COME WITH ME by Ronald Malfi has everything I hope for in a book…emotionally impactful, page-turning, complex, thrilling, scary/tension-filled, well crafted, atmospheric, and satisfying.
MY TEASE…
Aaron Decker’s wife wrote a column for a neighborhood paper called Allison’s A-List which highlighted local teens and their accomplishments. Nothing hard hitting, just feel good stories about young people doing good things.
Ironically, kids from Allison’s childhood town wouldn’t have made the cut for her positive newspaper articles, including Allison herself. Apparently, doing good things wasn’t commonplace in the smoky refinery town called Woodvine, Pennsylvania, where even fresh snow was greyed with soot. Maybe the shroud of despair was fueled by the town’s urban legend: Gas Head Will Make You Dead. No wonder Aaron’s wife had rarely talked about her years growing up in Woodvine. Anyway, her family was dead. In fact, dying was the only thing the residents of Woodvine seemed to do well.
Aaron and Allison had enjoyed five years of marriage in Maryland. But it all came to a tragic end one December morning when Allison left to go shopping at a strip mall and a crazed gunman opened fire, killing his ex-girlfriend and three random people, including Allison Decker.
After his wife’s death, Aaron soon learned he had never really known Allison as well as he thought.
First clue? He discovered his wife had padlocked her hope chest. Oh Allison. What kind of secrets have you been keeping in the files stuffed within your hope chest?
Now Aaron had some questions of his own. Where would those secrets lead him? And at what cost?
THOUGHTS…
WOW. I was thoroughly engaged in this story which was an eclectic mix of mystery and suspense, complemented by the haunting tension of restless spirits and the vividness of light horror. And of course, a story of grief. COME WITH ME is one of my favorite reads for 2021 and will be shelved within my top tier of all-time favorites. It was THAT good!
The story was written in third person from Aaron’s point of view, with emotionally gripping insertions of second person when he speaks directly to his wife. I found this combination so fresh, feeling about as close to Aaron’s intimate thoughts as I could get. This approach really worked for me!
The writing was excellent. Here are two samples:
“Directly overhead, the moon was a fat pearl wreathed in smoky black clouds.”
And then…
“Bits of gravel and sand slid out from beneath my shoes and bustled in compact little avalanches down the slope.”
If I was looking hard for some criticism, I would say that sometimes parts of the book could’ve been trimmed back (and would’ve been just as powerful). And every now and then, believability slipped. Even still, I loved this book so much!
QUICKFIRE RATINGS from 1 (ugh) to 5 (woo-hoo)…
Plot (the story): 5
Main character’s likability: 5
Development of supporting character(s): 5
Settings/Atmosphere: 5
Pacing (how fast did I turn the pages): 5
Believability (in the context of the story): 4
Satisfying ending: 5
Tension of the story: 5
Stirs the heart (romantic elements): N/A
Did I solve the mystery/guess the ending before the reveal? No
Cover: 5
OVERALL:
COME WITH ME was an enthralling, 5-star read that refused to let me go.