) all hold my interest when they emerge on the page.
The world the story is set in feels so real as well. It’s an alternative Victorian England, with an authentic feel that stems from the author’s love of the period. And set as the backdrop of Timothy’s struggles of finding a place and purpose and Mary’s efforts to help her family, is the reality of child labor that has built many people’s wealth — including Timothy’s family’s. It makes for a compelling background conflict.
I love the blend of humor and heartfelt in this story. It’s made me both laugh and cry. Every time I read this book (which has been several times now — it’s very re-readable), I pick up on something new. This time I’ve been finding new bits of wisdom. This is a book I needed to find at this time in my life, an acknowledgment of loss and pain and struggle with a reminder of hope and the beauty that can be found even in difficult times.
People who love classic literature will enjoy all the little nods to famous tales (and Timothy’s library) and people who love writing and telling stories will find a lot of relatable moments as Timothy embarks on that journey. There’s a natural beauty to the prose that’s enjoyable while not overly showy. As a fair warning, the ending will leave you longing for the sequel.
Definitely do not miss this book! But do come find me after you’ve read it so I have people to fangirl with.
I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
November 21, 2021
I love a story that gives me a lot to think about, and What is and Could Be certainly fit the bill. While Timothy and Mary tentatively developed their fledgling friendship, Buxton paints a picture of stepping outside your comfort zone and thinking about the needs of others. I loved that their friendship was not perfect; each made mistakes and had to learn to accept each other’s differences. I also enjoyed Timothy’s journey to discovering his purpose; there’s a part of each of us that longs for purpose, and that longing made his struggle easily relatable.
The story remains relatively serious as the family contemplates what their future will look like—still, I loved the comic relief brought to the narrative by a mischievous parrot named St. Vincent. He added a brightness to the somber mood of the Wright home and quickly won a place in my heart.
I’d recommend this book to those looking for a Christian-themed tale inspired by several well-known classics. The ending left me longing for more, and I hope to see what could be in the sequel very soon!
The story remains relatively serious as the family contemplates what their future will look like—still, I loved the comic relief brought to the narrative by a mischievous parrot named St. Vincent. He added a brightness to the somber mood of the Wright home and quickly won a place in my heart.
I’d recommend this book to those looking for a Christian-themed tale inspired by several well-known classics. The ending left me longing for more, and I hope to see what could be in the sequel very soon!
February 10, 2025
Timothy is extremely relatable to my introverted self. Mary is so sweet, I love her quiet strength. The friendship between the two of them begins begrudging and becomes sweet.
There's a tiny bit of mystery. The story also touches on the negatives of child labor along with depression.
A cozy, slice-of-life story about healing and friendship.
There's a tiny bit of mystery. The story also touches on the negatives of child labor along with depression.
A cozy, slice-of-life story about healing and friendship.
November 4, 2023
It's so hard to put into words how amazing this book is. It's cozy, filled with friendship and hardships, and a sprinkle of mystery.
Timothy's arc is good in my opinion. He starts as a cranky gloomy fifteen-year-old boy (missing a leg) and as the book progresses, he learns how to come out of his shell, makes a friend, and gains a deeper relationship with God. I can relate to him and find him multilayered.
Mary reminds me so much of one of my own characters. She's sweet and loyal but not to perfection and has her own struggles. I love how she tries and tries to be Timothy's friend and how she points out his flaws but in a way of helps him grow.
And you can't forget about St. Vincent. Makes me want to get a parrot but also makes me afraid. The way he says the worst things at the worst possible moment is so hilarious.
Overall, this book is my comfort book; I've already read it twice and I plan to read it again. Katelyn's writing style is unique and beautiful. I really recommend this book.
Timothy's arc is good in my opinion. He starts as a cranky gloomy fifteen-year-old boy (missing a leg) and as the book progresses, he learns how to come out of his shell, makes a friend, and gains a deeper relationship with God. I can relate to him and find him multilayered.
Mary reminds me so much of one of my own characters. She's sweet and loyal but not to perfection and has her own struggles. I love how she tries and tries to be Timothy's friend and how she points out his flaws but in a way of helps him grow.
And you can't forget about St. Vincent. Makes me want to get a parrot but also makes me afraid. The way he says the worst things at the worst possible moment is so hilarious.
Overall, this book is my comfort book; I've already read it twice and I plan to read it again. Katelyn's writing style is unique and beautiful. I really recommend this book.
November 17, 2021
This gentle story warmed my heart in so many ways: the sweet friendship at the story’s heart, the many tips of the hat to the classics, the characters' rediscovery of wonder, the author's pleasant sense of humor and comfortably eloquent prose, and the cozy sense of nostalgia for days gone by. I love that the story focuses on hope and healing, yet it isn’t afraid to engage with deep pain and doesn’t need to have a classic, fully-resolved happy ending to bring the characters to a better place. The ending is a brave and meaningful choice on the author's part. I can tell that the characters' journey means a lot to the author, and this book feels like a personal invitation to share in the things that have given her joy and comfort. Buxton's writing has beautiful spirit of expectancy and generosity that has left this reader feeling grateful, uplifted, and cared for.
The story isn't perfect—I would have liked to have gotten to know Mary as well as I got to know Timothy, and there are a few places where the characters' motivations weren't quite clear to me. But stories don't need to be perfect to be worthwhile, meaningful, and beautiful, and What Is and Could Be is all those things.
The story isn't perfect—I would have liked to have gotten to know Mary as well as I got to know Timothy, and there are a few places where the characters' motivations weren't quite clear to me. But stories don't need to be perfect to be worthwhile, meaningful, and beautiful, and What Is and Could Be is all those things.
March 15, 2024
My heart is very full right now as I just closed the pages of this wonderful book. Somehow I always gravitate to the books that make me cry, even if I don't know at the time that they will do so. This book is no different.
There was one point in the story where a character was going through something similar to what I went through this past year. His revelation and his prayer to God struck me in such a personal way that I felt seen and understood. Honestly, that is such a gift. Excuse me while I cry and hug this book. 😭
This book reminds me a lot of Frances Hodgson Burnett's "The Secret Garden ". It's whimsical, charming and extremely heartfelt.
The cast of characters is small, leaving them feeling like family. To say that I adore Timothy Wright and Mary O'Connor would be a VAST understatement. They have my heart, and I just want to give them hugs.
"What Is and Could Be" by Katelyn Buxton features a wonderfully bookish protagonist, a timeless friendship and an ornery bird you didn't know you needed. It's a book that instantly feels like home, familiar, safe and warm. It's a book that feels like a classic, like it should have been around for a long time, and a book I need to read over again because in Shakespeare's Juliet's words, "Parting is such sweet sorrow that I'll say good night till it be morrow."
There was one point in the story where a character was going through something similar to what I went through this past year. His revelation and his prayer to God struck me in such a personal way that I felt seen and understood. Honestly, that is such a gift. Excuse me while I cry and hug this book. 😭
This book reminds me a lot of Frances Hodgson Burnett's "The Secret Garden ". It's whimsical, charming and extremely heartfelt.
The cast of characters is small, leaving them feeling like family. To say that I adore Timothy Wright and Mary O'Connor would be a VAST understatement. They have my heart, and I just want to give them hugs.
"What Is and Could Be" by Katelyn Buxton features a wonderfully bookish protagonist, a timeless friendship and an ornery bird you didn't know you needed. It's a book that instantly feels like home, familiar, safe and warm. It's a book that feels like a classic, like it should have been around for a long time, and a book I need to read over again because in Shakespeare's Juliet's words, "Parting is such sweet sorrow that I'll say good night till it be morrow."
August 6, 2022
This is an easy short novel to read. The writing is fluent and very focused on the characters which makes it easy to turn the pages. After about 25% of the story, I began to wonder whether it was going to take off or would it be this relatively simple story of two teenagers who become friends and in so doing bring some much-needed light into the other’s life. I was a little disappointed in that the latter is really all that transpired.
Timothy Wright is a cranky 15 year old, having lost his leg in an unfortunate accident a few years back. He spends his days couped up in a study reading and re-reading some of the classics. Along comes Mary, a 14 year old maid, who is from a poor family of seven children. She provides an important income to assist her parents. Unlike, Timothy, Mary is quite the ray of sunshine with a positive outlook on life irrespective of her circumstances. Because of her strong faith in Jesus.
Gradually, Mary’s brightness coaxes Timothy out of his shell and he discovers there is more to life than having his head in a book. And he finds God again. But Timothy can also teach Mary much. Their friendship is a pleasure to read, their fascination with each other’s differences, their willingness to try new things and to enjoy the wonder of the imagination.
The story is apparently set in an alternate Victorian era. Unfortunately, the author doesn’t provide us with any great visual images of the times. This really could be a historical fiction novel, not a speculative one. Other than the unusual names of locations, there is nothing that reveals this ‘alternate’ world. I just pictured Victorian England, not unlike a Dickens setting.
And then there is the garden which is a source of joy for our friends. Once again, I didn’t get a great visual sense of this place and hence, for me there was no wonder or magic about it.
Besides the need for greater visualisation of the era, this novel lacked any real conflict which is so essential to making a good story. Yes, there’s a coming of age element to it and so we see Timothy grapple with his cantankerousness and disability but I feel this would have been a stronger story if there had a real external conflict that served as an barrier to Timothy and Mary’s friendship.
The story ends a little unsatisfying, however, I wonder if it’s set up for a sequel which perhaps makes me think Timothy and Mary’s story has still got some telling.
Timothy Wright is a cranky 15 year old, having lost his leg in an unfortunate accident a few years back. He spends his days couped up in a study reading and re-reading some of the classics. Along comes Mary, a 14 year old maid, who is from a poor family of seven children. She provides an important income to assist her parents. Unlike, Timothy, Mary is quite the ray of sunshine with a positive outlook on life irrespective of her circumstances. Because of her strong faith in Jesus.
Gradually, Mary’s brightness coaxes Timothy out of his shell and he discovers there is more to life than having his head in a book. And he finds God again. But Timothy can also teach Mary much. Their friendship is a pleasure to read, their fascination with each other’s differences, their willingness to try new things and to enjoy the wonder of the imagination.
The story is apparently set in an alternate Victorian era. Unfortunately, the author doesn’t provide us with any great visual images of the times. This really could be a historical fiction novel, not a speculative one. Other than the unusual names of locations, there is nothing that reveals this ‘alternate’ world. I just pictured Victorian England, not unlike a Dickens setting.
And then there is the garden which is a source of joy for our friends. Once again, I didn’t get a great visual sense of this place and hence, for me there was no wonder or magic about it.
Besides the need for greater visualisation of the era, this novel lacked any real conflict which is so essential to making a good story. Yes, there’s a coming of age element to it and so we see Timothy grapple with his cantankerousness and disability but I feel this would have been a stronger story if there had a real external conflict that served as an barrier to Timothy and Mary’s friendship.
The story ends a little unsatisfying, however, I wonder if it’s set up for a sequel which perhaps makes me think Timothy and Mary’s story has still got some telling.
January 3, 2023
4.5 stars
This is my first book by this author, and I absolutely loved it and look forward to reading more by her.
I love Buxton's writing style with the slightly vintage flavor.
Timothy was a great character. I appreciated that when he started to change, he didn't just all of the sudden become a perfect person. He still struggled and had to fight against his old self. I also loved that his change was not in himself, but in God.
Mary was a dear, but not one of those girls who are so perfect that they just become annoying. She had her own problems, struggles, imperfections.
The parrot was hilarious.
The parents were interesting. Part of me would have loved to get to know them a little better and even understand a little better what changed them because it seemed almost sudden for his parents.
The story was intriguing and as I said, well written. There were a couple times that I thought chapters ended rather abruptly or just too soon. But it didn't take away greatly from the story. I just hoped to read more at spots.
I was definitely reminded some of The Christmas Carol and The Secret Garden. The ending was a bit somber, but also left you feeling hopeful and, honestly, I am eager to read the next book in the series.
I appreciated the lessons in this book. I loved Timothy and Mary's sweet and innocent friendship. I loved Mary's response to Timothy's loneliness and need for a friend and that she made it clear that while she could be a friend, only God could fill his true needs.
This was overall a super sweet story. It was easy to read and I am guessing written more for YA but I enjoyed it too and did not find it overly simplistic like some YA can be. The cover is lovely. And I look forward to reading more by this author.
This is my first book by this author, and I absolutely loved it and look forward to reading more by her.
I love Buxton's writing style with the slightly vintage flavor.
Timothy was a great character. I appreciated that when he started to change, he didn't just all of the sudden become a perfect person. He still struggled and had to fight against his old self. I also loved that his change was not in himself, but in God.
Mary was a dear, but not one of those girls who are so perfect that they just become annoying. She had her own problems, struggles, imperfections.
The parrot was hilarious.
The parents were interesting. Part of me would have loved to get to know them a little better and even understand a little better what changed them because it seemed almost sudden for his parents.
The story was intriguing and as I said, well written. There were a couple times that I thought chapters ended rather abruptly or just too soon. But it didn't take away greatly from the story. I just hoped to read more at spots.
