What do you think?
Rate this book
Left, Right and Centre: The Idea of India
As India approaches its seventy-fifth year of Independence, its people continue to grapple with multiple discourses: a few from the left, a considerable sum from the right and an impressive lot from the centre. This book brings together diverse views from people across a wide spectrum of life-politicians, activists, administrators, artistes, academicians-who offer their idea of India. With a contextual introduction by Nidhi Razdan, this politically charged, argumentative, candid and humorous book opens a window to our understanding of India that largely remained untold and unknown for a long time.
288 pages, Paperback
Published March 1, 2022
11 people are currently reading
125 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews
July 14, 2022
The idea of India and what it means is fiercely contested nowadays. This book is an attempt to give some direction and nuance to the idea of India as percieved by individual contributors. It can be easily established that any truism about India can be immediately contradicted by another truism about India. It is often said that 'anything you can say about India, the opposite is also equally true'.
It is also true that no other country in the world embraces the extraordinary mixture of ethnic groups, the profusion of mutually incomprehensible languages, the varieties of topography and climate, the diversity of religions and cultural practices and the range of levels of economic development like India does.
The initial part of book focuses on conflict in Kashmir. Shah Faesal and Rahul Pandita have managed to showcase mirror to both sides of the aisle about the ongoing crisis in that land. The essay by Pratap Bhanu Mehta was very engaging and it explored the idea of identity and freedom. Sunita Narain was able to focus on environmental crisis along with other intersectional crisis which india faces everyday. Gautam Bhan focussed on dignity of sexuality or more so we can say the indignity associated with it as percieved by society.
It is also true that no other country in the world embraces the extraordinary mixture of ethnic groups, the profusion of mutually incomprehensible languages, the varieties of topography and climate, the diversity of religions and cultural practices and the range of levels of economic development like India does.
The initial part of book focuses on conflict in Kashmir. Shah Faesal and Rahul Pandita have managed to showcase mirror to both sides of the aisle about the ongoing crisis in that land. The essay by Pratap Bhanu Mehta was very engaging and it explored the idea of identity and freedom. Sunita Narain was able to focus on environmental crisis along with other intersectional crisis which india faces everyday. Gautam Bhan focussed on dignity of sexuality or more so we can say the indignity associated with it as percieved by society.
January 21, 2023
If the intention of the book was to present the idea of India from the prisms of left right and centre, I am afraid, the objectives were far from being achieved.
The selection of essays to expound the ideologies is not spectacular, even if those are from the very prominent voices, some of who I personally have great admiration for.
And, most voices in the book honestly very moderate, probably all leaning slightly towards the left. You can't have one essay from Chandan Mitra and claim to have covered the views of the right.
I liked some of the essays stand-alone, though.
The selection of essays to expound the ideologies is not spectacular, even if those are from the very prominent voices, some of who I personally have great admiration for.
And, most voices in the book honestly very moderate, probably all leaning slightly towards the left. You can't have one essay from Chandan Mitra and claim to have covered the views of the right.
I liked some of the essays stand-alone, though.
August 19, 2017
The book is a curious pot-pourri of 13 essays by different contributors- ranging from Shah Faesal, a Civil Services exam topper from Kashmir to Aruna Roy, an activist who resigned from IAS to work in rural Rajasthan. The best essays are by the usual suspects- Mukul Kesavan (original as always,he brings to light the role of Parsis in fathering an anti-colonial nationalism) and Pratap Bhanu Mehta ( scholarly essay which introduces the ideas of Federation Of Communities and Zone of Individual Freedom).
Aruna Roy and Sunita Narain fail to convert their field/domain expertise to readable essays. Shashi Tharoor regurgitates ideas he has been articulating right from his first non-fiction book. In times when even courts instruct us to rise for the National Anthem at theatres to prove our patriotism, the book's premise is promising but it falls short due to inconsistency in quality.
Aruna Roy and Sunita Narain fail to convert their field/domain expertise to readable essays. Shashi Tharoor regurgitates ideas he has been articulating right from his first non-fiction book. In times when even courts instruct us to rise for the National Anthem at theatres to prove our patriotism, the book's premise is promising but it falls short due to inconsistency in quality.
