I was annoyed Black Library split this clearly singular, lengthy story into two books (each fairly costly, by the way) but actually on reflection that may've been the right choice. The forced gap between the two gave me some time to let part one of the story sink in, and I think that contributed to me enjoying ‘The Magister and the Martyr’ a bit more and approaching it with even more eagerness. I do suspect that being able to buy them both in one hefty paperback and reading at your own pace is probably going to be the way to go, and I hope that people holding off for that paperback version is the reason that – according to Goodreads – ‘The Serpent and the Saint’ was the book I read in 2021 that was apparently ‘least popular’ (as in least catalogued, least rated, I guess).
At times, it felt like the first book was a selection of very good short stories, all cut together and presented as one story. Very enjoyable, but it didn’t feel too unified. In book 2, everything starts to come together. I want to keep it fairly vague, so I won’t say much about the plot – but this begins with an extremely satisfying ‘fighting back’ montage that works extremely well. I talked at length about how much I like Farrer’s writing style, characterisation, approach to the setting etc in my review of the first volume – all that still applies. Here it really seems he's pulled off the trick of capturing relentless combat across multiple simultaneous fronts without it being repetitive or overwhelming - maybe to the level of Dan's 'Know No Fear' at times.
What do you want? More of the Saint, more Damocles, and some of the other Iron Snake squads who seem to have been in a holding pattern finally get more time in the spotlight. Holofurnace shows up and his reunion with his brothers after so long away is just what you’d hope. There is a truly bloodcurdling and tense fight near the end that I think approaches the excellence of that Abaddon fight in 'Saturnine'. The Saint gets to have a confrontation with a very intimidating antagonist - multiple confrontations, kind of. Actually, I think the Saint makes a lot more impression here than in the first book, where she was rather subdued. Here you understand just why entire armies are willing to follow her without question, even as their bodies pile up. And there is one heck of a body count, it should be said. Farrer is so good at writing battles that make Space Marines feel like invincible godlike warriors that it’s truly a shock when they start dying, and their deaths are always very abrupt. I feel stung and personally insulted each time one of the Iron Snakes dies! And I'm normally a Chaos guy!
I really enjoyed Farrer digging a bit more into the World Eater, Nautakah, in this book – I mean this is the guy who did ‘After Desh’ea’ so you know he did the character justice. I always like a World Eater who is capable of strained, murderous calm at times instead of being a one dimensional screaming berserker 24/7. The novel also reminds us how good Farrer can be at writing about the bizarre schismatic Mechanicum and their traitor counterpoints (see also: ‘The Inheritor King’, ‘Vorax’).
Luckily I still have a copy of Farrer’s Necromunda book 'Junktion' to get through, but I feel kind of sad coming to the end of ‘The Magister and the Martyr’. It will probably be a long time before we get more fiction from this guy, sadly – he just isn’t one of the more prolific Black Library writers. I'd love to see an additional Iron Snakes book from him, but considering how long this one took, I'm not sure it's on the cards. Still, I strongly recommend this as additional reading to anyone who loves the Gaunt's Ghosts novels and doesn't mind the idea of trying an author with a bit of a different writing style from Dan's.
8.5/10