Whoa, wait a sec! This was actually... not bad?!
So yeah, I absolutely hated Tomasi's first volume of Superman. It was abysmal. Of course I was never intending to pick up the second one, but somebody convinced me that this one was still worth giving a read. I'm glad I did!
This book consists of seven issues which make up four short stories. The first one, issue #7, is brilliant, and could easily be the best Superman single issue in years. Yeah, it's one of those! A standalone, done-in-one little slice of life story is about Superfamily going to a fair and having a good time, and Supes still manages to save the day. It's a great issue, and I would recommend checking this volume out to any Superman fan, if only for this issue alone (or, you know, just get the single).
The next two-part mini-arc is set in The New Frontier universe, of all places! I happen to be a huge fan of Darwyn Cooke's classic storyline, and I was happy to go back to the Dinosaur Island with Superman (and son) for a fun, pulpy adventure.
Unfortunately, the book stalls out a bit after this arc. The next two-parter is focused on Jon 'Superson' Kent and Damian Wayne learning to be friends and superhero partners. While it had its moments, the story felt a bit overlong and sometimes poorly paced. I get it, Super-Sons is a big hit right now, and I will get to that comic eventually, but when I'm reading a Superman comic, I want more Superman. His involvement in this story was kept to a minimum, instead focusing much more on Jon, who I still don't quite like and can't yet forgive for killing that cat in volume 1 (Damian actually taunts him about that, reminding us that this shit occurred in a kid-friendly comic and was written as a sweet bonding opportunity for their Superfamily).
After that, the final two-issue arc is a sort of fight and then team-up between Superman, Lois and DC's Frankenstein. I believe this is the very first time I came across this character, and I can't say that I'm a huge fan. A pretty generic story that unfortunately did very little for me, although it was readable, and I liked Tomasi's characterisation of Lois here.
Overall, it was still a surprisingly solid collection for a writer I was all but ready to deem a hack. I'm not sure if I'll continue reading his Superman, because the same person who convinced me to read this volume says that the series goes right back to shit in the following ones (Tomasi attempting to expand on Morrison's Multiversity? Hell no, there's no way he could pull that off and not ruin anything), but now I'm willing to at least give his Super-Sons a try, even despite my prejudice towards Jon. Who knows, maybe one day I'll grow to like the kid?