Very excited to read a middle grade graphic novel from an Irish creator, and Aoife Dooley's Frankie's World brought the kind of freshness and dark humor I'd expect, with a sweet undercurrent of loyal friendship holding together a plot that felt a little disjointed at times. Dooley's art is simple, somewhat stark despite all of the rounded edges, and visually appealing, with blue, orange, white, and black standing out. It was so simple, in fact, that I found it at times distracting because I could not keep some of the characters straight, as they looked so much alike.
To the reader, Frankie is quirky and unique. To Frankie, she feels like an alien at times - like she doesn't fit in, like she doesn't say the right thing, like she seems to annoy the people around her. She gets bullied both physically and emotionally. She struggles with academics. She has sensitivities that others don't understand (such as loud noises and food touching). When she discovers her biological father's name, she sets out on a secret quest to find him in the hopes that she might discover a kindred spirit, someone who can help her better understand herself.
All along, while Frankie perceives herself to be a misfit, it turns out that she fits right in with two very loyal friends who stick together through Frankie's quest and the even more harrowing world of school bullies. Dooley's voice as an autistic creator gives authenticity to Frankie's experience of self-discovery, and her author's note at the end will be priceless for many young readers with autism or with autistic friends and loved ones.
The pacing of the book was way off at times...moving very slowly and then speeding up inexplicably, and there were times when I felt I must have skipped a few pages worth of panels because the plot took big jumps without explanation. Some parts felt unfinished, like the character development of Nadine, the most notorious bully; and others felt sped up at warp speed, like Frankie's relationship to her father.
Despite the somewhat disjointed plot, the jarring pacing, and the (for me) characters who looked too much alike, I'd recommend Frankie's World and will be adding it to my elementary library collection. The appealing cover art, fresh voice, and autism representation will add up to this spending very little time on the shelf waiting for its next reader.