What do you think?
Rate this book
Miss Morton Mysteries #1
Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder
Catherine Lloyd, author of the critically acclaimed Kurland St. Mary mysteries debuts with the first book in a new series set in Regency England,where circumstances compel one Lady Caroline Morton to become a lady’s companion whose duties will soon entail solving a murder . . .
The options for the penniless daughter of a deceased earl are few indeed in Regency England. So, following the suspicious death of her father, the Earl of Morton, and the discovery that she and her much younger sister have been left without income or home, Lady Caroline takes a post as a lady’s companion to the wealthy widow Frogerton.
Just as Caroline is getting accustomed to her new position, her aunt, Lady Eleanor Greenwood, invites her and her employer to a house party in the countryside to celebrate her youngest daughter’s birthday. Mrs. Matilda (Matty) Frogerton sees this as an opportunity to introduce her own rather wild daughter, Dorothy, to the ton, and Caroline is eager to see her sister, who as a child lives with their aunt.
But all is not well at the Greenwood estate. For one thing, Lady Caroline’s former fiancé, Lord Francis Chatham, is a guest and refuses to speak to her. Far worse, after a series of troubling harassments of the staff, an elderly family member is found stabbed by a knitting needle.
As Caroline and an unexpected ally—Mrs. Frogerton—attempt to solve the chilling crime, they discover the culprit may be leaving bizarre clues as to who will be next in the nursery. But they must make haste, for this heartless killer is engaged in anything but child’s play . . .
The options for the penniless daughter of a deceased earl are few indeed in Regency England. So, following the suspicious death of her father, the Earl of Morton, and the discovery that she and her much younger sister have been left without income or home, Lady Caroline takes a post as a lady’s companion to the wealthy widow Frogerton.
Just as Caroline is getting accustomed to her new position, her aunt, Lady Eleanor Greenwood, invites her and her employer to a house party in the countryside to celebrate her youngest daughter’s birthday. Mrs. Matilda (Matty) Frogerton sees this as an opportunity to introduce her own rather wild daughter, Dorothy, to the ton, and Caroline is eager to see her sister, who as a child lives with their aunt.
But all is not well at the Greenwood estate. For one thing, Lady Caroline’s former fiancé, Lord Francis Chatham, is a guest and refuses to speak to her. Far worse, after a series of troubling harassments of the staff, an elderly family member is found stabbed by a knitting needle.
As Caroline and an unexpected ally—Mrs. Frogerton—attempt to solve the chilling crime, they discover the culprit may be leaving bizarre clues as to who will be next in the nursery. But they must make haste, for this heartless killer is engaged in anything but child’s play . . .
290 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 31, 2022
329 people are currently reading
11596 people want to read
About the author
Catherine Lloyd
20 books522 followersCatherine Lloyd was born just outside London, England, into a large family of dreamers, artists, and history lovers. She completed her education with a master’s degree in history at the University College of Wales, Aberystwyth, and uses the skills she gained there to research and write her historical mysteries. Catherine currently lives in Hawaii with her husband and youngest daughter..
Please note only the Kurland St. Mary mysteries are written by this Catherine Lloyd, not the romances.
Librarian’s note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Please note only the Kurland St. Mary mysteries are written by this Catherine Lloyd, not the romances.
Librarian’s note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 457 reviews
July 25, 2023
EXCERPT: 'Mother said I must apologize for calling you stupid.'
'Thank you,' Caroline said.
'I still think you're foolish, though.' Dorothy curled one of her golden ringlets around her finger and pouted. She was a remarkably pretty girl with a large fortune who should take well with the ton, as long as she kept her origins and opinions to herself. 'But I suppose at your age, the chance of capturing a husband are fairly slim anyway.'
'True,' Caroline acknowledged. She had no intention of reminiscing with Dorothy about her very successful first Season, when she had attracted the attention of not only a Viscount, but the son of an Earl. That life was behind her now and she refused to continue to miss it.
ABOUT 'MISS MORTON AND THE ENGLISH HOUSE PARTY MURDER': Following the suspicious death of her father, the Earl of Morton, and the discovery that she and her much younger sister have been left without income or home, Lady Caroline takes a post as a lady’s companion to wealthy widow Mrs. Matilda (Matty) Frogerton.
Eager to introduce herself and her rather wild daughter to the ton, Mrs. Frogerton is pleased when they are invited by Caroline’s aunt, Lady Eleanor Greenwood, to a house party in the countryside. For her part, Caroline is eager to see her little sister, who now lives with their aunt. But all is not well at the Greenwood estate...
For one thing, Lady Caroline’s former fiancé, Lord Francis Chatham, is a guest and refuses to speak to her. Worse, after a series of troubling harassments of the staff, an elderly family member is found fatally stabbed by a knitting needle. . . . As Caroline and an unexpected ally—Mrs. Frogerton—attempt to solve the chilling crime, they discover bizarre clues in the nursery as to who will be next. But they must make haste, for this heartless killer is engaged in anything but child’s play...
MY THOUGHTS: This is a well written book which offers a glimpse of life from all angles at the start of Queen Victoria's reign. This story encompasses everything from the landed and titled gentry to orphans and foster children and everything in between.
There is a little humour - watch how Caroline deals with her relations who now find her persona non grata - a little mystery - a body or two - a little eeriness - who is setting up the dolls' house in the nursery to mimic the murders? - and the possibility of romance.
None of the characters are particularly appealing - Caroline is quite acerbic - except perhaps for Mrs Frogerton whom I came to quite admire.
An entertaining but not memorable read.
I listened to the audiobook of Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder and enjoyed Lucy Rayner's narration.
⭐⭐⭐.6
#MissMortonandtheEnglishHousePartyMurder #Libby
'Thank you,' Caroline said.
'I still think you're foolish, though.' Dorothy curled one of her golden ringlets around her finger and pouted. She was a remarkably pretty girl with a large fortune who should take well with the ton, as long as she kept her origins and opinions to herself. 'But I suppose at your age, the chance of capturing a husband are fairly slim anyway.'
'True,' Caroline acknowledged. She had no intention of reminiscing with Dorothy about her very successful first Season, when she had attracted the attention of not only a Viscount, but the son of an Earl. That life was behind her now and she refused to continue to miss it.
ABOUT 'MISS MORTON AND THE ENGLISH HOUSE PARTY MURDER': Following the suspicious death of her father, the Earl of Morton, and the discovery that she and her much younger sister have been left without income or home, Lady Caroline takes a post as a lady’s companion to wealthy widow Mrs. Matilda (Matty) Frogerton.
Eager to introduce herself and her rather wild daughter to the ton, Mrs. Frogerton is pleased when they are invited by Caroline’s aunt, Lady Eleanor Greenwood, to a house party in the countryside. For her part, Caroline is eager to see her little sister, who now lives with their aunt. But all is not well at the Greenwood estate...
For one thing, Lady Caroline’s former fiancé, Lord Francis Chatham, is a guest and refuses to speak to her. Worse, after a series of troubling harassments of the staff, an elderly family member is found fatally stabbed by a knitting needle. . . . As Caroline and an unexpected ally—Mrs. Frogerton—attempt to solve the chilling crime, they discover bizarre clues in the nursery as to who will be next. But they must make haste, for this heartless killer is engaged in anything but child’s play...
MY THOUGHTS: This is a well written book which offers a glimpse of life from all angles at the start of Queen Victoria's reign. This story encompasses everything from the landed and titled gentry to orphans and foster children and everything in between.
There is a little humour - watch how Caroline deals with her relations who now find her persona non grata - a little mystery - a body or two - a little eeriness - who is setting up the dolls' house in the nursery to mimic the murders? - and the possibility of romance.
None of the characters are particularly appealing - Caroline is quite acerbic - except perhaps for Mrs Frogerton whom I came to quite admire.
An entertaining but not memorable read.
I listened to the audiobook of Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder and enjoyed Lucy Rayner's narration.
⭐⭐⭐.6
#MissMortonandtheEnglishHousePartyMurder #Libby
August 12, 2023
This was my first book from this author who apparently has written another well liked series already.
Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder opens in London in 1837 where we meet our MC, Caroline Morton and her employer Mrs Frogerton. Caroline has been left penniless after her father's death and, rather than go and live the life of a dependant with a rich relative, she is trying to make her own way as a lady's companion.
When Caroline is invited to a party at her Aunt's family estate she manages to get invitations too for Mrs. Frogerton and her daughter and off they all go never expecting that there will be a series of murders, or that Caroline and Mrs F. will need to find their inner sleuths and solve the crimes themselves.
I thought the book was nicely written and I enjoyed the characters. Caroline is strong and determined and the way she handles herself when dealing with rich relations and ex husbands to be is fun to watch. Mrs Frogerton is an excellent sidekick, smart enough to offer good advice and rich enough to be totally independent. I enjoyed it all and look forward to a second book.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.
Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder opens in London in 1837 where we meet our MC, Caroline Morton and her employer Mrs Frogerton. Caroline has been left penniless after her father's death and, rather than go and live the life of a dependant with a rich relative, she is trying to make her own way as a lady's companion.
When Caroline is invited to a party at her Aunt's family estate she manages to get invitations too for Mrs. Frogerton and her daughter and off they all go never expecting that there will be a series of murders, or that Caroline and Mrs F. will need to find their inner sleuths and solve the crimes themselves.
I thought the book was nicely written and I enjoyed the characters. Caroline is strong and determined and the way she handles herself when dealing with rich relations and ex husbands to be is fun to watch. Mrs Frogerton is an excellent sidekick, smart enough to offer good advice and rich enough to be totally independent. I enjoyed it all and look forward to a second book.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.
May 31, 2022
Caroline Morton has skeletons in her closet that are not of her own choosing. Her father disgraced the family through irresponsible gambling and the choice to commit suicide. Now Caroline is in the unenviable position of being the disgraced daughter and an unwanted family connection. Miss Morton has taken up employment as an assistant to a spry, inquisitive widow with a daughter who is about to enter society. When the three of them (Caroline, employer, and daughter) are invited to a family house party in the home where Caroline grew up and her younger sister (Susan) still lives; misfortunes begin to befall members of the household. The dollhouse in the nursery eerily mimics each disastrous event. Who is behind these accidents and deaths? Caroline is determined to get to the bottom of it with some unexpected assistance from the neighborhood doctor and her curious employer. This mystery shines some light on the plight of foster children and orphans in the Regency era. It was entertaining, but I find with a one and done on this series.
Happy publication day and thank you to Kensington for a paperback ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Happy publication day and thank you to Kensington for a paperback ARC in exchange for an honest review.
September 27, 2022
I am a fan of the authors Kurland mystery series and looked forward to this book. The book had too many characters and subplots. I could not keep track of who was who. Mrs Fogerton was my favorite character but was not the heroine....that was kind of Caroline whom I did not like. It is hard to have an entire book written about someone you don't care for or about. Things that any sane person would go that was no accident were just brushed off. The way to solve the mystery as far as I could tell, was just accuse everyone you meet then go to the next person and accuse them. I had a wild guess who did it. A bit of a wild twist at the end. The book was too choppy as is my review.
October 11, 2023
Catherine Lloyd is an excellent author. The character, especially the featured characters, were excellently done. You didn’t learn everything about them right in the beginning, it was doled out a bit at a time and some of what you thought you knew, it turns out you didn’t. You aren’t sure who the good guys are or who the bad guys are. Highly recommend.
May 30, 2022
London 1837, after Caroline's father’s unfortunate death, she is employed to be by Mrs. Frogerton's side and to help ease her daughter Dorothy’s way in society.
Her aunt Lady Eleanor Greenwood didn't agree to this job but accepted to invite Caroline, Mrs. Frogerton and her daughter to a house party at Greenwood Hall, a huge house that was built in Tudor times.
This is a house where we face murder, secrets and unpleasant people!
“I have been to several such parties in my life, ma’am, and I can assure you that murder has never been on the agenda. The most scandalous thing I’ve ever seen is some gentleman being caught in the wrong lady’s bedchamber, ..."
I love the cover and I think this was an entertaining cozy historical mystery, easy to read, I always enjoyed murder stories in a castle, overall this was a good book, I liked the story, but unfortunately, this book has many unpleasant characters for me, they are mostly selfish and rude, probably was supposed to be funny!
Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder is a new start for the historical mystery, I hope the next one be more pleasant.
Thanks to Kensington Books via Netgalley for ARC, I have given my honest review, publication date 31 May 2022.
Her aunt Lady Eleanor Greenwood didn't agree to this job but accepted to invite Caroline, Mrs. Frogerton and her daughter to a house party at Greenwood Hall, a huge house that was built in Tudor times.
This is a house where we face murder, secrets and unpleasant people!
“I have been to several such parties in my life, ma’am, and I can assure you that murder has never been on the agenda. The most scandalous thing I’ve ever seen is some gentleman being caught in the wrong lady’s bedchamber, ..."
I love the cover and I think this was an entertaining cozy historical mystery, easy to read, I always enjoyed murder stories in a castle, overall this was a good book, I liked the story, but unfortunately, this book has many unpleasant characters for me, they are mostly selfish and rude, probably was supposed to be funny!
Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder is a new start for the historical mystery, I hope the next one be more pleasant.
Thanks to Kensington Books via Netgalley for ARC, I have given my honest review, publication date 31 May 2022.
March 30, 2022
As a mystery, this was a complete flop for me, as much as I hate leaving such negative feedback. I enjoyed Catherine Lloyd’s cozy mysteries set in Kurland St. Mary and was eager to try the first in her new series.
Lady Caroline Morton, following the disgrace of her father’s squandering of the family money (including both his daughters’ dowries) and subsequent suicide, becomes a lady’s companion out of determination to provide for herself and her younger sister rather than be the poor relation thrust on the mercies of her Greenwood family. She finds herself in a nice position despite her complete reversal of fortune, as her employer, Mrs. Frogerton, is a very likable and kind woman. Suffering from the social travesty of being new money in a time when snobbery amongst the ton was high, she and her daughter benefit from Caroline’s expertise in refining their lifestyle, mostly to secure a highbrow husband for Miss Dorothy Frogerton.
Caroline’s younger sister Susan still lives with the upperclass Greenwood side of their family, a home both girls lived in throughout their childhoods. Caroline’s goal is to secure her finances so that Susan, 15 in this novel, can come live with her. Their aunt Eleanor keeps urging Caroline to give up her position to come live with the family again, which Caroline knows all too well will result in her being dependent on them, as well as unpaid labor to help the ‘waifs and strays’ her aunt takes in as part of her charitable works.
The waifs and strays play a pivotal role in the mystery. For her cousin Mabel’s birthday ball, Caroline finds herself and the Frogertons invited to the Greenwood estate. There, things get interesting quickly, as not only is she met with being shunned by previous friends who refuse to acknowledge her in her socially lowered state, but her ex-fiancée is a surprising guest for the weekend. Then: enter a murderer. Or two. Or three. I’m still not entirely certain, and here begins the weak spots. Improbable storylines, including household staff by turns cursing at their employers and then bowing and scraping, as well as lower classes being invited to the ball at the whim of Mabel Greenwood, which none of the snobs seem to care about (so unrealistic), silly attempts to pretend murder was not murder by members of the Greenwood family (and getting away with it?), confusing timelines that didn’t add up (the butler’s age in relation to historical events?), dialogue at times too modern for the period, and no clear understanding of what exactly transpired, plus a rushed and oddly flippant ending to the mystery itself had me skimming to finish.
Things I liked: Caroline. Despite the rotten treatment she receives at the hands of family and former friends alike, she stands up for herself nicely and I liked her character. Mrs. Frogerton is great also, and I grew to like Dr. Harris as well. (the one surprising incongruity in Caroline’s character was the 200 pound note, without giving too much of the plot away — kinda sorta excused by the ‘justice over evil’ explanation attempt?)
Oh, another note: I wouldn’t quite classify this as wholly cozy. There was an underlying ickiness to the story with lots of thoroughly unlikeable characters and some heavier aspects touched on. Nothing over the top, but more so than her Kurland series. I actually would give the second in the series a try, as I do like the characters mentioned above. But I’ll read it with reservations about the mystery itself.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read and review this book in exchange for my unbiased review.
Lady Caroline Morton, following the disgrace of her father’s squandering of the family money (including both his daughters’ dowries) and subsequent suicide, becomes a lady’s companion out of determination to provide for herself and her younger sister rather than be the poor relation thrust on the mercies of her Greenwood family. She finds herself in a nice position despite her complete reversal of fortune, as her employer, Mrs. Frogerton, is a very likable and kind woman. Suffering from the social travesty of being new money in a time when snobbery amongst the ton was high, she and her daughter benefit from Caroline’s expertise in refining their lifestyle, mostly to secure a highbrow husband for Miss Dorothy Frogerton.
Caroline’s younger sister Susan still lives with the upperclass Greenwood side of their family, a home both girls lived in throughout their childhoods. Caroline’s goal is to secure her finances so that Susan, 15 in this novel, can come live with her. Their aunt Eleanor keeps urging Caroline to give up her position to come live with the family again, which Caroline knows all too well will result in her being dependent on them, as well as unpaid labor to help the ‘waifs and strays’ her aunt takes in as part of her charitable works.
The waifs and strays play a pivotal role in the mystery. For her cousin Mabel’s birthday ball, Caroline finds herself and the Frogertons invited to the Greenwood estate. There, things get interesting quickly, as not only is she met with being shunned by previous friends who refuse to acknowledge her in her socially lowered state, but her ex-fiancée is a surprising guest for the weekend. Then: enter a murderer. Or two. Or three. I’m still not entirely certain, and here begins the weak spots. Improbable storylines, including household staff by turns cursing at their employers and then bowing and scraping, as well as lower classes being invited to the ball at the whim of Mabel Greenwood, which none of the snobs seem to care about (so unrealistic), silly attempts to pretend murder was not murder by members of the Greenwood family (and getting away with it?), confusing timelines that didn’t add up (the butler’s age in relation to historical events?), dialogue at times too modern for the period, and no clear understanding of what exactly transpired, plus a rushed and oddly flippant ending to the mystery itself had me skimming to finish.
Things I liked: Caroline. Despite the rotten treatment she receives at the hands of family and former friends alike, she stands up for herself nicely and I liked her character. Mrs. Frogerton is great also, and I grew to like Dr. Harris as well. (the one surprising incongruity in Caroline’s character was the 200 pound note, without giving too much of the plot away — kinda sorta excused by the ‘justice over evil’ explanation attempt?)
Oh, another note: I wouldn’t quite classify this as wholly cozy. There was an underlying ickiness to the story with lots of thoroughly unlikeable characters and some heavier aspects touched on. Nothing over the top, but more so than her Kurland series. I actually would give the second in the series a try, as I do like the characters mentioned above. But I’ll read it with reservations about the mystery itself.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read and review this book in exchange for my unbiased review.
May 31, 2022
Families that play together?______3.5
A family reunion of a sort, a dead body, seemingly troubled staff, plus an unforgiving ex fiancé makes for a satisfying read. After her father’s untimely death revealed habits unbecoming a member of the ton, Lady Caroline Morton and her sister Susan had been living with their aunt, Lady Eleanor Greenwood. Treated more as an unpaid servant, rather than a family member, Caroline left to charter her own course. As Miss Morton she steps out and become a paid companion. Caroline returns to Greenwood Hall for her cousin Mabel’s birthday party and ball, and to see her young sister. Her employer a wealthy widow, Mrs Matilda (Marry) Frogerton and her daughter Dorothy will accompany Caroline. Matty sees this a chance for Dorothy to rub shoulders with loftier members of society. Caroline’s former fiancé’s presence, Lord Francis Chatham’s is disturbing, as is that of Dr. Harris for entirely different reasons.
When death strikes Caroline and Matty begin investigating. They discover a troubled household with a thinly veiled atmosphere of turbulence. And that’s just the beginning.
Quite a complex mystery, ending on a strange note even if the mystery was reconciled. I will be interested in seeing how this series progresses.
