UPDATE..... I rarely change my rating -- but after several conversations with friends about "Anthem" >> because I can't stop thinking about it ....
-- I'm raising my rating to 4 stars instead of 3.
Its a hard book to think about -to take in the 'devastating' parts -- (so I've been hesitate to recommend it strongly) -- but - I think its the type of book 'worth' having book discussions --
Its worthy to read --
My original review is below:
“Anthem” by Noah Hawley…..(a one of a kind author/ director who fascinates me)….has written such a surreal anti-inspirational chilling-contemporary dystopian thriller….where in part — it’s our teenagers who are at the center of fighting the world’s biggest fight……
This....
.... book is another one of those RARE — OH MY —novels …..where the reader who finishes it might react as I did….(besides feeling as if just hit over the head in bleakness)….
ME THINKING > “I can ‘completely’ understand every rating given to it.
I could see justifications for 5, 4, 3, 2, or 1 star ratings.
Let me back up.
Today is January 6, 2022 ….a date tattooed in our brains….the first anniversary of United States Capitol riot.
Current headline news ……as I reach for my phone …..5:33am Pacific Time….[after reading “Anthem” through the night]….
“On the eve the Capitol riot anniversary, January 6 investigation faces a pivotal . . . “
“A Year Later, Jan 6 Becomes Just Another Wedge in a Divided Nation”
“Opinion/ The impact of January 6 Is Still Rippling Throughout the World”
“CBS News poll: A year after January 6, violence still seeing through US democracy. . . “
“One year after January 6, signs of a nation deeper in peril”
THERE ARE MORE HEADLINES…….all trying to make sense of Jan. 6, 2021.
There will be more throughout the day.
President Biden will speak….
So….on this National Day of Mourning…..2021/2022….
I finished ANTHEM…
Believe me….I debated my own rating. But knowing I could easily give it 2 stars (because it’s not a book I’d go out of my way to recommend)….or 5 stars for the authors ( probably pure heart in examining one of the hardest things to do: OUR CURRENT LIVES)….
I’m giving it 3 stars……right down the middle. (The hardest rating to explain…..
to interpret its full meaning from one reader to another…..
I’ll try to explain - while sharing a few things ……[my experience along with sample excerpts as to give other readers a taste of what to expect should anyone else be curious to read it — regardless of ratings.
NOTE - SEMI- SPOILERS will follow…..
First…it must be said….this book GRABS your attention right away.
As to how long that ‘oh my’ ….’can’t-put-the-book-down’ feeling lasts could begin to wean for some readers …..starting as soon as 20%….
I mean….after awhile ….how much devastating gruesomeness thought can one person take in one sitting?
Point is….this ‘can’t-put-down’ book is laborious—and at times fatiguing to read.
It’s open to paradoxical feelings and thoughts.
“Imagine a kid, hearing that the oceans are dying, that the bees are dying, reading about the opioid epidemic, seeing these political battles and reading about sexual predation. The sense that the world you’re growing up into is being destroyed before your eyes, and what’s going to be there for you? What must that be like, and what can you do?”
Here are those excerpts I said I’d include (spoilers? — actually only slightly —as they are only the tip of the iceberg….
“This book contains math. Not calculus trigonometry— no dense columns of equations—but numbers arranged in order, divided or multiplied, added or subtracted”…..
The idea of fairness exists nowhere else in the animal kingdom.
The dinosaurs went extinct, and none of them said boo phooey.
“Imminent danger they understand. Morality is beyond them”.
“Be fruitful and multiply, God told Moses”.
“Divide and conquer, said the generals”.
“You do the math”.
“Now, your author understands that math is not the why readers read novels. He asks your indulgence and your patience and promises that there is more to the story than numbers. There is drama. There is catharsis. Everywhere you look in this book, you will find people people people in need. People who want what you want—to feel safe, to be loved, to do unto others as they would have others do unto them. Each of their deaths is an act of subtraction.
“This is their story. And if you don’t like it, your author encourages you to put the book down and shout—“
“Boo phooey”.
“The Summer our children began to kill themselves was the hottest in history”……
“What skills must our children master to survive in a world where reality itself is polarized? Had this impossible struggle driven them mad?”
“Each child is precious, unique, but once the phenomenon became widespread, their deaths became a statistic. We begin to think of our children as a collective. To talk about them as a ‘generation’, desperate for some kind of lightning-strike insight. They ‘were’ less connected, we told ourselves, to each other, to us, while conversely being more connected to the constant flow of misinformation that had become our society. Today’s teenagers were having sex later. They were going out less, spending less time with your friends—less physical time—while stink connected to them electronically close to twenty-four hours a day.
