I thought 'who are you anyway? My friend is a ridiculously talented person who has these amazing opportunities, she loves you, and you're bringing your riffraff self into these magical moments you're privileged to even get near.' I wanted to say to her, 'Amy, who the fuck does your boyfriend think he is?' To which she probably would have replied 'my husband.'
This is the 'Fuck Blake' book and I am here for it.
I can't seem to resist any first-person narrative from someone who was close to Amy. I think this is the 3rd one I've read; Mitch and Janis' being the other two. Mitch's was self-pitying and defensive, Janis' was warm and loving. This one is a lot more brutal and honest, in the way that only a best friend could be. It's 10 years since Amy died and it's so bizarre to think that she'd be 37 if she were still here. Would Amy have fulfilled her dream of having kids? Would she have continued making music? I wish we could've heard more from her.
I remember hearing 'Best For Me', Amy and Tyler's song they did together, and thinking that he had a nice, poppy voice but Amy's blew him out of the water. Interesting to note that they never actually dated! Amy would always refer to him as her boyfriend in interviews but he said here that she just liked making stuff up to tell journalists.
Tyler comes across as sweet and naive, but sometimes oddly arrogant, and self-aggrandising. He seems at pains to point out how he was there at all the crucial moments in Amy's career and introduced her to a lot of people who she later collaborated with, and I suppose we should acknowledge him for this. He was the one who pushed Amy to make the demo tape that got her signed with Nick Shymansky. Nick, I think, is the only other man who was close to Amy who really had her best interests at heart, rather than his own. Hearing about how Raye, her second manager, mistreated her and worked her to the bone after she fired Nick for trying to make her go to rehab was horrible. Raye should never have been her manager - he, like so many of the people around Amy, didn't actually care about her as a person and only wanted to get what he could from her. Bloodsuckers, the lot of them.
Speaking of bloodsuckers, this book comes down hard on the villain in everyone's minds - Blake. I knew he was a piece of shit but I didn't know he hit her. It's heartbreaking to read that he punched her in the mouth on her birthday because she wanted to go out and see her friends and he didn't want her to. He was truly an abusive, controlling man, and what's sad is that Amy herself could see it. She openly admitted to Tyler that Blake controlled her and used her for her money. But publicly, she was always talking about how wonderful and loving and misunderstood he was. It's bittersweet to finally get confirmation that he was actually the bastard everyone thought he was all along. He did some real low-life shit that Amy's fans didn't know about which Tyler lays out in the book - stole money from Prince (yes, the Artist Formerly Known As!), stopped Amy from going to make the video for 'Love Is A Losing Game' because he wanted to stay home doing drugs, and physically and mentally abused her behind closed doors.
Blake disappears from the narrative after he goes to prison and it's interesting to note that Amy does seem to move on from him quite well, making the connection that drugs and unhealthy behaviours were what kept them together rather than love. The wrong one died.
Obviously, as Tyler wrote this himself, it's hard to know how much of it is objective fact and how much is just his version of events. He spent plenty of time off his head on coke and booze (though he did get sober in 2009 and has remained so) and that has almost certainly coloured his perception of events. But he's a compelling narrator, endlessly loving and compassionate towards Amy, and treats her with genuine care. I liked that he said he didn't believe in the relationship with Reg Traviss - I never liked Reg, he seemed like a slimy user just close to Amy for the publicity. The fact that she asked him if he thought she should go to rehab for alcohol abuse and he said 'I don't know, if you think so?' is heartbreaking. She was clearly looking for a father figure and for someone to take her in hand and say 'enough'. Tyler did this many times himself and it seemed he was close to getting her all the way there just before the tragic end.
Mitch does not come off well in this book either, and frankly I've had enough of him peddling the story that he was always there for her. We've all seen how neglectful he was when she was trying to get better - bringing that Channel 5 TV crew to make a documentary about her in St Lucia when she needed him to be there for her as a father. He's a selfish egomaniac, and I've no doubt that his neglect of Amy contributed to her death.
Mitch's TV appearances started really winding Amy up. "Why's my Dad always on TV? Why's he talking about my addictions when he doesn't talk to ME about my addictions? Why doesn't he talk to me about my problems instead of going on every fucking eggy brekkie chat show and running his mouth to every newspaper that will have him? He's mugging himself and he's mugging me. You ducked out of my life, Dad. And now you're off with your album, trying to be a superstar." The way he behaved had a huge impact on her.
I've always had my doubts that Amy had quite the bond with Mitch that she claimed to have - he never really seemed to take great care of her and pushed her out of the way to get into the spotlight. Him pushing her to do work commitments because they would make a lot of money when she was trying to get sober is very damning. She'd say "I don't want to do a gig, I want to get sober" (she couldn't get onstage without a drink towards the end) and he'd say "but it's 6 million quid, Amy!". What kind of father puts money before his daughter's health? I hate that we're now seeing the same thing happening to Britney Spears.
I'm grateful to Tyler for writing his version of events, as he really was by her side for so long and had a unique insight into her life and her troubles. It confirmed a lot of suspicions and feelings I've always had about Amy's story; that her father walking out when she was small is what crushed her mental health, that Blake was a user who married her for money and played off her insecurity to control her, that the industry people around her didn't take proper care of her during her addiction, that Reg didn't care about her at all, and that the little gasp she did at the Grammys was fake! It also gave me a lot of information I didn't have before which is irresistible for any die-hard fan.
I want to live in the alternate universe where Amy marries Tyler instead of Blake and gets to be just a normal jazz singer, rather than the international juggernaut she became. I think she could've had a much happier, healthier life with Tyler. Just like in their duet, he really saw what was best for her, and tried so hard to make it happen.
I still miss her all the time.