Danny Boyle, the narrator of Free Fall, is a police officer in the New Jersey beach town of Sea Haven, where he grew up and where he seems to know just about everyone in town (and to have dated just about all the young women). His sometimes partner John Ceepak is a former MP veteran of the Mideast wars whose deductive savvy and strict code of honor make a perfect match with Boyle’s small-town savvy. As Free Fall opens, Danny answers a 911 call to a domestic situation to find old friend Christine Lemonopolous in a “knockdown drag-out” fight with the wealthy woman who employs Christine to care for her handicapped son. Danny and Ceepak trust Christine’s version of the story, and their police work leads to Christine being cleared of her employer’s charge of assault, but the situation begins to look more complicated when another of Christine’s patients dies suddenly and a background check shows that he is not the only one of her patients to have died under her care. In addition, Ceepak’s drunken father has come to town to try to pry money from his ex-wife, Ceepak’s mother, who has recently won millions in the lottery, and Ceepak is determined to protect his mother from her predatory ex.
Free Fall reminds me in an odd way of the classic British small village mystery, where everyone has ties to everyone elsez, but it also belongs to another distinct subgenre of mysteries that practically always please me: humorous mysteries set in New Jersey. The type of wit shown here reminds me most of David Rosenfelt’s Andy Carpenter books: wry but never mean commentary on society and humanity. But Danny definitely has his own voice, such as when he observes “Friday morning I’m in court, feeling like a marinated pork butt because I’m just waiting to be grilled by...Oppenheimer’s high-priced young attorney.” There are bad people in Free Fall and a great deal of heartbreak in the characters’ lives, but the humor is never very far away. In an otherwise very sober and sympathetic recounting of a funeral, the rabbi comments, “Arnold once told me he was named Dentist of the Year….When I asked him what the award was, he said, ‘Nothing much. Just a little plaque.’”
I enjoyed this book so much that I was immediately motivated to read the first John Ceepak mystery, Tilt-a Whirl, which won an Anthony award for Best First Mystery. About Tilt-a-Whirl, my Goodreads friend Eric W. said, “Some of the parts are LOL funny; others border on pathos.” This sums up Free Fall as well, with Tilt-a-Whirl being a bit heavier on the pathos and Free Fall giving me more laughs. Free Fall contains a number of plot spoilers that made it clear this is a series best read in order, but after I read Tilt-a Whirl I realized that there are also themes and character aspects that develop during the series, and I would have enjoyed Free Fall even more if I had first read Tilt-a-Whirl (and probably the others, which I certainly plan to do). In addition, although I think that Tilt-a-Whirl richly deserved its award, Grabenstein’s writing has become more polished. So, I expect Ceepak fans will be delighted with Free Fall, but if you have never met Danny Boyle and John Ceepak, don’t read this book. Do it right, as Ceepak himself would, and begin at the beginning. Get to know the duo properly, and I am confident you will like them as much as I do.