As per my review for the Volume one compilation - meh.
Why, oh why, do so many of the Roberts books have sex equals falling in love, or lust equalling long term commitment? Honestly! I find it obnoxious that 4 women from one family could be so stupid! Oh, sure, I believe in love at first sight. I believe that sex is a wonderful expression of love, but to have the women (usually) getting all hot and heavy and the men (usually) surly, confused, and a walking hard on to mean falling in love? I find that hard to believe.
The idea of the story line is one I find interesting, deep dark secrets in the family and all that. Nice little circle of time and fate between the dead and the living. I could not get my head around the all too familiar characterisation of many of the people in the story. I kept feeling like I had read the same story or similar another time. It is a habit of Ms. Roberts to have very similar stories with very similar characters in very similar situations in many of her books. I find that non-original. In fact, one book a while ago was so much like another author's book I felt litigation was due!
Read it, tossed it, and now onto something else.