Wow, this is one of, if not the, most insulting ending to a series I've ever read. I am so glad I got this out of the library because if I had spent money on it, I would have set it on fire. I hate this, I hate this ending so much, I am so glad I don't own it anymore.
UNA VERGÜENZA. ¿Como osa el/la mangaka en traernos este final tan malo? ¡NO TUVO LOS COJONES PARA ELEGIR UN FINAL A LA HISTORIA Y NOS DA DOS CANON IGUALES!
This review is specifically for Misaki's ending. (Since there are 2 route endings.)
I don't like this at all. There were some parts that were cute, like with the eraser and him proposing and lifting her up. But it also feels rushed? They both fell in love from a far but what do they really have as a relationship? They lose their friendship with Lili (Im using that name because it's the one I read), we don't see a future for them beyond literally graduating. Will Yukari die soon? We don't get a wedding or an idea about kids.
We don't see anyone else like Nisaka or Lili or Shuu or literally anyone else and their happiness. There isn't even a hint to them. It's as if this ending is Yukari and Misaki being together but isolating themselves from everyone else.
Now, I've never been the biggest fan of this pairing. I feel like they are the typical "first love" couple. They "love" each other from a far and for a long time but that love doesn't really translate to an actual relationship. Misaki is protecting him and sacrificing her own happiness for him but that's it? Every interaction we see with them, she is lying to protect him and he is clueless and can't do anything to help her. Knowing the burden she carries, does he love her more out of guilt and obligation or because he actually loves her?
It's not like it's a terrible ending, but it doesn't feel like the definitive one. I hate that Lili just leaves and hates Yukari now. And I hate that too many things are left unanswered.
The art is pretty as always though.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This is a terrible ending. I think it’s a cop out that the author even wrote both in the first place but this version is awful. Misaki is a selfish, attention seeking, immature twat. To risk her entire future and happiness to save someone that she barely knew is not noble, it’s idiotic. Then to try and kill herself over it (which would obviously invalidate her deal and cause Neji to lose treatment) because what? As a stunt to make him realize her ‘love’? Ugh just no. It’s ridiculous to think he would leave Lillina for someone, let’s face it, HE BARELY knows. Most of Misaki and Neji’s ‘relationship’ was secretly watching each other and not talking. Lillina he has actually went out with, talked to, gotten to know, built up a love with, as someone he could trust.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.