June 17, 2019
Even though the name is left right center it highly inclined in one direction
September 13, 2017
In full disclosure, I picked this book up because of the introduction by Nidhi Razdan. I have always liked her analysis and the piece did not disappoint. The rest of the book is made up of essays that cover a range of subjects from the politics of self, Kashmir, women's rights, LGBTQ rights, the Right movement and a lot more. And to each author's credit, everyone covers their respective subjects in great depth. While some are easy to read and comprehend, others are not so and that is where my issue lies with this book. Yes, they are complex subjects to cover but drowning the narrative in complicated terms and history does no one any favours and more over deters people from proceeding. This is not supposed to be light reading but I wish some of the language was more common place and relatable.
But overall the analysis on the range of subjects is solid and for anyone looking to go deep into these matters, this book will act as a good starting point.
But overall the analysis on the range of subjects is solid and for anyone looking to go deep into these matters, this book will act as a good starting point.
August 10, 2020
Nidhi, one of the finest journalist. Her shows are unique in NDTV, very polite,composed and gentle. No shouts & No scream. Very informative.
About the Book.....
70th years of Independence, under the title 'the idea of India' with various selection of essays from eminent people, starting from Nidhi's introduction, Shash Faesal - First Kashmiri Muslim cracked IAS, Rahul Pandita Kashmiri Pandits essay, Ghautam Bhan LGBT activist, Yashwant Sinha's essay, Chandan Mitra's very beautiful India's idea, Derek O'Brien's as usual style of his idea of India, Mukul Kesavan & Pratap Bhanu Mehta's history touch, Sunita Narain's idea of Utopia, Shashi's usual style of expressing idea of India, Aruna Roys feminism finally shabana Azmi's essay under the heading of negotiation. Its really superb collection of essay.
Really very interesting read. It covers all aspect of India.
About the Book.....
70th years of Independence, under the title 'the idea of India' with various selection of essays from eminent people, starting from Nidhi's introduction, Shash Faesal - First Kashmiri Muslim cracked IAS, Rahul Pandita Kashmiri Pandits essay, Ghautam Bhan LGBT activist, Yashwant Sinha's essay, Chandan Mitra's very beautiful India's idea, Derek O'Brien's as usual style of his idea of India, Mukul Kesavan & Pratap Bhanu Mehta's history touch, Sunita Narain's idea of Utopia, Shashi's usual style of expressing idea of India, Aruna Roys feminism finally shabana Azmi's essay under the heading of negotiation. Its really superb collection of essay.
Really very interesting read. It covers all aspect of India.
October 24, 2021
If you have been following Indian news even casually for the last 20 or so years, then the book doesn't add much- however if you are suddenly interested to know more about India, then perhaps its a good book to start.
The book is a collection of essays by people of various ideologies- It seems like there was no direction on what they are supposed to actually write about. The matter is all over the park. Frankly disappointed with the book.
The book is a collection of essays by people of various ideologies- It seems like there was no direction on what they are supposed to actually write about. The matter is all over the park. Frankly disappointed with the book.
December 27, 2017
essays by aruna roya, sunita narain fails to connect fully with the readers inspite of their enormous experience. Writings by unseasoned writers often get messy.
July 14, 2020
The title is quite appealing I must say , it can draw a lot of casual readers , scholars and likewise . It's a collection of accounts shared by a handful of known public figures with diverse ideological leanings .
Nothing out of the box , and definitely not a guide for demystifying the complexities of the ideological divide , neither does the book claims so. The editing could have been a little tighter as the book drags with unwanted detailings unnecessarily stretching the argument . But overall it was a good one time read .
Nothing out of the box , and definitely not a guide for demystifying the complexities of the ideological divide , neither does the book claims so. The editing could have been a little tighter as the book drags with unwanted detailings unnecessarily stretching the argument . But overall it was a good one time read .
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 11, 2020
The converging as well as the dichotomy of thoughts presented in the series of essays in this book gives food for thought. Essays by Pratap Bhanu Mehta, Aruna Roy and Yashwant Sinha are especially engaging.
August 1, 2017
Well edited and the collection of pieces does justice to the title. There are however some weak(er) pieces and be prepared to be dismayed when you chance on them.
February 10, 2023
A good view on each topic from different people which gave different perspective
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews