Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

All American Boy

The Boyfriend Checklist: All American Boy Series

Rate this book
Tiler
My life is a mirror image of my vision board.
Graduated college. Check.
Landed the job of my dreams with the Boulder Bullets. Double check.
Score VIP tickets to see my favorite band, The Whiskey Barrels, perform at the USA Music Festival in Bear Creek. Triple check.
Not only have those dreams become reality, but I nearly checked off the last remaining goal: find Mr. Right when I met Jonah at the music festival.
Jonah and I spent a whirlwind day together under the Colorado Rocky Mountains sky, and he almost turned into my one-night stand.
The only problem with Mr. Right?
He also happens to be a new rookie on the team. Which means he’s all wrong and off-limits because I can’t date one of the players. Even if he checks all my boxes on the boyfriend checklist.

Jonah
Getting drafted out of college to play professional basketball with the Boulder Bullets was a dream come true.
How lucky am I?
Even luckier when Tiler, the cute girl I spent the day with at the music festival but then lost in a crowd, ends up being the new social media assistant for the team. Score!
Although, she doesn’t see it that way. Tiler assures me we were a one-time thing and what started between us is no longer on the menu.
But this Iowa farm boy turned pro player has never backed down from a challenge. I’ll find a way to change her mind and prove that I’m the man she’s been waiting for.

**The Boyfriend Checklist is a standalone story in the All American Boy Series, a 15 multi-author series in a shared world experience.

Welcome to Bear Creek, Colorado, an idyllic all-American mountain resort town and home of the USA Music Festival. Filled with summer love, country music and unexpected pleasures, this brand-new series of short contemporary stories will bring together a mix of summer fun and music with the backdrop of the Colorado Rocky Mountains.

144 pages, Kindle Edition

Published November 3, 2021

15 people are currently reading
112 people want to read

About the author

Sierra Hill

71 books723 followers
Sierra Hill is a 2020 RONE Award-Winning author of Game Changer, as well as over 30 novels, including the award-winning college sports series, Courting Love, and the twice award-finalist erotic ménage serial, Reckless – The Smoky Mountain Trio.


Subscribe to her email list and download a FREE book here: www.sierrahillbooks.com

Your recommendation is the highest compliment I could receive. Please feel free to share your feedback by posting a review.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
36 (33%)
4 stars
51 (47%)
3 stars
15 (14%)
2 stars
5 (4%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews
Profile Image for QuinnReads.
3,725 reviews206 followers
November 4, 2021
Bruised Egos and Broken Rules

There's a bit of hot naughtiness here and there and some very toe-curling, melt-y kisses (loved these moments). 🔥💜 More than that, I liked this mostly sweet novella which is about finding a path forward and healing hearts and egos. This mostly applies to Jonah as Tiler's biggest hurdle is admitting to herself that Jonah just might be her forever, even if it is technically against the rules.

I love Frannie and her frankness throughout. She doesn't beat around the bush at all. It's refreshing. 😂🌟 My second favorite secondary character is Jonah's roommate, Dayton. 😍

I did really like the book but the ending wasn't exactly what I was anticipating. It felt a little incomplete.

I'm voluntarily reviewing an ARC of this book.
Profile Image for Ashley Herndon.
1,252 reviews19 followers
November 4, 2021
Loved Jonah!’ So much!

Tiler was just awesome too!

I liked the take on the lost love, connect and get separated in a crowd… to end up working together. Soooo good!

Hot. Sweet. Likable characters.
Athlete?? Yes please.

Highly recommend!
Profile Image for Julie Booklover.
2,099 reviews104 followers
November 3, 2021
The second round of the All American Boy series is just a fun as the first. The series takes place in Colorado, and the author stays within her basketball world.

Tiler has just landed her dream job and has a fun weekend at a music festival before it begins. Unfortunately, due to lousy cell service, she misses her meet-up with her girlfriends. Enter Jonah, who saves the day. But, after spending a fun and flirty day together, a mishap separates them at the concert's end.

Will they connect again? Neither has enough information to find the other? The chemistry is there, but both need to move on to start new jobs.

In a short afternoon read, find out if they can find each other again.

