I am a huge fan of Brittany Fichter. HUGE! She’s probably my favorite author. I’ve read almost all of her books and I almost always give them five stars (and would give them more if it were possible). For this one, though, I have to give it only four. That’s low for a Brittany Fichter book, but high in general. The reason for the “low” rating is mostly due to the genre, which (or course) I knew going into the book. My favorite genres are historical fiction, realistic fiction, and fairytale retellings. Obviously, the fairy tales are how I found Brittany Fichter’s book, and I adore them all. Even more, I am totally obsessed with her Air Force Fairy Tales, which are realistic fiction mixed with a tiny bit of fairy tale awesomeness. Those books are to die for!!!! But I digress. Since Brittany Fichter is one of my top three favorite authors, I will 100% read everything she puts out, even if it’s not my typical genre. I read the Autumn Fairy Trilogy, which was, again, outside of my normal reading box, but still delightfully written nonetheless. The same goes for The Seer’s Secret. Since it is so far outside of my normal genre, I felt like I was being hit over and over again with totally foreign ideas, what with all of the weird creatures, customs, and beliefs of this new world Brittany Fichter has created. I am more than fine with a little magic (like in her Classical Kingdoms series), but this was almost mind-bending for me. Nearly every aspect of the culture the characters were living in was completely foreign. The book felt almost dystopian at times, what with the lying-society-run-by-cruel-dictators thing. Also, at one point, there was a mention of “unicorn serum,” and I took a quick timeout from the book to ask myself what on earth I was reading!!! My novels are usually filled with historical facts and figures or modern everyday life. And now I’m reading about dragons with magical wish-giving scales, warriors who are happy to have their tongues removed, a whole society who is heavily drugged daily, and (last but not least) healing unicorn serum! It’s totally out of left field for me! However, as previously stated, I love Brittany Fichter’s writing, and she could literally lead me anywhere. I would probably read a textbook about the dissection of cadavers if it was written by Brittany Fichter.
With that lengthy disclaimer out of the way, I truly did enjoy the book. Eirin, Drystan, and many of the other characters are very relatable. I admired many qualities in each of them, and I was happy with the book’s pacing as well. Obviously, it’s a very long story (over 500 pages in my copy), so there’s a lot of events taking place, but it never dragged, nor did I feel like things were happening too quickly. If my “math” is correct, the plot took place over a two-month period, making the near-constant stream of revelations feel a little more realistic (but not much, since it is fantasy).
Some negative reviews I have read have despaired about the fact that key characters of the story with helpful knowledge kept being conveniently silenced for the sake of the plot. I noticed that, but I didn’t find that off-putting at all. Like the main characters themselves, I was reeling, trying to keep all of the new information straight in my head. If that had all come out at the beginning, say, from Eirin’s mother, my head would have nearly exploded!
With that being said, there are still some plot points that I do not understand. Why didn’t the human innkeeper ever try to fix the Time Stones? His crippled son would obviously be at a disadvantage, but (since it’s so important) why didn’t the father ever try? Also, where is the boundary of “Solevar”? Is it just anything besides the mountains that everyone seems to live in? Is it just the surface in general? They keep saying that humans all slowly die in Solevar, but I was under the impression that the innkeeper’s family was in Solevar, since I thought that the main characters had to run out of the underground cavern to get to the inn? No? I am also confused about what happened to Benjamin. Did he die? Last we saw, he was a merman and was in the water. How could a merman drown. He wasn’t right next to the waterfall, so he didn’t suddenly plummet to his death on the rocks. Did he swim towards the waterfall purposefully? If so, why? Couldn’t he have simply propelled the corpse-ridden boat to the rapids via a large splash and stayed safe himself? Additionally, the varying ages of different kinds of characters was mid-boggling. Yes, this was somewhat explained, but it’s still quite confusing. A surprising amount of characters have lived for over a century and are still apparently young-ish. Has no one wondered why Elder Luna has been around for so long. Also, if Elder Gerald has an apprentice, then why doesn’t Elder Luna? She’s way older. While we’re on the subject, May I please take a minute to complain about the bad names in the book? And I’m not just talking about the cities in Solevar or the confusing species names. Individual characters’ names range from totally normal to way-exotic. We have people names Benjamin, Anne, and Alexander, and then there’s Qeb, as well as Nuru’s mother, who has an apostrophe in her name. That’s all I remember about that Elder’s name. Who’s Nuru’s terrible mom? The character with the apostrophe. Anyway, that just my personal pet peeve.
Additionally, this is no reflection on the book but just a statement of fact, there are at least a half dozen typos, mostly having to do with pronouns, like Eirin touching his hand to her head. That’s just a reality with most of Brittany Fichter’s books since they aren’t published through a big-name corporation. However, the actual writing itself is beautiful and passionate, as always.
All in all, another good book from Brittany Fichter. It’s totally different from my normal genre, but still delightful! I highly recommend The Seer’s Secret.