Thoughts on the Overall Book: Overall is was a good read. Not the best thing I've ever read and I had a couple problems with it, but I did enjoy it and it's a good adventure novel with an interesting fantasy twist to it.
Cover--Yea or Nay: I don't really dislike it, but it's not amazing either. I don't think the boy really looks like Tormod, but it's not terrible either. Kind of indifferent.
Characters: Tormod was an okay protagonist. He's wasn't overly cocky, yet he didn't doubt himself more than is expected either and he was genuinely caring. Templar Alexander was a good character too, though not the most epic mentor character I have ever read about. I have always been very fond of mentor character, particularly the sardonic, prickly ones like Halt from Ranger's Apprentice. Alexander wasn't as awesome as Halt, but he was okay. One thing that kind of bothered me about the book was that, while I did like the characters and cared about what happened to them, I didn't fall unconditionally in love with them either as I do in some books. You got their personalities, yet they still kind of more seemed like acquaintances than best friends.
The Romance: There was no romance in this story, yay!
Writing Style: This was the other thing that kind of didn't sell the book to me completely. There was nothing wrong with it, but it wasn't really engaging during action scenes, and in parts it kind of seemed disjointed. I really didn't see where the story was going by the time I finished the book. There was a lot of foreshadowing, but then, nothing really happened. I do understand that this is a series, but I still kind of feel that nothing was really accomplished in this story, at least nothing I expected to be accomplished when I started it. Another thing that bothered me on a technical level was that this is a story that is set, at least in the beginning, in Scotland in the year 1307. I find it very strange that Bruce's rebellion is not even mentioned once. And I really don't know what Philippe of France was doing at this time since I don't really know anything about him after he turned William Wallace away when he came to ask for help, but I don't know if he was doing...whatever he was doing in this story, which I'm not quite clear on either, except he's the bad guy? I did like how Tormod kind of has the Second Sight and other characters have similar powers and stuff. It kind of adds a fantasy flair to a historical based novel. That was a unique part anyway.
Problems/What bothered me: There wasn't really anything else besides the things I have already addressed.
Conclusion: 3 stars. I enjoyed reading it and I will probably read the rest of the series eventually. Not the best book in the world but not the worst either and a quick read.
Recommended Audience: Readers who like historical fantasy and fans of Ranger's Apprentice would probably enjoy this one. It's not as good as Ranger's Apprentice, but if you've finished the series or are waiting for the nest book, this might tide you over. Guy or girl read 13 and up.