What does this say lingering vestige of the pandemic, or had some kind of deep fear of their fellow man settled in their bones, robbing them of the desire to touch? Was that the problem, a chronic sense of dislocation, a fatal remove, or something more immediate, a hidden trigger we couldn’t see? Returned to our priests for answers, to our rabbis and imams, to statisticsns and social scientists. They told us that rates of depression and anxiety disorders had been on the rise for years. Why were they just noticing now?”
“In the end all that mattered was that we were their parents.
It was our job to keep them safe, to make them happy, to keep them alive”.
“With a virus, you could inoculate. You could isolate. You could watch for physical symptoms. But this—this was something heretofore unseen in human existence”.
“An act of human surrender”.
“Look around, you have a population of adolescence, who in any other decade would be f…ing their brains out, but instead, we’re on TikTok”.
Half Earth 🌎
“First of all, your author would like to apologize for the world he has created. He knows it is ridiculous. The fact that the world he lives in is also ridiculous is no excuse. The author’s job is to make sense of the senseless.
To create coherence from incoherence. But if the author‘s job is also to reflect reality as he perceives it onto the page, then what is he meant to do when the world he lives in loses all sense?
“Reality has become a personal choice, denial of reality a weapon”.
“The lie is violence. You are its victim. Your injuries are psychological, emotional. Your condition is called ‘anxiety’”.
“Reality itself appears to break down. And with it the mental health of your author and his neighbors”.
“In summation, your author, would like to apologize for the world he has created. He knows it’s ridiculous. He is simply doing his best to re-create reality as he has experienced it”.
“Boo phooey”.
“On August 19, millions of Americans woke up to the sound of an Amber Alert on their phones. They reached for their devices, groggy, studying the blue cloud. They saw the familiar triangle, telling them a child was missing, but instead of a name, the text read your son, your daughter, your nephew, your niece, and the description of the suspects vehicle simply read ‘pray for their souls’”.
“Terrified, people took to the streets. Stabbings increased, clashes between police and protesters, but the assemblies had become confusing. Often the protesters’ signs were blank. When journalists pointed this out, men and women with angry eyes seemed puzzled. They studyied the clear white space where they’re outrage had once been written. They had forgotten to pen their grievances, or had the scope of their outrage exceeded the space available? Around the country men in Hawaiian shirts started showing up at rallies with more guns than they could carry, patriots strapped with six, seven, eight pistols, a stack of rifles weighing down their arms of slung over their backs, like a burden they been forced to carry as penance”.
Simon says:
“Where are my friends?”
“His father pauses, thinking”.
“See, I think that’s what made you so anxious. Nobody tells you the truth. Everyone says what they think you want to hear, or they say what they want, but not the real person they want it. That’s the problem with society. You can’t believe anybody. Nothing makes sense, so let me tell you the truth. This Earth was a gift to us from the Lord. He commanded us to use it. He filled the ground with oil for us to burn and filled the sea with fish for us to eat. Every animal living is alive because we allow it to be alive, and if we choose to hunt it to extension, that is our choice. This planet has seen ice ages, and molten eras as long before we showed up, and it’ll see them again long after we’re gone. We don’t have to be afraid, because we are doing what we were created to do. To enrich ourselves. And if that heats up the atmosphere and sours the seas, so be it. Do you hear me? We are the dominant species on Earth, which means we get to dominate the Earth.
End of story”.
“That’s—awful”.
My final thoughts….
America…..as in “Anthem” …..is a divided nation …..
Fake news, controversial topics, political polarization…..etc.
I applaud Noah Hawley for digging deep into our problems….
I believe wholeheartedly….his aim was to add awareness….and open vital discussions about our political divisions, climate change, insurrection, and explore what it means to be young in a collapsing world.
My personal thoughts….
Radical and compelling messages are awaken….
Instead of the Buddha awakening us within about love, power, and beauty ….
Noah Hawley awakens us ‘to look’ — ‘to deeply think’….about our emerging world….
…..from the pandemic…from climate change…from worldwide division… civil rights and protests, personal computers, mobile phones,….real stuff of science fiction ….
Much of the world’s population …. do not see substantial improvements…..
Noah Hawley gave us a book to process our thoughts and feelings…..
….even giving us the a teaser experience of the Star-Spangled Banner song 🎶…..to proudly reflect….
“O say can you see, by the dawn’s early light?” 🎶
I’m glad I read it ….
That said….I seriously worry about our children.
This is not a ‘happy-go-lucky’ book in any shape or form….but I also believe it’s rooted in humanity.