I was definitely reminded some of The Christmas Carol and The Secret Garden. The ending was a bit somber, but also left you feeling hopeful and, honestly, I am eager to read the next book in the series.
I appreciated the lessons in this book. I loved Timothy and Mary's sweet and innocent friendship. I loved Mary's response to Timothy's loneliness and need for a friend and that she made it clear that while she could be a friend, only God could fill his true needs.
This was overall a super sweet story. It was easy to read and I am guessing written more for YA but I enjoyed it too and did not find it overly simplistic like some YA can be. The cover is lovely. And I look forward to reading more by this author.
January 7, 2022
The story had heart, and a beautiful cover, and a pair of sweet young narrators. I kind of wanted a little more worldbuilding than I got before the Author Notes at the end though--all the way through I was like "if this is a fantasy world, why are the two countries mentioned basically England and Ireland under different names and why do they have our books and our Bible?" but apparently it's just a parallel earth where countries have different names but basically everything else seems super similar. I'm preaching to myself here a bit, since I have a fantasy world that's heavily influenced by a historical era in those isles and I'm struggling with this myself, but I wanted something more distinctive about this world that would mean the story wouldn't be the same if it were transferred to our Earth's history.
Other than that, I have no real quibbles with it--it's a cozy quiet plot with characters easy to get along with as a reader as you watch their growth, there are some decent threads leading to the sequel, and I think a number of you friends who read my reviews might quite enjoy it. I just...I didn't click with it, and that's a me thing.
Other than that, I have no real quibbles with it--it's a cozy quiet plot with characters easy to get along with as a reader as you watch their growth, there are some decent threads leading to the sequel, and I think a number of you friends who read my reviews might quite enjoy it. I just...I didn't click with it, and that's a me thing.
September 2, 2022
It has taken me way too long to write a review for this book. This book was so cozy and with classical feels and deals with tough subjects. I am really looking forward to continuing this series and following her author journey.
I loved that this book was in a fictional land but with some familiarities such as books and authors. As a writer who doesn't want to have to put up with being historically accurate it was really nice to see someone else doing what they want. It was kind of like it is a sign that, as a writer, I also am allowed to do whatever I went. XD
One thing I would have liked to see more is why Prissy is so awful before hand. We see Timothy is dead set she is the worst before she is introduced but I would have liked to see that before Timothy said so to make up my own mine (but also, she is pretty bad XD)
OH and the friendships. I loved them. I love a good romance in a story and it can be hard sometimes when characters don't end up together, but in this book they are kids, and so we get to see kids being friends- with deep friendship. Which honestly, the whole world needs more of this and a better understanding of this. I loved that.
I loved that this book was in a fictional land but with some familiarities such as books and authors. As a writer who doesn't want to have to put up with being historically accurate it was really nice to see someone else doing what they want. It was kind of like it is a sign that, as a writer, I also am allowed to do whatever I went. XD
One thing I would have liked to see more is why Prissy is so awful before hand. We see Timothy is dead set she is the worst before she is introduced but I would have liked to see that before Timothy said so to make up my own mine (but also, she is pretty bad XD)
OH and the friendships. I loved them. I love a good romance in a story and it can be hard sometimes when characters don't end up together, but in this book they are kids, and so we get to see kids being friends- with deep friendship. Which honestly, the whole world needs more of this and a better understanding of this. I loved that.
April 21, 2023
The best and worst I can say of this book is that if felt like reading a selection from Household Words expanded and put into modern language.*
The author does a lovely job with description and the prose was very smooth, which is why I didn't mind reading it so quickly. The two characters were also fun. I really found myself liking Timothy. Despite my below complaints, I did enjoy reading it. It was a fun story.
However, nothing really happens in this book besides two people becoming friends. There are two major red herring mysteries that were never explained or developed. Also, it takes a long time for the characters to develop at all. It's also very didactic in a way that doesn't always feel natural. The background history and characters also were rather vague and featureless.
But overall, a fun cute tale of friendship that a child might enjoy.
*Think vibes of Lizzie Leigh meets A Child Dreams of a Star, but while many people adore Gaskell I was not her biggest fan
The author does a lovely job with description and the prose was very smooth, which is why I didn't mind reading it so quickly. The two characters were also fun. I really found myself liking Timothy. Despite my below complaints, I did enjoy reading it. It was a fun story.
However, nothing really happens in this book besides two people becoming friends. There are two major red herring mysteries that were never explained or developed. Also, it takes a long time for the characters to develop at all. It's also very didactic in a way that doesn't always feel natural. The background history and characters also were rather vague and featureless.
