In de winter van 1795 ondernamen twee Nederlanders een diplomatieke vriendschapsmissie naar de Chinese keizer Qianlong, onder wiens leiding China was uitgegroeid tot een zeer welvarend land en een In de winter van 1795 ondernamen twee Nederlanders een diplomatieke vriendschapsmissie naar de Chinese keizer Qianlong, onder wiens leiding China was uitgegroeid tot een zeer welvarend land en een serieuze concurrent van het Westen. De kans op succes leek gering: twee jaar eerder was een soortgelijke Engelse missie pijnlijk mislukt en was de relatie met China ernstig bekoeld. Na een barre tocht arriveerden Isaac Titsingh en Andreas van Braam Houckgeest precies op tijd voor de viering van het zestigjarige regeringsjubileum van Qianlong. Hun missie werd een diplomatieke triomf. Met hun kennis van China en hun respect voor de Chinese gewoonten wisten ze de keizer te charmeren. Qianlong overlaadde zijn gasten met gunsten en vertrouwelijke informatie. Opgetogen keerden Titsingh en Van Braam terug van hun reis. Maar veel van hun voor Nederland en Europa belangrijke kennis over China ging verloren in het geweld dat daarna uitbrak. Nederland werd bezet door Napoleon. In China braken opstanden uit, en spoedig daarna volgden de Chinees-Engelse Opiumoorlogen. Aan de hand van grondig onderzoek en met een levendige pen laat Tonio Andrade het China van de achttiende eeuw herleven en reconstrueert hij een grotendeels vergeten episode in onze betrekkingen met China – met een glansrol voor Isaac Titsingh en Andreas van Braam.
This book was so very unique and charming, while still providing great historical analysis. It follows the colourful characters of the 1795 Dutch embassy to the Qing court, a story filled with misadventure, tragedy, complaints and a great ton of wonder.
Andrade’s tireless research allows the reader to not only dive into 1800s China, but also to peer into the very minds of the men leading the expedition as they navigate an untold journey for westerners of the era. It follows and far eclipses Lord Macartney’s disastrous mission, and gets in the good favours of the illustrious emperor Qianlong. The descriptions of so many temples, peoples and landscapes can get a little tiring, but they all faithfully paint an intriguing picture of the Middle Kingdom.
It was very enjoyable to read about the Dutch envoy to the Qing court in 1795. The book is well written and interesting both for sinologists as well as readers with little prior knowledge about 18th century China or Batavia.
This book is a reevaluation of the Dutch envoy which went down in history as a failure. Often history is told by the last men standing, in this case the British, who had sent a failed mission two years prior led by Lord Macartney and wanted to make the kowtowing Dutch one seem even worse. Tonio Andrade based his research on the diaries of the participants, and other documents in Dutch and Chinese that were missed by earlier scholars. He convincingly demonstrates that it is unjust to paint the Dutch mission as a failure, just because it didn’t lead to economic gain. This was mainly due to the collapse of the East Indies Company and the Netherlands being overrun by Napoleon’s armies that happened during the mission, which meant there was no commercial follow up possible. On their return to Europe the participants reports were not widely published and translated either, or misreported leading to further misunderstandings about the success of the trip.
Drawing from the personal observations of four members of the trip, in letters home as well as in diaries, Andrade could include many authentic details of what life was like in China. He provides day to day descriptions of the arduous 1500-mile trip over land from Canton to Beijing in the middle of winter, which is rushed so that the envoy arrives in time for the celebration of the 60th year reign anniversary of Qing dynasty emperor Qianlong. There are many details about the lodging, food, entertainment, scheming in the Dutch group as well as on the part of the Mandarins that accompany them on their trip up and down the country, that help pace the book. On their way back the envoy takes the more leisurely Grand Canal Route and stops off at many sights that are tourist attractions to this day.
What was considered most scandalous by contemporaries was the Dutch willingness to kowtow for the emperor. Andrade argues that the Dutch, with their diplomatic experience in Japan where they held a unique post at Deshima, understood that in Asia the role of diplomacy is not just about bargaining, gaining concessions, and signing treaties. Chinese diplomacy was “aimed at the maintenance of a regime of communications and interaction which both sides viewed as legitimate”. Arcade concludes that: “The Dutch visitors were greeted so warmly in the forbidden city and the imperial pleasure gardens, not just because their kowtows reinforced imperial order but also because it was fun to include these exotic outsiders in the holiday festivities”.