Thank you to the author for the advanced copy; this is my voluntary review.
Profile Image for Court.
900 reviews48 followers
November 3, 2021
Wow, The Boyfriend Checklist was such a fun read! Jonah gives you all the swoon-worthy feels and will steal your heart. Tiler is starting a new job and has a set of goals she wants to achieve. Jonah I’d starting basketball with a farm team for the Denver Nuggets and is looking to enjoy his time until his season starts. Then fate has these two meeting at a musical festival and the connection is instant and chemistry that’s hard to ignore. Then when they think they’ll never see each other the two run into each other in an unexpected way. Jonah is determined to win Tiler over and Tiler is determined he doesn’t meet her checklist criteria and better to leave things alone. Will Jonah win Tiler’s heart over or will she let her own set of rules get in the way of her true happiness? Tiler and Jonah will grab you from the start and have you devouring their story to see what will happen. Loved this book and couldn’t get enough of these two!
1,535 reviews21 followers
November 3, 2021
The Boyfriend Checklist is a short, fun, sweet and sexy story from Sierra Hill! Absolutely loved how Tiler and Jonah met, and I hated how quickly their time was cut short at the beginning - because you knew they had an instant spark between them that both wanted to explore. Luckily though, to both of their surprise, they found themselves working together on the Boulder Bullets basketball team. Even though Tiler wants to keep things strictly platonic now that they work together, Jonah knows what he wants - and that's Tiler. He really was a great guy, even when others on his team were giving him grief. He killed them with kindness, as much as he could - and just proved he was a class act even when he didn't have to. There's definitely no way Tiler could resist him.

(Also......I really love that Jonah went to Montana State and is a fellow Bobcat - that makes me love him even more!)
Profile Image for Sarah~Book Obsession Confessions .
1,309 reviews88 followers
November 4, 2021
Tiler is all about checklists. Life might not play fair though.
Tiler meets Jonah at a music festival where he swoops in and saves her day.
They share an instant attraction, chemistry and conversation is there.
It ends up as a kind of missed connection when they get separated with no numbers or way to stay in touch.
They meet again, unfortunately it’s in a work environment they are both new to. She wants to prove herself at her job.
A romance with one of the new basketball players doesn’t seem like the best idea to Tiler.
It’s a fast, cute and sweet sports romance.
Really likable characters and a cute set up to the story.
Profile Image for Patricia (Spellbound Stories Trish) .
2,834 reviews118 followers
November 4, 2021
The Boyfriend Checklist is a sweet, short read that had me smiling like a school girl from the start!

Jonah and Tiler met by chance but were brought together by fate! As they navigate what could be Tiler has to decide if love is worth the chance!

I love a hero who is sure of himself but not cocky or a jerk! Jonah was sweet, romantic but a total alpha when needed!

A definite must for anyone who loves a quick read jam packed with all you need from a sports romance!
Profile Image for Kaitie.
1,133 reviews34 followers
October 28, 2021
I’ve really enjoyed diving into this series! And Jonah and Tiler’s story was no different! I dove in and didn’t look back. I devoured it and just needed to know what happened next!
Profile Image for Sue Ouellet-Cofsky.
2,545 reviews47 followers
November 2, 2021
Short and not so sweet (meaning steamy) story of a girl who seems to have it all and truly believes in manifesting her destiny and a country boy who also seems to have it all as well. Wonderful meet-cute but alas, things go awry and the chances of ever seeing each other again is slim. But is it? And what happens if they do meet again? Will the circumstances lend itself to the one magical day they spent together or will there be powers that will keep them apart. Both Tiler and Jonah will find themselves at a crossroads and perhaps the two together can build that bridge.
Profile Image for Peggy M.
835 reviews8 followers
November 14, 2021
‘The boyfriend checklist’ is a sweet, light novella-length new adult story. I really enjoyed this story. Tiler and Jonah, the two main characters, were really lovely. Tiler was focussed, intelligent, ambitious, sassy but also kind and cheerful. Jonah was also a great guy. He too was ambitious but he was also charming, thoughtful and hard-working. Both characters may be young but they acted mature and responsible. Both knew very well what they wanted for their future. The interaction between Tiler and Jonah was entertaining and sweet. The chemistry between them was there from the beginning. The story was told from both POV’s.