But overall, a fun cute tale of friendship that a child might enjoy.
*Think vibes of Lizzie Leigh meets A Child Dreams of a Star, but while many people adore Gaskell I was not her biggest fan
March 19, 2024
I absolutely loved the story that was told within these pages.
Timothy, Mary, and St. Vincent are absolutely delightful and endearing, the descriptions are done very well so that you can see the story in your mind, and the message is poignant. This is an excellent and wonderful reminder for us to not get caught up in what is to the point that we miss the could be.
Timothy, Mary, and St. Vincent are absolutely delightful and endearing, the descriptions are done very well so that you can see the story in your mind, and the message is poignant. This is an excellent and wonderful reminder for us to not get caught up in what is to the point that we miss the could be.
January 3, 2022
I'm a bit biased because I know the author. I enjoyed the characters and the heart in it. I read it from cover to cover. Well done, Katie! I'm looking forward to the next one.
March 21, 2024
I like what I like, and what I like happens to be uplifting, character-study-centric historical novels with homage to classic lit. What is and Could Be is so wholesome, so gentle, so in tune with the real and the human, I felt both seen and connected to the deeper resonance of humanity across all time and space. I'll read anything Katelyn Buxton writes without hesitation, send book 2 and tissues please, thanks.
Literally the only thing I would wish different about this book is that it was straight up historical fiction – instead of a Victorian-era parallel universe– because it felt so genuine and so grounded that the occasional non-real-world name threw me. But that's not enough to dock even half a star because this book truly did hit all my sweet spots. Recommended for all ages and those who are fond of a poignant, introspective style + focus on characters over action.
Literally the only thing I would wish different about this book is that it was straight up historical fiction – instead of a Victorian-era parallel universe– because it felt so genuine and so grounded that the occasional non-real-world name threw me. But that's not enough to dock even half a star because this book truly did hit all my sweet spots. Recommended for all ages and those who are fond of a poignant, introspective style + focus on characters over action.
November 18, 2021
'What Is and Could Be' is a very sweet book about friendship, imagination and overcoming fears. In many ways it reminded me in ways of Louisa May Alcott's stories and writing style. Like Alcott, Buxton's story is character driven, with moral lessons and 'coming-of-age' struggles.
Timothy Wright's sarcastic inner dialogue was fun to read, he often made me laugh. On the other hand, the deep pain that he struggles with adds depth to his character. His harsh thoughts about himself, and often awkward sharp remarks to others were something he had to wrestle with throughout the book. I often wanted to wrap him up in a hug.
This is where Mary comes in, the other main character. She is the burst of sunlight in his world, who motivates him to learn to relate to others and face his fears by coming out of his shell. Mary's kind and warm personality is contrasted by the struggles she faces working in the Wright household. From being blamed for things she had no part in, to facing the often frigid attitudes of her employers.
Of course, no review of this book would be complete without mention of St. Vincent, the parrot who is very colourful in personality. He often made me laugh!
I adored the setting, although this is a fantasy novel, it is very reminiscent of Victorian England. The dark, grand and serious home of the Wrights is contrasted with the small, cosy and warm home where Mary's family lives.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book. The cover is SO beautiful, and matches so well with the story! You should definitely add 'What Is and Could Be' to your reading list, I look forward to publication when I can add the physical copy to my bookshelf.
Timothy Wright's sarcastic inner dialogue was fun to read, he often made me laugh. On the other hand, the deep pain that he struggles with adds depth to his character. His harsh thoughts about himself, and often awkward sharp remarks to others were something he had to wrestle with throughout the book. I often wanted to wrap him up in a hug.
This is where Mary comes in, the other main character. She is the burst of sunlight in his world, who motivates him to learn to relate to others and face his fears by coming out of his shell. Mary's kind and warm personality is contrasted by the struggles she faces working in the Wright household. From being blamed for things she had no part in, to facing the often frigid attitudes of her employers.
Of course, no review of this book would be complete without mention of St. Vincent, the parrot who is very colourful in personality. He often made me laugh!
I adored the setting, although this is a fantasy novel, it is very reminiscent of Victorian England. The dark, grand and serious home of the Wrights is contrasted with the small, cosy and warm home where Mary's family lives.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book. The cover is SO beautiful, and matches so well with the story! You should definitely add 'What Is and Could Be' to your reading list, I look forward to publication when I can add the physical copy to my bookshelf.
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews