Really, this is more of a 3.5 for me because the ending sort of redeemed it. But overall, the beginning was attention grabbing, the middle was wishy washy and felt like no one was making progress, and the ending was good for what it was.
First of all, this book should definitely have a trigger warning. How the editor didn't realize this is astounding to me. Incest should definitely be a trigger warning. Yes, they're technically step-siblings, but it felt as though the author uses their trauma to justify relations with each other that are consistently brought up. It's not even a once and done type of thing where it's stated it happened and not mentioned much after that. It's continual with butterfly kisses and touches and cuddling that comes across as incest rather than siblings clinging to each other their abuse. It gave me the ick, and I wasn't prepared for it. The reader is thrown into the thick of things in chapter three in Cove's point of view where he wakes up naked with his step sister and her "palm is below his belly button.". That's just a bit much for me. Josephine (Jo) , the female protagonist, also nearly experiences sexual assault from a cop, so SA should definitely be a trigger warning. Eating disorders are mentioned in passing, too.
Other than the triggering events, the plot sort of fell flat. We're in this dystopian world where it's a New United States that is set up with similar vibes to The Hunger Games where the revolutionists are punished for their uprising, except in this they're stuck on the other side of the mountain to die from starvation and disease rather than send their kids to fight to the death. That's as far as the similarities to The Hunger Games can go dispite the fact the blurb on the front calls this a darker Hunger Games. News flash, it's not. Josephine is on the poor, outcast side of the mountain, and Cove is on the well-off side of the mountain. Josephine is chosen to attend a Gala where she can become part of "New Georgia" society. A riot begins in the Ashes, which is her home, so she goes back for the sake of her loved ones. We see some of the riot (this is where her near assault occurs), she watches her best friend die, then she wakes up back in New Georgia. After that, we just watch her New Georgia life and her off-kilter relationship brew with Cove which has been forced to make her fall for him then break her by his abusive stepmother. A lot of back and forth happens and not much character growth is done. There are two decent scenes between Cove and Jo, and way into the book we see some growth from Cove. I wasn't expecting his trauma to be healed. It's only a 353 page book with alternating perspectives. However, with as much time jumping as there is, I was expecting a bit more of something from him. That's another thing, what little this book builds to is then glosses over. The scenes I wanted to see were states in a few sentences rather than shows.
One thing I grew to appreciate, however, was the writing style. At first it was really hard to get into, but somewhere along the way I appreciated it. Jo and Cove do have different tones. At least there's that.
As for the redeeming ending...it was good for what it could have been. With how Cove is, it's no surprise he made the choices he did. I can appreciate how he did make the wrong choices that he felt were his best option for Jo. Now, I hate how he just decides for her rather than letting her choose for herself, but for Cove's character, the author uses the "he's too damaged to offer the truth to her and see if she will find him lovable after" angle. As for Jo, there's a bit more closure when she goes home, finds her best friend living still, and help her people work toward a better life.
***MAJOR SPOILER***
I just want to touch on the kindness of Jo that really recovered this story. Cove's stepmother was forcing him to shatter Jo or he would lose his whole inheritance and his mother's orchard. Well, Jo has a majorly generous sponsor for her time in New Georgia. So AFTER Cove breaks her heart, she still goes out and buys his orchard for him so he doesn't lose it because she really does love him but simply can't stick around anymore. She decides to go back with the doctor and save her people from the disease plaguing them. (The doctor has the antidote). So that was the best surprise in all this. She went out of her way to give him the one thing he hoped for other than her love. His mother's orchard.