The Goodreads blurb for this book doesn't begin to do it justice. It may be the ultimate in wish-fulfillment horse stories. Connie wants a horse and doesn't have one when she and her friends decide to start a mounted scout troop. She's not the only one without a horse, and how everything works out for the girls is a cozy story complete with the messages about industry and perseverence required of stories for girls back in the day.
I got an old hand-me-down copy for my 12th birthday and gave it to my not particularly horse-crazy daughter at around the same age--she loved it, too. The camaraderie between the girls, the mysterious Silver Birch, the delightful 1940's line drawings--it's pretty near perfect.
I have always loved my mom's childhood copy of Golden Sovereign, but I only recently learned about the earlier stories. (Only they cost at least $50 now, so I was ecstatic to finally order a copy of this via Interlibrary Loan.) I loved seeing how it all began. The story of taming the title character may have been the main draw, but all the girls were delightful characters and I loved their friendship and perseverance in starting their own Girl Scout chapter. Sweet, wholesome fun.
This was one of the first 'chapter books' that I read, in fourth grade about a hundred years ago. It hooked me on horse stories and contributed to my own lifelong love of horses and writing.
How could I dislike a horse book? Three stars looks too low, but in the pantheon of horse books out there, I couldn't say I really liked it. It was pleasant and nostalgic.