[Thanks to Netgalley and Kodansha for an ARC in exchange for an honest review]
Ayumu is the junior at his school’s shogi club and, in fact, the only other member besides Yaotome, his cute sempai. They play constantly and are very attracted to one another, but Ayumu has promised himself he won’t confess until he beats Yaotome and, given his skill level, they might be pensioners before that happens.
We move from the middle school burgeoning feelings of Teasing Master Takagi-san to the already hormonal halls of high school for this one and it turns out that works really, really well. In fact, I think I might like it better.
Part of this is the balance - Takagi-san was cute but the story always ended the same way, with the male lead losing. That has not changed here, but Ayumu is constantly losing one game while Yaotome is very badly losing the other game (arguably they both are). It makes it a bit more fun.
Ayumu’s endless stoicism is great because the book wisely doesn’t conflate that with being uncaring. He isn’t ready to confess, despite many near misses (and poor Yaotome catches every single one), but he has no issue being free with the compliments and it’s a nice touch. It’s nice having an intense character who isn’t inherently dull or withdrawn.
Yes his pledge is dumb - I get the whole wanting to be equal thing, but get over yourself - but without it we wouldn’t have a book. I think accepting that is probably the biggest barrier to entry, though I do at least get where that’s coming from.
For her part, Yaotome has no trouble expressing herself and her reactions are half the fun - I love her trademark ’NWHA!?’ when Ayumu scores a direct hit. She is constantly trying to maneuver him into saying something, but the book cleverly makes it known that Ayumu’s strength is in playing defence.
As for how much shogi knowledge you need for this story, I am happy to say it is exactly none. There is a handy primer at the start for the curious, but I know exactly as much as I did before, which is ‘this is sort of like chess’.
What I do kind of love is how the shogi is used and how manages to cater to both the newbie and the hardcore. For the latter, several chapters end with full records of the game our leads were playing, so you can follow it along move by move.
For everybody else, well, more than once the circumstances of the game reflect what’s happening in the story at large. The best example is the Invincible Wall chapter, which you can see the ending of very quickly but is no less fun for it.
The author also smartly makes a point of staging chapters outside the club so the setting doesn’t get stale, but honestly the bloom never came off the rose in that respect. The running gag/drama about member recruitment is also very well realized.
The chapters see nice and short too, which keeps them punchy and doesn’t drag any one gag out any longer than it needs to be. Throw in a pair with great chemistry and what more can you ask for?
5 stars - give me a couple worth watching and endless cute moments and you’ve got me, it’s really that simple. The story might not be new at a primal level, but the way it’s telling it is and that makes a ton of difference. It’s probably more of a 4 star, really, but I have read a lot of mediocre (and worse) stories this week and this is hands down the best thing I’ve seen so far, no question.