A Kensington Books ARC via NetGalley
A family reunion of a sort, a dead body, seemingly troubled staff, plus an unforgiving ex fiancé makes for a satisfying read. After her father’s untimely death revealed habits unbecoming a member of the ton, Lady Caroline Morton and her sister Susan had been living with their aunt, Lady Eleanor Greenwood. Treated more as an unpaid servant, rather than a family member, Caroline left to charter her own course. As Miss Morton she steps out and become a paid companion. Caroline returns to Greenwood Hall for her cousin Mabel’s birthday party and ball, and to see her young sister. Her employer a wealthy widow, Mrs Matilda (Marry) Frogerton and her daughter Dorothy will accompany Caroline. Matty sees this a chance for Dorothy to rub shoulders with loftier members of society. Caroline’s former fiancé’s presence, Lord Francis Chatham’s is disturbing, as is that of Dr. Harris for entirely different reasons.
When death strikes Caroline and Matty begin investigating. They discover a troubled household with a thinly veiled atmosphere of turbulence. And that’s just the beginning.
Quite a complex mystery, ending on a strange note even if the mystery was reconciled. I will be interested in seeing how this series progresses.
A Kensington Books ARC via NetGalley
May 29, 2022
Many thanks to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing Group for this Advanced Reader Copy and the opportunity to review Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder. All opinions and comments are my own.
Penniless Caroline Morton, a peer’s daughter encounters more than a good time at her aunt’s garden party in this new book by Catherine Lloyd (author of the popular Kurland St. Mary mystery series). She’s taken a job as a paid companion so that she can get her younger sister out of the clutches of her disagreeable aunt. The aunt, meanwhile, thinks she’s doing her a going turn by inviting Caroline’s employer, Mrs. Frogerton and her employer’s daughter Dorothy to Greenwood Hall, and her cousin’s 17th birthday party. It’s a way for the daughter to be among the ton; who wouldn’t want that?
Caroline has been turned out of society because her nobleman father ruined the family. His suicide capped the matter. So, no good marriage for her. But she’s supposed to help find Dorothy Frogerton some likely prospects. Hopefully she’ll meet someone at the ball, and everything will turn out fine for all concerned. Does anyone expect this to be smooth sailing? Not if you’re a fan of mystery stories!
We meet quite the cast of characters in the book, from “upstairs” to “downstairs.” Readers find that Mabel, Caroline’s cousin, has invited people to her birthday ball that she’s grown up around and is used to, which includes what would be considered the “lower classes.” The upper class is represented by Caroline’s ex-fiancé and his family, who rejected her when society turned against her. You will get a sense of what that society was like; our author makes it quite clear what Caroline has had to endure. She is a strong character, and readers will learn much about her. But she is not a super-woman; the author knows to write within the confines of the time and society (1837, first year of Victoria’s reign) that the book is set in.
It soon becomes apparent that someone has a diabolic plan in mind for mayhem, and then, murder. As we’re told, “someone is enjoying inflicting pain on members of the household.” And beyond that, more crimes are discovered, via our assiduous sleuth Caroline and her new “assistant,” the village doctor. Poison pen letters, dead bodies, dolls arranged in gruesome displays -- and this is considered a cozy mystery! Well, the crimes are all “off stage,’ as it were, there is that. You’ll find a whole lot going on in Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder.
Caroline finally works it all out, and it’s a rather sordid story. There is revenge of sorts, but will there be justice? At least she is still settled with Mrs. Frogerton, and will be able to send for her sister soon. It appears that Ms. Lloyd has plans for a series. I would like to know if Miss Morton can continue to find her way in London. Something mysterious will probably turn up.
Penniless Caroline Morton, a peer’s daughter encounters more than a good time at her aunt’s garden party in this new book by Catherine Lloyd (author of the popular Kurland St. Mary mystery series). She’s taken a job as a paid companion so that she can get her younger sister out of the clutches of her disagreeable aunt. The aunt, meanwhile, thinks she’s doing her a going turn by inviting Caroline’s employer, Mrs. Frogerton and her employer’s daughter Dorothy to Greenwood Hall, and her cousin’s 17th birthday party. It’s a way for the daughter to be among the ton; who wouldn’t want that?
Caroline has been turned out of society because her nobleman father ruined the family. His suicide capped the matter. So, no good marriage for her. But she’s supposed to help find Dorothy Frogerton some likely prospects. Hopefully she’ll meet someone at the ball, and everything will turn out fine for all concerned. Does anyone expect this to be smooth sailing? Not if you’re a fan of mystery stories!
We meet quite the cast of characters in the book, from “upstairs” to “downstairs.” Readers find that Mabel, Caroline’s cousin, has invited people to her birthday ball that she’s grown up around and is used to, which includes what would be considered the “lower classes.” The upper class is represented by Caroline’s ex-fiancé and his family, who rejected her when society turned against her. You will get a sense of what that society was like; our author makes it quite clear what Caroline has had to endure. She is a strong character, and readers will learn much about her. But she is not a super-woman; the author knows to write within the confines of the time and society (1837, first year of Victoria’s reign) that the book is set in.
It soon becomes apparent that someone has a diabolic plan in mind for mayhem, and then, murder. As we’re told, “someone is enjoying inflicting pain on members of the household.” And beyond that, more crimes are discovered, via our assiduous sleuth Caroline and her new “assistant,” the village doctor. Poison pen letters, dead bodies, dolls arranged in gruesome displays -- and this is considered a cozy mystery! Well, the crimes are all “off stage,’ as it were, there is that. You’ll find a whole lot going on in Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder.
Caroline finally works it all out, and it’s a rather sordid story. There is revenge of sorts, but will there be justice? At least she is still settled with Mrs. Frogerton, and will be able to send for her sister soon. It appears that Ms. Lloyd has plans for a series. I would like to know if Miss Morton can continue to find her way in London. Something mysterious will probably turn up.
November 13, 2023
Started okay, but the anachronistic language and turns of phrase just got worse and worse. Plus a lot of the detective work seemed to involve revelations by other people, not the main character, whose unusual position (of good family, disgraced father, broken engagement, chooses independence/life of service over relying on relations) was intriguing at first but eventually just became less than believable. I admit I also liked the heroine less and less as it went along. Not the series or writer for me.
Audio Notes: Narrator is okay/not my favorite, but she still elevated the material. It took a little while before I started noticing the flaws in the writing, which is to her credit.
Audio Notes: Narrator is okay/not my favorite, but she still elevated the material. It took a little while before I started noticing the flaws in the writing, which is to her credit.
September 7, 2023
4.5 stars rounded up
2023 reread:
I reread this because I remembered it was more complicated than the average cozy mystery.
I enjoyed this just as much on my reread.
I need to check out this authors other series.
Original review:
I quite thoroughly enjoyed this.
I will definitely read the sequels.
This had a delightful set up and I liked the cast of characters.
The mystery was a touch darker than is usual for these type of cozy feel novels but well explored and surprising.
2023 reread:
I reread this because I remembered it was more complicated than the average cozy mystery.
I enjoyed this just as much on my reread.
I need to check out this authors other series.
Original review:
I quite thoroughly enjoyed this.
I will definitely read the sequels.
This had a delightful set up and I liked the cast of characters.
The mystery was a touch darker than is usual for these type of cozy feel novels but well explored and surprising.
March 12, 2022
Not my style of book at all. Overly convoluted plot, that requires you to believe people will insist that a someone with a knitting needle jammed into their neck died of natural causes. The characters are two dimensional, there's no chemistry between any of them. the main character is as incredibly boring. It feels like a book written by someone who thought watching Downton Abbey was enough research for anything set in the past. The attempts to highlight the social differences between various characters was bizarre; one minute servants are snarling, cursing, and threatening their employers with violence, the next they are doffing their caps and murmuring, "yes, miss." Random curtseys in the middle of conversations, too many modern idioms sprinkled through out. All in all, a hot mess.
I received this as an ARC from NetGalley.
I received this as an ARC from NetGalley.
September 27, 2022
I really enjoyed the main characters, even thought the mystery was a bit dark. I look forward to more adventures for Lady Caroline!
February 14, 2022
Miss Morton and the English House Party Murder by Catherine Lloyd is a great cozy mystery that is the first in a new series taking place in 19th century England. I enjoyed this one.
This book starts off in London, 1837. I like this time period, as it is balancing between “old” times and the beginnings of societal and industrial change. Much material can be used within plot lines for books placed during this time. The author does a great job in creating locations, characters, concepts, and dialogue to feel authentic and realistic.
Caroline is a great main character. She is complex, has a few mysteries surrounding her past which in time should slowly be revealed, and gors against the grain of the “norm” in regards to desires and gender/societal expectations. Trying to find her own way and exert some control and independence in her life, she becomes a lady’s companion to a friendly and unique woman Mrs. Frogerton (and her challenging coming of age daughter, Dorothy. I liked both Caroline and Matty Frogerton as they seem unconventional and down to earth in ways that other “higher society ladies” are not. It makes them endearing to some degree.
They travel to Caroline’s formidable Aunt’s estate for a birthday party, and here is where the murder/mystery ensues. Caroline ends up being wrapped up within the drama, and with plenty of secrets, mysteries, surprises, twists and turns, becomes an amateur sleuth in solving said crime.
I enjoyed this story and expect that future books will create more action as we now have the foundations of the characters and location presented and explained.
I will definitely read the next book.
4/5 stars
Thank you NG and Kensington for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.
I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 5/31/22.
This book starts off in London, 1837. I like this time period, as it is balancing between “old” times and the beginnings of societal and industrial change. Much material can be used within plot lines for books placed during this time. The author does a great job in creating locations, characters, concepts, and dialogue to feel authentic and realistic.
Caroline is a great main character. She is complex, has a few mysteries surrounding her past which in time should slowly be revealed, and gors against the grain of the “norm” in regards to desires and gender/societal expectations. Trying to find her own way and exert some control and independence in her life, she becomes a lady’s companion to a friendly and unique woman Mrs. Frogerton (and her challenging coming of age daughter, Dorothy. I liked both Caroline and Matty Frogerton as they seem unconventional and down to earth in ways that other “higher society ladies” are not. It makes them endearing to some degree.
They travel to Caroline’s formidable Aunt’s estate for a birthday party, and here is where the murder/mystery ensues. Caroline ends up being wrapped up within the drama, and with plenty of secrets, mysteries, surprises, twists and turns, becomes an amateur sleuth in solving said crime.
I enjoyed this story and expect that future books will create more action as we now have the foundations of the characters and location presented and explained.
I will definitely read the next book.
4/5 stars
Thank you NG and Kensington for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.
I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 5/31/22.
March 18, 2022
Set in 1837, following her father’s suicide and financial ruin and the discovery that she and her much younger sister Susan have been left without income or home because he spent their dowries, Lady Caroline Morton takes a post as a lady’s companion to the wealthy widow Frogerton and her rude daughter Dorothy. Caroline is motivated to earn her own income to someday provide a home for Susan, who lives with their aunt.
Just as Caroline is getting accustomed to her new position, her aunt, Lady Eleanor Greenwood, invites her and her employer to a house party to celebrate her cousin Mabel’s birthday. Caroline runs into her former fiancé there and is looked down on by everyone in the house. When someone is hurt and someone else stabbed with a knitting needle, Caroline and Mrs. Frogerton work together to solve the crime.
I enjoyed this author’s regency set Kurland series and was eager to read this new one.
Caroline used to move in higher circles but is determined to make her own way in the world. She had lost her security after her father died and her life turned upside, and she refuses to be beholden to anyone else again. She’s angry at the world that has rejected her but does a good job hiding it as she tries to move on.
“Hired companions and spinster aunts were rarely accorded any respect or even noticed.”
While I liked Caroline, I struggled to get into this mystery. The orphans and cousins were hard to keep track of, a few of the ages of the characters didn’t make sense to me, and some characters’ motivations were hard to pin down. Caroline’s aunt Eleanor was particularly inconsistent. The supporting characters were flat and I didn’t find the resolution satisfying. While the investigation seemed a little haphazard, Mrs Frogerton and even Dr Harris were good characters and I see enough potential here to give the second in the series a chance.
I received an arc from NetGalley
Just as Caroline is getting accustomed to her new position, her aunt, Lady Eleanor Greenwood, invites her and her employer to a house party to celebrate her cousin Mabel’s birthday. Caroline runs into her former fiancé there and is looked down on by everyone in the house. When someone is hurt and someone else stabbed with a knitting needle, Caroline and Mrs. Frogerton work together to solve the crime.
I enjoyed this author’s regency set Kurland series and was eager to read this new one.
Caroline used to move in higher circles but is determined to make her own way in the world. She had lost her security after her father died and her life turned upside, and she refuses to be beholden to anyone else again. She’s angry at the world that has rejected her but does a good job hiding it as she tries to move on.
“Hired companions and spinster aunts were rarely accorded any respect or even noticed.”
While I liked Caroline, I struggled to get into this mystery. The orphans and cousins were hard to keep track of, a few of the ages of the characters didn’t make sense to me, and some characters’ motivations were hard to pin down. Caroline’s aunt Eleanor was particularly inconsistent. The supporting characters were flat and I didn’t find the resolution satisfying. While the investigation seemed a little haphazard, Mrs Frogerton and even Dr Harris were good characters and I see enough potential here to give the second in the series a chance.
I received an arc from NetGalley
May 23, 2022
Usually these books keep me guessing and guessing and I love it! But this time, it was difficult to feel attached to any of the characters as they weren't flushed out enough and left the reader a bit confused as to what the main plot was to be. Perhaps the author will write a second one and give each character greater development so we can be more invested in the plotline and the main characters. This one was a bit muddy to me.
October 22, 2023
I think this is a good start to a historical mystery series. I liked Caroline & Mrs. Frogerton, I think they’ll make good allies. Was surprised at the main culprit, which shook things up a bit. Will definitely read the next one.
November 25, 2023
This could have been a shorter book
April 1, 2025
This was a mystery with intriguing characters.
May 29, 2022
This was such an amazing premise, with kinda a rushed ending.
When Caroline Morton's father mysteriously dies and leave her and her sister penniless, she doesn't have much options. Caroline decides to take a post as a lady's companion to the wealthy Mrs. Frogerton and to earn enough money so she and her sister can live on their own. When Caroline's aunt invites her and her employer to a house party in the countryside to celebrate her youngest daughter’s birthday, Caroline sees this as the perfect opportunity to visit her sister (who's staying at the aunt's house) and introduce Mrs. Frogerton's daughter to society. Before the party, strange events start happening around the house, culminating in a murder. Caroline, along with Mrs. Frogerton, try and solve the crime while having to dodge her ex-fiancé Francis, a young doctor, and her family.
I really enjoyed the first 3/4th of this book. I am always a fan of regency and when you combine that with a mystery, that is definitely my cup of tea. I really liked how Catherine Lloyd managed to create such a mysterious atmosphere where everyone can be a suspect. I had a lot of fun sorting through the various clues she left to try to figure out exactly what was going on and who was behind it all. Since this was a regency I really enjoyed Caroline's perspective, going from the daughter of an earl to the working class. You really get to see her independence and drive that usually isn't present in regency novels.
I wasn't a fan of how rushed the ending seemed. After all that build up, it felt like the main mystery got resolved too quickly, while at the same time other small questions were left unanswered. I really hope that there's a sequel because I would love to read more of Caroline's story!
This eARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
Publication date: 5/31/22
When Caroline Morton's father mysteriously dies and leave her and her sister penniless, she doesn't have much options. Caroline decides to take a post as a lady's companion to the wealthy Mrs. Frogerton and to earn enough money so she and her sister can live on their own. When Caroline's aunt invites her and her employer to a house party in the countryside to celebrate her youngest daughter’s birthday, Caroline sees this as the perfect opportunity to visit her sister (who's staying at the aunt's house) and introduce Mrs. Frogerton's daughter to society. Before the party, strange events start happening around the house, culminating in a murder. Caroline, along with Mrs. Frogerton, try and solve the crime while having to dodge her ex-fiancé Francis, a young doctor, and her family.
I really enjoyed the first 3/4th of this book. I am always a fan of regency and when you combine that with a mystery, that is definitely my cup of tea. I really liked how Catherine Lloyd managed to create such a mysterious atmosphere where everyone can be a suspect. I had a lot of fun sorting through the various clues she left to try to figure out exactly what was going on and who was behind it all. Since this was a regency I really enjoyed Caroline's perspective, going from the daughter of an earl to the working class. You really get to see her independence and drive that usually isn't present in regency novels.
I wasn't a fan of how rushed the ending seemed. After all that build up, it felt like the main mystery got resolved too quickly, while at the same time other small questions were left unanswered. I really hope that there's a sequel because I would love to read more of Caroline's story!
This eARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
Publication date: 5/31/22
June 9, 2022
This was my first book by Catherine Lloyd. I enjoyed it and will be trying more.It starts in London in 1837 and Caroline is the daughter of the late and disgraced Earl of Morton. She and her employer Mrs. Frogerton have been invited to a house party to celebrate the birthday of Caroline's cousin Mabel. They are certainly not expecting to get involved in a decades old conspiracy and murder at the house party.
Overall this was this was a very nice and well written Historical Mystery. There were however times when characters and situations were frustrating. Hopefully we will be seeing more of Miss Morton. I think her character has a lot of potential.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Overall this was this was a very nice and well written Historical Mystery. There were however times when characters and situations were frustrating. Hopefully we will be seeing more of Miss Morton. I think her character has a lot of potential.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
January 14, 2023
Daughter of a disgraced earl takes a paid position in 1830s England. Scandal!!!! Then, she attempts to solve a series of murders at the house where she grew up in the English countryside. Oddly, another scandal!!! How do you solve the crime? Accuse people, without evidence, of the murder. Harrumph when they say 'I didn't do it,' and move on to the next accusation.
The story quickly became repetitive. I understand this author's other series has a sound following so I'd try one of those, but I'm not sure I'd read another Miss Morton book.
The story quickly became repetitive. I understand this author's other series has a sound following so I'd try one of those, but I'm not sure I'd read another Miss Morton book.
December 15, 2024
4🌟
This was a very enjoyable listen on Audible. I guessed who dunnit and why (which I hardly ever manage to do, I would make an appalling detective and lament the little old lady solving murders in my village future that I had planned out) but it did not spoil the enjoyment of the story. It is a good, lighter, murdery instalment between more gothic books I have read of late. I intend to continue the series.
This was a very enjoyable listen on Audible. I guessed who dunnit and why (which I hardly ever manage to do, I would make an appalling detective and lament the little old lady solving murders in my village future that I had planned out) but it did not spoil the enjoyment of the story. It is a good, lighter, murdery instalment between more gothic books I have read of late. I intend to continue the series.
June 17, 2022
Entertaining Regency house party cozy mystery -- this is the beginning of what is meant to be a new series.
Socially shunned due to her father's disreputable behavior and death, Lady Caroline Morton has decided to make her own way in London as a paid lady's companion. When she's invited to her cousin's birthday party at the estate of her relatives, Caroline decides to return with her employer, Matilda Frogerton. Mrs. Frogerton is happy to be introduced to the ton so that she can position her daughter, Dorothy, as a wealthy entrant into her first season.
Their arrival at the Greenwood estate is a bit awkward since Caroline had left the house and the family's charity toward her and her sister, Susan, for her new position. It gets worse quite quickly when malfeasance and death make their appearances. Caroline and Mrs. Frogerton seem to be the only ones convinced that something really sinister is going on and they decide to get to the bottom of it. They find an unexpected ally in a local doctor who also has past connections to the estate.
This was quite enjoyable as an introduction to the era and the characters and I look forward to the next installment. I love period details and independent young women set in this time period. The narrative flows smoothly and though the plot was a bit complicated, the ending was not quite so neatly wrapped as I would have expected thus leaving things open for a follow up.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for this e-book ARC to read and review.
Socially shunned due to her father's disreputable behavior and death, Lady Caroline Morton has decided to make her own way in London as a paid lady's companion. When she's invited to her cousin's birthday party at the estate of her relatives, Caroline decides to return with her employer, Matilda Frogerton. Mrs. Frogerton is happy to be introduced to the ton so that she can position her daughter, Dorothy, as a wealthy entrant into her first season.
Their arrival at the Greenwood estate is a bit awkward since Caroline had left the house and the family's charity toward her and her sister, Susan, for her new position. It gets worse quite quickly when malfeasance and death make their appearances. Caroline and Mrs. Frogerton seem to be the only ones convinced that something really sinister is going on and they decide to get to the bottom of it. They find an unexpected ally in a local doctor who also has past connections to the estate.
