3.5 stars
Beryl and Edwina are called upon to assist the wealthy Constance Maitland in a sham investigation into the supposed improper conduct of her sister-in-law Ursula with a member of the artists colony staying at Maitland Park. This investigation comes at the perfect time as Beryl's offer to help the new maid Beddoes with cleaning nearly caused Beddoes to quit! Beryl is excited about visiting the artists colony but none too thrilled about her cover story of guest speaker to the Girl Guides also staying at the Park. Edwina has agreed to pose as a model for her friend Charles but almost leaves in a hurry when she encounters some of the scandalous goings-on of some of the artists. Beryl convinces Edwina to stay but there isn't much to base their investigation on. Even Beryl considers giving up until one of the Girl Guides discovers the dead body of one of the artists lying in the glade. With Constable Gibbs on the job, this murder is likely never to be solved, therefore Beryl thinks she might just do a little clandestine investigating on her own in spite of Constable Gibbs threatening the private detectives if they stick their nose in. However, Edwina soon discovers what it means to work for the upper crust and it could cost Constable Gibbs her job if Beryl and Edwina won't help. The trick is soothing ruffled feathers all around and finding a way to obtain permission to investigate from both Constable Gibbs and Constance Maitland. The more they get to know the artists, the more complicated the case becomes as the pair uncover giant egos, back room deals and one lovestruck teenager. When another body turns up, the friends are shocked as that person was their chief suspect. Now they have to start over! Can they solve this one before they're pressured into picking someone who is not a member of the Maitland family?
This series is such a delight. It's cozy but has a lot of history behind it. The mystery wasn't so interesting to me as some of the others. At least not to begin with. I thought I knew who the murderer was and why. It seemed kind of obvious that it was one of two people. Then Beryl and Edwina had the one of same suspects in mind so I thought for sure it was the other one. I turned out to be wrong both times. I had to stay up late to see the outcome of the investigation. I never guessed who or why. The clues really aren't there. I wasn't crazy about the cigarette company fortune and all the commentary about cigarettes and the future of cigarette companies. I would rejoice if these people went out of business! I learned something new though, about cigarette cards. I didn't know anything about that and I'm not sure I've ever come across one in an antique shop.
What really shines in this story is the character development. Edwina has come a long way since we first met her. She's become more bold thanks to Beryl's influence and her success solving crimes. Her latest endeavor, as a novelist, seems to be giving her further confidence. I believe Charles is the only one who sees her as she really is. Charles, too, is blooming. He has hidden depths he hasn't shown Edwina yet and he's really not such a nerd after all. I can't wait to watch him blossom further and come out of his shell now he's been accepted by the artists colony at Maitland Park. His choice of friends leaves a lot to be desired though. Beryl has grown up a bit. She's uncomfortable being the foreigner and the lone egalitarian American. She was raised much in the same way as Edwina, to have servants wait on her, but has grown more accustomed to fending for herself. I relate to both these ladies. Like Edwina, I'm cautious and rely on traditions and history. Like Beryl, I'm independent and would go mad living Edwina's life. Beryl means well but she's impulsive and that sometimes gets her into trouble. Here we see her slowing down and starting to consider how she appears to her friend and considering Edwina's feelings. Beryl is forced to confront her notions of "home" and what that means, for the first time. These two ladies are unlikely friends but good for each other. They were both so lonely before Beryl crashed into town.
I missed the residents of Walmsley Parva. We see Prudence only once, thank goodness. Constanble Gibbs plays a large role in this book. Her character development is quite good as well. Here she shows her vulnerable side and appears more human. She's better developed and not just a villainish police woman bent on thwarting Beryl and Edwina. She's actually right that they're just civillians (nosy spinsters) and she truly wants to solve the cases she's given but she's the ONLY one on the job. I'm not sure why she doesn't call the higher-ups but it makes for a better story of course, to have the nosy spinsters doing the sleuthing. In this case we're dealing with the upper crust who don't want the police interfering and causing a scandal. The investigation feels a bit repetitive at times and could have been reduced to narrative rather than repeating dialogue.
The Maitland family are not very pleasant people. Constance Maitland hires Beryl and Edwina and then treats them like hired help. She's not very sympathetic or understanding of her distant relative, Cressida, who may or may not suffer from paranoia and delusions. Constance cares about her servants only so much as they affect her - her routine, her meals. She could care less about them as people who are scared they will be murdered. Cressida is REALLY starchy and old-fashioned in her morals. She's super tough on the Girl Guides and suspects Constance's sister-in-law Urusula of having an affair and then confronts the woman with her nasty accusations. I think she's just old-fashioned and overly concerned with matters that shouldn't concern her but I don't see evidence of paranoia and delusions. Edwina notices things no one else does, why shouldn't Cressida? Constance is nice enough about her brother and his new, young wife. Hubert is an affable gentleman, lazy and unconcerned with running the household. He adores his wife, Ursula, who seems lovely but may be having an affair with one of the artists. Ursula doesn't seem like one who would cause a scandal by having a public affair. Even if she married her husband for money, what does she get out of the affair with an artist? Louis Beck may be a famous, wealthy and influential artist but I'm betting Mr. Maitland has more money and Ursula knows that and knows what she would lose if he divorced her.
That said, Louis Beck is a slimeball. He's too arrogant for his own good. He thinks he's charming and good looking and normally he does seem to be able to charm the ladies, but our sleuths are too astute for that. Edwina is shocked by Louis's painting a nude model out in the open! He's on her hit list now. Beryl knows the type too well. However, young Janet, a teenage Girl Guide, seems to be smitten. While I disagree with Beryl's assesment of Janet as a child incapble of rational thought, I do think Janet's teenage hormones and romantic sensibilities MAY have caused her to do something she shouldn't have. Several something, maybe. I don't trust Louis's motive in involving her in his painting. The Girl Guides should be off limits. If I were Janet, I would resent Cressida's intrusion into my private life and even the strict ideas of the Girl Guides. Helpful is a relative term and these girls seem to be nuisances. Could Janet merely be trying to be helpful or did Louis seduce her? Where does that leave Ursula? What about Tuva, his lovely model? Tuva, a former dancer from Sweden, before an tragedy left her disfigured, has no inhibitions about her body and more than happy to pose nude. Or maybe it's the money that drives her. Or perhaps merely being with artistic types again that drives her. At any rate, she is beautiful and graceful but not a very likable person. I find her very cold and unemotional about anything not involving dancing. Could she be having an affair with Louis and killed him when she discovered his affair with Ursula and his seduction of Janet?
Roger Hazeldine, an old aquaintance of Beryl's, is also an arrogant, sleazy man. Beryl knows him from the war years but she isn't saying how. He also nearly ran Edwina off the road in his motorcycle and therefore, she wants him to be a murder suspect. He was riding with Ursula-the very married Ursula. Are they having an affair? Roger hated Louis and was jealous of the other man's success. Louis Spencer Spaulding, a friend of Charles's, is not very nice either. Spencer seems shady and he was a huge rival of Louis's possibly both professionally and personally. Spencer has a good reason to want Louis out of the picture. How far will he go to get what he wants? What is with these artists? They all have huge egos and view women as objects. The men are jealous of each other and were spotted fighting. Does that make one of them a murderer? Perhaps Spencer and Roger teamed up to elimiate a rival?
I wouldn't say this series is a favorite but I do enjoy it a lot and recommend it to historical cozy mystery fans. In this case, I especially enjoyed reading about a lovely English summer when it was a rainy winter night here. I know what the future might have in store for Edwina and I'm curious to see where the author takes the story next, if she goes with that original idea or comes up with something new.
This was my last read of 2021!