Integrating into somebody’s life as their significant other isn’t always easy, and Yuki’s deafness provides another wrinkle to that experience. Itsuomi is nothing if not accommodating, possibly too much so, as the pair end up spending the night at his place after a little camping excursion offers a break from the norm…
In what is perhaps something I should have seen coming (and a friend pegged much earlier), this series has, not surprisingly for a Suu Morishita book, a real problem in its male lead. And it’s enough that I question how much better this series would be without him.
First off, Itsuomi is duller than a rusty nail. He seems like a zombie with a penchant for international travel and he’s somehow incredibly uninteresting. Plus, the way he looks at Yuki is downright creepy at times.
This is one instance where I legitimately think that the writing of the character is breaking down rather than the character inherently being a write-off (so to speak). Either way, it remains a fact that this relationship still isn’t working for me like it should.
Part of the problem is that I think for all the attempts at making Yuki feel normal, this is so far translating as Itsuomi being too perfect and this book constantly pulling its punches in terms of showing any difficulty for the pair. He’s SO good (supposedly) that I’m innately suspicious of him on general instinct (too many years of TV mysteries will do this to you).
When is this book best? Same as when the series is best - when it is about Yuki and how she integrates with the world as somebody who can hear very little of it. The way the book conveys her hearing is always so, so good and we’ve already seen how satisfying it is when she goes up against (and triumphs over) adversity rather than has somebody just paving the way.
I’m more invested in her getting a job and what that will entail and the secondary relationship between Rin and the bartender than anything involving Smirky McPerfect and his bottomless fount of acceptance. It might be my imagination, but I do think in his attempts at treating her like an equal and doing so much for her I am starting to also get a whiff of condescension.
There’s a moment when Yuki pulls on Itsuomi’s shirt and he goes wide eyed in that cute chibi style that Yuki’s frequently drawn in and it’s like his soul briefly reanimated his body for a second and the most relatable he’s ever been. He’s never surprised or much of anything and this shows how leaden he normally presents as a result.
It’s not all bad - the camping trip is a lot of fun and the relationships of the other characters are fine, but the relationship at the fore is a real pain in the aft some times. I’m more keen to learn more about Yuki’s new note taker than I am Itsuomi. I will give him credit for properly rolling his eyes and saying ‘are we really doing this’ to the expected reveal of childhood rival friend.
3.5 stars and you may be shocked that I am nudging this up, but it comes down to Yuki. She is amazing and when we see how she adapts to her hearing loss it’s always fascinating and seeing the world through her eyes is wonderful. I just honestly wish she was looking at something more interesting.