2.75/5
Della and the rest of the Outdoors Club are supposed to be heading out to Fear Island for an overnight adventure, but their chaperone drops out and cancels their excursion at the last minute. Determined not to miss out on a wild night, the gang decides to go by themselves. It's a decision they live to regret. It's Fear Street, y'all!
I found this story a little tough to get into, as Della is yet another weak female character of the RL Stine catalog whose whole world revolves around a boy (that she broke up with, but assumes will be able to win back on the upcoming camping trip) and her life just won't make sense to her until they're back together. I know many of these books were written in the 90s, and I'm sure some readers find them relatable, but that particular theme is one I continue to think is lame.
It gets better after an unexpected character shows up, a homicide soon follows, and an oath is sworn to never divulge a certain secret. More fun starts when someone who claims to know the secret leaves notes, as well as evidence of their knowledge, for Della and the supporting characters, and even begins stalking them around town. Our protagonists proceed to freak the f out.
What prevented me from ultimately enjoying the book more was that, what felt like a "whodunit" style mystery is tossed aside for a very unsatisfying conclusion wherein you never actually learn much about the antagonist. Who was this secret someone who saw what happened and tormented Della and the Outdoors Club? Apparently just some random person with no ties to anyone in the story. You never even learn a name. Incredibly frustrating!
At the same time, it's a book for teens, it's Fear Street, and thus classic Stine. So if you've read any of his other Fear Street books, you basically know what you're getting into. Despite my complaints, I enjoy the nostalgia, and will keep reading.