Do not make yourself small
just to appease others
when you can fill up the sky.
From “Museum in Her Head,” by Marie Lu
This collection of 30 contributions—short stories, poems, graphic art, one-act play—compiled and edited by the Coalition of Asian Pacifics in Entertainment (CAPE), captures the experience of Asians or Asian-Americans in America. Each contribution reflects a unique lived experience. Each is thoughtful, touching one’s soul. Together, this collection is powerful, in showing the experience of Asians in America; sharing their “otherness,” i.e., the feeling of not really belonging; confronting the challenges of being the “model minority” when the Asian collection is so diverse; attempting to assimilate, not to draw attention to themselves (see quote above), to be white, only to realize it does not apply to them; and succeeding when they accepted who they were and demanded their rights.
The book was birthed in the Trump era, that promoted anti-Asian sentiment and resulting in increased attacks on Asians in America. Yet, the stories reflect pre-Trump days and illustrate the systemic challenges faced by Asian immigrants and their children.
One beneficiary group of this book is Asian Americans who may have experienced similar situations. The stories can let them know they are not alone, and perhaps encourage them to take action to demand their rights, to be themselves and not what others want to them.
But the larger, white population will benefit from this book. Seeing the world through a distinct set of eyes can hurt, but it can help us grow beyond our lived experiences.
These stories also convey a wide range of emotions: hurt at being called out for looking different (“Where are you from? No, really, where are you from?”); remorse for how they regretted earlier behavior; confusion, then anger at playing the American dream only to reach the “you’re not white” reality; and pride when they took control of their own feelings and heritage.
All the stories offered personal insights. “Working While Asian,” by Ellen K Pao, describes her success in becoming the CEO of Reddit, instituting changes, and then being pushed out. She talks about how “the tech industry is built on barriers to progress for Asians—along with Black people, Latinx people, Indigenous people, women, nonbinary people, transgender people, disabled people, and so many others….” (p181). She persevered and founded a nonprofit Project Include “to give tech leaders an understanding of the structures and biases that block marginalized communities and to provide actionable and meaningful solutions… to give everyone in tech a fair chance to succeed.”
“Next Draft” by Aneesh Raman, describes in three drafts his transition in thinking from being Indian, born in the US of Indian parents, to a hyphenated American, where he wanted to country to be home to his children, inspired because “those generations of my family could help shape this countries future.” (p 208). But then, after being successful on CNN, he gave it up to help with the Obama campaign, hoping a non-white could be president. He became a speech write for the President. He then felt he had become an American. White America had accepted him. In the third draft of life, he became nonwhite, a nonwhite American. This resulted from Trump and the string of events that were never denounced: Charlottesville, Muslim ban, Breonna Taylor…. He gave up trying to model himself on white America. “As a community, we undeniably face anti-Asian racism. If we choose to see it, we also face the harsh reality that we are often complicit in systemic racism, especially in anti-Black systemic racism. As we lean into our proximity to whiteness, we only support the idea that at the base of being America is being white….” (p 216).
Yoonj Kim wrote in “My First Rodeo” of her desire to learn to ride horses. However, her teacher was not accepting of her, and at a rodeo that the teacher had half-heartedly invited her to (Kim was still a child then), Kim was ignored and felt unwelcomed. Her lesson: “Nationalists love to tell immigrants to assimilate, that if we act more ‘like them,’ we’d be accepted. But it’s like one of those half-hearted invitations where they don’t expect you to show up—like at a horse show—and if you do, you’re not exactly arriving to open arms and champagne.” (p 203) When growing up, she had not appreciated her parents, immigrants from Korea, always talking about Korea, and tried like other children to fit in to white America and run away from the world of her parents. “It was only once I tumbled back in that I began to understand its empowering authenticity, shielding me from disappearing into a harsh, fickle landscape uninterested in celebrating me as an individual. Thank you Umma and Appa, for making sure I never forgot who I was, even when I wanted to.” (p 204).
In David Kwong’s “Facing Myself” we read of a child who followed his dream, against his Chinese father and Jewish mother, to be a magician. He tried to reconcile who he was. Finally, he got the advice, “‘David, just be you and your identity will shine through. That’s the best thing that you can do to represent us.’ That is my advice, as well. Show your unmasked face, and the uniqueness of who you are will be all the magic you need.” (p 188)
FB. A moving collection of lived experiences by Asians in America, sharing challenges and triumphs, exposing myths and false behaviors, and touching the heart and soul of the individual. A valuable read for Asians and non-Asians in America. “Do not make yourself small… just to appease others… when you can fill up the sky.” from “Museum in Her Head” by Marie Lu in this collection.