3.75 stars! A solid, but flawed, start to a series. Kalynn Bayron is another hit or miss author with me, but I was curious to see how one of her middle grades was, and I’m glad I checked it out! I’ll get this out of the way first: I think Bayron writes kids much better than teens. A lot of the friend group interactions felt authentic, and honestly, those were my favorite parts of the book. Their nerdiness? Their trust of each other? Ugh, I love Boog, Cedrick, Jules and Aaron. (Oh, and a fem-presenting nonbinary character is part of the main cast, too!! Hi Jules! I want to get overalls so I can imitate your outfits.)
And I’m so surprised by how recent middle grades address the stress put on young protagonists!! The grief felt by Boog and the others when Aaron went missing hit so hard. Definitely nailed the “surrealness” of a young mind dealing with an incident like that.
I also liked that there was a bunch of information given on not just vampires, but the societal attitudes around them. That’s so interesting to me! I do kinda wish that they addressed more of the implications of all of our real-life pop culture vampire icons also existing in this universe, but that’s just me speaking as an older reader (and thinking about the ethics/questions about creating and romanticizing fictional vampire lore in a universe with actual vampires). I don’t really expect that to be answered LOL
This also had a couple more creepy elements than I expected from a middle grade horror! (I enjoyed that.) Honestly the only thing Bayron tones down in her writing is the number of deaths (and amount of blood/gore). Which isn’t much, aside from the juvenile language.
However, I intensely disliked the pacing, and it’s what made me lower my rating from a full 4 stars. The book seems to end when the action starts, and a lot of the story is Boog just trying to figure out what’s going on with her friends. And, of course, a lot of lying done by parents and adults along the way. (There wasn’t even a conversation around what was or wasn’t age-appropriate knowledge and involvement, and that was so frustrating!! Even moreso, after seeing the reviews for books 2 and 3, and figuring out that’s never going to happen. I don’t think I’m used to that after reading Witchlings.😕) I think the only perk of the kind-of slow pacing is that the mystery surrounding Aaron and the entire friend group’s close-knit dynamic (but also the sheer number of secrets they keep) is actually pretty Stranger Things s1-reminiscent, just without the 80’s nostalgia. I can see why that show is a comp title.
I’m still gonna be continuing this series, though. I had a lot of fun. I might have a bet on who could be the vampire the Vanquishers are looking for.