Profile Image for Sara Oxton.
3,800 reviews18 followers
October 31, 2021
The Boyfriend Checklist by Sierra Hill a five-star read that will check off all of the stars on your list. I adore this author, they just have a way with sports that brings the game alive. Tiler is a great character, she will warm you up with her lists and plans, she will warm you up like the sunflower that she is. Jonah is so much more than they player you would think when you first meet him. This is a great story and one you would miss.
2,397 reviews59 followers
November 7, 2021
The Boyfriend Checklist is the first book I've read by Sierra Hill. I was intrigued by the description, as well as the fact that this All American Boy series has each book written by a different author. This book is a short (20ish chapters) and steamy story about up-and-coming basketball player Jonah and Tiler, the girl of his dreams whom he meets at a music festival. They share an incredible connection right off the bat, but get parted by the crowd before they can take things to the next level. So imagine the surprise both of them get the following Monday when it's his first day of practicing with the team and her first day as the team's new social media manager.

Since shadowing Jonah is now a work assignment, Tiler tries to put some distance between them. Which only makes Jonah want her more. He is relentless in his pursuit of her, and eventually breaks through her walls. Is Tiler willing to risk everything she's worked for professionally? Will she pass up The One for her career ambitions? I really liked the obstacles this couple faced, which were mostly on Tiler's side. She was really torn over what to do, and her boss, Frannie, was a great sounding board, having been in that position herself of falling for one of the team's players.

I enjoyed the progression of Tiler and Jonah's romance, but I felt like the side story of his rivalry with another teammate took too much away from the romance at the end of the book. The story kind of ended abruptly with the focus being on Jonah's rivalry, leaving me to feel like the epilogue was a throw-in attempt to tie things back to the romance. But overall, The Boyfriend Checklist is an entertaining, quick contemporary romance.

I received an advanced copy and voluntarily left a review.
Profile Image for Rachel (Rrbookreviews).
606 reviews9 followers
November 2, 2021
📖ARC REVIEW 📖
Review: 4/5 ⭐️
Steam: 3/5 🔥

#theboyfriendchecklist by @sierrahillbooks is another book in the multi author #allamericanboyseries

Jonah is a new rookie to the farm team of the Denver Nuggets. He wants to prove himself to the coaches and his teammates. Being an athlete he gets some perks. So VIP tickets are key. Walking in he sees a girl struggling to call friends and without a ticket. Offering to help her, they hit it off. Only to get lost in the crowd. He’s frustrated but needs to move on. Until practice, when he meets the new social media guru. His prayers are being answered.

Tiler wants her perfect man. And she thought she found him, her knight in shining armor at the concert. Until being separated, she thought all bets were off. But day one on the job she sees him again. She’s trying to stay away and be professional. If only Jonah, her boss and her heart got the memo.

This is a really quick short read. Pretty minimal drama. There an instant attraction but not insta love. They get to know each other More and grow their relationship. Quick and sweet sports read if you’re i retested!
1,011 reviews18 followers
November 1, 2021
I love Tiler and Jonah from Sierra Hill’s new book, “The Boyfriend Checklist.” In Tiler’s mind, she always had an idea of what her perfect boyfriend would be like. Of course he would have to be kind, handsome and the chemistry should be off the charts. Tiler was very busy with her new job and wasn’t looking for romance, but it came looking for her. She was meeting friends at a country festival when she bumped into a mountain of a man who ended up saving the day for her. Their meet-cute at the festival was just the beginning of Tiler and Jonah’s romantic adventure.

