2.5★
i’m sad. i’m livid. i’m having too many conflicted feelings about this book but what i do know is that it has greatly impacted me in one way or another. i don’t know if this star rating is accurate; i’m pretty sure it will change as i think and ponder more on how i feel about this book.
hurricane summer is a chaotic storm of devastating, deeply rooted tragedies, as well as joyous, heartfelt celebrations.
i read this book in 3 days but it felt like i’ve lived the summer in jamaica with these characters. these whom i absolutely detested with all of my being—except for maybe two rarities, one of which i will constantly be thinking of.
it’s nearly impossible to properly review this book without spoiling it but i’ll attempt to walk you through the plethora of emotions i’ve had to experience here.
let’s start with vivid, pulsing, and incredibly vibrant jamaica! the setting couldn’t have been more perfect. we’re introduced to a colorful country glowing with so much life and culture and asha bromfield brought it justice with her stunning writing.
i was first thrown off by how the jamaican patois was the heart and soul of the dialogue, which i quickly grew to love and enjoy. with it came the culture shock that the main character, tilla, goes through and it feels as if i’ve lived it along with her. the reverberations of that were portrayed effectively and it left me glued to the page as the story progressed.
the story this book was telling had captured me entirely in the beginning, i was so engrossed with these characters and wanting to learn more about them and the island. however, somewhere around the 25% mark or so, i was lost.
for one, as much as i loved tilla in the beginning, she began to seem more selfish and self-absorbed in some ways. her actions didn’t match with her words and she was kind of stoic and stagnant, her arc unmoving while the story’s was seeping through. i almost went mad with how close i was to begging for her to do something, to prove someone wrong, but she didn’t and it made me furious. it was almost like she was watching everything happen to her and letting it.
almost all of the rest of the characters were hateful and despicable (which is intentional) except tilla’s little sister, mia, and of course: andre. he was the light of this story for me. i loved him so much. no other character came close to this boy. he deserved the whole entire world and more.
there is no doubt that this book addresses important topics, but i just think it took on too many too fast and, as much as i was appreciative of the effort at first, as the story progressed, more and more wounds were left unattended to. i don’t know if it was intentional but it was definitely not something i appreciated.
it just…upset me. it made me feel a lot of unease and frustration. i seriously wanted to punch a wall with everything that was going on—and nobody doing anything to stop it. at some point in the story, i just started to hate where it was going, what it was leaving behind, how it was being handled and how it ended.
i waited for something to change. anything. but the ending fueled me even more. and i cannot recover from the pain and scars hurricane summer has given me nor can i forgive it.
even with the many aspects that unsettled me, i empathize so much with the story. and i’m very aware it’s real so i’m definitely not trying to invalidate that in any way, i just did not like that it showed the ‘horrible side,’ and the lack of an impactful resolution left me more on edge. i wanted more of a deduction from the story. i wanted a richer, more complete outlook—one that i was convinced of and more well-rounded than what we were given for an ending. it’s not that i expected it all to be rainbows and sunshine by the end; (actually, the opposite. if you read the book, you know what i mean.) i expected more—resilience? “lesson learned”? changing?—from the main character. this could be a personal preference, but it’s the only way i view it.
all in all, i didn’t like many things about this book, but i’m not sure if it’s the story’s fault or my receiving it. either way, it did not sit well with me in the end. however, there are many things to love here, too, and many topics it addresses that are too important not to have conversations and discussions about. from that viewpoint, i highly recommend this book—though i cannot promise you an ‘enjoyable’ read.
see, this is what i meant when i said this book has me feeling all kinds of conflicted feelings!!!
hurricane summer is beautiful and ugly with all of its sharp edges, being rich with culture and full of nuance, bursting with adventure and heartache. it has made me smile, scream, cry and laugh. and it think it will stay with me for a long while.
——— please, please, please do not pick this book up if you can’t handle the trigger warnings. all of it is on-page and it’s horrible and disturbing, so please beware.
trigger warnings: colorism, racism, sexual assault, rape, incest, child neglect, slut-shaming, colonialism, natural disaster, mental and emotional abuse, physical abuse, manipulation, classism, cheating, abandonment, drowning, religious discussions/argumentation + may add more
——— digital arc provided by the publisher via edelweiss in exchange for an honest review.