This was quite enjoyable as an introduction to the era and the characters and I look forward to the next installment. I love period details and independent young women set in this time period. The narrative flows smoothly and though the plot was a bit complicated, the ending was not quite so neatly wrapped as I would have expected thus leaving things open for a follow up.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for this e-book ARC to read and review.
July 19, 2022
Catherine Lloyd's first mystery series, Kurland St Mary Mysteries, got off to a strong start with an engaging protagonist and entertaining storylines. After the third or fourth book, however, the books lost their appeal. I was hoping that this book would recapture some of the charm of the early books in that series, but it did not.
Miss Morton, the daughter of an Earl, is penniless after her father stole her dowery money, and she is living with the shame of that plus her father's suicide. Her circumstances have resulted in her becoming the paid companion of a wealthy widow who made her money in trade.
Mrs. Frogerton, the wealthy widow was the most interesting character in the book. Miss Morton had a personality like an ice cycle. There was a doctor who needed more development. Sometimes he seemed to have a prominent role, but near the end he is dropped.
Then reveal of the murderer is very muddied and the plot seems to drag on as nearly every character becomes a suspect. This entire mystery is begging to be rescued by another author and a sharp editor.
I did not care whether I finished it or not, but I was curious about who committed the murders and why. The answer seemed very unlikely.
There is no need to turn this into a series, so I hope the author isn't doing that. I recommend that she use her history degree for something else.
Two stars because I did finish the book.
Miss Morton, the daughter of an Earl, is penniless after her father stole her dowery money, and she is living with the shame of that plus her father's suicide. Her circumstances have resulted in her becoming the paid companion of a wealthy widow who made her money in trade.
Mrs. Frogerton, the wealthy widow was the most interesting character in the book. Miss Morton had a personality like an ice cycle. There was a doctor who needed more development. Sometimes he seemed to have a prominent role, but near the end he is dropped.
Then reveal of the murderer is very muddied and the plot seems to drag on as nearly every character becomes a suspect. This entire mystery is begging to be rescued by another author and a sharp editor.
I did not care whether I finished it or not, but I was curious about who committed the murders and why. The answer seemed very unlikely.
There is no need to turn this into a series, so I hope the author isn't doing that. I recommend that she use her history degree for something else.
Two stars because I did finish the book.
March 18, 2024
Er nope! Ι read it in Greek and it was just interesting enough not to put it down but it created no desire in me to turn the pages. It was not credible in many points (imagine a high society family inviting grooms and servants to the ball for the coming out of their debutante daughter, imagine two murders being committed and no one batting an eye lash, imagine a ladies companion being treated as a guest, imagine that there is no explanation as to how the murders were committed, imagine a titled person apologising to his former fiancee because he jilted her, imagine a reader's daughter invading ton parties and being accepted among the aristocrats).
I do not say the above is good but it was not in the social norms of the Regency period and that was a very down point for the book.
I picked it up thinking that I would read a very interesting whodunit in that historical placement and I read an uninteresting and unrealistic story that neither convinced me nor absorbed me.
A total no for thia writer.
I do not say the above is good but it was not in the social norms of the Regency period and that was a very down point for the book.
I picked it up thinking that I would read a very interesting whodunit in that historical placement and I read an uninteresting and unrealistic story that neither convinced me nor absorbed me.
A total no for thia writer.
July 8, 2022
3 stars
I enjoyed Catherine Lloyd’s mystery series Kurland St. Mary and I was looking forward to reading this new book.
The story is nice, although a bit long and repetitive. For the most part the main character is asking the same questions and suspects the same individuals. The ending was a bit rough and the crimes discovered and committed were quite unsavoury. I'd say a bit too much for a regency novel.
Nevertheless a great read and I am eager to read Catherine Lloyd’s next mystery book.
A big thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for allowing me to read this nice book!
I enjoyed Catherine Lloyd’s mystery series Kurland St. Mary and I was looking forward to reading this new book.
The story is nice, although a bit long and repetitive. For the most part the main character is asking the same questions and suspects the same individuals. The ending was a bit rough and the crimes discovered and committed were quite unsavoury. I'd say a bit too much for a regency novel.
Nevertheless a great read and I am eager to read Catherine Lloyd’s next mystery book.
A big thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for allowing me to read this nice book!
June 25, 2022
Interesting start to a new series. I like Caroline and her employer. The story line was a bit involved and convoluted. The atmosphere at the "party" house was quite an unhappy one. I definitely see promise for future books in the series. This was my first time reading anything by this author, but I see she has a series of books that I will definitely now have to investigate while I wait for the next book in this series.
September 25, 2022
I wasn’t a fan of this book which surprised me as I’ve enjoyed her past books. I found this mystery boring. The main character Miss Morton spends the entire book saying I’m an employee of Mrs Frogerton in multiple different ways. We get it! You’re employed by someone. Enough! The supporting cast was annoying for the most part.
October 19, 2024
What an unpleasant read.
Not only are we faced with a story seemingly unaware that, though it pretends to Regency-era chic, it takes place five full years into the Victorian era and features manners and 'rules' that would have been considered old-fashioned 20 years prior, but this book also contains as unlikable and dull a cast of characters and a nigh see-thru 'mystery' where the only real question is how many barbs against the gentry -- not the aristocracy, mind you, simply the gentry -- the religious, and the elderly Catherine Lloyd can anachronistically fit onto the page.
In short, this is a book that does everything wrong and nothing right. Getting through it required a Herculean effort to ignore the terribly...well, terrible main character-slash-narrator who is always right, despite the unlikelihood of that happening (given both random probability as well as the innate intelligence she doesn't have), as well as a plot that goes from eyebrow-raising to unbelievable to bizarre in less time than it takes to get tired of the constant whining, complaining, and tired soapboxes about how those with religious beliefs and/or money are evil (unless they make it in trade) and how those without it have no power (even if they're titled).
In 1837.
Lady Caroline Morton, our unpleasant narrator, is as out of place as calling this a Regency setting, but the only place I can imagine her fitting in is in Hell, so perhaps that shouldn't be a surprise. Ready to blame everyone but herself for everything in her life -- and proven right by the 'narrative', such as it is -- Caroline somehow lost all social power that the adult daughter of an earl would have in a 'Regency' setting and believes everyone openly and viciously hates her.
She deserves it, note, but it turns out the only people who don't like her are secretly bad people, who of course don't matter anyway due to their one-dimensional bad-people-ness! What a relief!
