Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Witch of November: A Great Lakes Story

Rate this book
A young football player fights for survival after being paralyzed in a high school game in Cleveland. His father, a miner in Minnesota, desperately tries to get back to his son. After the father's truck breaks down, he is befriended by a young sailor who offers to stow him away on the iron boat on which he works, also headed for Cleveland. But the weather on Lake Superior in November is fraught with danger. Can the young sailor get his new friend to his son before it is too late, or will the Witch of November exact the ultimate price?

177 pages, Kindle Edition

Published November 18, 2021

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Rick Collins

15 books2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
39 (51%)
4 stars
18 (23%)
3 stars
13 (17%)
2 stars
4 (5%)
1 star
2 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
Profile Image for Martin Hill.
Author 33 books88 followers
February 20, 2022
In 1975, I was a young U.S. Coast Guard petty officer temporarily assigned as a SAR coxswain to a lifeboat station on an island in Lake Michigan just off Wisconsin’s Door County peninsula. During my time on the island, I gained a profound respect for the tumultuous weather over the Great Lakes. The term “lakes” is a misnomer. The Great Lakes are vast freshwater inland seas, complete with their own tides and weather patterns.

Ore boats—large ships, really, that carry iron ore—were a common sight on the lakes. I had been gone from the island only a few weeks when I heard the news that one of the largest ore boats, the Edmund Fitzgerald, had disappeared in Lake Superior during one of its notorious November gales—the so-called Witch of November—along with all twenty-nine crewmembers. It would be some time before the wreck of the Fitz would be found, having struck bottom during the storm, and breaking her back.

Rick Collins, author of The Witch of November: A Great Lakes Novel, has written a gripping fictional account of the sinking of the Fitz, and the horrors endured by her crew in their final hours. Joe Willis is an ore miner desperately trying to get to his home in Cleveland from a mining job in Minnesota to be near his young son who was injured in a football accident. When his truck breaks down en route, a merchant sailor offers to smuggle Willis aboard the Fitzgerald, which is heading for Cleveland with a load of iron ore. Neither man knows the November Witch is waiting for them.

I’ve spent some time on the pitching and reeling decks of ships and small boats in foul weather, and Collins’ account of the Fitz’s crew struggling to survive the storm rings true like a ship’s bell. His description of crew members swept off their feet and clawing for their lives for handrails and safety lines as the ship rolls in the seas was real enough to cause a flashback to my own experience hanging by one hand over the North Atlantic during a heavy sea.

No one will ever know what happened in the last hours of the Fitzgerald’s life. As Gordon Lightfoot wrote in his ballad about the tragedy, “Does anyone know where the love of God goes/When the waves turn the minutes to hours?” But Rick Collins does a brilliant job of imagining and describing those horrendous minutes turned to hours.
Profile Image for J.R. Alcyone.
Author 2 books65 followers
January 19, 2022
A superb reimagining of the story of the Mighty Fitz

“Superior they say never gives up her dead when the skies of November turn gloomy.”

It might have been a footnote to the rest of the country, but for those of us who have lived our lives on the Great Lakes, the Edmund Fitzgerald is akin to the Titanic. The “Witch of November” takes some liberties with the story of the Mighty Fitz, following perhaps more closely Gordon Lightfoot’s famous song (for example, Collins’ Fitz is headed for Cleveland whereas the Fitz was actually headed to Detroit) but this is historical fiction, and like Lightfoot’s song, Collins perfectly captures the spirit of the brave men not only who crewed the Fitz, but also the men (like my grandfather) who worked in the steel mills or mining iron ore.

The premise of the novel is fairly simple. Told in alternating points of view, “The Witch of November” tells the story of Joe, a blue-collar iron ore worker on the Minnesota iron range who desperately needs to get home to Cleveland. The reason Joe needs to get home so badly is his son, Charlie, was paralyzed in a football game. Joe’s ancient truck breaks down somewhere outside of Duluth, and he stows away on the Fitz with the help of Bruce Hudson and the ship’s cook, Robert Rafferty. Although this is Joe’s story, we also get the perspectives of his wife, Betsy, waiting with their injured son in Cleveland, as well as some other individuals.

(Hudson and Rafferty are real. Hudson was a deckhand who grew up in a westside suburb of Cleveland, just like I did.)

To say more would likely spoil the story. Suffice it to say, this is part adventure novel, part historical fiction at its finest. And the fate of the Fitz and her crew are always handled with respect.

In terms of the writing, at 130-pages, this is perhaps best styled as a novella, and the story is quick to develop, with almost short-story style pacing. The prose is workmanlike, lean and muscular, and is a perfect fit for the story. The story is somewhat predictable if you know the history (I mean, history is what it is), but the insertion of the fictional character and his family will keep you guessing as to what happens even if you know the Fitz's story by heart.

