What do you think?
Rate this book
When Stone Wings Fly: A Smoky Mountains Novel
Uncovering a long-lost family story is the only way to bring her grandmother peace
Kieran Lucas's grandmother is slipping into dementia, and, when her memory is gone, Kieran's last tie to the family she barely knows will be lost forever. Worse, Granny Mac is being tormented by flashbacks of her mother’s death and the loss of their home.
In 1931, Rosie McCauley's Smoky Mountains home is threatened by the Tennessee Great Smokies Park Commission as they create a new national park. But Rosie vows the only way they'll get her land is if they haul her out in a pine box. When a compromise offers her and her disabled sister the opportunity to stay for her lifetime, it seems too good to be true.
Ornithologist Benton Fuller arrives to conduct a bird survey for the park and the two form a tenuous bond. But their friendship broadens a rift between her and the other mountain folk who are suspicious of any government connections. Then the discovery of an illegal still in the woods near her cabin leads to a violent clash between sides that could destroy them all.
Eighty-five years later, Kieran heads back to the Great Smoky Mountains National Park to find answers to her great-grandmother's mysterious death and bring peace to Granny Mac before it's too late. Park Historian Zach Jensen may be the key to locating both the answers and a precious family heirloom. But just as in the past, Kieran's needs clash with government regulations. Will Zach block her from recovering what she needs and solving this family mystery?
Kieran Lucas's grandmother is slipping into dementia, and, when her memory is gone, Kieran's last tie to the family she barely knows will be lost forever. Worse, Granny Mac is being tormented by flashbacks of her mother’s death and the loss of their home.
In 1931, Rosie McCauley's Smoky Mountains home is threatened by the Tennessee Great Smokies Park Commission as they create a new national park. But Rosie vows the only way they'll get her land is if they haul her out in a pine box. When a compromise offers her and her disabled sister the opportunity to stay for her lifetime, it seems too good to be true.
Ornithologist Benton Fuller arrives to conduct a bird survey for the park and the two form a tenuous bond. But their friendship broadens a rift between her and the other mountain folk who are suspicious of any government connections. Then the discovery of an illegal still in the woods near her cabin leads to a violent clash between sides that could destroy them all.
Eighty-five years later, Kieran heads back to the Great Smoky Mountains National Park to find answers to her great-grandmother's mysterious death and bring peace to Granny Mac before it's too late. Park Historian Zach Jensen may be the key to locating both the answers and a precious family heirloom. But just as in the past, Kieran's needs clash with government regulations. Will Zach block her from recovering what she needs and solving this family mystery?
344 pages, Paperback
First published June 1, 2022
51 people are currently reading
1294 people want to read
About the author
Karen Barnett
11 books610 followersKaren Barnett is the award-winning author of the Vintage National Parks Novels, the Golden Gate Chronicles (Out of the Ruins, Beyond the Ashes, Through the Shadows), and MISTAKEN. She lives in Oregon with her husband, two kids, and a bevy of furry friends. You can learn more about Karen's writing journey at http://www.KarenBarnettBooks.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 185 reviews
July 5, 2022
I just left the Smokies. I've been clinging to a branch--one rooted deep into rich, rocky, fertile soil that goes back nearly a century. I didn't want to let go, even as the final leaf fell away.
Some books do that to you. They beckon you to go out on a limb with them, and then when you do, you're left clinging to the hopes and dreams, joys and sorrows of the lives within the pages.
Karen Barnett didn't just write a compelling and heartwrenching and heartwarming story in When Stone Wings Fly. She told a history of a people--one we often forget or relegate to stereotype. In Rosie and Granny, Lorna, and even Kieran we see the fierce, determined, beauty-loving, loyal-to-the-end mountain folk of the Smokies. In others, we see the not-so-good sides of those same folks. And that's how it is, isn't it? In every group of people, there are those who give the others a bad name. I think Lorna is the most brilliant of all. In her, we see the misguided idea that the people who lived in those hills back in the early 20th century were somehow "simple" or "feebleminded." But Lorna proved to be... well, more. I can't say more without giving her away. All I can say is that I think she's one of the strongest and most admirable characters in the book, which is just as it should be.
The same is true of Kieran, Zach, Benton, and the early park officials. They show that the "G-men" weren't all noble... nor were they all evil. Once again, perception and stereotype both fit and don't in that dichotomy that is life.
The spiritual lessons in the book give it life and power. Readers can't help but see God's guiding hand even where it feels like He's abandoned them. And the soul rests lightly on that branch because of it.
The best part, however, is how Karen shows that actions always have consequences. Always.
But the book is over, and I'm still clinging to that branch. I don't want to let go--don't want to say goodbye. It's time, though. There are other stories to read, and I sure hope another one from Karen Barnett is coming soon.
Some books do that to you. They beckon you to go out on a limb with them, and then when you do, you're left clinging to the hopes and dreams, joys and sorrows of the lives within the pages.
Karen Barnett didn't just write a compelling and heartwrenching and heartwarming story in When Stone Wings Fly. She told a history of a people--one we often forget or relegate to stereotype. In Rosie and Granny, Lorna, and even Kieran we see the fierce, determined, beauty-loving, loyal-to-the-end mountain folk of the Smokies. In others, we see the not-so-good sides of those same folks. And that's how it is, isn't it? In every group of people, there are those who give the others a bad name. I think Lorna is the most brilliant of all. In her, we see the misguided idea that the people who lived in those hills back in the early 20th century were somehow "simple" or "feebleminded." But Lorna proved to be... well, more. I can't say more without giving her away. All I can say is that I think she's one of the strongest and most admirable characters in the book, which is just as it should be.
The same is true of Kieran, Zach, Benton, and the early park officials. They show that the "G-men" weren't all noble... nor were they all evil. Once again, perception and stereotype both fit and don't in that dichotomy that is life.
The spiritual lessons in the book give it life and power. Readers can't help but see God's guiding hand even where it feels like He's abandoned them. And the soul rests lightly on that branch because of it.
The best part, however, is how Karen shows that actions always have consequences. Always.
But the book is over, and I'm still clinging to that branch. I don't want to let go--don't want to say goodbye. It's time, though. There are other stories to read, and I sure hope another one from Karen Barnett is coming soon.
January 10, 2023
Phew! I devoured this book with it's unique dual timeline in what seems like a nanosecond! How can it be over so soon? The exquisite writing style brought the Smoky Mountains to life and introduced me to some history I wasn't aware of. But it is the characters that leapt to life and made me feel a multitude of emotions. Happy, sad, mad, confused...everything in between...and left my heart aching by the end. There really aren't adequate words to do justice to the storytelling.
Two romances -- two (and more!) women of strength and courage, qualities carried over from one generation to the next. The richness of family history lost and then found and not glossed over in order to make a pretty picture. A woman in the past who holds onto her faith through incredible hardships; a woman in the present who discovers faith for the first time.
Intensely emotional in all the beauty of it's messiness. The kind of story that seeps into your bones and settles into your heart. Just stunning!
Two romances -- two (and more!) women of strength and courage, qualities carried over from one generation to the next. The richness of family history lost and then found and not glossed over in order to make a pretty picture. A woman in the past who holds onto her faith through incredible hardships; a woman in the present who discovers faith for the first time.
Intensely emotional in all the beauty of it's messiness. The kind of story that seeps into your bones and settles into your heart. Just stunning!
June 29, 2022
Gorgeous storytelling, knit together with Karen Barnett‘s signature love of nature and national parks. When Stone Wings Fly is a touching and heart-wrenching story of family and love and of letting go. Rosie and Kieran and Granny Mac are compelling women trying to make it on their own in difficult circumstances and finding strength to do so. I have loved every single one of Karen Barnett’s books, but this one may be her best yet!
March 12, 2023
Present Day & 1932-1942 Tennessee
Enchanting! Both threads captured my interest and didn't let go.
Fun quote: "A romantic getaway for one - just me and a stack of novels."
At the very end of the present day thread, I didn't love how one piece was handled, but this was minor. Overall, an excellent novel.
Enchanting! Both threads captured my interest and didn't let go.
Fun quote: "A romantic getaway for one - just me and a stack of novels."
At the very end of the present day thread, I didn't love how one piece was handled, but this was minor. Overall, an excellent novel.
July 23, 2022
“These mountains will whisper our stories long after we’re gone.”
If you’ve been around me for a minute, you already know that the Smoky Mountains are my happy place. I feel at home there, and my soul is always invigorated by even just a few hours spent in the area. One of my very favorite ways to pass the time on a visit to the Smokies has long been a drive through Cades Cove, but it’s only been in recent years that I learned about the history of the park – about why those cabins and churches stand abandoned amid the peaceful beauty of sweeping mountain views, roaming wildlife, leafy trees, and babbling brooks. About the days when generational homes were bought up & residents relocated to pave the way for the Great Smoky Mountains to become a national park.
It’s against this backdrop that Karen Barnett paints a beautifully poetic picture of strong women, family secrets, and gentle heroes. Rosie, Kieran and Granny Mac each thoroughly captured my heart, one a historical heroine with courageous wisdom, one a contemporary heroine walking in her wake, braver than she realizes … and one that rests poignantly in the gap between. Ben & Zach are swoonworthy and sweet heroes, both a bit on the quieter side, each one assisting his respective heroine with her spiritual journey in unique ways and being indelibly influenced by her in return.
Barnett’s word-weaving lilts perfectly with the cadence of Appalachia, immersing readers in both the historical and contemporary timelines with ease. She also effortlessly connects the two – in ways both familial and metaphorical – and I loved watching all the individual pieces come together, even the painful ones. Because without them, the ending wouldn’t have been nearly as sweet… and isn’t that just like our lives in the hands of our Creator?
Bottom Line: I loved Barnett’s historical novels that took us vicariously to Mount Rainier, Yosemite, and Yellowstone National Parks, but my heart & my roots lie in the Smokies so I was ecstatic when I learned about When Stone Wings Fly. It was everything I hoped for – and more. Atmospheric. Touching. Heartwarming. Lyrical. I may have even hugged the book when I was done – yes, it’s one of those reads that wraps you up so completely that even the pages themselves become friends. Do not miss this book! It’s Karen Barnett’s best yet!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
If you’ve been around me for a minute, you already know that the Smoky Mountains are my happy place. I feel at home there, and my soul is always invigorated by even just a few hours spent in the area. One of my very favorite ways to pass the time on a visit to the Smokies has long been a drive through Cades Cove, but it’s only been in recent years that I learned about the history of the park – about why those cabins and churches stand abandoned amid the peaceful beauty of sweeping mountain views, roaming wildlife, leafy trees, and babbling brooks. About the days when generational homes were bought up & residents relocated to pave the way for the Great Smoky Mountains to become a national park.
It’s against this backdrop that Karen Barnett paints a beautifully poetic picture of strong women, family secrets, and gentle heroes. Rosie, Kieran and Granny Mac each thoroughly captured my heart, one a historical heroine with courageous wisdom, one a contemporary heroine walking in her wake, braver than she realizes … and one that rests poignantly in the gap between. Ben & Zach are swoonworthy and sweet heroes, both a bit on the quieter side, each one assisting his respective heroine with her spiritual journey in unique ways and being indelibly influenced by her in return.
Barnett’s word-weaving lilts perfectly with the cadence of Appalachia, immersing readers in both the historical and contemporary timelines with ease. She also effortlessly connects the two – in ways both familial and metaphorical – and I loved watching all the individual pieces come together, even the painful ones. Because without them, the ending wouldn’t have been nearly as sweet… and isn’t that just like our lives in the hands of our Creator?
Bottom Line: I loved Barnett’s historical novels that took us vicariously to Mount Rainier, Yosemite, and Yellowstone National Parks, but my heart & my roots lie in the Smokies so I was ecstatic when I learned about When Stone Wings Fly. It was everything I hoped for – and more. Atmospheric. Touching. Heartwarming. Lyrical. I may have even hugged the book when I was done – yes, it’s one of those reads that wraps you up so completely that even the pages themselves become friends. Do not miss this book! It’s Karen Barnett’s best yet!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
November 7, 2023
I have a really hard time with split time novels, because I almost always find myself preferring one story line over the other. As was with this one. But it was still good! I felt like one of the sacrifices made by Benton was a bit of a reach with the story line that led up to it, and wished there would have been more depth to his decision. But overall I enjoyed it. It was faith based and clean. I'll try another book by this author.
July 7, 2022
This is Karen Barnett at her best!
With an adept pen, Ms. Barnett has crafted a beautiful tapestry of words, with prose that brings to life the beauty of the Smoky Mountains. The two timelines are skillfully connected, bringing a story of family that will tug at ones' heart.
Ms. Barnett's expert research skills provided a voice of authenticity to the history of the founding of the park and the struggle between the Appalachian mountain people and the park officials over the land. I absolutely loved Rosie, a courageous mountain woman who fought hard for family and the home she loved. Decades later, discovery of her family's story will bring peace to Kieran's Granny Mac. This is an incredible story of strong family roots but is also one of letting go, so that one can fly.
With an adept pen, Ms. Barnett has crafted a beautiful tapestry of words, with prose that brings to life the beauty of the Smoky Mountains. The two timelines are skillfully connected, bringing a story of family that will tug at ones' heart.
Ms. Barnett's expert research skills provided a voice of authenticity to the history of the founding of the park and the struggle between the Appalachian mountain people and the park officials over the land. I absolutely loved Rosie, a courageous mountain woman who fought hard for family and the home she loved. Decades later, discovery of her family's story will bring peace to Kieran's Granny Mac. This is an incredible story of strong family roots but is also one of letting go, so that one can fly.
May 21, 2023
Audiobook (narrated by Susan Bennett)
The story of Rosie McCauley and her family is both tender and harsh in the telling. It both warms the heart and breaks it.
Robin’s Ratings
5🌟 = Out of this world. Amazing. Unforgettable. A personal favorite.
4🌟 = Enjoyed/loved it. Will recommend to others.
3🌟 = Liked it. Glad I read it. Engaging/entertaining/interesting.
2🌟 = The book was okay, but I’ve enjoyed other books so much more.
1🌟 = For whatever reason, I didn’t like it and can’t recommend it.
The story of Rosie McCauley and her family is both tender and harsh in the telling. It both warms the heart and breaks it.
Robin’s Ratings
5🌟 = Out of this world. Amazing. Unforgettable. A personal favorite.
4🌟 = Enjoyed/loved it. Will recommend to others.
3🌟 = Liked it. Glad I read it. Engaging/entertaining/interesting.
2🌟 = The book was okay, but I’ve enjoyed other books so much more.
1🌟 = For whatever reason, I didn’t like it and can’t recommend it.
October 24, 2023
Karen Barnett is the queen of National Parks fiction. As a former park ranger she's the perfect author to write them. Each book is well researched which means the park itself becomes a character. When Stone Wings Fly is no different, the Smokies become a main character of the book. As well fall the dual time line of Rosie McCauley in the 1930s and 1940s with Benton Fuller the hero of the past. And Kieran Lucas in present day and Zach Jensen. This one for me was the hardest of Karen's books to read. It's not a bad book. Just for me it hits to close to home. Reading about Kieran and her grandma in the present was an emotional roller coaster but it's worth. The past setting was even harder as my own family lost family land for a National Park just not the smokies Mammoth Cave. But if you don't have that hanging over your head its a good read, and probably a quick read. It took me almost two months to read it because I kept needing to take a break to process my emotions that were heightened because of family history. Other readers won't have that problem.
June 15, 2022
When Stone Wings Fly is for the National Park enthusiast and historical Christian romance reader alike. A former park ranger and naturalist, Karen Barnett honors park history while being realistic about how the establishment of the Great Smoky Mountains National Park unsettled so many families just like Rosie’s. And in perfect split-time form, Karen Barnett gives you just enough hints in the present to prepare you for the past scenes that will break your heart.
When Stone Wings Fly digs deep into family secrets, generational issues, and the conflict between justice and sentiment—not to mention the housing problems facing our country’s unemployed and seniors alike. If you’ve ever had a loved one who struggled with dementia, be aware that this book may evoke more emotions than the typical split-time. But for me, the beautiful word pictures and the tribute to family ties were worth the tears.
When Stone Wings Fly digs deep into family secrets, generational issues, and the conflict between justice and sentiment—not to mention the housing problems facing our country’s unemployed and seniors alike. If you’ve ever had a loved one who struggled with dementia, be aware that this book may evoke more emotions than the typical split-time. But for me, the beautiful word pictures and the tribute to family ties were worth the tears.
September 29, 2023
In When Stone Wings Fly you will find a pitch-perfect blend of the past meeting the present. Normally, I connect more strongly with only one of the timelines. I could as I read easily see how the past intersected so well to show what was happening in the present and maybe why. There is a strong emphasis on family, on the choices we make within a family whether they be biological or not.
Each of the characters was given a stage to shine on and have their story told. Of all the novels I have read by Karen Barnett this is definitely my favourite.
Each of the characters was given a stage to shine on and have their story told. Of all the novels I have read by Karen Barnett this is definitely my favourite.
Read
January 22, 2022Endorsement:
“Once again, Karen Barnett paints America’s historical landscape with deft skill and steady hand. Her deep-seated love for the Smoky Mountains etches each page like a poem. Pitch-perfect research and incomparable heart paint every corner of When Stone Wing’s Fly’s brilliantly coloured canvas. Readers get ready: your newest split-time fiction experience rests in the hands of a master.”
“Once again, Karen Barnett paints America’s historical landscape with deft skill and steady hand. Her deep-seated love for the Smoky Mountains etches each page like a poem. Pitch-perfect research and incomparable heart paint every corner of When Stone Wing’s Fly’s brilliantly coloured canvas. Readers get ready: your newest split-time fiction experience rests in the hands of a master.”
September 5, 2023
Karen Barnett has woven a colorful family tapestry in When Stone Wings Fly. I thoroughly enjoyed this engaging drama rooted in love, loyalty, courage, and true belonging. This dual era story is the perfect balance of mystery, romance, faith, Americana, and a right neighborly helpin' of Tennessee mountain charm. It’s warm and engaging and full of well-paced tension and intriguing (a.k.a. page-turning) mystery.
In my “book,” a good story keeps me thinking about the characters and what makes them tick. A great story does that but also gets me thinking about my own heart and challenges me to grow in character, faith, and grace. This is one of those stories. Well done. Highly recommended!
In my “book,” a good story keeps me thinking about the characters and what makes them tick. A great story does that but also gets me thinking about my own heart and challenges me to grow in character, faith, and grace. This is one of those stories. Well done. Highly recommended!
Read
June 20, 2024This dual timeline story is enjoyable and has a wonderful message. The ending shows how God heals his people and how He helps us forgive. I never knew that people had been displaced to make a national park, and that saddens me. Our government still uses imminent domain when it wants, often when it could easily be avoided.
Skillfully written. My hat is off to Karen Barnett. This beautiful story is one I will never forget. Heartwarming and vividly painted, readers will be touched deep down into their souls.
Skillfully written. My hat is off to Karen Barnett. This beautiful story is one I will never forget. Heartwarming and vividly painted, readers will be touched deep down into their souls.
July 30, 2022
"When Stone Wings Fly" is a Christian historical romance, a split-time story set in 1932-42 and in present day. When the Tennessee Great Smokies Park Commission starts to forcefully buy up the land to create a national park, Rosie refuses to leave. Her family's roots are in this land, and her simple-minded sister wouldn't handle moving very well. Even when a kind, handsome bird watcher captures her heart, she refuses to leave--he'll have to leave his prime job as a university professor and join her on her dirt-poor farm if he wants her. Her refusal to loosen her grip and trust that God could provide a good life outside of her land brings about a series of tragic events leading ultimately to her death.
In the present day, Kieran's broken family meant that she spent years in foster care, but she's finally found family: Granny Mac. Mac talks about her mother, Rosie, and a stone bird she had, but her memories are muddled due to dementia and being so young when she left Rosie's land. Kieran hopes to find the old homestead and dig up the bird to help Mac (and herself) reconnect with the past. Park historian Zach kindly spends extra effort helping her uncover the past, but digging up the bird is illegal and he's very by-the-rules. Granny warns Kieran that she also holds on to things too tightly (by following her own way to keep happiness). Will Kieran be able to choose a way that will finally break the string of tragedies in her family?
In both timelines, the characters were likable, complex, and reacted in realistic ways. Historical details were woven into the story without slowing the pacing. Suspense came from the lurking danger from a growing feud with a neighbor. Both couples became friends before moving into deeper caring and romance. The Christian element was trusting God enough to let go of the things that provide (sometimes false) security. There were no sex scenes or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable historical.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
In the present day, Kieran's broken family meant that she spent years in foster care, but she's finally found family: Granny Mac. Mac talks about her mother, Rosie, and a stone bird she had, but her memories are muddled due to dementia and being so young when she left Rosie's land. Kieran hopes to find the old homestead and dig up the bird to help Mac (and herself) reconnect with the past. Park historian Zach kindly spends extra effort helping her uncover the past, but digging up the bird is illegal and he's very by-the-rules. Granny warns Kieran that she also holds on to things too tightly (by following her own way to keep happiness). Will Kieran be able to choose a way that will finally break the string of tragedies in her family?
In both timelines, the characters were likable, complex, and reacted in realistic ways. Historical details were woven into the story without slowing the pacing. Suspense came from the lurking danger from a growing feud with a neighbor. Both couples became friends before moving into deeper caring and romance. The Christian element was trusting God enough to let go of the things that provide (sometimes false) security. There were no sex scenes or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable historical.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
October 5, 2023
I really enjoyed this time-slip novel. Both timeframes were quite compelling, and I'd be hard-pressed to choose a favourite. I liked how Kieran's quest to help her grandmother ultimately resulted in her learning to trust God and spread her wings to fly in His plan for her, just as her great grandmother Rosie had done.
I also really enjoyed the family history aspect of the story. As the daughter of a professional genealogist, I love seeing the paths taken to piece together the puzzle of where we came from in our previous generations . . . both the physical locations, but also the stories of our ancestors' lives.
I also really enjoyed the family history aspect of the story. As the daughter of a professional genealogist, I love seeing the paths taken to piece together the puzzle of where we came from in our previous generations . . . both the physical locations, but also the stories of our ancestors' lives.
August 23, 2023
This book lead me kicking and screaming into a 4 star review, and I am still pondering how it accomplished that.
About 8 chapters in when I realized it might be a romance and that it certainly was a Christian faith based book I just about stalled out. Those are two genres I struggle to find genuine with enough reality in conflict, doubt, disappointment and tenacity to hold my attention.
But author, Karen Barnett, won me over with her setting of the Great Smokey Mountains National Park, the grievances of it’s creation as well as plenty of realistic doubts and inner conflicts in her characters.
The grittiness of life full of pain, misunderstandings, uneasy plot choices finally hooked me.
Having finished the book I am not sure to whom I would recommend it or gift it. I am pondering who retains enough of a challenged and shaken faith to not resent the Christian faith overtones. And who wants to read a chaste, restrained romance? (And I am shocked to say perhaps me???! No, no, no…evidently I am not the reader I think I am.)
It was a delight to see the author lives in Oregon and that she has worked in a National Park in the NW and a beloved Oregon State Park. Coupled with the fact she likes to decorate “crazy birthday cakes” I confess my admiration for her as well as her engaging writing.
About 8 chapters in when I realized it might be a romance and that it certainly was a Christian faith based book I just about stalled out. Those are two genres I struggle to find genuine with enough reality in conflict, doubt, disappointment and tenacity to hold my attention.
But author, Karen Barnett, won me over with her setting of the Great Smokey Mountains National Park, the grievances of it’s creation as well as plenty of realistic doubts and inner conflicts in her characters.
The grittiness of life full of pain, misunderstandings, uneasy plot choices finally hooked me.
Having finished the book I am not sure to whom I would recommend it or gift it. I am pondering who retains enough of a challenged and shaken faith to not resent the Christian faith overtones. And who wants to read a chaste, restrained romance? (And I am shocked to say perhaps me???! No, no, no…evidently I am not the reader I think I am.)
It was a delight to see the author lives in Oregon and that she has worked in a National Park in the NW and a beloved Oregon State Park. Coupled with the fact she likes to decorate “crazy birthday cakes” I confess my admiration for her as well as her engaging writing.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 16, 2022
I really wish Goodreads had half star options for ratings, this one gets a 3.5 rating, rounded up to 4 for Goodreads. There is a lot to like about this story, the Smoky Mountains as a main setting is wonderful, the cast of characters both in the historical timeline and the present-day timeline are likable and fit the story perfectly. The story is compelling, and I enjoyed it. What brought my rating down a notch, was how some of the story was resolved. I realize the way it was resolved was logical from a legal standpoint, but it just didn't set well with me. There was also a little too much heartbreak and tragedy in the story as well. All in all, a good story and worth a read, especially if you love a good dual time/family generations story.
August 2, 2024
A beautiful and evocative time slip novel set in the Smokey Mountains, that follows two women more than 80 years apart as they discover the meaning of roots, faith, and home.
Kieran Lucas had a troubled upbringing, and has just recently reconnected with her long-lost grandmother, who is suffering with dementia. She hopes to bring comfort to her grandmother, by recovering the lost family heirloom that she has been asking after, the only problem is that where it is buried is now part of the Smokey Mountain National Park. Will a handsome park ranger, thwart her plans to recover the heirloom?
Rosie McCauley is fighting to save her family's homestead from the encroaching offers from the government to buy her out and add the only she and her sister have ever known to the newly formed Smokey Mountain National Park. The arrival of a young ornithologist, Benton Fuller upends her simple way of life and has her asking questions about how deep her roots are tied to the land.
A stunning and emotional dual timeline novel, that delves into the rich history of the accumulation of the land the Smokey Mountain National Park sits on. It was a little slow to start for me as there are multiple characters that we follow, 4 in all, Kieran, Zach, Rosie, and Benton. But after getting acquainted with each of them, I was quickly pulled in.
A wonderful read, with complex characters that captured my heart. Kieran has had a complicated life, but she has big heart for others, evidenced by her job and care for her grandmother. Rosie loves her home, and will do anything to protect her sister, Lorna, who is considered slow. Lorna has a big heart, but the innocence of a child, and her ways aren't always understood by their neighbors. I loved how Benton embraces Lorna as part of Rosie's life, getting to know the sisters while studying the birds on their land. Zach is a rule follower, and he is intrigued by Kieran's quest to find the family heirloom, I liked his strong commitment to his faith, as well as his close-knit family.
Overall, a well done read that drew me in with its combination of a riveting plot, and complex characters. I loved the strong themes of faith, forgiveness, and family woven throughout. Well worth the read, and highly recommend!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Kieran Lucas had a troubled upbringing, and has just recently reconnected with her long-lost grandmother, who is suffering with dementia. She hopes to bring comfort to her grandmother, by recovering the lost family heirloom that she has been asking after, the only problem is that where it is buried is now part of the Smokey Mountain National Park. Will a handsome park ranger, thwart her plans to recover the heirloom?
Rosie McCauley is fighting to save her family's homestead from the encroaching offers from the government to buy her out and add the only she and her sister have ever known to the newly formed Smokey Mountain National Park. The arrival of a young ornithologist, Benton Fuller upends her simple way of life and has her asking questions about how deep her roots are tied to the land.
A stunning and emotional dual timeline novel, that delves into the rich history of the accumulation of the land the Smokey Mountain National Park sits on. It was a little slow to start for me as there are multiple characters that we follow, 4 in all, Kieran, Zach, Rosie, and Benton. But after getting acquainted with each of them, I was quickly pulled in.
A wonderful read, with complex characters that captured my heart. Kieran has had a complicated life, but she has big heart for others, evidenced by her job and care for her grandmother. Rosie loves her home, and will do anything to protect her sister, Lorna, who is considered slow. Lorna has a big heart, but the innocence of a child, and her ways aren't always understood by their neighbors. I loved how Benton embraces Lorna as part of Rosie's life, getting to know the sisters while studying the birds on their land. Zach is a rule follower, and he is intrigued by Kieran's quest to find the family heirloom, I liked his strong commitment to his faith, as well as his close-knit family.
Overall, a well done read that drew me in with its combination of a riveting plot, and complex characters. I loved the strong themes of faith, forgiveness, and family woven throughout. Well worth the read, and highly recommend!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
July 22, 2022
I have really enjoyed Karen Barnett's national park books in the past and so I picked it up at a writer's conference last month and got my copy signed by the author. I was prepared to enjoy the story, but not for how much this author has grown in their story craft. This story is deeper, more complex, and absolutely spellbinding! I was especially impressed with how the author was able to honor both the story of the founding of the Smokey Mountains National Park and their desire to preserve the land for all to enjoy as well as honoring the heartbreaking tale of individual landowners who had their property taken by the government against their wishes. This novel is amazing in how it tells both stories with depth and authenticity. So lovely. It was also a compelling read and I couldn't flip pages fast enough. Well done!
December 23, 2022
When Stone Wings Fly is a dual timeline story set in the Smoky Mountains that will keep you turning pages! I sped through this one within a couple of days. The alternating storylines really help with the pacing and suspense as you start to piece together the story of a family shrouded in the mist of time.
Kieran Lucas is a young woman without roots--except for her recently discovered Granny Mac, a sweet older lady with a failing memory. As hazy stories seep out from years in the Smoky Mountains, Kieran finds herself eager to track down the names and places that shaped previous generations, hoping that it might bring some peace both to Granny Mac and herself. Along the way, she meets handsome historian Zach Jensen. He has access to the resources she needs, and their friendship shows signs of morphing into something deeper.
This novel has a lot to say about generational trauma, the importance of oral storytelling and documentation, and the uneasy relationship between the park service and the mountain residents whose land was swallowed up by the national park. There are points where it's a tough read, but it never ceases being compelling. If you're a fan of books like Christy by Catherine Marshall, you'll probably devour this one!
Thanks to Kregel Publications and NetGalley for this digital review copy!
Kieran Lucas is a young woman without roots--except for her recently discovered Granny Mac, a sweet older lady with a failing memory. As hazy stories seep out from years in the Smoky Mountains, Kieran finds herself eager to track down the names and places that shaped previous generations, hoping that it might bring some peace both to Granny Mac and herself. Along the way, she meets handsome historian Zach Jensen. He has access to the resources she needs, and their friendship shows signs of morphing into something deeper.
This novel has a lot to say about generational trauma, the importance of oral storytelling and documentation, and the uneasy relationship between the park service and the mountain residents whose land was swallowed up by the national park. There are points where it's a tough read, but it never ceases being compelling. If you're a fan of books like Christy by Catherine Marshall, you'll probably devour this one!
Thanks to Kregel Publications and NetGalley for this digital review copy!
July 13, 2022
Barnett has such a way with words. The way she describes the surroundings, emotions, thoughts, and well pretty much everything is just amazing. She pulls you right into the novel. You can see the beauty in the surroundings. It’s like being in a time machine going back and forth between Kieran’s story and Rosie’s. I was enchanted by them both.
When Stone Wings Fly is a story of faith, emotion, heartache, persistence, love and family. More than once it is mentioned that sometimes a family is yours by choice and that is so true. On top of that, Barnett happens to discuss some pretty tough topics, both in the past and in present day. I just say, she did so poetically and tenderly. Lorna’s character…… oh man I don’t want to give away any spoilers but she really touched my heart and surprised me in so many ways. Granny Mac’s living in the past brought tears to my eyes, as did so many parts of the story.
So many things to love. The birds. The research. The plot. The characters. The list could go on forever. I’ve been waiting for a book from Barnett and boy she did not disappoint. I just hope there’s another in the pipeline!!!
**I purchased a copy of this book for myself.**
When Stone Wings Fly is a story of faith, emotion, heartache, persistence, love and family. More than once it is mentioned that sometimes a family is yours by choice and that is so true. On top of that, Barnett happens to discuss some pretty tough topics, both in the past and in present day. I just say, she did so poetically and tenderly. Lorna’s character…… oh man I don’t want to give away any spoilers but she really touched my heart and surprised me in so many ways. Granny Mac’s living in the past brought tears to my eyes, as did so many parts of the story.
So many things to love. The birds. The research. The plot. The characters. The list could go on forever. I’ve been waiting for a book from Barnett and boy she did not disappoint. I just hope there’s another in the pipeline!!!
**I purchased a copy of this book for myself.**
June 14, 2022
Barnett's tale set in the Great Smoky Mountains flows as smooth as wildwood honey. The two timelines are stitched together like alternating blocks of a quilt passed down through the decades, keeping family connected and rooted. I love a good Appalachian tale and Barnett's hits all the right notes from the familiar dialect to the natural beauty of the mountains. I felt utterly at home.
March 21, 2023
Enjoyed the story, especially when the story followed characters back in time.
July 23, 2022
I've only read one other of this author's books at this point, which was a historical and was a good read, but not one of my favorites. However, having grown up vacationing at the Smokies several years because it was not a great distance and getting a cabin for our family of 6 was a cheaper way to go, I knew I wanted to read this book when it came out. This one is a dual timeline, which is a favorite style of mine as well - I love reading about how the pasts influences the present. And combining those 2 elements - the favored way of storytelling along with the familiar setting, along with the author's lovely writing style and vast knowledge of national parks in general, this was a stellar read. I enjoyed learning more about the park's history (I had no idea that there had been people who'd lived in the mountains and were displaced by the park) as well as re-viewing it in modern day.
This book tells the story of Rosie McCauley in the past timeline, who lives with her mentally handicapped sister in the cabin that their dad built after her parents' deaths. When the park comes in to buy her land, she struggles with the decisions that come her way. Benton Fuller is an ornithologist in Ithaca, NY, and has come to Tennessee on behalf of the park to survey the bird wildlife. He falls in love with both the land and with Rosie. Their story is one fraught with hardships and love conquering all. In the modern timeline, their descendent Kieran who has recently discovered her grandma Mac seeks to find pieces from her Gran's past in order to help her have more lucid moments as dementia slowly claims what's left of Kieran's family. As Kieran travels to the Smokies to hopefully obtain the stone bird that her grandmother keeps asking for, she comes across Zach, who is both rigid in his rules and kind to her. Both story lines have great love and sorrow, a sweet romance and tensions, and a solid faith thread. This book included mysteries in the past that were solved in the present, along with beautiful character growth and development in both timelines. All in all, this was an excellent read that I would recommend to fans of all genres.
Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to provide a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.
This book tells the story of Rosie McCauley in the past timeline, who lives with her mentally handicapped sister in the cabin that their dad built after her parents' deaths. When the park comes in to buy her land, she struggles with the decisions that come her way. Benton Fuller is an ornithologist in Ithaca, NY, and has come to Tennessee on behalf of the park to survey the bird wildlife. He falls in love with both the land and with Rosie. Their story is one fraught with hardships and love conquering all. In the modern timeline, their descendent Kieran who has recently discovered her grandma Mac seeks to find pieces from her Gran's past in order to help her have more lucid moments as dementia slowly claims what's left of Kieran's family. As Kieran travels to the Smokies to hopefully obtain the stone bird that her grandmother keeps asking for, she comes across Zach, who is both rigid in his rules and kind to her. Both story lines have great love and sorrow, a sweet romance and tensions, and a solid faith thread. This book included mysteries in the past that were solved in the present, along with beautiful character growth and development in both timelines. All in all, this was an excellent read that I would recommend to fans of all genres.
Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to provide a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.
July 20, 2022
BOOK REVIEW 🦉
"When Stone Wings Fly"
by Karen Barnett
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️+
I have read and loved all of Karen's books but this one might be her best!
This book combines my three favorite things - reading (ha, of course), National Parks and stories of God's love and forgiveness. (Plus one of the characters literally has my dream job - a historian for the National Park Service! 😍)
Taking place in the Smoky Mountains - the narrative switches between a mountain family who lived in the Smoky Mountains before it was a park (c. 1930) - where life was hard but God's lessons great - and present day Smoky Mountain National Park where the mountain family's ancestor searches for family, connection and meaning.
From an historical standpoint I love that this book tackles the messy history between the US government and the lands they took to be national parks. There's no doubt that these places are beautiful and I'm glad they will be protected for years to come but it's necessary to acknowledge their less than honorable acquirement and the deep importance they held to their original occupants. There's no way to wrap what happened in a pretty bow and this book doesn't try to - which in turn shows honor and respect to those who came before us.
I also love that this book doesn't shy away from the messiness of family and life. We all have crooked pasts - whether by way of our family or ourselves or, most likely, both. This book helps show that none of these things define us or determine our meaning. All we need is to loosen our grip on our lives and let God lead us to what He has planned.
Such a beautiful story. Definitely a must read!
"When Stone Wings Fly"
by Karen Barnett
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️+
I have read and loved all of Karen's books but this one might be her best!
This book combines my three favorite things - reading (ha, of course), National Parks and stories of God's love and forgiveness. (Plus one of the characters literally has my dream job - a historian for the National Park Service! 😍)
Taking place in the Smoky Mountains - the narrative switches between a mountain family who lived in the Smoky Mountains before it was a park (c. 1930) - where life was hard but God's lessons great - and present day Smoky Mountain National Park where the mountain family's ancestor searches for family, connection and meaning.
From an historical standpoint I love that this book tackles the messy history between the US government and the lands they took to be national parks. There's no doubt that these places are beautiful and I'm glad they will be protected for years to come but it's necessary to acknowledge their less than honorable acquirement and the deep importance they held to their original occupants. There's no way to wrap what happened in a pretty bow and this book doesn't try to - which in turn shows honor and respect to those who came before us.
I also love that this book doesn't shy away from the messiness of family and life. We all have crooked pasts - whether by way of our family or ourselves or, most likely, both. This book helps show that none of these things define us or determine our meaning. All we need is to loosen our grip on our lives and let God lead us to what He has planned.
Such a beautiful story. Definitely a must read!
October 1, 2022
I enjoyed this novel by my friend Karen Barnett.
As a former park ranger, Karen brings insight into the ranger life coupled with a poignant story set in Smoky Mountains Nations Park. The novel highlights an aspect of the park's creation that brought grief to many even as it opened a beautiful site for millions more over the last nearly 100 years.
It's a reminder that trauma and grief often are behind some of the most beautiful works of "art."
As a former park ranger, Karen brings insight into the ranger life coupled with a poignant story set in Smoky Mountains Nations Park. The novel highlights an aspect of the park's creation that brought grief to many even as it opened a beautiful site for millions more over the last nearly 100 years.
It's a reminder that trauma and grief often are behind some of the most beautiful works of "art."
August 7, 2022
What am incredible story! I was intrigued by Granny Mac from beginning to end.
Her story really made sit on the edge of my seat.
This story is full of emotions from each of the characters and you will feel their emotions deeply.
I loved every minute of it and spent a delightful afternoon in the Smokies without ever leaving the comfort of my home.
This will be my favorite one from this author even though it is a dual time line story. She does such a nice job with it.
I didn't want the the novel to end! When they're so good but at least I can savor the story long after it's over.
Well done! 5 stars!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Her story really made sit on the edge of my seat.
This story is full of emotions from each of the characters and you will feel their emotions deeply.
I loved every minute of it and spent a delightful afternoon in the Smokies without ever leaving the comfort of my home.
This will be my favorite one from this author even though it is a dual time line story. She does such a nice job with it.
I didn't want the the novel to end! When they're so good but at least I can savor the story long after it's over.
Well done! 5 stars!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 10, 2024
I adore historical fiction and dual timeline novels! This story was amazing! The characters stayed with me for days! Now I want to read all of Karen Barnett's books! I listened to the audio; the story was easy to follow, and the narrators did an amazing job. Highly recommended!
November 15, 2024
4.5 stars for this captivating story! Lovely characters with a plot that has a bit of a mystery to solve. Beautiful descriptions of the setting in the Smoky Mountains in Tennessee.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 185 reviews