Jonah is sexy, easy to talk and definitely fun to be with. He is the perfect book boyfriend and checked off all the boxes on Tiler’s list. As they got to know each other they realized that what they had was special and even though they worked together, their budding romance never got in the way of their responsibilities. Jonah was very attentive and romantic towards Tiler and always put her feelings first. He took her on fun dates where they shared stories about their childhoods and their aspirations for the future. I really enjoyed seeing Tiler and Jonah fall in love and it was fun to witness their sweet and tender romance.
11.5k reviews49 followers
November 7, 2021
It is a full court press once he finds her again

The Boyfriend Checklist by Sierra Hill is part of the multi-author All American Boy series. I enjoyed this addition to this really solid series, at least the books I have read I have liked a lot. This is a delectably sweet and entertaining story about Jonah and Tiler. He is a basketball player with the Denver Nuggets and she works in the PR department for the organization. When they first meet they do not know there is a link between them and instead he becomes her hero at a music festival. They have a great time together until they are separated, not thinking they will see each other again. But when their paths cross again Jonah is determined to win Tiler over and make her his.

I received a copy of this book and am leaving my honest review. My opinions are all my own.
Profile Image for Amy Dufera - Amy's MM Romance Reviews.
2,698 reviews138 followers
November 7, 2021
4.5 Stars

The Boyfriend Checklist is Sierra Hill's contribution to the multi-author All American Boy series.

I adore everything about Jonah and Tiller. They had a chance meeting, but they were definitely meant to meet. Seriously, their meeting is one dream worthy. They meet and never get to exchange numbers before being separated. It's pure agony to see them longing for what should have been.

It's a story with a swoony meet cute, plenty of list making, and lots of sports moments. These two need to get past some obstacles in their way, but if they can do so, it can be so good between them.

The Boyfriend Checklist is a sweet romance; perfect for the next time you're in the mood for a short sports romance. Sierra Hill captures the emotions with this second chance/forbidden romance book.
Profile Image for Emma bramley.
2,570 reviews26 followers
November 29, 2021


The boyfriend checklist (All American boy series)

Wow, what an amazing short fun read from this author this book was. This is the amazing story of Tiler and Jonah, the sparks definitely fly with these two characters from the start. This story is sweet, sexy and fun and you fall in love with the characters from the beginning. This is a sports romance at its best. The story has a little but of drama within the story line, this just adds to the whole story. This is an amazing short read from this author.

I was given an advanced reader copy of this book and this is my honest review
www.obsessedbookreviews.com
2,991 reviews16 followers
November 6, 2021
OMG !!! just loved it !!! love this series !!! love Jonah !!! swoon... love Tiler...too... this is their story... a fast paced drama...Tiler just graduated and got her dream job... then VIP tickets to her favorite band and then, no ticket.. she couldn't find her friends... no cell service... then Jonah to the rescue... he has VIP tickets... he just got his dream job... rookie on the basketball team... tickets to an outdoor concert and the cutest girl to spend it with...then, they get separated in the crowds...she's working for the team !!! yeah !!! until, she says no !!! he has to change her mind... sweet story... swoony story ... OMG !!!

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Syd Springer.
4,034 reviews6 followers
November 3, 2021
This was a really sweet book. Tiler and Jonah were great together. I really liked the connection and the chemistry between these two. These two had a chance meeting and they thought that they finally found their other half but fate decided to throw them a curve ball and separate them. Just then these two were ready to move on, these two are brought together again and their hearts won't keep them apart for long. I really enjoyed this book and I would recommend it and MS. Sierra as a wonderful author.

I received a e-book free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
Profile Image for Kari Hansen.
12.3k reviews92 followers
November 5, 2021
Tiler was really looking forward to attending the music festival with her friends however when she arrives they have the tickets and she can’t find them. A sexy stranger comes to her rescue, and they enjoy the concert together until circumstances separate them and she never expects to see him again.

Jonah is a basketball player who has just joined the Denver Nuggets. It must be fate that Tiler is working for the PR department of the team and he is determined to show her that what they share is too special to just walk away from despite the challenges they face.

Fun and flirty I enjoyed both the characters and seeing the relationship unfold between Jonah and Tiler.
Profile Image for  •Cici• Theory of A Dreamer Book Blog♥.
3,439 reviews156 followers
November 9, 2021
Having read Ms.Hill's work many times before I always look so forward to picking up a new release of hers! As soon as i found out she was releasing a story in this series i couldn't wait to pick it up! I enjoyed The Boyfriend Checklist!

Right from their memorable first meeting, Tiler and Jonah's journey grabbed my attention! I really liked how these two were brought together and how i wasn't sure how things would play out for them. I so enjoyed the chemistry between them!