She of course is really the only one capable of seeing How Bad They Are, as she's intelligent and smart and brilliant and a bunch of other synonyms that the author wants to throw out. Never fear, she's also the prettiest girl who ever lived -- but of course, no rich tradesmen nor landed/untitled gentry wanted to bring that blood, breeding, deportment, training, and title -- she still has it after her father's death, so it's not patrilineal nor a courtesy title -- into their line just because her father died in what was publicized to be An Accident (this isn't Catholic England; a suicide wouldn't ruin a family in 1837, especially among the landed and titled, where it was politely ignored and chalked up to momentary medical insanity, essentially exculpating the person from any fault).
After all, after all that happens at the end, so the book itself isn't even consistent -- things must be Worse for her for absolutely no reason and against sense for Caroline to show off her virtue and how Awesome she is, right?
At the end of the book, . In the face of all that, Caroline internally says it’s too late for her false regret. And she’s played as being Wonderful and Moral for her response. That scene alone is enough to make her one of the most repugnant characters ever devised in fiction.
The 'good' doctor is undeniably unpleasant and has absolutely zero chemistry with Caroline, a statement also true of Lord Francis, the other man battling for her affection -- though Heaven only knows why they'd want it. (The author also seems convinced that women without a dowry never married, which was even less true in 1837 than in the actual Regency era, and it was pretty untrue then.) Eliza is a pointless hate-sink, Eleanor can't decide what caricature she wants to be in any given chapter, George is a non-entity (as are most 'characters' in this book), the Price brothers are insufferable -- and not for the reasons they're supposed to be, Mabel is a blank slate, Susan is obnoxious and acts like a 5 year old rather than the teenager she's supposed to be, and, despite the fact that the vast majority of 'villainous' characters are female, the book cannot shut up about how evil men are and how preyed upon -- yet very awful, b/c they hate Caroline -- women are. It can't figure out what soapbox it wants to stand on, and ends up incredibly unstable with a toe on each problème de jour it can manage.
And underneath terrible, inaccurate history -- both social and periodic -- and even worse characters, there's what passes for the plot. An obvious mystery that the author keeps trying to dial up and only succeeds in making it more pathetic isn't enough to keep even the most oblivious reader's attention. The side plots -- such as they are -- don't add anything and in fact seem designed to slow down the plot further, just in case there's a one-legged flamingo hopping along, trying desperately to keep up with a pace that a toddler would find unadventurous.
Not a single moment in his book lands. Not a single character rings close to lifelike, let alone complete. Not a single page feels like a historical novel, despite the "ma'am"s, "Niece"s, and "my lady"s peppered through it. In short, not a single moment of this book justifies its existence.
I guess you could recommend this book to a seven-year-old that you hate. For the life of me, I can't think of a single other audience that might get more enjoyment from reading it than they would setting it on fire and roasting marshmallows over it.
Not only are we faced with a story seemingly unaware that, though it pretends to Regency-era chic, it takes place five full years into the Victorian era and features manners and 'rules' that would have been considered old-fashioned 20 years prior, but this book also contains as unlikable and dull a cast of characters and a nigh see-thru 'mystery' where the only real question is how many barbs against the gentry -- not the aristocracy, mind you, simply the gentry -- the religious, and the elderly Catherine Lloyd can anachronistically fit onto the page.
In short, this is a book that does everything wrong and nothing right. Getting through it required a Herculean effort to ignore the terribly...well, terrible main character-slash-narrator who is always right, despite the unlikelihood of that happening (given both random probability as well as the innate intelligence she doesn't have), as well as a plot that goes from eyebrow-raising to unbelievable to bizarre in less time than it takes to get tired of the constant whining, complaining, and tired soapboxes about how those with religious beliefs and/or money are evil (unless they make it in trade) and how those without it have no power (even if they're titled).
In 1837.
Lady Caroline Morton, our unpleasant narrator, is as out of place as calling this a Regency setting, but the only place I can imagine her fitting in is in Hell, so perhaps that shouldn't be a surprise. Ready to blame everyone but herself for everything in her life -- and proven right by the 'narrative', such as it is -- Caroline somehow lost all social power that the adult daughter of an earl would have in a 'Regency' setting and believes everyone openly and viciously hates her.
She deserves it, note, but it turns out the only people who don't like her are secretly bad people, who of course don't matter anyway due to their one-dimensional bad-people-ness! What a relief!
She of course is really the only one capable of seeing How Bad They Are, as she's intelligent and smart and brilliant and a bunch of other synonyms that the author wants to throw out. Never fear, she's also the prettiest girl who ever lived -- but of course, no rich tradesmen nor landed/untitled gentry wanted to bring that blood, breeding, deportment, training, and title -- she still has it after her father's death, so it's not patrilineal nor a courtesy title -- into their line just because her father died in what was publicized to be An Accident (this isn't Catholic England; a suicide wouldn't ruin a family in 1837, especially among the landed and titled, where it was politely ignored and chalked up to momentary medical insanity, essentially exculpating the person from any fault).
After all, after all that happens at the end, so the book itself isn't even consistent -- things must be Worse for her for absolutely no reason and against sense for Caroline to show off her virtue and how Awesome she is, right?
At the end of the book, . In the face of all that, Caroline internally says it’s too late for her false regret. And she’s played as being Wonderful and Moral for her response. That scene alone is enough to make her one of the most repugnant characters ever devised in fiction.
The 'good' doctor is undeniably unpleasant and has absolutely zero chemistry with Caroline, a statement also true of Lord Francis, the other man battling for her affection -- though Heaven only knows why they'd want it. (The author also seems convinced that women without a dowry never married, which was even less true in 1837 than in the actual Regency era, and it was pretty untrue then.) Eliza is a pointless hate-sink, Eleanor can't decide what caricature she wants to be in any given chapter, George is a non-entity (as are most 'characters' in this book), the Price brothers are insufferable -- and not for the reasons they're supposed to be, Mabel is a blank slate, Susan is obnoxious and acts like a 5 year old rather than the teenager she's supposed to be, and, despite the fact that the vast majority of 'villainous' characters are female, the book cannot shut up about how evil men are and how preyed upon -- yet very awful, b/c they hate Caroline -- women are. It can't figure out what soapbox it wants to stand on, and ends up incredibly unstable with a toe on each problème de jour it can manage.
And underneath terrible, inaccurate history -- both social and periodic -- and even worse characters, there's what passes for the plot. An obvious mystery that the author keeps trying to dial up and only succeeds in making it more pathetic isn't enough to keep even the most oblivious reader's attention. The side plots -- such as they are -- don't add anything and in fact seem designed to slow down the plot further, just in case there's a one-legged flamingo hopping along, trying desperately to keep up with a pace that a toddler would find unadventurous.
Not a single moment in his book lands. Not a single character rings close to lifelike, let alone complete. Not a single page feels like a historical novel, despite the "ma'am"s, "Niece"s, and "my lady"s peppered through it. In short, not a single moment of this book justifies its existence.
I guess you could recommend this book to a seven-year-old that you hate. For the life of me, I can't think of a single other audience that might get more enjoyment from reading it than they would setting it on fire and roasting marshmallows over it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 457 reviews