Solving two separate major mysteries on the national stage wasn't enough for Stevie Thomas and Susan Carol Anderson, so the fourteen-year-olds are back for more in book three of the Sports Beat series, Cover-Up: Mystery at the Super Bowl. The news stories they broke at the NCAA basketball tournament and the U.S. Open tennis championships led to an offer to host Kid-Sports for the USTV television network, but problems are on the horizon as Cover-Up begins. The show's executives notify Stevie that he's no longer part of USTV's plans going forward: teen pop singer Jamie Whitsitt will be Susan Carol's new cohost, despite his lack of sports knowledge. Being fired is a shock to Stevie, who loved spending time and discussing sports with Susan Carol via livestream even though they live in different states. Now she and Jamie are headed for Indianapolis, Indiana to cover Super Bowl XLII for USTV while Stevie sits home by himself. At least, that seems to be his fate until Bobby Kelleher, a Washington Herald journalist, gives him a call. Kelleher and his wife, Tamara Mearns, provided the adult support necessary for Stevie and Susan Carol's investigations at the NCAA tourney and the U.S. Open, and he wants Stevie to accompany him to Indianapolis as a guest Super Bowl reporter for the Washington Herald. Still smarting from USTV's rejection, Stevie isn't sure how he'll cope with watching Susan Carol and "gorgeous" Jamie Whitsitt interview football stars together, but he'd rather be in Indianapolis than stay home. Who knows what could happen during Super Bowl week?
Susan Carol's kneejerk reaction is to quit Kid-Sports the moment they release Stevie, but he reluctantly talks her into staying. The Anderson family can use the money, and Stevie doesn't want her to scuttle her potential career in sports. Indianapolis in January is cold and gray, but the scene at the state-of-the-art football stadium is electric, swarming with famous athletes, media personalities, and A-list celebrities. Stevie is uncomfortable with how well Susan Carol and Jamie work on camera, and USTV producer Tal Vincent is less than gracious in his treatment of Stevie now that he's no longer with the company, but Stevie has more than his job with the Washington Herald to occupy his time. CBS, television broadcaster of Super Bowl XLII, wants to hire him to do freelance coverage leading up to the game. A lot of important people are counting on him, but he's lived up to the challenge before.
Stevie's first couple of days in Indianapolis are tense. Susan Carol resents his attitude toward Jamie, who she insists is a nice guy and not as vacuous as he seems. She even defends Tal Vincent, which really gets Stevie mad. Their relationship is in serious trouble, but Bobby Kelleher helps take Stevie's mind off his problems by floating him some top-notch story ideas for the Super Bowl. How about the fact that Darin Kerns, equipment manager for the California Dreams, was the number one wide receiver for Baltimore Ravens quarterback Eddie Brennan in high school? No one else in the media seems aware of this connection between the two teams that will play Sunday. Or how about an exclusive interview with Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti? Working for the Washington Herald and CBS keeps Stevie too busy to dwell on his hard feelings toward Susan Carol, until late one night he gets a phone call from her in his hotel room. Susan Carol has stumbled onto a story so big it could blow the doors off Super Bowl XLII. At one of the countless media parties this week, Dr. Snow, a physician for the California Dreams, let it slip to Susan Carol that all five starting offensive linemen on his team tested positive for human growth hormone (HGH) and would have been suspended for the Super Bowl had team owner Donny Meeker not covered up the results. An uncomfortable question looms: how deep does the corruption go?
It doesn't take long for Stevie and Susan Carol's wounded relationship to start healing. They know how it feels to be in the journalism foxhole with no one to depend on but each other, and until they gather concrete evidence of Meeker's duplicity, they can't even tell Bobby Kelleher. Stevie's all-access pass with CBS and Susan Carol's reputation as a star on Kid-Sports open a lot of door in Indianapolis, even scoring them an extended interview with California Dreams quarterback Eddie Brennan. Stevie takes a risk and bluffs Brennan with what Susan Carol found out about the HGH coverup, and without further prompting the QB admits he had an inkling that something fishy was going on. Brennan is torn between team loyalty and the demands of fair play, so it's up to Stevie and Susan Carol to trace the scandal back to Meeker, a hothead billionaire who cares a great deal about his public image. If he finds out that journalists are on his trail, would he harm them? As the full scale of the scandal comes to light, Stevie and Susan Carol must find incontrovertible proof so Meeker and his cronies can't wriggle off the hook. Will the young reporters go three for three in solving high-stakes cases at prestigious sporting events, or have the odds caught up to a pair of teens in over their heads?
Cover-Up: Mystery at the Super Bowl is arguably the best book in the Sports Beat series so far. The tension rises early on as Stevie and Susan Carol sort through their feelings about USTV firing him; tempers flare and unkind remarks are made, but they are too resilient a duo to be ripped apart so easily. You can count on them to get their heads straight and act prudently when the chips are down. Speaking of chips, I enjoyed the many cameos in this book, including one by Chip Graber, college basketball star from Last Shot: A Final Four Mystery. Other notable appearances from figures in the 2007 sporting world include Tony Kornheiser and Michael Wilbon (of ESPN's Pardon the Interruption), NFL commissioner Roger Goodell, CBS executive Sean McManus, NFL Hall of Famer and broadcaster Joe Theismann, and NBA legend Michael Jordan. Celebrity appearances include Billy Joel and Tom Cruise. I'm not surprised that John Feinstein created fictional teams and characters to fill controversial roles (the California Dreams, for example, and owner Donny Meeker), but I was taken aback by the potshots Feinstein took at real people, including Washington Redskins owner Daniel Snyder and (to a lesser extent) Tom Cruise and QB Jeff George. I mustn't end this review without acknowledging that in the real 2007-08 NFL season, the Baltimore Ravens and quarterback Steve McNair finished 5-11, nowhere near a Super Bowl. Super Bowl XLII was the classic between Tom Brady's New England Patriots and Eli Manning's New York Giants, in which the ragtag Giants spoiled the Patriots' bid for a 19-0 season by pulling out a stunning 14-10 win following David Tyree's miraculous helmet catch. I should also point out the game was played in Glendale, Arizona, not Indianapolis. But, I digress. I rate Cover-Up: Mystery at the Super Bowl two and a half stars and strongly considered rounding to three; the story is very much a time capsule of its era, but that isn't such a bad thing. I love Stevie and Susan Carol's chemistry, and I'm glad there are three more novels in the series. I'll be sad when the adventure ends.