With The Boyfriend Checklist, Ms.Hill has created such a good read!


*I volunteered to read and review a copy of this book from WordSmith Publicity / the author*
1,669 reviews2 followers
November 23, 2021
OMG !!! just loved it !!! love this series !!! love Jonah !!! swoon... love Tiler...too... this is their story... a fast paced drama...Tiler just graduated and got her dream job... then VIP tickets to her favorite band and then, no ticket.. she couldn't find her friends... no cell service... then Jonah to the rescue... he has VIP tickets... he just got his dream job... rookie on the basketball team... tickets to an outdoor concert and the cutest girl to spend it with...then, they get separated in the crowds...she's working for the team !!! yeah !!! until, she says no !!! he has to change her mind... sweet story... swoony story ... OMG !!!
Profile Image for Elizabeth Clinton.
864 reviews36 followers
October 30, 2021
The Boyfriend Check-List by Sierra Hill is such a fun read. Meeting Tiler & Jonah will keep a smile on your face throughout their whole story.
Both of them are starting new careers her as a Marketing & Social Media person for the Boulder Bullets and Him a rookie basketball player for the same team.
What they didn’t know that when they first meet unexpectedly that it would lead them to meeting again at work. The chemistry between the two of them is Fantastic, it’s fun & flirty but it also a connection that is undeniable.
1,498 reviews15 followers
November 5, 2021
Sweet, sporty, swoony

I loved how Jonah had a little bit of cockiness, I mean confidence, when it came to Tiler. Their meeting seemed to be the perfect day. I couldn't imagine meeting the perfect guy and losing him, so that's why I love second chances. I kind of appreciated that a relationship was pretty much given a green light, even though there's something to say about a forbidden one at times. I loved that the two were fun, flirty and spicy. I also loved that Jonah got to be Tiler's protector, too.
Profile Image for casvec.
7,458 reviews75 followers
November 8, 2021
Tiler and Jonah's story is a fun chance meeting story with a twist that will pull you into the story from the start. Tiler just landing the job she wanted, while wanting to spend the weekend with her friend, she runs into a snaggle that a stranger comes and help. When the work day comes around, she realizes the stranger she got along with was Jonah, who is on the team.

Great story from start to finish.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Pat.
1,581 reviews18 followers
November 8, 2021
Sierra Hill has written a great book , The Boyfriend Checklist, a book that I didn’t put down until I was finished.

Tiler and Jonah have chemistry between them , they meet at a concert but unfortunately they get separated… can they find each other again to continue this relationship?

A cute read with plenty of humour and very low on angst, written extremely well.

Extremely likeable characters who were in the midst of mystery and mayhem!
I throughly enjoyed this book …

Great characters, Jonah is extremely sure of himself in a good way and Tiler is easy to like .
6,136 reviews17 followers
November 8, 2021
This story is part of a multi-author series called "All American Boy". They are stand alone reads with connected characters. The series is set in Bear Creek, Colorado with a music festival, summer fun and music. This is a fairly quick read that is not overly short more novella size. This is the story of Tiler and Jonah. This is a fun story with some sweet and sexy. These two meet and get lost in each other but there is a problem with him checking all of her boxes. I really love how this story develops.
10.8k reviews125 followers
December 6, 2021
I've read several books written by Sierra Hill; she is becoming one of my favorite authors. I can’t wait to read more of her books.

This is part of the All American Boy Series; it is a stand-alone book. The story is about Tiler & Jonah; right after they graduate from college they have a one night hookup. He’s been drafted to play professional basketball and when he finds out she is the new social media assistant he thinks they may have a change but she doesn’t want to continue anything between them.

I received a free copy of this book via booksprout and I’m voluntarily leaving a review.
776 reviews
November 1, 2021
Contemporary Sports Romance!

Wow! I loved this story. It is short and sweet. A rookie NBA player and a newly hired marketing rep meet at a music festival. Things are going great until the get separated. Then they meet again at the first day of training camp. Tiler tries to keep it professional and Jonah doesn’t. That’s where the fun begins. Just what we need right now to lift our hearts. I did receive an advance copy for my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.