"This book is designed to provide both an immersive narrative and a historical argument", reads the note on the first page. Mission accomplished on both counts. The book takes you along on the Dutch East India Company's last embassy to the Chinese court, as the company itself was going bankrupt and the Dutch Republic back in Europe was on the verge of being invaded by the French. The unprecedentedly rich sources, and the wonderful writing (the whole book is in the present tense, unusual for a work of history but works like a charm), really bring alive not only its protagonists, but also the setting of late 18th-century China. It reads like a novel, but then also makes an extremely valid and insightful point about western perceptions of the Chinese Empire leading up to the Opium Wars. Andrade's earlier book about the fall of Dutch Formosa, Lost Colony: The Untold Story of China's First Great Victory over the West, was already an impressive combination of scholarship and great reading. In this new book, he has outdone himself.
“The Dutch mission of 1795 also offers new perspectives on eighteenth-century China and Sino-Western relations, helping us step decisively beyond the culture-clash narrative that still pervades our understanding of both China and the West. That’s because in contrast to other embassies from this period, the Dutch embassy was successful. The Qianlong emperor was delighted with it, granting favours and access never extended to other European envoys.”
“So why has the mission been maligned? The main reason is that it doesn’t fit the culture-clash narrative.”
“One reason that his words didn’t achieve the readership or influence of British accounts is that the Dutch Republic itself ceased to exist. Even as Van Braam was drinking tea with the emperor at a party, French troops were marching on Amsterdam. The successor to the United Provinces of the Netherlands, the Batavian Republic, was a French puppet state…. It wasn’t long before the Dutch East India Company itself was abolished.”
Andrade strikes again! I’ve got to hand it to the man, his ability to take what seem like almost chuckle-inducingly niche subjects - this time the Dutch embassy to Qing Dynasty China of 1795 - and make them both highly readable AND appear highly relevant to our understanding of something bigger is commendable. With The Last Embassy it feels like Andrade is at the peak of his powers. Just take for instance this “note to the reader”:
“This book is designed to provide both an immersive narrative and a historical argument. If you’re in the mood for a story, skip to Chapter 1. If you feel like a thesis statement and some historiography, read the Prologue first. If you’re not sure, start with Chapter 1 and return to the Prologue later, if you wish.”
Whether or not you’re interested in this period of history, Andrade does an amazing job using primary sources to reconstruct an interesting “immersive” narrative that reads like historical fiction. It really makes the people come alive and helps make their actions explicable. If you’re interested in Chinese history, it also offers an extremely unique, up-close take of what it was like to be there at that time (Andrade studied under Jonathan Spence - if that means anything to you).
To zoom out, Andrade’s main point that Western engagement with China (at least circa the close of the eighteenth century) has been mischaracterized and misunderstood based on a small number of sources which have had an outsized influence on Western understanding of this period all the way down to the present day is well-taken. Many people are very familiar with the McCartney mission (where the Brit famously refused to kow-tow and was quickly sent away), but many - including myself - were unaware of the Dutch embassy led by Isaac Titsingh shortly afterwards which actually went quite well. It really does ignite the imagination to consider how Western engagement - and perceptions - of China might have unfolded had the Dutch Republic not fallen. It’s definitely possible to overstate the case, but I think at a minimum we’d have had a more nuanced view.
The picture of the Qing Dynasty that emerges here, in the journals of these Dutch (and French) men, is complicated. On the one hand, it’s obviously poor, sad, and corrupt. (It’s nice that Andrade occasionally interjects to explain some of their misapprehensions though) On the other, the system clearly works well to some extant, and it’s clear the emperor’s power is real and extends to the edges of his empire. It’s particularly interesting to see how charmed the octogenarian Qianlong emperor was with these exotic foreigners. He comes across as charmingly human. Lots of gazing at them with interest, smiling as the Dutch did their thing, and laughing and delighting as they messed up their kow tows or tried to speak Chinese. Clearly the man enjoyed their presence and invited them to all sorts of things which it was borderline unprecedented for foreigners to be invited to. It’s a very human and interesting portrayal of one of the most significant emperors in Chinese history.
So the book is great. It’s just a wee bit long and journal-esque at times. At some point: I get it. It was another long hard day of travel. Or it was another nice reception for them. The portions covering the long journeys there and back got a bit dull and repetitive for me, that’s why I took off a star and probably wouldn’t recommend this to anyone who isn’t very interested in either Qing China, Dutch diplomacy in Asia, or Sino-Western engagements.
Professor Andrade knows how to write a quality scholarly-trade crossover and this by far is his best work yet. Lost Colony was a masterpiece, but Last Embassy is a touching story with a memorable cast of characters such as Andreas Everardus van Braam Houckgeest, Isaac Titsingh, and the Qianlong Emperor. Last Embassy is an exciting journey from start to finish!
Andrade is a master of his craft, as he paints a picture of pre Opium Wars China that is unheard of in recent literature. The book conveniently came out at a time when US-China tensions are again at levels comparable to the 1990s; with the same mistakes of Macartney being repeated once again. The US shows unwillingness to conform with Chinese demands, shows zealous pride in Western superior values and alienates the Chinese by considering them as irrational and hostile. The book brilliantly shows how a meagre Dutch mission, contrary to popular belief, was able to conduct a successful diplomatic embassy, and leave a positive impression at the Chinese court. The Last Embassy is a practical class in personal diplomacy, with its vibrant storytelling of encounters between the Dutch mission and the Chinese officials; highlighting the important role of establishing personal relationship in conduct of grand diplomacy.
Given China’s rising power, I thought this book offers a unique perspective of Chinese history from a pov that’s not the usual war/politics/economics analysis.
I enjoyed how the book was supplemented with images and was also well researched, sharing an unbiased view from different accounts.
Unfortunately, the embassy’s journey wasn’t really that interesting to me. Most of the book is a description of the journey. As a reader I kept waiting for some sort peak or climax to the journey, but it was factually reported in a rather flat way.
The conclusion was an opportunity to bring some meaning to the book, where the significance of the journey could be analysed and we could learn what happened to the characters after. However, I found the writing style a little too lengthy for my preference, and honestly wasn’t much analysis beyond the different ideas of whether it was a successful and what’s the definition of a successful embassy and where western views different from eastern’s on relationship and purpose of embassies. I thought this idea was already rather known and wished for further comparison with the world today.
I also wished there were more accounts from the Chinese’s pov. But understandably, that might all have been lost to history.
I think the book would have more significance if we still lived in a world where the west are still rather ignorant of China’s culture and history. Then as a reader, I might have felt more surprised and appreciated the lesson on China’s cultural wealth.
Nonetheless, given another chance, I would read this book still. It’s a good supplement to my current interest in China.
An interesting and focused book. This is a very entertaining narrative that really helped my understanding of both the VOC and High Qing culture. Despite being written by an academic historian, this would serve as an excellent pop history book. A combination of both excellent writing and careful archival research.
One caveat: I found the conclusion of the book shockingly unconvincing. The author adds a short argument that Qing diplomacy was effective and that the "tribute system" was a stable diplomatic order (Among other things, he states that system was peaceful, which is not how I would characterize the era of the Ten Great Campaigns.). He suggests that ignoring the Titsingh/Van Braam mission was one of the reasons why past scholars were dismissive of Qing diplomacy. The author never engages with the obvious question about High Qing diplomacy: if it was so effective, why didn't it work? Why couldn't the Qing maintain peaceful relations into the 19th century if they had created such an effective and flexible system? This argument clearly needs more space to be fully argued. The book would be better if he had left this argument out or fully developed it
Such a unique and genuinely immersive take on historical non-fiction. I loved that Andrade manages to make a very academic topic feel almost novelistic while still building a compelling historical argument.
Reading in present tense through Andrade’s analysis of journals/letters from the embassy members made late 18th-century Qing China feel incredibly alive and immediate. Andrade actually addresses this directly, explaining that writing in present tense creates both “immediacy and intimacy” while also making the historian’s act of imagining more visible to the reader. You really feel that throughout the book—it genuinely feels like you’re in the pockets of Titsingh and van Braam as they travel hundreds of miles through unfamiliar countryside in the dead of winter and navigate the exhausting complexity of Emperor Qianlong’s court.
The details about the Dutch embassy’s journey, Qing court customs, diplomacy, food, travel, and even the interpersonal drama within the delegation were fascinating. Also, my guys Titsingh & van Braam are funny af 😭
One of the most interesting parts was Andrade’s argument about Western misunderstandings of Qing diplomacy and how differently both sides viewed legitimacy, negotiation, and power. It adds a ton of nuance to a period that usually gets flattened into “East vs West” narratives leading into the Opium Wars.
I’m fairly certain my mother-in-law gave me this book, and honestly? Great recommendation! I’d absolutely recommend this to anyone interested in Qing court history, diplomacy, or narrative-driven history writing.
I was enraptured with the introduction and so excited to read it. I think the change for the rest of the book into the present tense and the “on the ground” approach to the whole journey of the embassy was a bit awkward at first or it was just for me as I expect a “birds eye view” of the history books I read. I think it would have been better in longer reading chunks but because I was reading it before I went to bed and not too long it was a slog constantly jumping in and out of following along with these characters. While I appreciate all the research and quotes from letters and observations in the text, I feel like it could have worked better as a historical novel. I was ready to give it a lower star but then the conclusion was fantastic and brought everything together putting the trip into context which is what I really enjoyed.
I really like this book. It’s a fresh perspective on a time in history that had previously been countlessly recounted in a singular fashion. Furthermore, it is well supported using a plethora of evidence that was meticulously collected.
My only issue is that the author does seem quite a Sinophile. I appreciate that history written by a single person will always have bias and it does help the book in parts. However, I feel he often wants to dismiss other perspectives of the time rather than letting both co-exist.
This book is about the Dutch mission to Qing China in 1795, which is relatively less well-known when compared to the famous failure of the Macartney Embassy. The author has successfully presented and reconstructed the mission's aim, history, and significance. But in general, a large proportion of the book is devoted to description of the trip, e.g. what they saw, what they ate, how they were treated by the local officials, which seems a bit monotonous to read. To me, this book is less intriguing than Lost Colony, another book by the author.
play along, and you'll begin to understand. Yes, it's a far cry from Europe, but one of the beauties of life is how differently its lived, her and there.
A detailed account of the Dutch Embassy to the Qing Court in 1795, a ceremonial embassy to celebrate Emperor Qianlong's sixtieth year rule on the throne. The last European delegation to be received in the traditional Chinese imperial court. The next one wont happen until after the Opium War.
I wish more academic research was presented in such an engaging narrative. I liked the amount of detail and it even made me laugh when one of the traveler's porters ran away and locals subsequently stole his hat. It was interesting to read about the way the narrative was changed in the following decades to make the mission seem like an embarrassing failure.
Een heel goed boek over een handelsreis in het China van eind achttiende eeuw en de ervaringen van de reizigers. Het feit dat er constant gebruik wordt gemaakt van de tegenwoordige tijd is soms wat verwarrend.
Fascinating recounting of the little-known Dutch embassy to the Qing court doing old fashioned diplomacy and perhaps providing a glimpse of another path that European-Chinese relations may have travelled over the ensuing centuries
Difficult to rate. A really interesting story on itself but really too long on the description of how the members of the embassy (dis)liked the various lodgings, means of transport and meals.
A modern sinologist reduced himself no more than a bunch of western travellers two-hundred years ago in illustrating an ancient China. Too many gossips, less insights.
Honestly, I can’t think of a reason not to give this book 5 stars. Andrade masterfully transforms a journey through 18th-century China into an engaging and enjoyable read. The book goes beyond merely recounting the journey; it offers diverse perspectives, rich historical context, and vivid descriptions that bring the scenery to life.
What was it like to be among the only westerners to visit the Qianlong emperor in his private palace? Traveling through the Chinese countryside, viewing sites never seen before by non-Chinese, this is the account of a forgotten "embassy" (diplomatic mission) by some Dutch diplomats.
Written in an easy-to-read style, this is as close to a page-turner as you can get for an academic book. The author has gone to exhaustive lengths to map out each portion of a unique voyage to Beijing by a Dutch mission in 1795. Ultimately the audience is China scholars, so although I enjoyed it for its meticulous details, it will remain to somebody else to write a shorter account for non-Chinese experts.