Set against the backdrop of the Irish Abortion Law Reform in 1983, this book feels incredibly relevant, depicting as it does the battle for ownership of women's bodies and their roles within this battle.
The story takes place in the eponymous Dolly Considine's hotel where 18 year old Paddy reinvents himself as Julian and decides to tell the stories of the people who live and stay there. The narration changes between 1950s when Dolly inherits the hotel, and 1983 when Julian enters the hotel. It is mainly told through the perspective of Julian, but sometimes switches with no warning to other characters mentioned, some dead, some alive. It took me quite some time to realise these aspects were Julian's reimaginings of their stories, and so were unreliable and told with an agenda in mind.
I really struggled with the character of Julian. I couldn't understand why he was allowed to stay in the hotel and allowed to continue with his quite frankly disrespectful and dangerous behaviour, considering the underground activities going on within the hotel. He seemed to have just waltzed in and managed to get immediate power over everyone he meets - sexual, political, controlling. These are people who are politically well known and have been carrying out dodgy dealings for years and would know how to handle people far more astute than he was. Julian allows his imagination to get away with him, ignoring the very real danger around him and culminating in tragedy and fatality.
I would have liked to see more of Dolly, who clearly is a strong character but we hardly see anything of. She intrigued me, with her strong matriarchal role, and her ability to get the men around her to do what she wants while thinking it was their decision.
The book is very dense, with historical and political references. I had to stop a lot to research certain elements to have a full awareness of the circumstances that motivated the characters, which meant it took a lot of concentration and time, and for a 500+ page book this was a large commitment. I think I would enjoy this book more on a rereading as I could enjoy the fictional elements more, although I did enjoy the educational element and felt I came out of it with a broader understanding than I went into it.
The writing is experimental and interesting, changing voices and time frames as often as it does, it sometimes feels like a different book. The writer has a dark sense of humour, with some lines that made me laugh and some scenes that made me gasp. There are dark scenes of death, and abortion, and some graphic sex scenes as Julian experiments with his sexuality. Again, I couldn't always understand his sexual relationships, some were clearly for gain (with women) and some seemed motivated by want (with men) but not really desire as he was dismissive and often disdainful of his sexual partners, particularly Mikhail. There is an age gap between Julian and Mikhail, which leads to a power imbalance but it is difficult to tell who is taking advantage of who.
The ending is shocking, dark and confusing. I found it difficult to tell who was still standing at the end of the book, and how accurate it was or whether it was the ramblings of people struggling to come to terms with what had happened. It's difficult to discuss without giving spoilers as one of the death scenes is so incredibly original and shocking!
Overall I really enjoyed the book. I think if I had understood the journal elements of it earlier I would have understood it more, and enjoyed it as the unreliable fictional element would have been clearer.