I received an ARC from the author, and I’ll start by saying that Zoe York is definitely in the top ten of my favorites. That said, I’m not able to give this particular novella five stars. I really did enjoy it and I found the characters, Ben and Chelsea, realistic and relatable. It’s a love-at-first-sight story, and I’m fine with those too. It veers into painting their relationship as almost a fairytale romance, and even that I can handle. What bothered me was when the characters started voicing their undying love for one another. This may not bother other readers, but to me, it felt saccharine and overdone. I guess I found it hard to believe that either of them could harbor such strong emotions for the other when they’d had so little time together.
Love-at-first-sight is all well and good, and I can even see a couple determining that they are meant to be together and should be married within a very short time. However, I’ve always imagined that kind of decision accompanied a feeling that love would grow over time and not that it was already so intense. Perhaps that is my misconception. Be that as it may, it pulled me out of the story, and as a result, reminded me that it was fictional. Since my main reason for reading fiction is to escape reality for a few moments at a time, I don’t like when I’m pulled from the fantasy to question the likelihood of something that’s happening. I still recommend the book because it’s a great story to get you in the mood for Christmas miracles.