Two aspects of the description for "The Finding" appealed to me. I love stories about hidden treasures, and this book had a genealogical facet that called to this family historian.
Author Elizabeth Pilcher has created a tangled tale that crosses the decades between antebellum Louisiana and the present day. The first few chapters are introductions to the novel's cast by a ghostly character who teases as much as informs. After a while, the style settles down and the plot begins to come through. The main characters have plenty of individuality, but there are so darn many of them. I found it hard to keep some peripheral characters straight, which I think may have caused me to miss some clues important to the resolution of the mystery. In at least one case, an important character disappears for weeks - or months; the passage of time is not always clear - aside from a few brief mentions. The ghostly narrator also disappears at long stretches, which I think improves the reading experience.
I gave "The Finding" four stars because the characters and the heart of the story are all strong. I'm also allowing for unrelated personal and work factors that affected my focus and how long it took me to finish the book. I'm withholding the final star in part because of the aforementioned difficulties following the story and characters, and because the genealogical aspect of the mystery was ignored by even the characters who should have recognized its importance - a slight acknowledged within the context of the book. I feel like the author didn't incorporate that information because it was an easy way to drag out the story.
If you enjoy stories that have footprints in two centuries, like reading about Cajuns and other peculiar characters against a backdrop of exotic locations in Louisiana, you will probably find plenty in "The Finding" to enjoy.
I received a review copy from BookSirens; all opinions are my own.