All and all, this is a fine piece of historical fiction. Even if you’ve never heard of the Fitz, this book is worth reading, sticking close to the historical record, yet diverging to create an excellent adventure story with taut stakes. Highly recommended.
3 reviews
December 9, 2021
Strong Praise for the Witch of November

I am from Superior. I used to sell newspapers on the boats which were about three blocks from where I lived. I wrote a song titled The Witch of November the day after the Fitzgerald tragedy. The Witch was a featured article about the disaster. It was a new expression for me. I dedicated my song to an uncle and cousin that drowned in other separate Great Lakes situations.
This book totally captivated me.
I would encourage anyone interested in this tragedy to read it. As a former teacher and principal I give it an A+.
Bob Randa
Profile Image for Annalisa.
553 reviews5 followers
November 15, 2024
This was an incredible story! It was a quick gripping read but also a bit hard to read because it was so emotionally strong and filled me with anxiety worrying for all the characters. I have a definite respect for how risky some of the jobs were in this story. It is equal parts terrifying and hope inspiring which is interesting. I read this for a book club and can't wait to discuss!
Profile Image for Katie.
197 reviews3 followers
November 3, 2026
Suspenseful and well done. Everyone who loves the Great Lakes should read at least one story about the Edmund Fitzgerald.
Profile Image for Megan Beech.
256 reviews8 followers
November 22, 2025
"We are holding our own...": Captain McSorely of the Edmund Fitzgerald

The last words of a courageous seasoned captain of the ship, deemed by many nicknames throughout the Great Lakes but the one I'll refer to as "The Titanic of the Great Lakes". With a nickname such as this, this was an omen for the unexpected event to occur on November 10th 1975 when the freighter Edmund Fitzgerald or the "Mighty Fitz" took her last voyage and never made it home.

Although this story is a work of fiction, it is written beautifully in a way that pays tribute to the men onboard instead of pulling bits of history and throwing together a story that is loosely based on the tragedy. I'm an immersive reader at best and quietly played "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" by Gordon Lightfoot in the background and it instantly brought me to tears.

Although the Great Lakes are notorious for having treacherous weather patterns (as someone who grew up on Lake Erie myself, I can definitely speak for experience the way Northwestern Ohio gets slammed with bad weather onshore), they have claimed many ships throughout the years that many people just don't know about unless you're from the region. *Fun fact: I'm from Toledo where the Edmund Fitzgerald would make her last run of the evening before heading back home to port and is very familiar with the "Toledo Express"; another nickname for the Edmund Fitzgerald whenever she would dock in Toledo's harbors.

Gordon Lightfoot brought the story of the Edmund Fitzgerald to life in his ballad and cemented the memory of Captain McSorely and the other 28 men who perished on Lake Superior that fateful night.

I found this book to be an incredible read and I would love to have a physical copy of this book to add to my library to remind myself and my children about how precious life truly is and to never take anything for granted because you never know if you'll ever make it home to your family again.
Profile Image for Ronald.
Author 1 book5 followers
October 5, 2023
Familiar with The Witch, The Song, and The Story

Became interested in the fate of the Edmund Fitzgerald through Gordon Lightfoot’s song about the disaster on Lake Superior in 1975.

As a high school senior at the time, I have only a fleeting memory of hearing about the ship’s and crew’s horrible fate. Only as I grew older and started losing friends and loved ones was I ready to learn about The Witch of November.

No one could have survived the conditions and circumstances that destroyed the ship that night—when the waves turned the minutes to hours. And that’s what makes Collins’ story intriguing.

We want someone to tell us about the Fitzgerald and her crew. We need some details only they can provide. We still crave answers some 45 years later.

Where did the Love of God go as Superior tore through steel like tissue?

Collins provides some answers in his fictional account of the disaster’s “lone survivor.”

An unlikely story?

Impossibly so.

Don’t care.

Thanks, Rick, for your sensitivity in handling a delicate matter that has impacted so many.

#29times
Profile Image for Lisa .
955 reviews59 followers
October 2, 2022
Judge This Book by Its Cover

This book has such an amazing cover but the story inside is even better. I'm old enough to vividly remember the loss of the Edmund Fitzgerald in November, 1975. The author includes the unique weather intricacies that created the monster storm over the Great Lakes and you can feel it building while you read. There are two heart-pounding plots intertwined in this quick read with characters that have such depth that you experience their emotions as they do. You don't want to miss this one. It's a wild ride!
3 reviews
May 31, 2022
You know the song... Now know The Fitz.

Having lived in Michigan, I was always familiar with the Great Lakes surrounding that fair state. However, I never knew how vicious the lakes could be, thinking that only the Oceans and Seas could be so mean.

This book will be difficult to put down once you start reading it...
Profile Image for Sam.
159 reviews5 followers
January 22, 2022
“Does anyone know where the love of God goes when the waves turn the minutes to hours?”

Well, this short novel seems to answer that question about the story of the Edmund Fitzgerald.

Poignant. Powerful. Encouraging.
2 reviews
December 4, 2024
Seaworthy Book!

Great cold winter reading! A very enjoyable reading! You can feel the overwhelming cold and dismay as the crew tries to fight off the inevitable!
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews