What do you think?
Rate this book
Product Management in Practice: A Practical, Tactical Guide for Your First Day and Every Day After
Product management has become a critical function for modern organizations, from small startups to global enterprises. And yet the day-to-day work of product management remains largely misunderstood. In theory, product managers are visionary leaders building products that delight customers. In practice, product managers are thoughtful facilitators navigating difficult conversations, frustrating compromises, and hard-won incremental gains.
In this thoroughly revised and expanded second edition of his beloved Product Management in Practice, author Matt LeMay provides the practical, day-to-day guidance that product managers need to navigate an ambiguous role in a fast-changing world. Updated and expanded for the era of remote and hybrid work, Product Management in Practice answers the tricky questions that you may have been afraid to ask about the real-world practice of product management.
For current and aspiring product managers, this book explores:
Choosing clarity over comfort to avoid disastrous miscommunications
Learning to love the unique constraints of your role and organization
Talking to users and working with executives
Crafting simple and actionable product strategies
Choreographing space and time to facilitate remote collaboration
Avoiding pointless arguments about Agile
In this thoroughly revised and expanded second edition of his beloved Product Management in Practice, author Matt LeMay provides the practical, day-to-day guidance that product managers need to navigate an ambiguous role in a fast-changing world. Updated and expanded for the era of remote and hybrid work, Product Management in Practice answers the tricky questions that you may have been afraid to ask about the real-world practice of product management.
For current and aspiring product managers, this book explores:
Choosing clarity over comfort to avoid disastrous miscommunications
Learning to love the unique constraints of your role and organization
Talking to users and working with executives
Crafting simple and actionable product strategies
Choreographing space and time to facilitate remote collaboration
Avoiding pointless arguments about Agile
294 pages, Paperback
First published November 8, 2017
453 people are currently reading
2638 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 116 reviews
July 22, 2019
NOTES:
• Pursue clarity over comfort to build your communication skills.
• Seek out opportunities to solve organizational problems on the systemic level rather than the individual level. If the rules aren’t working, change them, don’t break them.
• Don’t let the day-to-day organizational conflicts of your work pull you out of your user’s reality. Remember that what your company cares about and what your users care about are different things, and be a relentless advocate for the latter.
• Remember that there is no work beneath you, and no work above you. Be willing to do whatever it takes to help your team and your organization succeed.
• Even if you don’t self-identify as a “technical” person, avoid saying things like “I’m not a technical person, so I could never understand that!” Trust in your own ability to learn and grow.
• Find ways to align, motivate, and inspire your team that do not require formal organizational authority.
• Don’t let insecurity turn you into the caricature of a bad product manager! Resist the urge to defensively show off your knowledge or skills.
• Don’t be afraid to ask “the obvious.” In fact, the more obvious something seems, the more insistent you should be about making sure everybody is in fact on the same page.
• Ask your teammates about the most valuable and well-run meetings they’ve ever attended, and work with them to set a clear vision for what a “good” meeting should look like in your organization.
• Create and protect space for informal communication in your organization, like team lunches and coffee breaks.
• Ask yourself how a particular best practice might help your team deliver user value, instead of just how it will change the way you work.
• Take the time to truly understand the goals and needs of your organization before rushing to implement any specific practices.
• Avoid the temptation to solve the problems that seem the most familiar to you, as opposed to the problems that are having the most impact on your users.
• Approach best practices as a place to start, not a prescriptive one-size-fits-all solution.
• Organize “demo days” and other opportunities for product teams to share and discuss their work with the organization at large.
• Be just as vigilant about getting to know people outside of your immediate team, and take the time to understand their goals and motivations before you need something from them.
• Reach out to folks in your organization, ask to meet up for coffee (or over Slack, Skype, or whatever other remote collaboration tools you might use if you are not colocated), and say, “I’m curious to learn more about the work that you do.”
• If you can, take your goals for a “test drive” with the senior leaders who are setting the company vision and strategy. See if the goals can serve as a stand-in for their vision, and change your goals if they aren’t giving you the guidance you need.
• Remember that learning, testing, and experimenting is still valuable work, and should be treated as such. Prioritize tasks like creating prototypes and researching implementation approaches alongside the work of actually building your product.
• Make sure that everything on your roadmap is tied back to a “why” so that if that “why” changes, you can adjust the roadmap accordingly.
• Be prepared for short-term prioritization to be much more challenging than creating a long-term roadmap.
• Do everything in your power to make sure that the goals against which you are prioritizing are clear, well understood and actionable.
• Don’t make assumptions about how your organization uses roadmaps. Ask lots of questions, and create a clear and well-documented understanding of how roadmaps are to be used within your organization.
Key Concepts/Templates:
Disagree and Commit
Goals:
• Encourage people to share dissenting and complicating information that might prove critical in deciding upon a path forward.
• Avoid consensus-driven compromise solutions that placate meeting participants but fail to meet underlying goals.
• Force a clear decision, and create shared accountability around that decision.
• Allow participants to pick their battles by committing quickly to low-stakes decisions that are often prone to disagreement (i.e., “What’s for lunch?”)
How to do it:
Introduce disagree and commit before you use it
Interpret silence as disagreement
Ask for affirmative commitment
Set clear goals, test, and learn
Org-level Problem Statement
My organization is facing the following challenge:
This challenge is affecting our ability to deliver value to our users in these ways:
I believe that this challenge is caused by the following current beliefs and practices:
Emergency Requests Template
What is the issue?
Who reported this issue?
How many users is it affecting?
Is there revenue directly tied to this issue?
If so, how much?
What would happen if this issue were not addressed in the next two weeks?
What would happen if this issue were not addressed in the next six months?
Who is the contact person for further discussing/resolving this issue?
Making Data-Driven Decisions
The decision I’m trying to make or problem I’m trying to solve:
The data I’m using to make this decision:
Why I believe that this data will help me make this decision:
What I believe the data is telling me:
What assumptions are present in my interpretation of this data:
How we might test those assumptions:
The next steps I intend to take:
• Pursue clarity over comfort to build your communication skills.
• Seek out opportunities to solve organizational problems on the systemic level rather than the individual level. If the rules aren’t working, change them, don’t break them.
• Don’t let the day-to-day organizational conflicts of your work pull you out of your user’s reality. Remember that what your company cares about and what your users care about are different things, and be a relentless advocate for the latter.
• Remember that there is no work beneath you, and no work above you. Be willing to do whatever it takes to help your team and your organization succeed.
• Even if you don’t self-identify as a “technical” person, avoid saying things like “I’m not a technical person, so I could never understand that!” Trust in your own ability to learn and grow.
• Find ways to align, motivate, and inspire your team that do not require formal organizational authority.
• Don’t let insecurity turn you into the caricature of a bad product manager! Resist the urge to defensively show off your knowledge or skills.
• Don’t be afraid to ask “the obvious.” In fact, the more obvious something seems, the more insistent you should be about making sure everybody is in fact on the same page.
• Ask your teammates about the most valuable and well-run meetings they’ve ever attended, and work with them to set a clear vision for what a “good” meeting should look like in your organization.
• Create and protect space for informal communication in your organization, like team lunches and coffee breaks.
• Ask yourself how a particular best practice might help your team deliver user value, instead of just how it will change the way you work.
• Take the time to truly understand the goals and needs of your organization before rushing to implement any specific practices.
• Avoid the temptation to solve the problems that seem the most familiar to you, as opposed to the problems that are having the most impact on your users.
• Approach best practices as a place to start, not a prescriptive one-size-fits-all solution.
• Organize “demo days” and other opportunities for product teams to share and discuss their work with the organization at large.
• Be just as vigilant about getting to know people outside of your immediate team, and take the time to understand their goals and motivations before you need something from them.
• Reach out to folks in your organization, ask to meet up for coffee (or over Slack, Skype, or whatever other remote collaboration tools you might use if you are not colocated), and say, “I’m curious to learn more about the work that you do.”
• If you can, take your goals for a “test drive” with the senior leaders who are setting the company vision and strategy. See if the goals can serve as a stand-in for their vision, and change your goals if they aren’t giving you the guidance you need.
• Remember that learning, testing, and experimenting is still valuable work, and should be treated as such. Prioritize tasks like creating prototypes and researching implementation approaches alongside the work of actually building your product.
• Make sure that everything on your roadmap is tied back to a “why” so that if that “why” changes, you can adjust the roadmap accordingly.
• Be prepared for short-term prioritization to be much more challenging than creating a long-term roadmap.
• Do everything in your power to make sure that the goals against which you are prioritizing are clear, well understood and actionable.
• Don’t make assumptions about how your organization uses roadmaps. Ask lots of questions, and create a clear and well-documented understanding of how roadmaps are to be used within your organization.
Key Concepts/Templates:
Disagree and Commit
Goals:
• Encourage people to share dissenting and complicating information that might prove critical in deciding upon a path forward.
• Avoid consensus-driven compromise solutions that placate meeting participants but fail to meet underlying goals.
• Force a clear decision, and create shared accountability around that decision.
• Allow participants to pick their battles by committing quickly to low-stakes decisions that are often prone to disagreement (i.e., “What’s for lunch?”)
How to do it:
Introduce disagree and commit before you use it
Interpret silence as disagreement
Ask for affirmative commitment
Set clear goals, test, and learn
Org-level Problem Statement
My organization is facing the following challenge:
This challenge is affecting our ability to deliver value to our users in these ways:
I believe that this challenge is caused by the following current beliefs and practices:
Emergency Requests Template
What is the issue?
Who reported this issue?
How many users is it affecting?
Is there revenue directly tied to this issue?
If so, how much?
What would happen if this issue were not addressed in the next two weeks?
What would happen if this issue were not addressed in the next six months?
Who is the contact person for further discussing/resolving this issue?
Making Data-Driven Decisions
The decision I’m trying to make or problem I’m trying to solve:
The data I’m using to make this decision:
Why I believe that this data will help me make this decision:
What I believe the data is telling me:
What assumptions are present in my interpretation of this data:
How we might test those assumptions:
The next steps I intend to take:
March 26, 2018
Read the full review at my blog
tl;dr – Product Management in Practice has great practical advice for aspiring product managers.
The skill of actually figuring out what you need is probably as important as what you do after you figure it out.
What is the book about?
Product Management in Practice: A Real-World Guide to the Key Connective Role of the 21st Century is written by Matt LeMay, an experienced product leader.
This book has been written, according to Matt LeMay, to talk about the day to day practice of product management with all its ambiguity, contradictions and compromises. This book does not have any fancy framework or tool that will solve world hunger or make you superman; rather it is a look at the work from the trenches.
What does this book cover?
Product Roadmaps Relaunched is a short book with 12 chapters that covers the following topics.
- What is/is not Product Management? Who is/ is not a good Product Manager.
- The CORE connective skills of a Product Management
- The importance of being curious
- Best Practices and why they suck
- Overcommunication > Undercommunication
- Dealing with Senior Stakeholders
- Understanding Data
- Roadmaps / Prioritization
- Working in an Agile fashion
- Good Times, Bad Times
- Every chapter is independent of the other and is followed by a summary.
Read the full review at my blog
tl;dr – Product Management in Practice has great practical advice for aspiring product managers.
The skill of actually figuring out what you need is probably as important as what you do after you figure it out.
What is the book about?
Product Management in Practice: A Real-World Guide to the Key Connective Role of the 21st Century is written by Matt LeMay, an experienced product leader.
This book has been written, according to Matt LeMay, to talk about the day to day practice of product management with all its ambiguity, contradictions and compromises. This book does not have any fancy framework or tool that will solve world hunger or make you superman; rather it is a look at the work from the trenches.
What does this book cover?
Product Roadmaps Relaunched is a short book with 12 chapters that covers the following topics.
- What is/is not Product Management? Who is/ is not a good Product Manager.
- The CORE connective skills of a Product Management
- The importance of being curious
- Best Practices and why they suck
- Overcommunication > Undercommunication
- Dealing with Senior Stakeholders
- Understanding Data
- Roadmaps / Prioritization
- Working in an Agile fashion
- Good Times, Bad Times
- Every chapter is independent of the other and is followed by a summary.
Read the full review at my blog
September 16, 2018
This belongs on your shelf next to Managing Humans and Radical Candor. It’s written in a conversational style that focuses on where the theory of getting things done breaks down in real life — and then it tells you how to push through. Highly recommend for anyone managing teams that make things. This book was a 10x confidence booster, corrective, and guide for me.
April 13, 2024
LeMay delivers an entertaining and practical guide based on the CORE (Communication, Organization, Research, and Execution) skills. Guiding principles like agility, clarity over comfort, disagree and commit, are packaged with good anecdotes showing how brutal it can get though it is one of the most crucial roles today.
“Because product management is a connective and facilitative role, the actual value product managers bring to the table can be very difficult to quantify. Your developer wrote 10,000 lines of code. Your designer created a tactile, visual universe that wowed everybody in the room. Your CEO is the visionary who led the team to success. Just what did you do, exactly?”
“Generally speaking, the “classic” profile for a product manager is either a technical person with some business savvy, or a business-savvy person who will not annoy the hell out of developers.”
“Taking a genuine interest in the work of your colleagues is one of the most important things you can do as a product manager. But product management often poses a particular challenge to those who come from the “never mind, I’ll just go do it myself” school of problem-solving. If you, like me, are the kind of person who absolutely hated “group projects” in school and sought to take on as much work as possible for yourself, product management is likely to teach you difficult-yet-important lessons about trust, collaboration, and delegating.”
“Although many people are drawn to product management by the promise of “building products that people love,” the day-to-day practice of product management involves much less actual building than it does supporting, facilitating, and communicating.”
“Because product management is a connective and facilitative role, the actual value product managers bring to the table can be very difficult to quantify. Your developer wrote 10,000 lines of code. Your designer created a tactile, visual universe that wowed everybody in the room. Your CEO is the visionary who led the team to success. Just what did you do, exactly?”
“Generally speaking, the “classic” profile for a product manager is either a technical person with some business savvy, or a business-savvy person who will not annoy the hell out of developers.”
“Taking a genuine interest in the work of your colleagues is one of the most important things you can do as a product manager. But product management often poses a particular challenge to those who come from the “never mind, I’ll just go do it myself” school of problem-solving. If you, like me, are the kind of person who absolutely hated “group projects” in school and sought to take on as much work as possible for yourself, product management is likely to teach you difficult-yet-important lessons about trust, collaboration, and delegating.”
“Although many people are drawn to product management by the promise of “building products that people love,” the day-to-day practice of product management involves much less actual building than it does supporting, facilitating, and communicating.”
December 30, 2021
The best book I've read so far about product.
Some of my favourite quotes / ideas / highlights:
- "Because product management can be a creative and facilitative role, the actual value PMs bring to the table can be very difficult to quantify."
- "Best practices should be implemented only after understanding the specifics of an organisation."
- "Best practices should only be implemented gradually."
- Set goals first, then use practices that help you reach those goals.
- Idea of 3pm coffee breaks (create rituals that help your team bond).
- Idea about always on video screens between 2 offices (idea originally coming from Gawker media, with offices between New York and Hungary).
- With designers: instead of launching straight into criticism of the design (even mild one) ask them to walk you through the thought process that resulted in them arriving at the design.
- The book contains a template for Data driven decisions which I found very useful.
- Truly data driven experiments often involve following your intuition, rather than establishing a feedback loop of some sort to test whether your intuition is correct.
Some of my favourite quotes / ideas / highlights:
- "Because product management can be a creative and facilitative role, the actual value PMs bring to the table can be very difficult to quantify."
- "Best practices should be implemented only after understanding the specifics of an organisation."
- "Best practices should only be implemented gradually."
- Set goals first, then use practices that help you reach those goals.
- Idea of 3pm coffee breaks (create rituals that help your team bond).
- Idea about always on video screens between 2 offices (idea originally coming from Gawker media, with offices between New York and Hungary).
- With designers: instead of launching straight into criticism of the design (even mild one) ask them to walk you through the thought process that resulted in them arriving at the design.
- The book contains a template for Data driven decisions which I found very useful.
- Truly data driven experiments often involve following your intuition, rather than establishing a feedback loop of some sort to test whether your intuition is correct.
February 6, 2022
Це фантастична книга. Я, напевно, буду рекомендувати її багато багато разів.
Вона надзвичайно практична і головне, проникає в саме серце цієї нечіткої галузі, яка називається “product management”. Ця книга не про те як «перемогати»; вона про те, щоб відкласти наше его, визнати реальність і досягти більших речей, ніж будь-хто може зробити сам.
У книзі немає “води”, зате є море надзвичайно практичних і простих для розуміння турів по світу управління продуктами. “Чек-ліст” в кінці кожного розділу є тепер моїм основним списком для всього, від планування дорожньої карти до визначення пріоритетів та управління зацікавленими сторонами.
Хотілося б, щоб таких книг було більше. На відміну від більшості бізнес-книг, які є або занадто сухими, або в яких складні концепції з повторенням одного і то ж знову і знову, Метт ЛеМей ділиться своїм досвідом так, ніби він сидить навпроти і розмовляє з вами за чашкою кави.
July 13, 2025
Alltaf erfitt að gefa bókum sem maður þekkir helstu conceptin og er sammála þeim flestum einkunn.
Þessi skrudda fær fjórar stjörnur þar sem hún er stutt, hnitmiðuð og einblínir á actionable taktík fram yfir að lýsa abstract vandamálum. Báðir hlutir eru nokkuð sjaldgæfir í þessari týpu af bókum.
Það er mjög stórt sniðmengi milli hvernig Matt LeMay skilgreinir Product Manager hlutverkið í hugbúnaðarþróun og Producer stöðugildisins í tölvuleikjagerð. Ég hef viljað lesa kafla 5 (The Art of egregious overcommunication) og kafla 6 (Working with senior stakeholders: or, Throwing the Poker Game) áður en ég byrjaði hjá mínu fyrsta stóra fyrirtæki.
Þessi skrudda fær fjórar stjörnur þar sem hún er stutt, hnitmiðuð og einblínir á actionable taktík fram yfir að lýsa abstract vandamálum. Báðir hlutir eru nokkuð sjaldgæfir í þessari týpu af bókum.
Það er mjög stórt sniðmengi milli hvernig Matt LeMay skilgreinir Product Manager hlutverkið í hugbúnaðarþróun og Producer stöðugildisins í tölvuleikjagerð. Ég hef viljað lesa kafla 5 (The Art of egregious overcommunication) og kafla 6 (Working with senior stakeholders: or, Throwing the Poker Game) áður en ég byrjaði hjá mínu fyrsta stóra fyrirtæki.
October 19, 2019
One of those rare books which changes professional paradigms. Clear, practical, memorable and easily applicable.
August 24, 2021
This book has great advice for new and existing product managers. It’s like having a mentor around whenever needed for guidance on approaching common challenges at work.
November 16, 2025
I don't usually take very long finishing books, and I didn't expect that this one - 150-something pages - would be with me from September till November. Really, it shouldn't have. A disconnected October that left my routine fragmented, but a much needed reading break helped me get back on my feet.
I think this book, like The First 90 Days, will be more meaningful years down the road. Insightful now on how to communicate and lead in the workplace, but what is better than to do it IRL? I've been thinking about my distinct love for consumer psychology, growth & marketing, and making visionary business predictions (with a too good track record), and had to find out whether PM'ing could be worth trying out.
I think this book, like The First 90 Days, will be more meaningful years down the road. Insightful now on how to communicate and lead in the workplace, but what is better than to do it IRL? I've been thinking about my distinct love for consumer psychology, growth & marketing, and making visionary business predictions (with a too good track record), and had to find out whether PM'ing could be worth trying out.
November 17, 2023
Quite good. Would have benefited from 2-3 more detailed case studies though. Stayed safely in the shallows…
January 23, 2019
It is a must read book for whoever wants to understand what a product managers is meant to do. Reading this book was how reading my daily diary of my working activities with all critical points I have to manage. A really illuminating book about a key role in a company. But as stated into the book "No matter how
smart you are, product management demands that you learn how to be wrong.
No matter how charismatic you are, product management demands that you
learn how to back up your words with actions. And no matter how ambitious you
are, product management demands that you learn how to respect and honor your peers. Product management does not give you an airtight job description or a
veneer of formal authority to hide behind. If you want to succeed, you will need
to become a better communicator, a better colleague, and a better person."
smart you are, product management demands that you learn how to be wrong.
No matter how charismatic you are, product management demands that you
learn how to back up your words with actions. And no matter how ambitious you
are, product management demands that you learn how to respect and honor your peers. Product management does not give you an airtight job description or a
veneer of formal authority to hide behind. If you want to succeed, you will need
to become a better communicator, a better colleague, and a better person."
June 25, 2023
Product management is a new role in the world of business. Mainly built around building and deploying technology, product managers began to spring up in early-21st-century corporations. They have been pioneered by organizations around computer technologies, like Intel, Google, or Microsoft. As common with most new roles, figuring out how to meet the challenge on day one can be daunting. To fill that need, Matt LeMay provides a book filled with sage advice from somewhere who has been there before.
Of note, this book exists in a second edition, which does not have an audiobook (yet). Therefore, I read this book instead. The revised edition appears to have its subtitle revised to target those who aspire to become a product manager.
LeMay offers anecdotal stories and pearls of wisdom to spur product managers on to producing great works. He often tries to de-glamorize the role by emphasizing how much grunt work is required. (It isn’t all mimicry of Steve Jobs!) He contends that this job is about the only managerial title without direct reports, despite heavy responsibility and accountability. This type of advice helps those new to the role or ambitious to achieve the position, but those already exposed and with a good mentor might not need this advisory approach. No new research data or philosophy is presented here, unfortunately, just mentorship based on experience.
LeMay’s most popular chapter, no doubt, consists of his takes on Agile Methodology. In it, he argues for a pragmatic approach to now-popular Agile management methodologies and their many derivatives. A lot of people fall in love with a “perfect” Agile process – the how’s – instead of understanding the why’s. By doing so, they end up missing the opportunity to improve their process critically – which runs contrary to the ethos of Agile to begin with! Many advanced product labs, alongside original leaders of the Agile movement, have realized this, but LeMay gives wider published voice to their objections.
This book clearly most helps for early career folk who want to master the role of a product manager. It can also help those who, like me, want to cross-train in someone else’s job to learn how to work with their co-workers better. The skills and broader perspectives described here can frankly benefit anyone working in a production environment. Nonetheless, this book best excels at demystifying a complex job to aspirants while coaching how to avoid common mistakes.
Of note, this book exists in a second edition, which does not have an audiobook (yet). Therefore, I read this book instead. The revised edition appears to have its subtitle revised to target those who aspire to become a product manager.
LeMay offers anecdotal stories and pearls of wisdom to spur product managers on to producing great works. He often tries to de-glamorize the role by emphasizing how much grunt work is required. (It isn’t all mimicry of Steve Jobs!) He contends that this job is about the only managerial title without direct reports, despite heavy responsibility and accountability. This type of advice helps those new to the role or ambitious to achieve the position, but those already exposed and with a good mentor might not need this advisory approach. No new research data or philosophy is presented here, unfortunately, just mentorship based on experience.
LeMay’s most popular chapter, no doubt, consists of his takes on Agile Methodology. In it, he argues for a pragmatic approach to now-popular Agile management methodologies and their many derivatives. A lot of people fall in love with a “perfect” Agile process – the how’s – instead of understanding the why’s. By doing so, they end up missing the opportunity to improve their process critically – which runs contrary to the ethos of Agile to begin with! Many advanced product labs, alongside original leaders of the Agile movement, have realized this, but LeMay gives wider published voice to their objections.
This book clearly most helps for early career folk who want to master the role of a product manager. It can also help those who, like me, want to cross-train in someone else’s job to learn how to work with their co-workers better. The skills and broader perspectives described here can frankly benefit anyone working in a production environment. Nonetheless, this book best excels at demystifying a complex job to aspirants while coaching how to avoid common mistakes.
February 12, 2024
This book shows the real-world side of what Marty Cagan describes in "Inspired." "Inspired" lays out how product management should ideally works, focusing on customer needs, creating a clear roadmap, and thinking about problems (not features or solutions). This book dives into the messy reality most product managers face in many companies. It highlights that product management involves a great deal of project management. It took me a few years to get to grips with this.
I recall being asked in interviews for Product Manager roles whether I would prioritize customer needs or stakeholder demands. I said "always customer needs", believing that to be the key for a product manager in building successful products. But this book has opened my eyes to the importance of maintaining strong relationships with stakeholders and colleagues. While aiming for customer goals is crucial, it shouldn't come at the cost of alienating your colleagues. Product managers should not keep their teams away from meetings or customer interactions.
A peer engineering manager once emphasized to me the value of "disagree and commit," including the advice to never speak poorly about superiors to the engineering team. This book ties in well with "The Five Dysfunctions of a Team," particularly the challenge for product managers in a matrix organization who might view their direct engineering team as their primary team. Instead, the book suggests they should see their peer product managers as their primary teammates. This perspective shift is vital for fostering collaboration and effective teamwork.
I recall being asked in interviews for Product Manager roles whether I would prioritize customer needs or stakeholder demands. I said "always customer needs", believing that to be the key for a product manager in building successful products. But this book has opened my eyes to the importance of maintaining strong relationships with stakeholders and colleagues. While aiming for customer goals is crucial, it shouldn't come at the cost of alienating your colleagues. Product managers should not keep their teams away from meetings or customer interactions.
A peer engineering manager once emphasized to me the value of "disagree and commit," including the advice to never speak poorly about superiors to the engineering team. This book ties in well with "The Five Dysfunctions of a Team," particularly the challenge for product managers in a matrix organization who might view their direct engineering team as their primary team. Instead, the book suggests they should see their peer product managers as their primary teammates. This perspective shift is vital for fostering collaboration and effective teamwork.
November 11, 2019
In this book, Product Management guru Matt LeMay offers his wisdom surrounding the question: "So, what exactly does a product manager do all day, anyhow?"
The acknowledgment of the ambiguity of the role is a welcome relief. He offers the primers to frame the role: (1) You are not the boss (2) You are not actually building the product yourself and (3) You can’t wait around until somebody tells you what to do.
The introductory profiles lampooning the "bad examples" of product managers were both entertaining and surprisingly easily identifiable. The Jargon Jockey, The Steve Jobs Acolyte, The Hero Product Manager, The Product Martyr, and The Nostalgic Engineer all embody attributes that are easy to gravitate towards but must be avoided to be successful.
When the book gets down to the nitty-gritty, I found the discussion about Product Roadmaps to be most valuable. This quote in particular: "As a product manager, your job is not to covet and defend the roadmap; rather, it is to open the roadmap to a shared, company-wide discussion about what you are building, who you are building it for, and why. As a rule, the product roadmap should be something that encourages collaboration and focuses that collaboration around high-level goals."
Getting people on the same page, talking to each other, and discussing points that are actually relevant to the product itself seems to be the key function of product managers, in addition to taking responsibility for product outcomes.
The acknowledgment of the ambiguity of the role is a welcome relief. He offers the primers to frame the role: (1) You are not the boss (2) You are not actually building the product yourself and (3) You can’t wait around until somebody tells you what to do.
The introductory profiles lampooning the "bad examples" of product managers were both entertaining and surprisingly easily identifiable. The Jargon Jockey, The Steve Jobs Acolyte, The Hero Product Manager, The Product Martyr, and The Nostalgic Engineer all embody attributes that are easy to gravitate towards but must be avoided to be successful.
When the book gets down to the nitty-gritty, I found the discussion about Product Roadmaps to be most valuable. This quote in particular: "As a product manager, your job is not to covet and defend the roadmap; rather, it is to open the roadmap to a shared, company-wide discussion about what you are building, who you are building it for, and why. As a rule, the product roadmap should be something that encourages collaboration and focuses that collaboration around high-level goals."
Getting people on the same page, talking to each other, and discussing points that are actually relevant to the product itself seems to be the key function of product managers, in addition to taking responsibility for product outcomes.
January 4, 2023
Exceptional book that offers a solid foundation to both new and established product managers.
How it helped me:
Made me let go of my perfectionist approach, which more often than not results to be counterproductive for the development of the product. It made me aware of my own tendencies to act as a "Product Martyr" and realising how unsustainable it is.
Served as a reminder that over-the-top BRDs or PRDs are not going to bring as much value to end users like making sure that any Product Specs documents, together with any resulting PBIs - are linked to the actual Product Goal, which (hopefully) is aligned with the end business goal(s).
Redefined the roadmap as a strategic communication document rather than a promise to the executive team (which often feels like it), nor a hard-laid-out plan to be cited, usually without much accountability, by the sales team. Liked the idea of doing a retrospective on the roadmap itself as a learning opportunity and am keen to test it out in practice.
You will find a lot of questions that will make you reflect, and be hooked on the real-life scenarios that make you laugh in agreement ("Heh! That definitely happened at my last project", etc.), plus there is always a great checklist at the end of each chapter to consolidate the findings.
I Wholeheartedly Recommend It.
How it helped me:
Made me let go of my perfectionist approach, which more often than not results to be counterproductive for the development of the product. It made me aware of my own tendencies to act as a "Product Martyr" and realising how unsustainable it is.
Served as a reminder that over-the-top BRDs or PRDs are not going to bring as much value to end users like making sure that any Product Specs documents, together with any resulting PBIs - are linked to the actual Product Goal, which (hopefully) is aligned with the end business goal(s).
Redefined the roadmap as a strategic communication document rather than a promise to the executive team (which often feels like it), nor a hard-laid-out plan to be cited, usually without much accountability, by the sales team. Liked the idea of doing a retrospective on the roadmap itself as a learning opportunity and am keen to test it out in practice.
You will find a lot of questions that will make you reflect, and be hooked on the real-life scenarios that make you laugh in agreement ("Heh! That definitely happened at my last project", etc.), plus there is always a great checklist at the end of each chapter to consolidate the findings.
I Wholeheartedly Recommend It.
September 17, 2020
Lemay did a great job of speaking the truth about the day-to-day effort of product management. He offers great insights into the new career and I enjoyed the organization of the material.
One part that I really liked was his presentation of CORE skills of product management. He offers these guiding principles for each one
* Communication - “clarity over comfort.”
* Organization - “change the rules, don’t break the rules.”
* Research - “live in your user’s reality.”
* Execution - “no work beneath, no work above.”
This is great advice.
His voice is down-to-earth and speaking to those that are in the trenches or work with those that are. I like how Lemay dispels the common assumptions about product management and brings the reader back to what it is really about.
This quote hit home:
"In theory, product management is about triangulating business goals with user needs. In practice, product management often means pushing relentlessly to get any kind of clarity about what business “goals” really are. In theory, product management is a masterfully played game of chess. In practice, product management often feels like a hundred simultaneous games of checkers."
All in all, a great book for a product manger's library. Will come back to it again at some point.
One part that I really liked was his presentation of CORE skills of product management. He offers these guiding principles for each one
* Communication - “clarity over comfort.”
* Organization - “change the rules, don’t break the rules.”
* Research - “live in your user’s reality.”
* Execution - “no work beneath, no work above.”
This is great advice.
His voice is down-to-earth and speaking to those that are in the trenches or work with those that are. I like how Lemay dispels the common assumptions about product management and brings the reader back to what it is really about.
This quote hit home:
"In theory, product management is about triangulating business goals with user needs. In practice, product management often means pushing relentlessly to get any kind of clarity about what business “goals” really are. In theory, product management is a masterfully played game of chess. In practice, product management often feels like a hundred simultaneous games of checkers."
All in all, a great book for a product manger's library. Will come back to it again at some point.
January 30, 2023
Very valuable book that focuses on the soft skills of product management. A few lessons that'll stick with me:
- Hard skills are important to understand contextually, from the folks you'll be working with, as compared to a formal workshop/class
- Provide options, not arguments
- Don't conflate product failure with personal failure
- Couching requests in niceness can lead to miscommunication and lack of clarity
- When getting feedback, getting somebody to quickly check the box is not the goal. You want their active agreement and commitment, or thoughtful reasons as to why they disagree. The focus of "disagree and commit" is equally on disagreement as well as the ultimate commitment
- Even when a user says they want exactly what you're building - ask them why -- it's possible their reasons differ from your reasons, and there's something to be learned
- Best practices are "useful fictions", but ultimately not meant to be followed by the book. Adapt what you learn to the specific needs and situations of your team
- Share messy first drafts ASAP to get early alignment - don't wait until things are polished
I especially liked the examples of what your stakeholders might say, different ways to react, and the outcomes - very realistic!
- Hard skills are important to understand contextually, from the folks you'll be working with, as compared to a formal workshop/class
- Provide options, not arguments
- Don't conflate product failure with personal failure
- Couching requests in niceness can lead to miscommunication and lack of clarity
- When getting feedback, getting somebody to quickly check the box is not the goal. You want their active agreement and commitment, or thoughtful reasons as to why they disagree. The focus of "disagree and commit" is equally on disagreement as well as the ultimate commitment
- Even when a user says they want exactly what you're building - ask them why -- it's possible their reasons differ from your reasons, and there's something to be learned
- Best practices are "useful fictions", but ultimately not meant to be followed by the book. Adapt what you learn to the specific needs and situations of your team
- Share messy first drafts ASAP to get early alignment - don't wait until things are polished
I especially liked the examples of what your stakeholders might say, different ways to react, and the outcomes - very realistic!
July 22, 2022
Tam, kde Inspired od Martyho Cagana povznáša, tak táto príručka vracia späť na zem a zároveň umožňuje človeku si oddýchnuť hlavne od (nárokov na) samého seba, keď sa bavíme o každodennosti výkonu produktového managementu. Ono je to neustále a už pomaly všadeprítomné parafrázovanie a inšpirovanie Inspired trochu otravné a samo seba karikujúce (tým nijak neznižujem, že to je najlepšia knižka). V ten moment sa táto "down-to-earth" príručka, ktorá navádza človeka v denných situáciách, číta veľmi príjemne. Jak píše autor, doporučil by som túto knižku každému začínajúcemu produkťákovi, pretože si myslím, že dokáže dôležito poslúžiť, a nepísal som to ako náhodný výstrel, ako protiváha k Inspired, ktorý je schopný vyvolať nereálne predstavy a očakávania od výkonu danej role. Prečítať ale treba oboje ! :)
Taktiež vhodná knižka pre niekoho, kto si chce počítať o komunikačnom a "connecting" aspekte PM a menej o tom technickom alebo biznisovom.
Taktiež vhodná knižka pre niekoho, kto si chce počítať o komunikačnom a "connecting" aspekte PM a menej o tom technickom alebo biznisovom.
July 26, 2020
I recently moved from years of working in a startup space and needed some guidance into the wild world of software enterprise. I've read several books leading up to the position that talks about methodologies, terms, etc. But this book is really a "real-world" guide, which is what I needed. Scenarios that are more about human interactions than "what would an agile-minded product person" and where most of the problem lie in communication and understanding.
I think the cover may offput some people who work in software (not as hip "modern" look) but O’Reilly generally outputs wonderful technical books (I own at least a dozen
python/data science books from them) and its awesome to see it expanded into "softskills" areas.
If you want a product book that is written by a human and not what "model product person" should be, highly recommended.
I think the cover may offput some people who work in software (not as hip "modern" look) but O’Reilly generally outputs wonderful technical books (I own at least a dozen
python/data science books from them) and its awesome to see it expanded into "softskills" areas.
If you want a product book that is written by a human and not what "model product person" should be, highly recommended.
April 22, 2025
Controversially, I think that this book is barely worth the paper it is printed on.
While it does have some useful tips on managing a team, it utterly fails to explain product management itself, go into any detail for what it repeatedly mentions as « important for a team » (the Agile retro), and continuously disrespects the entire design and research disciplines by saying that product managers effectively invent the product by talking to customers. No, you hire researchers who know how to learn from customers. You don’t half-ass research or doodle without structure with random people to give ideas to your design team. Just no. You hire experts in these fields to collaborate with.
Overall it was a frustrating-to-infuriating read and I have never defaced a book so much in my life!! Never thought O’Reilly would ever publish anything like this. It’s like one guy’s blog.
While it does have some useful tips on managing a team, it utterly fails to explain product management itself, go into any detail for what it repeatedly mentions as « important for a team » (the Agile retro), and continuously disrespects the entire design and research disciplines by saying that product managers effectively invent the product by talking to customers. No, you hire researchers who know how to learn from customers. You don’t half-ass research or doodle without structure with random people to give ideas to your design team. Just no. You hire experts in these fields to collaborate with.
Overall it was a frustrating-to-infuriating read and I have never defaced a book so much in my life!! Never thought O’Reilly would ever publish anything like this. It’s like one guy’s blog.
December 6, 2018
The best book for starting product managers
I’ve been in the product manager role for a year, I’ve read dozens of articles and several books, I’ve been in charge of old and new products, and this book has been like a gift from the gods to me. There were several situations where what I was reading just happened to me or was about to happen and I was able to apply what I learned with great success.
I think this is one of those few books that I want to read several times, I cannot stress enough how reading it helped me as a starting product manager in ways that no other article or book could.
I’ve been in the product manager role for a year, I’ve read dozens of articles and several books, I’ve been in charge of old and new products, and this book has been like a gift from the gods to me. There were several situations where what I was reading just happened to me or was about to happen and I was able to apply what I learned with great success.
I think this is one of those few books that I want to read several times, I cannot stress enough how reading it helped me as a starting product manager in ways that no other article or book could.
August 15, 2019
I recently completed this book and I have to say, this is one of those books that you would want to revisit at various stages of your Product Management career. You can buy it from Amazon here.
The learnings present in this book are timeless and would be applicable differently to product companies at various different stages but principles more or less remain relevant and highly applicable.
I highly recommend reading this book but just so you get a glimpse of what to expect, here is a summary of the book.
You can read the full summary here https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/produc...
The learnings present in this book are timeless and would be applicable differently to product companies at various different stages but principles more or less remain relevant and highly applicable.
I highly recommend reading this book but just so you get a glimpse of what to expect, here is a summary of the book.
You can read the full summary here https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/produc...
February 15, 2023
This is probably the only Product Management book needed for PMs at all levels. Very grounded in reality, pragmatism and common sense unlike some other really patronizing influencer style content out there that neither inspire nor empower when the rubber hits the road. Still ended up being a great read for me even at this stage of my career as I try to rewind and retrospect based on Matt's storytelling on the mysticism that surrounds real Product Management. Highly recommend this as the first book any new PM should pick up on the subject. And as I said, also for seasoned PMs to read and think about.
June 28, 2020
An excellent book. It provides the fundamentals of product management without prescribing a lot of methods but instead a lot of guidelines or first principles. As of such it seems to be always timely and prevents going into whatever's in vogue like scrum or kanban.
The author has lots of experience and distills all of this very clearly into guidelines and principles. There's plenty of excellent war stories as well from other product managers.
Really recommend this book for product managers or even people who work with product managers.
The author has lots of experience and distills all of this very clearly into guidelines and principles. There's plenty of excellent war stories as well from other product managers.
Really recommend this book for product managers or even people who work with product managers.
November 15, 2020
Finally, a product management book that is real and practical. As much as we PMs love vision and idealism, sometimes we need people who've been there to tell us how things actually work in organizations and roles and products that are not perfect. Matt LeMay is that author. This book resonated with me more than anything else I've read on the discipline of product management because I could see my frustrations and struggles and failures in it, and it taught me how I might be better without needing to change my entire world to bring about the change he teaches.
September 29, 2021
Matt LeMay is consiltant, couch and former product manager. He has irreverence and humor style, so if you don't manage product, you will enjoy this book.
A product manager’s responsibility is to do anything and everything necessary to make the product succeed.
Product managers need four “CORE” skills: “communication, organization, research and execution.”
Product managers don’t need to know “data science” or programming, but they must talk with experts who do know in order to learn and build alliances and trust.
A product manager’s responsibility is to do anything and everything necessary to make the product succeed.
Product managers need four “CORE” skills: “communication, organization, research and execution.”
Product managers don’t need to know “data science” or programming, but they must talk with experts who do know in order to learn and build alliances and trust.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 18, 2020
*I am a Product Manager*
This book really tackles some very important aspects of actually being a Product Manager that I could have used since day 1.
For me, this book is a gap from the 'Theoretical' Product Manager to the 'Working' Product Manager.
Also, it covers some pitfalls very very well, It's like she was walking in my shoes for the first 2 years of me being an amateur Product Manager.
Super informative, effective, and enjoyable read.
This book really tackles some very important aspects of actually being a Product Manager that I could have used since day 1.
For me, this book is a gap from the 'Theoretical' Product Manager to the 'Working' Product Manager.
Also, it covers some pitfalls very very well, It's like she was walking in my shoes for the first 2 years of me being an amateur Product Manager.
Super informative, effective, and enjoyable read.
July 29, 2022
This book deserves a high rating, just like it has. While the rest of "Product Manager" books talk about the ways, this one strongly puts the emphasis on communication above everything. And curiosity. Soft skills way over hard skills. So this is a superb book for a person considering the role of Product Manager, it is a very nice introduction to teamwork in a bigger picture. And it is full of real life stories about many different aspects. Strongly recommend it - read it! :)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 116 reviews